PATRON TIER LIST - TNG S6E22 - Suspicions
What tier do you rate Star Trek TNG S6E22 - Suspicions
Open to ALL Patrons
Comments (11)
There's a real problem with an episode when I enjoy the reactions much more than anything in that episode.
I guess Worf is a pretty good teacher
Big D
Solid B, the only thing this was missing was Beverly gathering all the suspects together explaining the case, Riker accusing everyone incorrectly and then Beverly unmasking the killer.
B+ for sure as a good Dr. Crusher episode, but not really A tier.
Crusher as Detective Noir. Nothing exceptional, but good fun.
I love it, high A!
Solid B Tier for me. People keep talking about the behind the scenes, the plot being meant for Worf, etc. Here's the thing: I don't really care about that. If there was tension behind the scenes but the result is an episode that I liked, my enjoyment isn't going to be affected all that much by hearing how the sausage was made. I don't think there's any issue with Crusher doing her own investigation from a medical side of things, and it make sense that she would take Reyga's death personally because she's the one who put this experiment together in the first place. The scientists were an interesting mix of suspects, Ogawa got some shine, Guinan got another episode, and we watched a guy get a hole put through his chest. Good times, solid episode.
I tend to agree. I graded the episode for what it is not what it was originally supposed to be. That said, I’m not the biggest fan of this one because it makes no sense that this would be a Crusher story. Her “who done it” should’ve been medical related.
D for Dreadful. This episode is my Dr. Stubbs. I can't help it, it must be instinctual.
A decent Beverly episode. I like seeing the different alien species outside of the normal dynamics. Ferengi and Klingon scientists, Vulcan suspected of murder etc.