UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E5 - The Last Outpost
Comments (65)
Yeah, this is one I never quite got the hate for. It's certainly far from a great episode, and it's rather ridiculous that they chose to have the ferengi act like "pygmy cretins" as Worf said and expect they're going to be the big bads of TNG. But underneath all that I love the addition of the Tkon Empire to the lore of the Star Trek universe. Portal was a pretty interesting character, and I've always wished we would learn more about him and the Tkon. While it's not canon(alpha canon anyway), we do actually see Portal again in the recent Star Trek Resurgence video game. At this point they were clearly still struggling with how best to use most of the cast, but Riker at least was starting to find his groove a bit more. Data's desire to learn more about being human obviously stuck around, but the way it's executed later on is so much better. At this point it's presented as a distraction from his duties, and it makes him feel aloof regarding his job. Mostly just alright as episodes go, but the lore drop does help balance out the negatives.
As others have said, the Ferengi get much more tolerable as the seasons progress. They were supposed to be dangerous rivals to the Federation, but they just work better as capitalistic scammers.
In Roddenberry's mind, money was responsible for a lot of pain in humankind and so ultra-capitalists probably seemed like ideal villains to him. Of course, he was a hypocrite because he would work the system however he could to make a buck, including starting up Lincoln Enterprises to make money off of Star Trek memorabilia and putting lyrics to the original Star Trek theme so he would earn royalty money anytime the music was used (even though Alexander Courage never wrote it to have lyrics).
In TOS it was "landing party", in TNG it is "away team". You mixed it to "away party".
Sadly, this is where the episode goes into political messaging and preaching where you have the Ferangi who are said to be capitalist and the actors were given instructions literally to act like angry gerbils, while you have our Heroes like Riker standing tall and proud the messaging becomes clear and it’s on the level of propaganda.
The only one here who is preaching propaganda is YOU.
Data was comic relief early on and that will change
Picard not beaming down is gonna be forgotten pretty quick
This Ep. was ok, I did like it more when it first aired than now because the Ferengi acted like such Annoying, Hyper & Wormy little Runts! It is a good thing they toned them down in later Eps. 😀🖖
The Ferengi start out annoying but end up fantastic. Takes awhile. Yes, Riker was supposed to be the charming “Kirk” of TNG. But he does become a good, distinct character., not a type of a past character. Yknow you guys are reminding me how I did enjoy most of this, even in the weaker first two seasons, because it was Trek.
I always thought this episode was okay. The Ferengi take some getting used to. "I'm not sure if i love them or hate them". Yes, this but I think you will eventually love them more than hate them, even more so if/when you get to the next show.
My parents were TOS fans and definitely were not keen on TNG to start with, but both knew about Patrick Stewart and mum liked Jonathan Frakes in North and South so they kept watching. By season 3 the whole family was watching the show together, literally the only show we ever watched together. Fond memories.
Wow - I enjoyed this episode way more this time around I still don't think the Ferengi worked here, but there was a lot of great stuff in this episode
This was boring and awful and a great example of why I abandoned this show so quickly. There was never any sense of rising stakes, the script and director did nothing to instill any sense of drama. The crew speak their lines so blasé, so there is never anything creating excitement or interest. The color palette is very muted and the video quality looks awful compared to the film quality of TOS. On the planet the Ferengi never posed any sort of serious threat and even at the moment they knock the crew out all that happens is two seconds later the crew wakes up. Then this god-like character pops up and nobody is impressed much by him either. And then these munchkin Ferengi just prancing around for no reason. Back on the ship the doctor is hearing her son will die and barely can muster a reaction. This episode has no pulse. 3/10.
I hope you didn’t completely give up on this show forever back then. It gets so much better.
Thank you! Not my favorite episode but I can find something to enjoy in all episodes and it's so fun watching you experience them for the first time.
Where are the bad episodes? To paraphrase a quote from one of my favorite movies: "If you wait for them, they will come." Every season has at least one or two...lesser episodes. Some more than others.
The lead Ferengi on the ground team (the one making all the accusations), is none other than Armin Shimerman, whom you must certainly remember as Principal Snyder from the later episodes of Buffy season 1, after the first principal was eaten by hyena-possessed bullies.
As far as generations enjoying TOS and TNG… I can tell you my perspective. In 1987, TOS had just premiered in rerun syndication on the FOX network five days a week. Nickelodeon was airing the TAS on weekends. I’m in Syracuse, NY. TNG premiered and would air on, like Saturday evening. So, all three shows were going strong.
Yes, Gene Roddenberry intended Ferengi to be the main Federation nemesis. At the time, they were building them up for fans, not showing what they looked like until this episode. What we got was a caricature of the 80's cut throat capitalist. Where the Federation was all about being beyond money and the acquisition of wealth, it was what dominated the Ferengi. Yes, they were more goofy than menacing. Also, some have made a charge that these aliens wallow in Jewish stereotypes (which I think is a huge reach) . So... yeah... this episode might be racist too. LOL
People can say what they will about the Ferengi, I do feel like they are one of the best Star Trek alien makeup designs.
For Worf's Sash, it's actually the same sash John Collicos wore as Kor in the TOS episode Errand Of Mercy. In universe it's just a Klingon sash used to show off the emblem of what house you belong too. Not a required choice for a Klingon, just an optional way to show off you family crest
The show definitely takes a minute to find its feet.
IDK if this is a *spoiler alert* (sort of?) Ferengi episodes *throughout* ST are hit and miss. In this one they did seem extremely hyper. They do calm tf down. Some Ferengi characters in the future you may love; others you may hate. You'll rarely be bored lol.
You will find that Worf does get his ass kicked throughout the series.
Except against other Klingons
I noticed for the first time how much makeup comes off on Brent Spiner's finger when he get's the finger trap off.
High Definition remastering can have some downsides for sure lol
Wow I'd forgotten that this was First Contact w/Ferengi and I was tempted to use the classic line from a later show: "Didn't they teach you about Ferengi at the Academy??"
Can’t we just skip ahead to Tapestry, or Cause and Effect, or Yesterday’s Enterprise, or Time’s Arrow? I guess not. Josh and Alex…. This is NOT the TNG yet to come. For all your analysis right now…. this will wind up being the season you have no interest in thinking about again. Thankfully, the storytelling, characterization, and even the actor performances improve considerably. Everyone — without spoilers, am I wrong?
You're wrong in wanting to skip part of the journey, good or bad, just to get well down the river to what you consider good. Josh and Alex are enjoying this section of Trek history far more than many of us did, and we should envy them, not pity them.
Yup. Terrible episode. Sorry, folks. I can’t sugar coat this. And I think the Ferengi suck until Armin’s second contribution.
One of my favorite things about TNG (and other Star Trek series onward) is the ensemble. All of the command staff have important roles - not in every episode, but most. The captain confers with his group of experts. It's not just the Captain and/or his top 2 friends providing the majority of the input. It's more realistic in that the captain is not a know-it-all or can-do-it-all.
Barbaric Hu-mans!
Quark and DS9 goes along way to redeem the ferengi.
That is an understatement, but totally true: I wish DS9 wasn't so far off for Josh & Alex to see; it also had a rocky start but got INCREDIBLY good!
I did have a good chuckle at just straight up calling Josh's feelings on the Ferengi. I THINK the implication is that those two boys Riker rushed out of the conference room were the ones that left the finger trap, but it wasn't focused on enough to be clear. Worf's sash is from the first appearance of the Klingons back in "Errand of Mercy." In fact, it is the exact same sash worn by John Collicos as Kor in that episode. Worf's actor was apparently very fond of his unique wardrobe accessory. This show will just get better and better at highlighting its whole crew.
Yeah the kids left behind the finger trap. That's how I read it too
The Ferengi were this species here with the big ears. The people in the pilot were called the Bandi, and the two shapeshifting "jellyfish" creatures did not have a proper name.
Roddenberry tries the concept of the Ferengi again, using another unsubtle character in the season 1 finale. And, yes, the Ferengi were supposed to be the TNG main 'bad guys', which lasted about several more episodes before petering out.
I think you have already assessed how you will always feel about the Ferengi
I could see Josh's "Joke Mode" start to warm up during the first finger-trap scene. Lol Also, every time Alex calls Yar, "Tar"...😏 ...no spoilers, but Holy Shit!
Right? I WISH I could have seen my own face when I heard him call her Tar.. 😂
I've said before that I am glad that you think the episodes are good and are enjoying all of them. I think the perception of them being bad comes from a combination of things but mostly down to repeated viewing. The later stories are just that much better and the characters feel fully formed and not the slightly awkward clunkiness here. So when you've seen the whole series and come back to early stories, it feels very weird. Even the direction choices, the music, etc. I won't say this episode is bad but it definitely does the Ferengi dirty since they didn't know what to do with them.
I think I wouldn't have minded them not thinking about the planet for so long if Troi hadn't literally said they've been ignoring the planet followed by everyone continuing to ignore the planet while considering surrendering to the ferengi.
Worf's sash is a callback to a similar one worn by Kor, the first Klingon, from TOS's Errand of Mercy.
Not just a callback, it IS the sash worn by Kor, John Collicos himself back in the '60s.
Enjoyed revisiting this episode and the first appearance of the Ferengi. They're not really used well here, but they're definitely entertaining down the line, whether you love them or hate them! They get their best episodes in DS9 in my opinion.
I had this one on vhs back in the day. There’s a campy charm to it, but everyone gets some character moments. Early on TNG suffers from pacing and a lack of tension. Even when the crew is in a “life or death” situation, it just never seems serious. Fortunately that’s something the show overcomes when they finally figure out it’s a 80s/90s show, and not a 60s show..
There is something kind of fun in hearing you ask if they will figure this out and that out. Figure out Data? Yes they will. They pretty much figure out everyone. Troi's character especially early on was made fun of for just being "I sense they're angry, sir." She ends up being used better in the future. This really is in major contrast to TOS an ensemble show. In that way, it's much more a show of its time. Whereas in TOS you have to settle for "Oh, that was a nice little scene for Sulu," versus this series where everyone gets a lot of focus. Granted, if you had seven years of TOS, that would've been more likely.
There's a bit more elaboration on the Prime Directive to notice here. When Riker admits that sometimes they withhold advanced tech from beings they deem not ready for it, as well as not always stepping into conflicts between two other species.
It's good you guys liked this one, and I don't think there's anything in particular that stands out as terrible. I just always felt they take a very long time to basically get to nothing that special. The "humans are evolving but are pretty good already" was kind of covered in conversations with Q. It's a common refrain in many Trek episodes. And the opening parts with the Ferengi reminded me again of the parts with the Ligonians where it was all about arguing with unreasonable aliens. I see this as one of the episodes that becomes forgettable, as we often get in 25 episode seasons.
"If you want battle come to me!!!" Gotta love Worf. They had no idea what to do with him early on, but between Dorn's performance and a few hints along the way he actually has a marvelous evolution in the years to come. I like the universe Judged on intent, this episode fails. The Ferengi were basically supposed to be the Klingons of TNG, and this episode sorta.... Faceplants, the lead Ferengi actor even apologized because he feels his performance is to blame. I think it's a mixture of the make up, writing, and the performances. They don't look particularly threatening when you see them in full. I absolutely love the lore element of the universe though. This ancient species. We've heard about others from hundreds of thousands of years in the past.
It was a pleasure to do, and I'm so glad that so many people showed up for it.
Josh is right about the planet numbering, it's the order of planets from sun out, so Earth would also be called Sol III.
I was going to relate that small detail; JD beat me to it. That was far more subtle in TOS/TAS, but was hinted at - now it's canon.
Nothing to do with the episode in particular, but have you guys noticed the tiny tiny person moving through the observation lounge on top of the saucer section during the last ship pass-through of the opening credits? The FX guys were very proud of that.
I loved the story on the blu-ray about how they found the little scrap of film in the archives for that animation and remastered that as well.
Worf's sash is a Klingon baldric that he uses to hold the symbol of his family House as well as signify he's officially a Klingon warrior as well as a Starfleet officer.
Yeahhhh..The Ferengi don't really come into their own until Deep Space Nine. There is so much great stuff ahead, that it's fun watching the expanded world building from the beginning again.
Please forgive this whole season...
I meant to say Ferengi, not friends
I’m looking forward to this one. I have almost no memory of this episode. I saw it once almost 40 years ago. All I remember I think is the massive friend he had on the view screen which I thought was really awful, and some pumpkin headed alien on the planet surface who turned out to be a nice guy. And that. Is. It.
First. The Ferengi were still in Flux
Aww yes!
