UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E9 - The Battle
Be the first to own Target Audience merchandise - http://tee.pub/lic/xv4js4f_14U
Comments (38)
I always found this one pretty solid, but not amazing. This is a much better showing for the ferengi than The Last Outpost. Bok was a reasonably good villain for the episode, and avenging the death of his son is a believable as a motivation. Kazago was great though, and I like the rapport he and Riker built, first officer to first officer, over the course of the episode. I can see the criticism of making Picard vulnerable/weak too often this early in the show. He just gave up and surrendered to Q in Farpoint, couldn't "hold his liquor" as well as Riker in Naked Now, has to go beg to get Tasha back after that, had a fairly passive response to his ship being drained of power and was ready to surrender to the ferengi in Last Outpost(he's French after all), got taken over by an alien and had to be rescued in Lonely Among Us, and almost loses his mind here. On the other hand, it makes you appreciate Picard more later on when the character shows considerably greater strength of character. I'm sure that wasn't planned, but it works as an arc. It's also a good episode to start building up Picard's backstory. We knew next to nothing about his past apart from having known Crusher's late husband. Now we know about his previous command and a battle tactic he invented. Fuckin Wesley with his "adults" line though. It's the little things that made the character so disliked IMO.
I kind of love the Constellation-class design. The four nacelles joined directly to a tiny saucer make it look like a super speedy but rickety little starship.
Solid episode. Again, realizing the first 2 seasons are plot oriented (for the most part) it is a good episode. C+ Maybe? I can deal with Troi’s one-liners because she’s hot lol. Marina Sirtis (who I’m happy to admit I got her autograph at a convention) is/ was a beautiful woman especially with the contacts. Off topic, I got Jeffrey Combs autograph and a selfie. Nicest guy in the world.
If you look closely, Wesley says “Constitution Class”, but it was changed to “Constellation”, as I recall, for reasons of production model availability. I got this from one of the official Mike Okuda guide books on the technology. It may have been the Star Trek Chronology book.
There was a good story here bogged down by bad direction. The only good bits were the Stargazer scenes, but the rest of it was drama free. It's really frustrating that the directors sap every last drop of drama out of every scene. There was a little bit borrowed from The Lights Of Zetar where Picard's brainwaves match exactly the emission from the Ferengi ship. If you watch the TOS scene where they discover this exact problem with Mira Romaine, they make sure it is presented in a serious dramatic way, and they let it sit with you for the scene. Here, in as undramatic a way as possible, Wesley discovers this off-camera, his mother and Troi get 10 seconds so they can't even sell the implication of what this all means, and then it is on to some scene on the bridge where Ryker asks how they know this. If they filmed the show with any kind of eye, he'd have been with Wesley in engineering when Wesley discovers it and explains the problem. Then give a moment for the cast to react to this development, throw in a bit of music, and cut to a commercial. 6/10 for the Airplane! style trauma voiceovers and the actual Stargazer reliving scenes.
I found it very interesting, since zi haven’t seen this episode in a long time, how vulnerable Picard was in this episode. Especially the scenes with Beverly. “I just don’t know anymore! I just don’t know!” He was near tears and very confused. They were definitely back and forth on how to write Picard, and the other characters, but thats usually like any show in the 1st season.
You guys are too young to remember but this show hooked up with an instant coffee commercial to generate a minor meme before there really was an internet. https://youtu.be/mcMpJlYynBw?si=3WlyxrPyKxSLLtNz&t=17
Ironically, I watched this reaction while suffering from a headache. And no, it wasn't on purpose. And I am definitely looking forward to your reaction to one of next week's episodes.
Don't worry, Troi does get better. They didn't quite know what to do with her in the first season.
Troi, Data, and Picard were my least favorite characters in the 1st season and this episode shows some my reasons why for at least 2 of them. I got so sick of hearing Troi "feeling", especially when she did it across vast distances between the Enterprise and whoever was on the viewscreen. Picard came off as a dick at times and other times more of a wimp. The writers improved on these characters in season 2. Interesting speculation about Riker and Picard. Hmmmm.
I'll make a prediction; by the time you get to the end of this season you won't have any problem coming up with your top ten lists, although I doubt any of the previous episodes will be on them. (With the possible exception of the pilot.) There are some excellent episodes coming up, also a couple of real duds, but overall the last half of the first season is quite good.
I agree with that. Frankly, Symbiosis is one of my favorite episodes. Not going say any plot spoilers, but to me anyway, great plot
Is the next Ferengi episode in season 3? That's quite a statement about the rapid re-assessment of them if so.
Regarding the Ferengi not being strong enough to be the regular "big bad", you weren't alone in feeling this; the show's writers felt it, too. And yes, the Romulans are still out there, but are laying awfully low and being very quiet at the moment. Over the run of TNG you'll see new races (and enemies) emerge at various threat levels given where the Federation is strength-wise.
Notice Wesley's new shirt now that he's an acting ensign? It has the strips of red, gold and blue across the top. All three colors of Starfleet officer uniforms, so this is a student's uniform since they don't know what field they'll get into yet.
MUCH better than the Pumpkin Nightmare sweater they had him in for a while.
Early on the show really struggled with Troi and although she becomes significantly better I don't think they ever used Marina Sirtis to her full potential, she's actually a pretty good actress and it shows when they give her good material. Seeing Sirtis at conventions is a hoot, she has a very acerbic sense of humor and is not afraid to speak her mind.
She was great in the pilot when she had stuff to do!
It was a pretty thin blanket, but then again the climate control has got to be much better than even most upscale hotel rooms these days.
My question is always “why don’t they take off their shoes before lying down?” I wouldn’t get any comfort while wearing shoes in bed.
Lol just like TOS I always thought “In the future, beds will not be comfortable”.
Non-canon, but in a novel concerning the Maxia events, Picard while abandoning ship set the Stargazer on a course to drift into the atmosphere of a gas giant, but due to a fluke it missed crashing into the planet and was spun off back into space.
Good episode for some Picard backstory, and for ironing out the Ferengi a bit after their horrible introduction. I too felt the dream sequence stuff aboard the Stargazer, as well as the conversations between Riker and the Ferengi first officer (who i can never remember the name of) were quite well done.
What's really interesting that I don't think I've seen as an opinion on the first season is your view that Picard is somewhat being diminished in favor of Riker as far as being a dynamic lead? I think that appearance definitely goes away as characters settle in but it's a new perspective I found interesting.
Things slowly changed as Patrick Stewart began to complain about the Captain not being in the center of the action off the bridge.
Regarding Picard coming off as almost weak, I think that's because Gene really didn't like the more military tone of Starfleet in the movies and wanted to very specifically get away from that in TNG, and he over-corrected. We've already had Picard surrender twice, once to Q in the very first episode, and once to the Ferengi in The Last Outpost. And as you mentioned, this is the second time in just a few episodes that Picard personally has been in a very vulnerable position. They strike a better balance after these early episodes. They figure out how to let Picard be the more peaceful and diplomatic captain (versus Kirk's more cowboyish tone) without making him look weak. And yes, Riker was definitely the backup "Kirk 2.0", so if audiences hated Picard they could write him out and have Riker take over.
Funny enough, DC Fontana’s original script for Encounter at Farpoint had Picard surrender the ship, and the crew captured and put to work as slave labor on the planet.. not even to distract from the “hostile” going after the saucer section as in the final episode. It’s odd that a writer like DC Fontana would make such a fundamental character error, because we would have never taken him seriously as Captain again. *For the record I am a huge Fontana fan, and know she got the absolute shaft on TNG.
I've had a little headache today and thought, "Oh good, I'll just sit and watch some TNG!" I forgot this is the headache episode. It started making me feel worse. I think I'll watch later. :)
That’s actually hilarious, but I hope you feel better soon
Fun fact, in early casting calls for TNG Wesley Crusher was instead Beverly's daughter Leslie
That would've added a different dynamic to the shows, and having a young female science genius on the show would have been a perfect Trek thing to do.
It remains amusing to me that in the course of this episode, it's never mentioned that Wesley's dad died serving on the Stargazer
It was implied in the pilot, since Picard brought home Jack Crusher's body to his family.
Personally I am finding that episodes I did’nt like as much years ago don’t seem as bad as true stinkers from later years I won’t be specific but out of 178 eps. I rank only 5 or 6 as stinkers. Sometimes they are ambitious and can’t achieve it. Others times they are lost those episode yield some of the best blooper reels.
I've always thought season 1 was at least superior to season 7. Season 1 at least has a lot of energy in it. Season 7 has a lot of... BOREDOM.
Oh... Great. Merch. Sell outs. I guess i'll buy two.
Looking forward to this one! I bet it will be Josh's favorite episode so far 😉Happy November!
Yay new episode!
