💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E8 - Justice (1 of 2)
UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E8 - Justice (2 of 2)
October 27, 2023

UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E8 - Justice

Comments (63)

T
Tim Nikiforovs · June 19, 2024

I got a good laugh out of the scenario of the kid being embarrassed to be caught watching and the dad chasing him off to watch himself. I grew up is a pretty conservative house and this was one my parents didn't let me watch till I was maybe 8 or 9. Didn't end up being nearly as over sexualized as I would have thought based on that, but I do think the time all that stuff took from the episode was to it's detriment. I don't completely agree with Picard's sentiment at the end of the episode in a general sense, but "there can be no justice as long as laws are absolute" is still what I would mark as the first of Picard's memorable speeches/statements on law and/or ethics, and Stewart is starting to show his acting chops. I say I don't completely agree because I do think there are some laws which shouldn't be compromised on, and I do think there are certain offences that do warrant the death penalty, but only when guilt is proven with 100% certainty by hard evidence. There's wisdom in the idea that you structure society to steer people away from criminal behavior, and if that results in harsher sentences never being used because nobody is committing serious crimes, great, but I still think the laws should be on the books. Of course in the case of the Edo, the law is so extreme that it's impossible to justify. I expect there's some crime on Earth, but very little, and with laws nowhere near as draconian. I certainly don't think if the Edo changed their laws to a system of fines and prison sentences that made some sense in relation to the crime, they wouldn't turn into some violent, savage society. Sure, you're need more police, not just random enforcement zones coupled with relatively minor consequences even if you're caught. I do agree the ending falls a bit flat with them just slipping out with both the prime directive and the planet's laws being violated with no consequences. First, I wish there had been a line where Riker immediately offered to repair the damage and make material restitution, to show some responsibility beyond "whoops, our bad". I do think one of Picard's best scenes in the episode is when he tells Crusher he's just as scared for Wesley's life as she is, even if he doesn't show it. I would have the ending proceed much the same, though I would not have the Edo "god" release them after Picard says his line, and instead have it seem it's not going to release them. At this Picard will say something along the line of "as captain, I am responsible for the actions of my crew. Wesley's actions were a matter of clumsiness, not malice. To ask for a life in exchange for minor property damage is not reasonable. But, if you require a life, then I offer mine". This results in the Edo "god" speaking directly to those gathered asking why Picard would be willing to do this. He says that while he does not agree with the Edo laws, it's not his place to judge, and if the only way to save Wesley's life without violating the prime directive is to sacrifice himself, then he does so willingly. In response the entity tells Picard they are free to leave(the Edo won't argue with their god), and that they will consider his words, implying that legal reforms will follow. I think This ending would have worked a lot better. Lastly, the guy filling in for Worf at tactical. I dunno, he didn't seem to have the right disposition for the guy handling the ship's weapons. He'd probably work better as an engineer.

S
Sir, This is A Quark's. · June 16, 2024

It was a different... thirsty time... before the internet. "DAD! It's star trek. I just need the vcr to record it for my friends.... 😳"

S
Scarpad’s Domain · November 2, 2023

By the way “man” isn’t woman or men, it’s mankind

S
Scarpad’s Domain · November 2, 2023

Picard speech swayed the god to let them go.

R
Rhett Coates · October 29, 2023

Another great Christmas movie is for that Season and is a TV movie based upon a true story. It's "THE HOMECOMING: A CHRSTMAS STORY," and is the movie that inspired a 9-year long TV series called "The Waltons." This happened in Depression-era Virginia, and the village of Schuyler (pronounced SKY-ler), 29 miles south of real-life Charlottesville, Va.), is what is called "Walton's Mountain" in the movie and the series. I think you will be pleasantly surprised at this story, and if you choose to watch this one as well, remember that it actually happened to a real family with the last name Hamner. I have been to their town many times (it's a museum town dedicated to the Hamner family memory and the TV show), and have photos of me sitting on the front porch of their house - which still stands! (A small Star Trek connection: William Windom, who played Cmdr. Decker in TOS episode "The Doomsday Machine," is also in this movie.)

R
Rhett Coates · October 29, 2023

6Some here have already suggested "IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE" starring James Stewart. It's not necessarily a Christmas movie, but does take place at that time of year - and thus is often shown during the Season. That being said, IF YOU LIKE STAR TREK's way of telling a really good yarn - and then throwing a HUGE twist or two in the middle of it all - then THIS is the movie you two need - NEED - to see. BTW, the "making of" videos on YouTube reveal the Christmas scenes with lots and lots of snow were filmed at night during the HEAT of Summer time (about 90 to 100 degrees during filming, we're told!) where the town's sets were constructed. Frank Capra did astonishing work with the story, and it's good in both black and white (as filmed) and also in the colorized version. You choose which one you want to watch; I know what grabs me about it and makes we FEEL about life the way I do each and every time I watch it; I hope to witness how both of you react to seeing it for the first time if you haven't seen it already. I tear up tremendously in the JOY of being Given my life even when watching it in re-runs! I wont say more so as not to spoil it for you, but will note the capital "G" in Given, in the last sentence..................

J
Jef Etters · October 29, 2023

The idea that this system of Justice would be a deterrent is completely ridiculous since any time there is a danger zone, there is a white fence. Therefore, the opposite of a deterrent would occur. The citizens would have a license to commit crimes constantly anywhere they didn’t see a clearly marked fence. Even the cops stood there and let Riker assault them standing next to it. This is a faulty premise and makes the episode very hard to take seriously.

A
Anthony Bernacchi · October 29, 2023

The dialogue is unclear, but I think the white fences are permanent fixtures indicating areas not to be disturbed (such as flowerbeds). The actual punishment zones are unknown to the populace, but no one goes beyond the white barriers because that would incur the death penalty if the punishment zone happened to be there at that time.

S
StonyD · October 28, 2023

So, what's the Patreon level I need to subscribe to where you have made it to the latter half of Season Two? ; )

T
Target Audience · October 29, 2023

Hahaha

A
Anthony Bernacchi · October 28, 2023

Since you guys have repeatedly wondered about the details of the Prime Directive, here is the actual, canonical text of the first two sections of the form of the Directive in effect at a time 19 years after TNG Season 1, as it appears on a computer display later in the franchise. "Section 1: Starfleet crew will obey the following with any civilization that has not achieved a commensurate level of technological and/or societal development as described in Appendix 1. a) No identification of self or mission. b) No interference with the social, cultural, or technological development of said planet. c) No reference to space, other worlds, or advanced civilizations. d) The exception to this is if said society has already been exposed to the concepts listed herein. However, in that instance, section 2 applies. Section 2: If said species has achieved the commensurate level of technological and/or societal development as described in Appendix 1, or has been exposed to the concepts listed in section 1, no Starfleet crew person will engage with said society or species without first gathering extensive information on the specific traditions, laws, and culture of that species civilization. Then Starfleet crew will obey the following. a) If engaged with diplomatic relations with said culture, will stay within the confines of said culture's restrictions. b) No interference with the social development of said planet." Items a), b) and c) in Section 1 are paraphrased from dialogue in "Bread and Circuses." Although this text does not specify the level of development described in Appendix 1, references throughout the Star Trek franchise indicate that it refers primarily to the development of warp drive. An alternate text of General Order #1 (i.e., the Prime Directive) was featured on a prop for a scene that takes place in Captain Kirk's era, but in an alternate timeline, not the timeline depicted in TOS. It is unknown whether the prop was visible on screen and therefore whether the text is to be considered canonical: "As the rights of each sentient species to live in accordance with the normal cultural evolution is considered sacred, no Starfleet personnel may interfere with the normal and healthy development of alien life and culture. Such interference includes introducing superior knowledge, strength, or technology to a world whose society is incapable of handling such advantages wisely. Starfleet personnel may not violate the Prime Directive even to save their lives and/or their ship, unless they are acting to right an earlier violation or an accidental contamination of said culture. This directive takes precedence over any and all other considerations, and carries with it the highest moral obligation." The reference to "normal and healthy development" echoes Kirk's reasoning for his societal interference in TOS episodes such as "The Apple," and may imply that the Prime Directive was more lenient in Kirk's time than in Picard's. However, even if this alternate text is canonical, it comes from an alternate timeline version of Kirk's era, not from the familiar version.

A
Anthony Bernacchi · October 28, 2023

I apologize for my negativity in my Patron Takes comment (which, fortunately, you didn't use, and no one liked it, either). The episode is much better than I remembered, although I'm still dissatisfied with the ending -- Picard just goes ahead and breaks the Prime Directive with no real consequences. Much of what happens in the last act that Josh said is what he's hoping to see from TNG is what TNG becomes as it goes on -- Josh has a lot to look forward to.

T
Thicketdweller · October 28, 2023

The Phrase you were reaching for was: Diplomatic Immunity A phrase to be forever burned into your consciousness by the movie Lethal Weapon 2

T
Thicketdweller · October 28, 2023

Next thought relates To the Edo in the Observation Lounge Picard Calls for the Transporter and there is a long delay. I don’t recognize that Chiefs voice and don’t recall him again. It occurs to me that Picard is still, rounding out his crew, Like C. E. MacDuggle in the naked now she couldn’’t cut it against Wesley, She is gone never to be seen again probably shuffled off when they met up with the fearless, and we got C. E. Argyle, who also appears deficient . So, I’m curious how many transporter chiefs and Chief engineers we go through as Picard picks a crew he has confidence in? I would be interested in your observation on personnel changes as you notice.

J
Joe Concepts · October 29, 2023

This is one of the things that stand out as one of the strangest parts of this season, seeing the weird engineering situation. Note that in "Where No One Has Gone Before" Riker refers to Argyle as "one of our chief engineers."

T
Thicketdweller · October 28, 2023

I am not sure if it was Alex, or Josh who commented on the 24 inch model of the Galileo 7 shuttle craft on display with the other models. (Being blind haven’t worked out your voices yet, or consistently) Production Assistant John Dwyer (might have misspelled that) Found the original shooting model of Galileo in a storage closet badly damaged at the beginning of of TNG Wasn’t sure what it was and took it to Michael Okuda who recognized it immediately restored it as best he could (one side was to badly damaged.). And placed briefly in the observation lounge, which restricted camera use on set. Then Later moved it to a fix position in Commander Rykers room. The original model was thought to have been lost stolen or destroyed until J D. Found it.

P
Philbot · October 28, 2023

I feel like there’s an issue to execute a stranger, a visitor to your world. Could you imagine us doing it to some foreign vacationer?

N
Nolan · October 28, 2023

This episode is mostly just breadcrumbs. Sprinkling the PD info here and there/ Actually Alex, regarding your wondering about Patrick Stewart not wanting to be Kirk-like, when a new writer comes on at a later point, he is introduced to the cast as they are working on his episode and when he was introduced to Patrick Stewart, apparently Patrick gave him some advice: "The Captain doesn't do enough fighting or F#^$ing."

D
Duane Chancey · October 28, 2023

I gotta say this - Josh & Alex your reaction to that Reveal on the Planet with the Eloi...I mean Edo running around in those Outfits was Too funny! Great Custom running everywhere, and in those outfits. Josh from that grin you seemed to me to enjoy this one from the beginning, Alex also. I bet if this had been an HBO series at the time Roddenberry would've flipped the outfits of the men and women....as in Game of Thrones! LOL I did notice you guys seemed to have a lot less convo during this one and are watching in silence more than most eps. I could be wrong but it seemed that way. Still Batting almost 1000! 😉🖖

C
Carl Peterson · October 28, 2023

Okay episode especially for thd first year. Some good philosophical discussions and I liked how Captain Picard had to weigh his decision based upon being a captain and a friend. He could not just let Wesley die but he had to weigh thd options. He also had to fo the hard work of law and think through thd options logically but slso give tender responses to Beverly and show his own emotions. A better ending would have had more explanation on that conundrum. One must look at the letter and spirit of the law. There could have been a great speech by Picard about it. There was almost no real resolutions or even many responses to the philosophical questions with the ending we got. They might have been in a hurry to resolve the matter since they were running out of time for thd episode. They could have cut down some of the beginning. Way too long to get to the real problem. Way too many sex jokes. Or they could have made this a 2 parter but that would have been a bit much. I also hate whenever Star Trek talks about God. Way to modern for my tastes. The world moved away from that view after the 2 world wars. Okay episode but just okay because there were no resolutions. In fact a lot of thd issues that were raised as negatived are shown to be true. The federation does look at this planet now as backwards or just so primitive. They did just take Wesley and beam out. Not enough wss shown that the people thought Gox had let the crew go.

K
Ken R · October 28, 2023

This episode was weak and a watered down version of a TOS plot. The whole thing hinges on Picard/Kirk delivering a speech that is so logical, powerful, just and true, that the all-powerful god relents to the logic. Kirk would have a rousing, dramatic speech delivered with accompanying music, Picard got one sentence with no drama in his speech, Ryker added a footnote four words long, and the whole thing is resolved without any sort of journey from A to B in how they win god over. It's beige writing, it's as dramatically presented as faded wallpaper. So far the best episode was with the Traveler. 4/10

K
KatWithAttitude · October 28, 2023

Another one that I kind of enjoy, but it isn't one of the best. More of a guilty pleasure, sort of. And the first "Shut up Wesley" of the TNG era, and they don't even realize it yet.

D
David Felgate · October 28, 2023

You have to give this episode credit for keeping alive the grand Star Trek tradition of making the female guest stars wear horrible wigs.

C
Carl Peterson · October 28, 2023

Yes except I was not looking at the wig that much.

L
Lost Monk · October 28, 2023

Ugh. This episode. Planet Sex. That's what my friend and I called it back when it first came out. And I haven't seen it since. On purpose. Sorry to be sour about all these early episodes, but how can this be your favorite episode so far? The first half was poorly written and poorly directed. Drawn out, people running around half naked, making out... the story not advancing for far too long. The viewer getting bashed on the head with the same blather. It was cartoonish. Lots of broad strokes. Civilization of the Week, demonstrating One Thing (care-free running around and sexxing) , until the one Counter Thing (overly rigid law) makes its way into the story. Two extremes. Cartoony.

T
Target Audience · October 28, 2023

It had my favorite scene of the series thus far with Picard and Data, I enjoyed the on-location setting and the premise was ridiculous enough to get some laughs out of it. Low bar as I said.

M
Monty Crawford · October 27, 2023

Seeing as how you guys are enjoying the first season so far...you are gonna love the rest. Season two really starts getting the mojo.

N
Nerd's Gold · October 27, 2023

I think I like this even less than I remember from the first time I watched it. There are good interactions between characters in this, but the overall story is dumb. The whole episode was them repeating over and over how they can't violate the Prime Directive, the consequences would be dire, we can't violate the Prime Directive... and the solution? Oh, we'll just violate the Prime Directive.

G
Glenn Johnson Barnes · October 27, 2023

Plus the fact that by making contact (transporter and all) with a pre-warp civilization they’re already violating the prime directive.

M
Mike Rogers · October 27, 2023

Funny, I saw it much like you when I first saw the episode. Now, I see the cringe. But you put me back in touch with my thoughts about my first viewing.

M
Mark Chrisco · October 27, 2023

From the first time I saw this episode years ago, there were two obvious outs for Wesley, They could have used the Code of Honor tact by beaming a dying Wes up to be revived, allowing the Edo to have their "justice". Or, giving a more tragic ending would be one of the other youngsters taking the blame and being executed. A life lesson for all involved.

C
Carl Peterson · October 28, 2023

When Wesley said he was part of the decision I thought he was going to lay down his life for the rest of the crew. That would have been interesting. They could have killed him and then the God like creatures could have brought him back alive on thd Enterprise. Maybe not the best ending but better than what we got.

M
Mike Rogers · October 27, 2023

I want to start a drinking game when one of the crew says " Wesley... the BOY?"

W
WEB · October 27, 2023

Yeah, you're right in how you took my comment on objectivity (and my wondering if I lack it when it comes to TNG or Trek in general)... I've been watching Star Trek basically my whole life.. but I really haven't engaged in any discourse with an online community about it. And so when the poorly ranked episodes come around and they're just getting torn to shreds in the comments but all I really want to comment on is what I liked about it, I do sometimes feel like I'm missing a bone meant for critical thinking lol. I'm not even a very positive person! I tend to be quite negative! Just not about Star Trek ;)

S
Steven Johnson · October 27, 2023

Okay, that "WOKE GARBAGE!" Right at the beginning made me spit my soda everywhere.

S
Steven Johnson · October 27, 2023

Wesley's "It's about this long and this thick" thing gets taken out of context all the time, by the way.

A
Analog Mind · October 27, 2023

Oh Boy! The episode where they visit Hitler's Orgey Planet

W
WEB · October 27, 2023

I could tell you guys were digging it. You were locked in most of the runtime

N
Numinous2019 · October 27, 2023

Roddenberry suddenly developed a revised idea of ST during the late 1970's/early 1980's, where humanity had overcome their weaknesses, especially their collective weaknesses. This is the basis for why the season 1 episodes have such thin plots. The characters also feel like cyphers for Roddenberry to propound on his new vision. The Ferengi intended as the contrast to the evolved humans, as well as many of the alien races encountered. It's a very limiting foundation and the thrown-together writing team struggled to find ways of working within Roddenberry's template. If TNG had arrived without the pop culture support of TOS, then I don't think the series would have been able to continue to season 3 without serious cost-cutting.

A
Analog Mind · October 27, 2023

Ironically the portrayal of these "brave new evolved humans" in Season 1 came off as Inhuman most of the time

C
Chris S. · October 27, 2023

Solid episode. Allegory….Star Trek does it best! Thats what caused such a huge fanbase. The intelligence and philosophy behind many of the stories is unmatched.

J
JD Nevesytrof · October 27, 2023

There's no reason Worf wouldn't know what Rome is...but we'll find that out later.

L
Lost Monk · October 28, 2023

Regarding Rome, I thought the same thing. But in fairness, the creators didn’t know how Worf was going to evolve. ‘Nuff said for now.

J
JD Nevesytrof · October 27, 2023

Loved Josh's helpless laughter at the Edo outfits, that was the appropriate response.

J
James H · October 27, 2023

I wasn’t following TNG during season 1, but my sister was really into it, so I used to irritate her by calling Picard and Riker “the bald guy” and “the real captain.” Good memories.

J
Jonathan · October 27, 2023

Haven’t rewatched this episode in 30 years but this is one I think of when people say they hate the first season. This isn’t a bad episode just a bit of a boring one, but “the away team gets into some stupid problem and then gets rescued” episodes are my least favorite unless it’s a vehicle for some character growth. This episode would have played better if Picard had debated the “god” ship instead of just oh they let us beam up so I guess we can leave. Talking about characters getting focus for trek moving forward since they want to give each actor something they usually alternate which character gets the bigger focus each episode. Rewatching all the episodes I do like to see the subtle character growth. Part of it is they haven’t figured out what each characters role on the ship is so they keep trying things. They don’t get a clear handle until the next season which is part of why this season annoys fans because so much stuff is against the norms that everyone got used to.

C
Collin Freeman · October 27, 2023

I like this episode for the most part because Star Trek at its best is always when it tackles tough social issues. Here we have capital punishment as the focus. I agree with Josh - this episode showed me there was hope for the series. Negatives: I dislike the dialog the writers gave Wesley - sounds like what 60-year men think kids would say, like in Lassie or Leave it to Beaver. Also, we have more of Picard being a dick at times, which is why I didn't start to like his character until the 2nd season. And having Tasha being a horn-dog I find to be distasteful considering she grew up around rape gangs. Horny Gene had to have his beautiful people running around half-naked and have sex at the drop of a hat (wish fulfillment?) Which was not what part of what the original writer John D. F. Black (TOS Naked Time writer) had in his story .

D
David Crabtree · October 27, 2023

At least with Tasha, we'll get to see her grow beyond this type of episode with her character growth over the next several seasons.

J
Jeff Cornell · October 27, 2023

Once you get past the first half of the episode and into the part where Wesley is up for execution, it gives me similar vibes to A Taste of Armageddon, where the planet is in a simulated war and everyone calculated as a casualty has to step into a suicide booth. Though of course Kirk had absolutely no hesitation about wrecking the status quo of that planet.

D
David Wayne Fox · October 27, 2023

Upon rewatching this I actually liked it better than I remember. I still think the ending is weak though.

C
Ca$hWednesday · October 27, 2023

Even with the weird horniness, costumes, and dialogue in the first part of this episode, the ending really is what brings it down for me. It's the first real Prime Directive episode, and they just kind of ignore it and dip with no repercussions.

A
AzoriusMage · October 27, 2023

He put the pin on her so that the chief could lock on

C
Carl Peterson · October 28, 2023

But how did the chief know to beam her and not another person wearing a pon? I think they kind of skip over some dialogue that would help so the pace is better.

A
AzoriusMage · October 27, 2023

Curious that Geordi's visor can see more than the sensors

P
Phillip Grischa · October 27, 2023

That never made a lot of sense to me, if they miniaturize technology like that to work in the visor it should be trivial to have regular sized sensors that can do the same on the ship.

A
AzoriusMage · October 27, 2023

Nice, the first real horny Riker episode

G
Glenn Johnson Barnes · October 27, 2023

Wesley’s cringe inducing “there are some games I don’t know yet”.. When you’re done with TNG if you get a chance to check out Will Wheaton’s take on some of these first season episodes, it’s so worth the time!

M
Michael Nemo · October 27, 2023

Oh dear. What a slog to get through.

C
Ca$hWednesday · October 27, 2023

I call this the "Wesley, get off my grass" episode. There's some interesting stuff here once you get over the ridiculousness of the crime. but there's also a lot of Wesley... for better or worse depending on whether you like or despise his character.

G
Glenn Johnson Barnes · October 27, 2023

Much like Troi, my affection for Wesley has more to do with my love for the actor..I will say Wesley and Troi both get a lot more character growth through the series.

R
Rich Cirivilleri · October 27, 2023

Another episode I have almost no memory of it all. Just something about Wesley stepping on a flower or something and they want to chop his — off or something. It should be interesting to rewatch with you all. Looking forward to it.

D
Dion James Pitman · October 27, 2023

One thing I'll say about this episode is that the Tillman Water Reclamation plant is an absolutely stunning location

R
Rich Cirivilleri · October 28, 2023

Back in the aughts, are used to live in Van Nuys and commuted to Encino so I went by that spot every day. I never thought about it for this episode though because it was used so much better and more effectively in some future installments of Star Trek. It’s a great place to grab a Subway sandwich and eat there. I could write a book about Star Trek locations I’ve picnicked at over the years. God, how unspeakably dull.