Conversation about men/women cheating! Slight "DARK" Spoilers!!
I had this yap session while discussing an episode of Dark, but I wanted to share it with the community to hear your thoughts. I want to start by saying this is NOT a "Gender Wars" conversation. I think those are a waste of time and only cause more division! I was just curious about your thoughts on the matter (If you feel like sharing). I am forever in a state of learning, and I respect a lot of y'all's opinions. Val also thought it was a good idea to share here. I'd appreciate it if you watch the whole video before commenting🫶🏾
Comments (8)
Yep--it's important to see these moments (fictional or actual) in terms of, "What good choices were available?" Because the best choice would be, "Sit down with your spouse. Tell them you have discovered a new dimension of your sexuality. Tell them you can't take this boarder on because you NEED them, that way. Then ask for an honest conversation about what this means for the marriage, the family, etc." Was that choice available to this character in this time and place? HELL no. Only bad choices abound.
I hardly judge fictional characters the same way I judge real life people, and my views tend to favour women heavily, so when I saw Doris cheating I was just like "good for her", nevermind I was shaking my head at Ulrich for doing the same thing 😂 But that's the thing, it's not really the same. Like you pointed out, circumstance matters. For most of history, women have been judged more heavily for engaging in any kind of sexual activity outside the marital bed because they were seen as first their father's, then their husband's property. (Penelope, the ever faithful wife from the Odyssey, springs to mind. She was seen as the ideal woman for a long time, waiting patiently for her husband to return for 20 years while refusing suitors. Meanwhile Odysseus did sleep with other women while he was gone, but he was still also seen as faithful because in the end he returned home to his wife. The double standard goes back a long way.) Not to mention the way women have been considered to not have sexuality at all, just be a passive recipient of a man's sexuality. The echoes of that are still present in the times Doris grew up and lives. Add in being trapped in a domestic life with a husband who's hardly home... All that makes Doris' cheating feel less like cheating and more like liberation. But if Doris was in the same position as Ulrich--living in modern times with a hella lot more options and equality (and easy divorce!), having a spouse who was present and actually did housework and shit--I wouldn't be cheering, I'd be shaking my head (a little bit). I wasn't cheering for Hannah either--she wasn't cheating on her husband since he was already gone, but she was fooling around with Katharina's husband behind Katharina's back and lying to her face, so of course that's asshole behaviour! She had no respect for Katharina, and frankly not much for herself either. Like you, I also didn't judge Peter that much for cheating, either, because of similar baggage of repressed sexuality. I suppose a big part in how I feel and react when things like these happen (in TV shows) has to do with whom do I feel the most sympathy for. I did feel sorry for Egon even though I was cheering Doris on, because he's not a bad man at all, and he does care for his wife and kid. All this reminded me of something I heard in a TV show called The Great. If I remember correctly, some character told another character named Elizabeth that they weren't interested in the "why" of things, only the "who" and "what". To which Elizabeth responded something along the lines of, "But it's the 'why' where humanity lives!" That stuck with me, and when it comes to topics like being unfaithful to your spouse, I try to remember the 'why'.
haven't seen a house party scene yet, but that would definitely make Hannah even more of an asshole! completely different feelings about her actions versus Doris'
With Egon and his wife specifically: in the 50’s you couldn’t really be out as a lesbian and it was a hell of a lot harder to leave your husband. She would have been out on the street and shunned. You could tell that was the first orgasm that woman had EVER had. It’s hard to hold her cheating against her - she’s doing what she has to do to stay sane without hurting Egon more than necessary or ruining her life.
Love ur yaps! Super interesting question. I think for me it boils down to the “why”. Is someone cheating because they dont have a safe way to leave the relationship for some reason? There’s a million good ones and the world is full of power imbalances etc. Or are they doing it cus they’re a slimy coward who assumes they’ll get away with it or don’t want to deal with breaking up for some bad reason. Anyone could be either type. But I mean. I don’t know the numbers but it’s fair to assume quite a few women are in the fist category. Certainly not all of them (look at orange is the new black, which has examples of both in many different ways). But definitely not all women are. A lot just cheat cuz they can, just like a lot of men. It’s shitty. I hate cheaters. It’s such a cowardly thing. Just break up. But I get some ppl are trapped in a million ways and I think it’s cool to have conversations about the nuance of the situation. Stoked to read ppls thoughts!
I think you kinda answered your own question. It's just super context specific. For sure, you named some reasons (i.e., patriarchy) that the context is almost universally different between men and women, and that can/should never be ignored. And, occasionally, that's kinda the sum total of what we're presented with in a given situation--someone whose context is totally and completely dominated by social and hierarchical strictures, such that we should probably excuse a lot that we wouldn't in other situations. But often we're given more than that, and, depending, I think we can modulate (or not) off of baselines that may begin in very different places. I've also noticed that something makes me uncomfortable with how people sometimes use the word "cheating" particularly on the internet. Particularly that word. It's like, as soon as it's invoked it somehow collapses the context. I especially noticed it with how people talked about certain stuff in Sinners. I guess I just think it's better, if one wants to sort through how the feel about a given act... describe exactly what the act entailed, what may have prompted it, and how it affected people. Nine times outta ten, when you're done doing that, you'll have a good idea how to feel (even if it's conflicted!).
You must consider the generational differences when analyzing this topic. My belief is that historically overall more men are unfaithful than women; but as generations come and go that gap has leveled out. Now as to the motivations behind cheating, I don’t dare touch that topic in a post. And Frank, I believe subconsciously you know that in this cancel culture you have to watch your Ps and Qs as they say. So it’s “safer” for you to condemn more harshly the men. My advice—avoid relationships! lol
Well, i think a talk like this should start off with statistically men and women cheat in equal number. Last I checked it was about 49% present of women admit to cheating and 51% of men. Most of which do so not because of their partner or who they cheat with but rather for something going on in their own mind like insecurity and a desire to feel 'wanted' again or take a different level of control in their life. Or even just wanting the thrill of taboo. That just my take as a sociology grad.
