Artificial Blood predicament poll

I want to add some hazard like this one pictured. Obviously we need a penalty for falling for such a trick. What would be the best, as a player?

FATIGUE LOSS:
Pro:
- you will go back home faster, that means Lucille will raise her affection towards the bulls faster
Con:
- You might end up not achieve anything at all if lucille falls 3 times

HP LOSS:

Pro:
- You might let her have fun more often! :)
Con:
- If you lose a battle because you had low HP, you'll go home 

lemme know your thoughts! It's very important to me :)