PATRON TAKES - Star Trek TNG S1E22 - Symbiosis
Comment on this post your ‘takes’ on this episode and we will read a few in our discussion!
We love reading ALL of your takes so comment whatever and however you’d like! Just no future spoilers please. If you want your take to be read in the video, comment ONE of the following:
- A brief review (2-3 sentences) of why you like/dislike the episode
- A question for us about the episode
- A prediction of how you think we will react to a certain aspect of the episode
- A fun fact about the episode
We are watching this episode Monday so we won’t be reading the comments on this until then. If you have questions shoot us a message!
Comments (50)
Denise Crosby spelling out addiction to Wesley seemed dull when I was a kid. Later in life that line actually helped me realize and find my way out of a dark time in my life. Not my favorite episode, but it turned out to be very important to me personally.
I feel like some of the comments get a little “spoiler-ish” occasionally. like when I first saw The Sixth Sense with a friend who already saw it, and he didn’t exactly spoil it, but he did keep whispering “notice how nobody talks to Bruce Willis except the boy?” Lol
This one was decent, when I saw this on the first run I remember how much I didn't like that Female Brekkan and wanted to slap her! Did I see a Vulcan in engineering at the start of this one? I never noticed Tasha waving as Picard & Crusher leave the cargo bay. I think you will like this one and I believe you will recognize David, also you should figure the Drug angle about the same time as Crusher does. That's it! 😀🖖
Middling episode, but I always find it difficult to watch Merritt Butrick's character suffering from an (apparent) illness, knowing that Butrick was ill in real life. I always wonder how much of what we see is the actor's real illness versus acting/makeup.
I love the fact that Picard uses the Prime Directive to circumvent the Prime Directive. We can’t stop you from supplying drugs but we also can’t fix your ship you use to supply the drugs!
Oh yes, the anti-drug episode and I always found Wesley to be a complete moron for him to not understand, even when it was explained to him by Tasha. By the way, a little fun fact, the drug addicted planets leader, who appears on the view screen is played by the actor who played the old man who stood up to Loki in the first avengers film. Also at the end of the episode, when Picard and Crusher are walking out of the cargo bay, you see Denise Crosby, waving to the camera the reason why will become clear I think in the next episode.
Merritt Butrick had contracted AIDS by the late 1980s, and you can tell his health is suffering here, having lost a lot of weight since we'd last seen him 5 years earlier in Star Trek III. It made his performance as an ailing junkie even more credible. He passed away less than a year after filming this episode, the first TNG guest actor to die. He has two panels on the AIDS Memorial Quilt which read "The Needs of the One, The Needs of the Many." After he died, someone claimed Butrick had been homosexual, his Wrath of Khan co-star Kirstie Alley said in her autobiography "oh no, he was definitely bisexual." I don't know why the aliens had bioelectric powers here. It added pretty much nothing to the plot, but I guess Gene needed a sci-fi element...
I only vaguely recall this episode. I guess it didn't make much of an impression.
I thought this was a little too preachy what can you say? Just say no. It is good trek Just a generally slow ep. Just felt like an episode that lost a step somewhere
IS TASHA WAVING AT FLIES?
The “Don’t Do Drugs” episode. It gets a lot of flak for the overly naïve and earnest scene of Wesley asking about drug addiction, but overall the story isn’t so bad. Picard gets to use the Prime Directive to screw over the villains, which is fun to watch.
"I guess I don't understand." That's because you're a nerd, Wesley, but that's okay.
That's the show's (Roddenberry's?) way of stating very clearly that pleasurable pursuit and abuse of drugs is not part of the 24th century human utopia.
I really like this episode. The Non Interference policy hits both ways. To me this is what Non interference is really all about. Development must happen naturally even if it not pretty. I am certainly glad no alien came down when Humans were destroying (and hunting maybe) Neanderthals and said "that does not seem fair let's help those poor lower species". We might not exist at all.
Nailed it
Okay Alex and Josh…how did you like to see your favorite actor from ST2 return for TNG? Lol. Actually, I know this might not be a popular opinion, but I LOVE this episode. The commentary of addiction is an important message. And its again the aliens that we encounter that have our issues. The twist is excellent, where they actually aren’t taking medicine. Its freaking Heroin basically! Crusher is great, and Picard not giving them what they want at the end is awesome. You can’t have your cake and eat it too, looking for a handout from the Federation with arrogance. Upholding the Prime Directive is perfect, and the discussion in the turbolift between Beverly and Picard is a great convo. To me, this episode is one of the best of the season.
Well stated!
I think the moment when Beverly realizes the true nature of the illness, and we see the plot twist written on her face before she reveals it in dialogue, is Gates McFadden's best acting in Season 1 (and she's had many other fantastic moments).
In the UK no broadcaster had the rights to show TNG, so Paramount released them on VHS from rental shops from 87 to 89, before the BBC started broadcasting the show. As a result we saw episodes out of order and they even dropped some entirely. You had UK fan groups gathering to watch US episodes on VHS tapes sent over in the mail. I found a group in a local newspaper ad. Trek fans were and are the best when it comes to sharing.
The broadcasting rights in Europe for TNG involved a 2 year delay before TV screenings could start. This was very deliberate and allowed more profit from the VHS sales/rentals. In Ireland, once the initial delay expired, TNG ran almost continuously, with only Christmas and Easter schedules interrupting it for two weeks each.
The Star Trek II rematch no one saw coming as David and Joachim battle it out again in the 24th century, but seriously kids don’t do drugs.
The scene where they stop the plot and have Wil Wheaton and Denise Crosby act out a "Say no to drugs!" after school special is probably the most 80s the show has ever been. I generally like it but the ending is bad, while it is satisfying to see the smiles wiped off the drug dealers faces, the crew leaves an entire planet to go through a painful withdrawal thinking they'll die and citing the prime directive doesn't make sense, you can't even tell an abused and manipulated population that their "medicine" is unnecessary? I call bullshit on that one.
I thought the Yar/WCrusher scene was well done. Drug abuse IS bad, and the main reason they're bad is they mask reality by making you feel not bad. I'll urge you to revisit the turbolift scene between Picard and Crusher as to why Picard's decision is the right one. And the Prime Directive definitely applies! This story was well written!
I bet you guys notice the parallel between this ending and the end of City on the Edge of Forever. Picard being like, "just get us out of here, I don't care where", is reminiscent of Kirk's "let's get the hell out of here".. and shows just how disturbed he is by this encounter. Then Geordi picks everyone up, refocuses everyone on their mission of exploration. Possibly the best ending of the season
The final scene of the episode is almost sooo "star trek" that it's a parody of itself.
It's so satisfying seeing Picard wipe that smug smile off the brekkian lady's face. Crusher is great in this episode, figuring out what's really going on with the drug and once again completely lacking calluses on her feelings. Yar's lecture on drugs is pretty "after school special" but that's the 80s for you. Rest in peace Merritt Butrick
The episode with two actors from Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan -- for some reason. This episode was filmed out of order as one might discover later.
I love Tasha’s “Drugs make you feel..GOOD” but like, don’t do them, speech..so very 80’s. There are some plot holes big enough to fit the Enterprise, but I’ve still always liked this one. And getting to see Merritt Butrick one last time is bittersweet.
What are the plot holes?
Love this one (minus the 'just say no to drugs' scene). Cool story. Feels like a later seasons episode to me.
Are you both surprised just how tough Data can be? For some reason I always loved his jumping scene, or maybe he just drops.
Wrong episode, sir! (You're obviously referring to the episode before this one.)
Just for fun… there’s some trivia about a scene in this episode that we CANNOT point out to you yet. 😁
This is one of only five TNG episodes (and the only season one episode) that doesn't have a stardate
37:50 The smug and defiant look on the woman's face while Picard and Velma unravel the entire plot out loud could make me angry!
They were SO good at being smug snakes! They know the Enterprise crew can't do a single thing about their little profitable scheme...
I like this episode and the moral implications it explored. I find it a lot better than some of the "moral issues of the day" episodes that come later. Thinking back on my initial viewing of the series, I was never perplexed or intrigued by the Prime Directive and what, exactly, it means. I intuitively understood its crux, meaning don't pollute other cultures, especially lesser-developed ones. (If you can help it.)
Picard could have had a big brain moment and seen if the planet of junkies with useful lightning hands might want to join the Federation instead and sidestep all that Prime Directive business.
i'd never thought of that! But Federation membership takes years, as does full detox.
I wish I had known drugs are bad before I just popped a couple of Advil.
Interesting episode.. Picard played the only card he could that could go around the Prime Directive without breaking its rules. A smart play in the hopes that it will eventually help these people, but it’s a shame that they couldn’t do more to help them through the withdrawals as Crusher wanted to
Hey, Alex, it's your favorite character from Star Trek II and III, only not! This is actually a quality episode, dealing with a, granted, simplified relationship between two parties. This is also RedLettermedia's/Mike and Rich's "only good episode" from Season one.
Really? I thought almost everyone preferred "Farpoint," "Where No One," "The Big Goodbye" and "Coming of Age" to this one.
The "drugs are bad!" episode. A bit after school specialish. Also the return of Kirk's Son!?! Well, not really, the producers gave him the role so he could get medical benefits to help with his Aids diagnosis. As you know it sadly didn't help in the long run. Also the return of Khan's maybe son Joachim, but also not quite. Gotta get used to Star Trek reusing actors. 😆
We interrupt this episode of TNG for a special anti-drug PSA. Not the best, some definite good stuff, and I thought Picard's solution to the issue of the episode was a really good and creative solution to adhere to the Prime Directive. Fun Fact: From that same Reading Rainbow episode featuring TNG I mentioned before, they were filming this episode at the time, so we get to see some extremely rare (at the time) TNG bloopers on it!
A prime directive and anti-drug episode all wrapped up into one. It will be interesting to see if you guys catch on to the drug pusher, junkie angle before Crusher figures it out. Jonathan Frakes hated the look he gave when he was being shocked by one of the aliens, he said it was straight from the Jack Palance school of acting (this was before Jack won his oscar). And yes, who knows if it was stunt casting to have the guy that played Kirk's son and the guy that played Khan's right hand guy (believed to be Khan's son) in Star Trek 2 be the ones opposing each other. Merritt Butrick would die about a year after this episode.
The fact Riker's look is so un-nuanced and kind-of ridiculous makes it look more authentic to me! An electric shock like that is just gonna cause all the affected muscles to contract and freeze. RIP Merritt Butrick. He definitely had the chrisma and looks to be a plausible Kirk's son!
Beam up for a double take! It's a Starfleet family reunion with Kirk's mini-me, David, warping in. And what's this? Joachim, Khan's potential offspring, joining the cosmic carousel too? Star Trek's casting is like a Genesis Device, constantly reanimating familiar faces in new roles. You never know when a familiar face will pop up in future shows!
I actually really like this one from S1 because we get more insight into the Prime Directive. Also, there's a special guest star!
Drugs are Bad, McKay
