RED or LOVER?? (TAYLOR)
Which album should I react to next? Red or Lover?
**Please know that what is voted on will not be 100% for sure the album that I will react to next. I simply need to get the information from my Patrons what you want. Yes it makes an impact but it's not definitive. Also this album reaction will most likely come out at the end of next month... unless she releases a TV of something out of nowhere!
Comments (27)
I think Red, her least sonically consistent album, is probably foundational for Lover so I'd pick that. Both albums are raw and sprawling in their lyrics and have a sense of liberation of not only herself but her as a person who is experiencing real love for the first time. I think Red was the first time she thought she understood true love, but according to her Lover is the first time she actually did understand that. Both are full of contradictions and so they bring a very sharp realism but they're certainly different stages in life.
red, since you have so many questions about all too well 10 minute version outro lyrics, i think listening to the album will answer them
I think sonically you may actually vibe a lot with Lover, and I think it is underrated. However, I do think Red TV should come first as it has a lot of context and content that I think is important for understanding Taylor as an artist.
Definitely RED (TV). They're both excellent albums, both are kind of musically all over the place - which is their beauty - but there's a lot of foundational elements to RED that will explain some lyrical tiebacks and some musical evolution.
I can’t wait for you to react to all of them but REC(TV) especially since it’s 2 hours long.
I always try and tell ppl that will be reacting to Red for the first time to get back story on Ronan before listening to it because it’s such a powerful and important song.
YES. I could not agree more.
I would say lover just because I love that album
Don’t forget Fearless TV and Evermore
This was a hard vote both excellent albums. I think Lover is highly underrated. I ultimately ended up voting for Lover because it is the underdog. I of course will be highly looking forward to both album reactions when ever they occur. I am also still rooting for a fearless reaction along with a reaction to Journey to Fearless
i think you’ll love both but maybe do red first to keep perfect anticipation for lover
Red next for sure! But I’d love Fearless(TV) after that. It’s the first album she won AOTY for at the Grammys and is considered her breakout album. Or Evermore because it seemed like you really enjoyed that era during the concert and it’s a masterclass in writing! Lover is meh 🤷🏻♀️ not horrible but not great by any means
Don’t let anyone persuade you about Lover it’s such a. Good album ❤️😭 people hate the album because of me and you need to calm down the album tracks themselves are so fun so good
lol you may want to put the songs in quotes cause I read this as you are the reason people don’t like Lover 😂😂😂
Red because I feel like you have seen or heard a lot of the lover songs through other reactions so outside of the big singles, red will probably have more that you’ll hear for the first time.
It’s Happening! I’ve been waiting for Red! While I appreciate Lover, I think it’s important reputation comes before lover, Rep (TV) should be next so hopefully you won’t have to wait too much longer on that front. Red is such a patchwork quilt of an album, she describes it as her real break up album because it’s kind of all over the place. you will most likely know some of the songs off of Red as it was her first to kinda punch out the wall people kinda placed her within. She’s said that it was a tough album for her because it was all real experiences, so she’d be crying between interviews or after performances but still kinda rolling with it. It is a crying album though. There is a pretty heavy change in the song Girl at Home from the OG album to the TV. The song on the original album was rumored to be a demo track, so the changes made to TV make more sense if this it’s how Taylor originally intended it, but didn’t get to do it that way. Red is my top Taylor album, TV secured that for me, I’m so excited to see you react to it! Goodluck!
lover is amazing but i'm choosing red tv. also i'd love for you to react to her debut album. it came out when she was 16 (2006), written between 12-15, and is highly underrated and personally top 3 albums for me.
I love Lover but it’s gonna lose so I’m gonna choose Red 😂
Just FYI - Fearless TV is out (you have the vinyl). I’d love for you to hear that one as it’s probably still my favorite album of hers.
Lover slander 😭 it’s so much more vocally interesting
I love Lover but you gotta do Red Taylor's Version first 😊
Red, only because I NEED to see your reaction to Ronan😂😈
Red was the first time I remember people “coming around” on Taylor in a major way musically. Something about this album really changed public perception of her for the better. She was definitely pigeonholed for a while as just a little country girl with a guitar. So red was her way of saying “hey you ain’t seen nothing yet”. It was her first “grown up” album and I think this album truly was the thing that changed the trajectory of her career. Also lil fun fact: Taylor talks a lot about how Blue by Joni Mitchell is her fav album. And so I think it’s cute that she gave a little nod by call her album Red.
Oh, Lover is losing, this is so sad. Red is not even on my top 5 favorite albums, even though I think it was a big shift in her career, I dont think the songs are as good as they could have been. With the exception of a few here and there
I love Lover but I think you need to react to Reputation and then Lover after to get the full narrative effect, I think it will feel weird to do Lover first and then go back in time to the headspace she was in when she wrote Rep
But Reputation doesn't have a TV yet right?
I love the lover album with my entire being but I think you really need to listen to red to understand Taylor better
