PATRON TIER LIST - Star Trek DS9 S2E9 - Second Sight
TIER RATE Star Trek DS9 - S2E9 - Second Sight
Open to ALL Patrons
Comments (23)
I thought it was... Ok. I can see where they were going, but this feels like they had a two-parter in mind, and had to cut it in half for a single episode. And the last line... Oof man. I'm ranking it as C, because it could have been done better.
I liked it. No it's not a masterpiece. It's just an interesting romantic episode. I like this more than Melora. And even Melora wasn't horrible it was just mid IMO. Nothing horrible or fantastic either. This episode was actually enjoyable to me. Still is.
So forgettable two of the characters forget at least half the episode during it. Normally to be an E to me it has to offend me as well as being bad. This one secures it though by being aggressively bland and E for Empty
For me it's the scenes between Dax and Sisko that keep this a C and not dropping to D.
I originally thought low C Tier, but then I remembered what the tiers represent and dropped it to a solid D. It shouldn't be eliminated from the canon, but it doesn't really do anything or accomplish anything.
This is one of the few where I rate it lower than the rest of the crowd. I just don't see what the point was. I have seen other people explain as something to do with moving on from his widow but I don't see it. He had a brief crush on a person that doesn't exist? I don't see that as much progress.
I suppose that at least it is a Sisko-centered story, which was long overdue. So for that reason it can't be an E.
I legit want to hear from the people who gave this an A or S (C- for me). Not to bash them but to hear why they love this. I think that would be an interesting conversation. And to prove I'm sincere I'll admit in public, I give Sub Rosa an S, it's one of my favorite episodes :D
I assumed they were trolling. I assumed the people who gave Sub Rosa an S (it's the worst episode of TNG in my opinion) were trolling as well. Proven wrong on that front at least.
How have half the people voted as a C? It’s so bad 😂
It's a C- for me (mentally a D+) but I put it in the C category rather than D because there's a couple scenes I like and for the joke that aged so well - they used Richard Kiley and spared no expense.
There are good parts but it feels a bit cheap.
I could watch Salli Richardson all day, but even with that this one's mediocre, at best. It's a good reminder that back in the days of 26-episode seasons there were always a few "filler" episodes that made us appreciate the bangers that much more.
Wow I’d thought more would’ve liked this episode
I would put it somewhat between high D and low C. Probably in the five most forgettable episodes of the season for me.
This is S for me for Richard Kiley alone, they spared no expense.
It wasn't an E..,not much more to say than that. although episodes like this might get curved down to an E once you start handing out 15-20 S scores out of 26 in each of the later seasons
I don’t care, I liked it. The idea of astral projecting your dreams was interesting.
D-ickbag Terraformer
Distraught Damsel in Distress Daydreams of DS9's Dashing Director. Difficult Douche "Daddy" Desires Deathly Divorce, Diving Directly into Dead Dwarfstar. Decent Drama? Dull! Deserves D.
Your comment deserves an S rating.
The only thing I remember about this one is that I didn't like it.
The 'C'ist of Cs.