UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E14 - Angel One
Comments (39)
Not sure about the take that they didn't go over the top with the sexism. This episode is cartoonishly sexist. You have to get into like middle eastern kind of repressive societies to see the reverse of that. That planet isn't even close to 1800s America but with the gender roles swapped. On the vote, sure, but the problems on that planet go so far beyond that. Nah, this pile of garbage episode was a perfect example of why Roddenberry needed to be out of the writers room. Also the application of the prime directive made no sense here. I will credit the cast. Frakes and Crosby did the best with the material they had, Geordi taking command and Worf being like "dude, you got bigger fish to fry" were good for their characters. Crusher was holding that whole ship together, and I'd appreciate Picard being down with the sickness if there weren't already so much of Picard being vulnerable this season. He's still human after all. I thought it was downright stupid having Crusher refuse to transport them aboard. They were literally going to be executed. Certain death vs possible death. Just beam them into a cargo bay and have them quarantine there. Bottom 5 episode of the show.
From your initial discussion before you discussed the episode, my take is that basically this is your channel and you’re going to do what you want, which is fine and as it should be. If people like other formats, they can go elsewhere. There are certainly enough YouTube and Patreon channels to follow. If you can’t enjoy what you’re doing, the audience won’t enjoy it, either. Feelings of enjoyment, boredom, or animosity come through. So do what you want - it’s fine and life’s too short.
54:00 Data being affected by the "Naked Now" infection was one of the dumbest plot line/armor decisions made in TNG.
2:56 This planet (many of these) are NOT in the Federation.
What always bugs me about “Virus” episodes is shouldn’t every room on the ship be airtight In case of a hull breach? They should be able to quarantine Ramseys people in the Transporter room?
Thanks for the fun reaction. I've never liked this episode...except for all the chest hair! Lol
This was one I'll skip. I saw it once when first aired. Enough for me.
Hey, my comment's mentioned again! I'm pretty sure I even heard Frakes himself said he was pushing for Riker to lighten up, and let more of Frakes' real personality come through.
This image of a nearly naked Riker… with “Full Uncut” beneath him…. I’ll just leave it at that
The discussion of perfume reminded me of an interesting passage in the novelization of "Encounter at Farpoint" (by David Gerrold): The book states that Riker has a keen enough sense of smell to identify the exact perfume worn by any woman he encounters. When he meets Tasha Yar for the first time in the Transporter Room after beaming up from Farpoint, he notices that she isn't wearing any perfume -- he only smells soap. The most recent role listed on IMDb for Leonard Crofoot (Trent) is a 2020 music video.
Soap? But they use sonic showers...
Less than mid episode, 3/10. Why didn't Dr Crusher get sick? I guess for the same reason Ryker didn't get drunk. Anyway, the planet: this reminds me of a forgotten Norman Lear show called All That Glitters and by 1987 US society did not reflect this silly premise. Not sure why the commentary on such an outdated premise even 35 yrs ago. While this episode was airing Margaret Thatcher was Prime Minister for 8 years. Regarding feeble Picard, he's feeble, just look at him and its a total senior vibe. Kirk > every other captain.
Going into this reaction, all I really remembered from this episode was the Riker outfit. While this isn't a great episode by any means, after watching the episode again, I didn't dislike it. The virus B-plot kind of went nowhere, but the stuff with the planet itself had elements of a classic episode of Trek. It's funny you guys mentioned the "Kirk speech". Without getting into spoilers; I think most fans of would consider Picard to be the captain known for his speeches.
"Mistress something starting with a B".... hmmmm....
I have to say I love what you guys are doing! I am new here but wow do you guys put out a lot of show! Some of the other people I sub to I'm happy if I get a few shows every month! Keep up the good work!
The best part of this entire episode was that they never explained how a Holodeck created a mutating variant super-virus....and why.
It didn't. The episode dialogue states Wesley and the other students picked up a virus on a field trip to Quazulu VIII, it only had begun to spread by the time they came out of the holodeck.
The original idea for the Enterprise-D was a 20 year mission, a considerable increase over the old Enterprise, represented by the new ship's huge size, comfort, and families on board. They never really expressed this on screen, but the idea was that the new ship would stay out on the frontier exploring much longer than previous ships.
When they were developing TNG, David Gerrold, in particular, stressed how in TOS, it was not realistic to put Kirk in the middle of the action, since a captain would usually remain on the ship to call shots to people he sends out on the ground. This is why Picard is sidelined a lot in the first season. That changes as the show goes on.
THE score update Tosha - 3 Riker - 2 ADD ONE to the hairy chest brigade. Data - 1 Troi - 1
Oh, sweet merciful God in Heaven! It's this episode. This is one of those story concepts that appears in most SF TV shows of the 1970's and 1980's. Roddenberry even did a variation of this for one of his 1970's TV pilots.
Speaking of evolving the channel, I can't help but wonder when the channel is going to receive a 5-6 second musical intro for the logo, after cold open of course..... you know, a short theme song for the channel to nod your head/air drum to every video. dooooo it
Branded intros kill retention unfortunately
I like your guys format. I ALWAYS appreciate when reactors don't just react, but discuss and analyse what they watch. As for the intro, I think it's smart to cue up viewers on what to expect going in, rather than have them be disappointed as they watch the reaction.
I should say, not that they'd be disappointed in your reaction as a given, just that, if they like an episode you guys didn't, knowing that ahead of time probably softens the blow.
Riker did have sex with her, they just couldn’t show more or be more direct. Roddenberry was a swinger, womanizer and all about a more pleasure focused enlightened future. He wrote the novelization of Star Trek The Motion Picture…and it’s pretty wild the stuff he included…
I presume that Riker and Beata made love after the fade to Ramsey's campfire.
Data is the 2nd officer, right below Riker who is 1st officer. La Forge is a very junior rank, but anyone can be given the con Later on the series will address a bit more about ranks and command training and which officer specialties are in the command line
This is not at all a spoiler but the Prime Directive only applies to Starfleet because they are the military. Regular citizens of the Federation are not beholden to the Prime Directive.
This is actually contradicted by a season 7 episode (no spoilers) and honestly, logically so. What's to stop any Federation citizen from meddling in a pre-warp society unless there was a law against it. If it's clearly that important, it should apply to any Fed citizen with the means to travel to other worlds.
It's super funny all the "decrepit Picard" depictions when I clearly remember Patrick Stewart being a sex symbol in the early 90s, lots of TV Guide covers and things. Of course, that was after the show got going. https://twitter.com/SirPatStew/status/931520165640056833
Definitely back to a more TOS-y style plot line, Star Trek never shies away from social issues but it tends to get less...hamfisted? And cringe? Also, #JusticeForTrent
The freighter was missing for seven years, the Enterprise-D is not on a seven year mission.
It's your channel. You can do things however you see fit. This episode doesn't rank very highly on most lists. For me despite some good moments it's another timefiller episode. There are a couple episodes in Season 1 still to come that I think most of us are looking forward to seeing what you think, but that's as much as I'll say about them. For now.
This is one of my TNG guilty pleasures..not the most memorable episode, but for some reason I will always watch if I’m flipping channels.
I don't drink, but uh *cracks open a cold one* in this case i'll make an exception. It's rubbing alcohol, by the way.
When we got to Haven, I thought that was this episode because I got the titles mixed up, so I was somewhat happy when that wasn't this episode but, well, now we're here. It's not as bad as I remember, but I forgot about that b-plot on the Enterprise. Maybe because it wasn't needed...
The traditional gender role reversal episode. Shades of Spock's Brain ;-)
Riker looking hot
