PATRON TIER LIST - VOY S2E15 - Threshold

Could be any grade from A to E. Goes all the way round the horn from terrible to laughably good plus RDM puts in a tongue spittingly good performance putting the man in salamander.

I like when Tom is mid transition in sick bay, but the ending really pulls this down for me.

I don't think I've ever seen a poll this evenly spread out before.

No level of excellent acting/directing can save a terrible premise/writing. A bad episode is just a bad episode.

In a weird sort of way this one is growing on me the more I watch it. It's really not a bad episode... I just don't know how it goes from an interesting story with quite a bit of potential to, well, whatever it is we got in the last 8 minutes.

I couldn’t believe the pass you guys gave this episode for it’s…“quirkiness” I guess. But it’s still a colossal shitstain on the Trek legacy. I generously give it an E-Tier.

A C of which I am disproportionately fond

Its a wierd one, and grade can depend on if I am being my, I want scientific reality self, or my this story….self or if I am being its Trek I like it self

It's too ridiculously dumb to get an E, but I can't give it more than D

The only thing I find entertaining about this one is Paris' Cronenberg transformation. Emmy well earned on that.

I'm giving it an E, but it's an S tier E.

I give it an S for Shits and Giggles.

I never liked this one. After seeing TA react to it, I can definitely concede that there are ok parts to it, but overall I just hate the mutant plot. Not my 🍵🍶

Ya'll nuts, this is S Tier! It's also extremely stupid. S for Stupid! (And Awesome!)

Time to get your S votes out

I'm going to be generous and give it a C because I do find it entertaining despite how silly it is. C is for crazy, lol.

Its a weird one. Technically its so ridiculous that its canon breaking. But its also incredibly enjoyable in how silly it is and how good the acting is. E for Excellent Fun.