POLL: Next Patreon Exclusive Movie Reaction
Below is a combination of the highest ranking movies from the last poll that did not win and some new additions we have been recommended. Keep in mind this will be a FULL UNCUT reaction, so you will need to sync with your own copy. If there are different versions of the film chosen we will cross that bridge if/when we get there.
Any movie that exceeds 10% of the vote but does not win will stay on for the next poll, and please continue to give other suggestions for the next poll as well.
Neither Alex or Josh has seen any of these movies
Comments (34)
Jason and the Argonauts was amazing!
My suggestion is Don Chaffey's 1963 Jason and the Argonauts film, which I think is interesting for the score (composed by Bernard Herrmann who is known for his collaboration with Hitchcock) and the top-notch stop motion special effects (this is peak stop-motion, imo). I also think there are elements in there of healthy, non-toxic masculinity and camaraderie. It's also a great adventure based on a classical tale. Just something to keep in mind. Don Chaffey also directed our main man Shatner in the TV series "T.J. Hooker", so there's a connection for ya! As for voting I went for 12 Angry Men, which I urge you to watch even if you don't end up reacting to it; it's definitely one of the most important films of the 20th century and its message resonates to this day.
I had trouble voting, but went with 12 Angry Men. It’s different from your usual fare on the channel, and might be a tad slow for you. I ended up choosing it precisely because it is different.
Future suggestions, Rocky, The Shawshank Redemption or The Martian.
I voted for 12 Angry Men. I'd just love to see you guys react to more classic films, as I'm a classic film fan. If you haven't already seen it, I'd like to recommend both "It's a Wonderful Life" (1946) starring James Stewart and "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" (1939) also starring James Stewart. Both films are directed by Frank Capra and I have the feeling you'd really like his films. I'd also like to see you react to some Alfred Hitchcock films, my two favorites being "Dial M For Murder" (1954) starring Ray Milland and Grace Kelly, and "Rear Window" (1954) starring James Stewart and Grace Kelly.
Love ‘Wonderful Life’ & ‘Mr. Smith’ James Stewart is such a great actor!
All of these are great choices, except for Legend. Wife and I rewatched it a couple of years ago and it just was not as good as I remembered it. I must have been drunk the first time. But I picked 12 Angry Men because of the different genre, not to mention it's a damn good movie.
If you watch Tombstone, there are tons of Western movies after that. I don't know which ones you would find faced-paced enough for you. I remember liking The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance and High Noon which are black and white movies, but I haven't seen either one in decades. Then there is William Shatner's 1968 movie White Comanche which "is listed in Golden Raspberry Award founder John Wilson's book The Official Razzie Movie Guide as one of the 100 Most Enjoyably Bad Movies Ever Made."
If you have never seen My Cousin Vinny, you could watch that after Twelve Angry Men, as that is about the only other popular courtroom movie found on reaction channels.
That is a brilliant movie!
To be honest, for a lot of this kind of stuff, I would prefer you just did a post-watch review or an edited for YouTube reaction) rather than a full length reaction. I mean, I’ve seen “Twelve Angry Men” a few times. And it’s not the kind of thing (like Star Trek or Galactica) for which I’ll be willing to hunt down the stream or even purchase it online or on DVD (like I did for Galactica) just because I want to watch it along with you. I don’t really need to see it again. That’s why I’m not watching the full length “Quantum Leap” reactions. I don’t really want to hunt it down, I saw most of it when it originally aired, and it’s not really something I live enough to re-watch anyway. (Luckily, “Firefly” was easily accessible on streaming.) Also keeping full-length reactions synched up is a pain in the kiester.
Well we are doing discussion videos on these for YouTube so there you go
12 Angry Men and Tombstone are great in various ways. You should probably re-watch the Star Trek episode Spectre of the Gun before or after watching Tombstone. Time After Time is neat as it is by Star Trek's Nicholas Meyer, but I don't remember much about it as perhaps I never saw the whole movie. I don't know as much about the other three. I have never seen The Abyss, but there are lots of crazy stories about that movie.
That made me curious.. what kind of crazy stories? Like, behind the scenes making-of type stories? Drama and/or scandal? Can you point me in the direction of what to look up?
Such a good poll. Hard to choose but went with 12 Angry Men for something different. Suggestions for future polls. Final Countdown and Flight of the Navigator. Both sci-fi movies.
Time After Time
Come on '12 Angry Men'!
Picked Last Starfighter. The only other one on the list I’ve seen is The Abyss, and I don’t think that’s actually a good James Cameron movie. I think it’s actually bad.
Felt like I had to vote 12 Angry Men since I proposed it initially and it’s a favourite movie I haven’t seen for ages but I’ve never seen The Last Starfighter…
Non-spoilery fun fact: Time After Time was made by Nicholas Meyer, one of the main writers of Star Treks 2, 4, and 6 as well as Director of 2 and 6! For that reason I'm giving it the vote, although there are several of these I'd like y'all to see!
Another fun fact about Time After Time - the great David Warner has a prominent role in it. No spoilers so obviously not saying who but Mr. Warner appears in multiple roles in the Star Trek franchise over the years.
Not even a choice. Tombstone all the way!
12 Angry Men is one of my favs. Great bottle movie!
I'm very happy to see Tombstone on the list and even though for now I'm sticking with The Abyss, I really hope Tombstone can get watched soon. A true story that happened in your own country's not too long ago history, that unlocks an understanding of a TOS episode you don't currently have. Chalk full of badass characters and quotable lines. Maybe just maybe it'll spark some more interest in the genre. And if it doesn't, well now we know. As for The Abyss... it's James Cameron. C'mon everyone. ;)
I gotta go with Tombstone. They're all excellent choices, and you can't go wrong with any of them, but knowing the perspectives of both gentlemen on the subject it might make for a very dynamic conversation piece.
I would throw in on Tombstone but now I feel like I have to spend my point on merely keeping The Abyss alive for next time... while "reaction channel staple" 12 Angry Men runs away with it... 🙄😂
Tombstone?!?! Oh Josh. I wouldn’t do that to you!
Ooh Tombstone! I know Josh isn’t into western, but this is the one to start with!
I mean they weren't into Star Trek either, until they watched it. (cut to cosplaying wrestle battles)
The only one of these I've seen is 12 Angry Men. I watched it myself for the first time about a year and a half ago and it immediately became one of my all time favorites. I have little to no interest in any of the others, so guess which one I voted for.
Gahhhhh. all good choices, Tombstone is a classic, but so is 12 Angry Men. However, I haven't seen The Last Starfighter in a few decades. That could be postponed for another time, (as a double feature with Flight of the Navigator?? ;) )
Well, only one of these is considered to be one of the greatest films ever made. But, don't let that sway you!
The Last Starfighter IS a great choice! :)
I'm your huckleberry 🤠
