PATRON TIER LIST - VOY S2E12 - Resistance
TIER RATE Star Trek VOY S2E12 - Resistance
Open to ALL Patrons
Comments (13)
This has to be a B because the positives greatly outweigh the negatives.
Seriously SOOOOOOOO tempted to give you a thumbs down on this one for the Joel Grey hate! So Disappointed!!! Joel Grey is a NATIONAL TREASURE! He's been in so much stuff "Stage, screen and TV"! Most Notably in "CABARET" 1972 with Liza Minelli and 1985's "Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins" as "Chiun", a sorta Asian-Yoda like teacher of Marital Arts, Also played a great Villain role in Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 5!
They don't hate Joel Grey...they hate his performance in this episode. Big difference, lol.
I'd take this episode over a generic monster of the week episode at any point. I realize the guest actor's performance is annoying to certain people, but I felt like his eccentric behavior supports his mental illness, and also the cruelty of the government given the way he is treated.
I'm surprised this episodes has such an overall low reception. It delivers a compelling story with strong performances from Kate Muglrew and guest actor Joel Grey, who plays his character so well that you feel his pain and real sympathy for him.
R [E] si [S] t [A] n [C] e (it's a B tier)
Performances by Joel Grey and Kate Mulgrew elevate this episode. Moody sets also contribute to the gloomy mood. This episode is an emotional downhill slide to a sad ending. Performances are A but the overall plot feels forced. B plus.
Cheerful it is not: the one-note depressing mood drags it down to a C for me. I agree performances are good though.
3rd worst episode of voyager ever
Cringy Caylem: crazy co-conspirator & cantaloupe capped circus clown combined.
Worst episode of Voyager? Not even close LOL
There's one episode that I loath above all - and the annoying thing is 90% of it is a great episode, its just that 10%... We have a while before that one though.
Despite this being a mini reunion of the cast of "Remo Williams - The Adventure Begins".... this just sucked