EARLY ACCESS - Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home is HILARIOUS & Heartwarming | NEW Star Trek fans Discuss
Comments (18)
Great review! The whole not knowing what the whales are saying to the space probe fits with the whole human arrogance theme. The arrogance of humans to think they are entitled to hunt to extinction a species that they think is inferior, only to realize too late that that species is what could have saved them. As Spock says earlier in the film: "Only human arrogance would assume that the message is meant for them." To the space probe, humans were beneath their notice; they were communicating long-distance with the whales. Of course the final message should be above the audience's heads and be a mystery. I imagine that the whales at the end said, "Don't kill them. They may have been stupid once, but this lot just brought us here, so there's hope!" :)
I just realized something. You guys mentioned how it was possible that Back to the Future might have been an influence for the time travel portion of the story. This movie and BTTF are two films released within a year and a half apart from one another, and in both of them a dead Christopher Lloyd has his ride taken from him, where it's then used to go back in time to get some stuff done, and then brought back to the future. Mind you in Star trek, most of these events occur over two films, but it's basically the same.
Mark Lenard played an interesting alien in an episode of Buck Rogers.
I have a strong theory that these guys are going to LOVE Final Frontier. Seriously. That movie is nothing but an episode of TOS with a budget. It will be right up their alley.
Glad you loved it. Hate to say it, but STV is gonna suck like an 8 pound Oreck ....
Sad but true. To all you apologists out there, saying, “Star Trek 5 is underrated,” or “Star Trek 5 isn’t that bad” . . . you’re lying to yourselves.
Many think that Back To The Future inspired the time travel. But it was probably more the fact that Nick Meyer (co writer of this movie) had done a movie called Time After Time (which maybe you should do a reaction of someday) where H.G. Wells goes forward in time to stop Jack the Ripper who stole HG's Time Machine. I had read somewhere that a lot of the fish out of water gags that did not make TAT were used in trek 4.
I don't think anything like Malcom MacDowell ordering a big mac, fries, and large coke in that hilarious nasally voice would have quite worked in the star trek world, lol. It's also wild, I was a kid during this time, I LOVED time after time (David Warner going on to be the villain in literally all my favorite movies) but I never connected it to being at all like ST4.
It always seemed to me that Kirk's remark "they're still using money" just referred to hard cash as opposed to electronic credits. Certainly not that there wasn't some medium of exchange in the future.
Walter Koenig once said "you scream once, you're a screamer forever." He screamed a couple of times in TOS, then in three or the four movies!
It's important to remember that these movies only form a trilogy after the fact. They never set out to make a trilogy, there was no three movie deal. Nowadays they sign contracts to do trilogies from the get-go. Star Trek films were made one at a time, and the next one was only greenlit after the current one made money. They easily could have pulled the plug after Wrath of Khan if it had not been a success. 3, 4, and 5 were very much written as "what happened last time? Okay let's do this next."
I am glad I joined your patreon the day and I love your reactions. Now I know you are watching the movies in release order in conjunction i guess with TNG but I think that is strange.....Kirks crew is 80 years before TNG so not sure why you wouldn't just watch the other 2 movies of TOS first. Either way I love your reactions.
Thanks! We think sticking strictly to release order is best. That is why we are starting TNG now. We will get to experience Star Trek in the order fans did when it was releasing.
I'm from Iowa myself, and I have been accused of having my head in the clouds.
“I’m from Iowa, I just work in outer space” is the most lol line in Star Trek, probably because it’s so true..
I always wondered if Gillian's colleagues on Earth thought she killed herself. She just disappears without a trace after driving away from the Institute in a rage after finding out the whales were gone.
It would have been funny if like Gillian had stayed in the past she’d marry a man named Cochrane and had a grandson named Zefram..oops
Star Trek IV was the most successful of the original cast films in terms of ticket sales, largely because many people went to watch it who were not Star Trek fans. It was more relatable because of the 1980's setting and the comedy. Hard to do a 2 hour film and give the audience everything it wants from the characters in 1 film. With a series, you can do that by spreading things out over a season (or more). But like you both noted, they gave us something over the course of these 4 films that together are like watching continuing TOS episodes. Shatner is as good (or better) a comedic actor as he is a dramatic one. Airplane 2 is largely not worth watching, but seeing his over-the-top performance makes it worth a look.
