PATRON TIER LIST - DS9 S4E7 - Starship Down

Solid stuff. This is a DS9 B. So to me that's an A for most of TNG and an S on voyager.

Eh, I enjoyed this well enough. Solid, setup for a variety of small bits with character pairs. Would you rather take two of them and stretch to fill an entire episode? Sounds like the boys gotten too comfortable with the dice rolls being up their Alley. It's Star Trek from the old days. It's still gonna be a variety.

First grow back the beard Alex, you look too much like Elon. Second you like scifi because you get a sandbox for unusual storytelling, but you don't like the religion part, though it is part of the sandbox that you might have advanced aliens that some people would choose to worship and where that might take them for good or bad. True for the profits and the founders. Dune explores it too.

Is it just me, or do only I get Odo/Renee vibes from the performance by Cromwell? Great episode for me A tier.

I think the whole episode hinges on whether you buy the Kira/Sisko emotional bridge scene (which I do) because the rest of the episode is kind of dull

Can't you C this is just a basic under the C submarine plot?

Good episode, a lot of fun. Solid B, maybe B+

I love the episode. I love Cromwell and Quark. I love Worf's growth in command. But the episode is a B at best. It's just missing something to push it higher.

I know you and Alex weren't the biggest fans of this one, but i love it. A valid A!

You guys are wrong. It's S tier. Cancelling my membership. Reported creator to Patreon. Filing restraining order.