UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TAS ep22 - The Counter-Clock Incident
It's the final episode of TAS! Is it good?
Here is our full uncut reaction to The Counter-Clock Incident
Thank you for being a Patron & enjoy!
Comments (19)
TOS (and TASs) Sex Scoreboard The end but the movie start. Kirk 12 Chekov 4 Spock 4 Bones 4 Scottie 2 Uhura 1 Extras: Robert +1 Sarah +1 Oh yeah one last freaky-deaky before getting old again. I would not have gone back old. Now on to the movies. We will use the above board going into the movies. There is a couple of stretches here but I feel it is consistent on scoring.
That skit at the end was like an X Files episode teaser. Ok, that wraps TAS. I definitely like this ep more than Turnabout Intruder. Obviously the production quality was much higher there, but this one was just a nice way to end the five year mission. We get this new lore on the Enterprise's first captain and his wife, and they get to go on one last adventure together. It's a sweet little story. Obviously the whole thing makes no sense at all, but it was still an interesting concept all the same. My first thought with the Aprils was that because they were younger and we saw the others losing their memories as they got younger, I assumed they had also lost all the memories of their later years and wanted them back. But then how would he know that he wouldn't want to change anything. Even if he didn't remember, his past would be intact, and they would just have time to add to those experiences. Yeah I'd definitely take the opportunity in their shoes. It was also very generous of Karla 5 to give them her ship. Her planet, Arret, aside from meaning stop in French, is also Terra backwards which is the Latin word for Earth. Would have been cool seeing an Earth where the continents are the oceans and vice versa. We also get the second reference in 2 episodes to Capella IV from Friday's Child, the Minara supernova from The Empath, and the Beta Niobe supernova from All Our Yesterdays. So a few references, much like Turnabout Intruder. Anyway, on to the movies.
I feel the Aprils would have decided to stay young so they could live their bliss for another 50 years.
That "skit" at the end of your reaction was funny with surprisingly good cinematography. Well done. On to the movies! I can"t wait.
Fun fact, Robert April was the name of the captain in Gene Roddenberry's first proposal for Star Trek, which was never filmed. Then Christopher Pike for the first pilot "The Cage", and finally James Kirk for the actual series. So they decided to make the canonical history of Enterprise captains match the history of the show's development. Edit: I see now Retro Tom beat me to the punch on this.
Robert April is portrayed in Strange New Worlds - with a twist. His wife, Sarah, has not been introduced yet, but just give SNW time and more seasons..... we're waiting for that day. The actor who portrays Robert April on SNW is exceptionally good, showing respect, great leadership and love for those around him, and like many other aspects of TAS, many items, people, species and back-story from The Animated Series (1973/1974) are making their way into the Star Trek shows and movies that came after it.
Since you were trying to figure it out, the way it goes is Robert April commanded The Enterprise when it launched from 2245-2250. Pike took over for a 5 year run from 2250-2255. The ship then went under a 10 year massive overhaul & refit pretty much only keeping the outer hull & expanding the crew capacity from 200 to 430. in 2265 Kirk took command & the ship was relaunched
It's possible this is a retcon, but I'm pretty sure Pike had two five-year missions. Strange New Worlds is currently set I think 7 years before the start of TOS. With The Cage having taken place about 6 years earlier in Pike's first five-year mission, and the premier of SNW being the start of his second. So I think it goes: Robert April commands 2245-2250 Pike commands 2250-2255 (The Cage) Enterprise has a couple years downtime for repair and refurbishment Pike commands approximately 2257-2262 (SNW) Enterprise has another few years downtime for upgrades. Kirk commands 2265-2270 (TOS)
As I said in a previous comment, next to Yesteryear, this is my second favorite episode of the animated series. There are only a couple other episodes of TAS that I liked, but I enjoyed this one because of Robert and Sarah April and the lore. Speaking of lore, in the Menagerie, Spock states he served under Captain Christopher Pike for 11 years, 4 months, 5 days, I would assume by that statement that Pike had at least 2 tours of duty as the Enterprise captain after Robert April and before James Kirk.
May not be quite the end for TAS. As we speak, a certain company is making plans to produce a live-action version of the animated episodes using actors, advanced deepfake technologies and CGI. Saw a test CGI Arex that looked pretty good.
There are several YouTube videos showing OTHER EPISODES actually voice by TOS cast, and could easily be "finished" to add to TAS canon. Here's the title to look up on YouTube: "Star Trek: TAS Continues | Demon World | Proof of Concept".
An enjoyable episode that tips a little more towards fantasy than the usual Star Trek. Alan Dean Foster did novel adaptions of the animated episodes and they were on varying lengths. Most of the books carried short stories of three of the episodes. Some were longer making it two. Counter Clock Incident was one of a few to get a full book length adaption. When you read it, you discover the events of the actual episode are covered in roughly the first half. The rest of it was a story that eventually winds up demonstrating that the events of the episode were some sort of hallucination since the author obviously thought a universe where people were born old out of people who were young was ludicrous.
I have that book (somewhere) and read it many years ago. My favorite part was the beginning with a flashback to when April was named as the first captain of the Enterprise.
When developing Star trek, one of Gene Roddenberry's early drafts the ship captain was named Robert April. They added Robert April here & said he commanded the Enterprise prior to Pike as a nod to that & Gene was tickled by it so this was the only part of the Animated series he considered canon
The last line of each series... Star Trek TOS: "If only... If only..." Star Trek TAS: "It gave all of us a second life."
101 down, 790 to go lol Fun fact: Beta Niobe was the impending supernova in "All Our Yesterdays", which caused the inhabitants of its orbiting planet Sarpeidon to flee to their planet's earlier time periods. So an extra bit of continuity in addition to the mentions of Babel. And I think this might be the first time San Francisco's importance is hinted at.
Also, the flower was from Capella IV, the “Friday’s Child” planet.
April is African-American now...
Must be one of the side effects
