Pluribus 1 x 3 | Full Length Reaction
Comments (30)
Loved your commentary this episode, I think it took me a bit longer to put together the fact that hey are trying to erase all suffering. That looks very different as a human and community or world like you said where we only want the good things/fantasy. I can't wait to watch the rest with you. Also have you seen Wonder man yet? i think you'd like it.
That's such a good thought. I absolutely loved Wonder Man
I remember looking at my SO and being like how did she not understand that they would giver anything after meeting the guy who has sex with them often? Then, I started thinking about what I would have immediately asked them to do and that would have been asking them to figure out how to remove the power plants, how to decommission them as safely as possible. Then my SO said something absurdly accurate, she isn't asking the right questions. He would have asked them to reverse what they did, to find a cure. Obviously they wouldn't want to, they did set this in motion but finding out if they can avoid curing themselves would be interesting.
Not even just losing her wife losing the ENTIRE of your species bar the other 11 who don’t even live in the same country I’d be losing my mind I’m talking legendary crashout 😭 I would’ve accidentally killed more than 11 million
Carol has a lot in common with Daniel Molloy, honestly.
I think what they were trying to show in that scene where Carol says: “you are always content… Or you’re in Norway, in a hotel made of ice” is that Carol was happy but didn’t know it. She had a good life but yet she was always complaining. Like we saw in the cold opening. I think that’s why she got mad. Not even because they mentioned Helen. It’s because she couldn’t appreciate the good moments she had with her. It’s the feeling of regret she doesn’t like. This show is so good!!
"having a drink with google" 😂😂 some thoughts from this episode on grief, efficiency vs art, and last resorts: Other folks have commented on it but I want to reiterate how glad I am that you spoke on it more / the episode gave more attention to the fact that Carol is deep in grief after a shocking loss with absolutely no support system. Judging her character is a lot bigger than discussing whether some people are calm under chaos or would crash out, as literally no behaviour is 'abnormal' when in deep grief like that. The hive's drive for efficiency which was highlighted again this episode. What about when they let efficiency run it's course to completion (which they will inevitably be able to do) what then - will everyone be sat around? Is it possible for them to create art? They seem to appreciate art since the mention of the guggenheim last episode... but how can you make art without multiple perspectives. Saving Carol from the hand grenade was super reasonable BUT what if she wants to avoid being integrated into the hive and decides to end her life before they have found the scientific breakthrough to do that. I personally think she would be entirely justified to make that decision, but would they prevent her from harming herself if they were made aware of those intentions?
The restocking scene feels eerie, like forced normalcy—but for her, that routine might be an act of survival after everything she’s lost, love how much this show makes you think and feel
Yeah there's the horror of a hive mind intent on converting you, but I think I'd be really stoked if all of humanity was suddenly super devoted to making sure I was safe, content, and well looked-after. If the world was suddenly safe from dictators, racists, misogynists, religious zealots, abusers, etc, AND I didn't have to worry about making money to survive, I think I'd take my chances with the hive. 🤷🏽♀️
very valid honestly
I think a lot of viewers (esp straight men let's be real) make the mistake of NOT relating Helen to their partners and not giving Carol any grace as a result.
valid
I relate to Carol and empathize with her. I love that she's not an easy character. So complex, such a complex performance. RHEA SEEHORN IS FUCKING INCREDIBLE. I'm finally watching Better Call Saul now because I'm completely in awe of her acting and need more of her post Pluribus!
She's fantastic in that
Things that I noticed about Carol wrt white Westernness: she only wanted to meet with the English speakers because she doesn't want the hivemind translating BUT she doesn't consider the possibility that some of the English speakers might be able to translate for the non-English speakers. People who speak 2 languages often speak 3 or 4! She immediately dismissed the opinions of the other immune people, positioning herself as smarter, more righteous, the only one who cares about humanity. The "white America vs global majority" dynamic is apparent. I don't think it's meant to be centered or make Carol look overtly racist, but it def deepens the "Carol vs the world" vibe. I think the most interesting contrast is cultural: individual vs communal. Carol not only lost her closest family but is American. The others not only still have their hivemind family members around them but come from various much more communal cultures.
Such a good point about communal cultures and the difference
I wonder why the hive has such a strong urge to make Carol and the other survivors “happy”. Even to the point that they would give Carol a weapon that she could hurt the other survivors with? Is it that they won’t protect the survivors from themselves or each other if it means violating their autonomy in any way? That seems totally at odds with their “biological imperative” to bring everyone into the hive. Carol, please please get drunk and argue philosophy with these weirdos I need to understand them!
Her telling Carol the whole thing of seeing a person drowning and throwing a Life support kind of speaks to it a little bit, but yes, I want so many more answers. haha yessss I was hoping them getting drunk would lead to more discussions, but Carol's frustration with the whole thing got in the way
Frank, I like your 1 episode a week view for this show because it holds a lot! In this episode, Carol's behavior in the flashbacks makes me think she must harbor some past trauma(s). I saw anxiety, discontentment and anger in her even before the Hive hit, for instance in the book store in prior episode. I saw this behavior and emotions in her with her partner, Helen. When Helen and Carol were at the Norwegian ice hotel, despite Helen being in awe of the place, Carol cannot bring herself to speak a single positive word about it. Carol resisted her partner Helen’s efforts to get her to appreciate the wonders around her. Carol fixates on how she expected her latest book to be higher up the bestseller list in its debut week. The patient and understanding Helen needled her, saying this vacation was perfect because “You love feeling bad”....that is telling about Carol. Something in her past keeps her locked in to more negative than positive and now the Hive world is feeding the negative more. I hope that we find out if that is true. BTW, I have friends who stayed in a ice hotel and they loved it. They provide lots of insulation and coverage on the beds that you don't even know there is ice underneath. And the bathrooms were not icy. As soon as I heard the familiar voice of Betty White’s sweetly dim Rose Nylund coming out of Carol’s television set, I wondered if the "hive" were still operating TV stations and cable channels since Carol is watching DVDs. I tip my hat to this episode’s writer-director Gordon Smith and the Pluribus creative team for the cool shot of The Golden Girls’s Rose, seen in the reflection of a DVD. I did notice a prescription bottle on Carol's table for Alprazolam, a drug commonly used to treat anxiety and panic attacks...so that is a clue also as she has had this medication and needed it prior to the Hive. I'm glad she has the medication to help her deal with the Hive world. Carol stated that she's a very independent person and doesn't want the hive waiting on her hand-and-foot, but seemingly has no problem with requesting their labor to restock her local grocery store when she discovers it's empty. Though she does seem a little embarrassed after watching a whole group restock the entire store solely for her benefit, implying that she realizes the double standard. In addition, this takes place immediately after Carol demands that "they" leave her alone so she can have that self-sufficiency, so part of it is her realizing how much of the world is "theirs" now. But how wasteful all that food for one person! And we see her eating a thawed frozen meal, which makes me think she doesn't trust anything fresh the Hive stocked in the store since it could be tainted. My favorite moment in the Sprouts sequence is when a cheery fellow carrying supplies back into the store says, “Carol! May we sneak past you here?” Followed by a solo Carol shopping for groceries while Sade’s “The Sweetest Taboo” plays over the PA...love that song! That whole grenade thing was telling since it shows the incredible level of cooperation and yet in some ways stupidity and incompetence exhibited by the Hive mind. Although the Hive are, presumably, very busy, they still make time to cater to Carol whenever she has a request or a complaint. It’s scary how efficient and effective they can be. It also makes for some funny sight gags, as these ordinary-looking people go to extraordinary lengths for Carol, smiling all the while. Also while talking to one of "them" at the hospital, Carol realizes that they can't say "no" to any request she makes, even if it violates common sense. What she's going to do with that knowledge in the future, I wonder?? I too Frank wonder about things, like Carol getting drunk effecting the Hive. Why doesn't it effect them since when Carol got upset and angry, it caused the Hive to collapse...so why don't the Hive get drunk when Carol does....they say it doesn't work that way, so what fences or guardrails has the Hive set up? I find the idea of the Hive all switching off their lights at night to be chilling. Do they not take evening walks? Do they not gather around tables to play board or card games? Do they not watch TV?! I can’t imagine a happy life without those small pleasures, and so many others. Without tiny joys, who are we? This episode definitely showed both the potential and the limitations of Carol’s new life as one of Earth’s few non-chilled out humans. Yet, the whole planetary population is at Carol’s disposal and the Hive will try to accommodate her demands, no matter how potentially destructive. That’s how much her happiness means to the hive and also the hive still intends to convert Carol, as soon as they can figure out how. There’s still so much we don’t know about what just happened to humanity or why. Carol doesn’t trust the Hive to give her honest information. But I sure want her to ask things, like: Why did the aliens send the "happiness formula" to Earth in the first place? And always my biggest question, why did humans have to fuck with it.....maybe because humans are always looking for answers, for cures...just perhaps there is a lesson in this that humans should heed.
Kim I fucking love this. So many important questions. I can't wait for next week
This is the episode where I realized “they” could be a metaphor for AI. The way each person has all of humanity’s knowledge and you can ask them for anything and they can provide. It’s like how the advertisers say AI can help in any situation, but it actually makes your life so much worse while it “improves efficiency.”And for the other immune people like Carol, they kind of represent the people who create relationships with AI or tell AI to act like their favorite character. Like with the mom getting so upset when Carol asks her son what speculum he prefers. It made the kid break off script and it ruined the illusion for the mom, similar to when a character AI goes off script. And with Zosia’s fun facts, it’s like when AI provides way too much info for a simple question.
So much like AI.
The line delivery of “would you like an atom bomb?” is amazing kuddos to the actor
Absolutely. so many emotions behind that question and the acting
i was arguing with someone on reddit who used carol's mood in ice hotel as an argument that she's an asshole lmao. like, “she is in this beautiful place with her partner, and all she can do is complain. it's not normal and she's a curmudgeon.” bruh she actually handled this better than i would. i'd immediately tell helen that we're getting out of here to somewhere warm. i can't imagine staying somewhere with 0 escape to comfort/warmness. ice beds? are u kidding me?😭😭😭 also i've never heard the “carol is racist” take. i've heard the “she's unlikable cause she's a typical american with hero complex.” but i guess the racism thing could come from the fact that she only wanted to meet english-speaking immune people in the 2nd episode. but i never took it as a racism thing. i thought it was pretty obvious that she just didn't trust the hivemind and didn't want their help, so she chose people who she can understand without the hivemind. i guess it's kinda iffy, but it's understandable. and the typical american thing, i also didn't think about it like that at all, cause in her place i'd also want to fix this whole alien takeover thing, and it's not about wanting to be a hero. i'm not even american bruh
Moving forward, we refuse to argue with anyone on Reddit or Twitter! Those are places where context and proper discourse go to die🤮 People like that are just sickening. so because it's a wonderful place, I should ignore all my discomfort? Absolutely, I think this illustrates different kinds of people. People who conform or "stay in the middle" and people who rage against oppressive systems
I love that last conversation, it’s just insane lol. Like you said it would also hurt them, but they can’t say no. Carol actually managed to make this thing take a minute to think, and show apprehension ! 😆 To an extent, Carol and the others’ immunity prevents "It" from having its own free will, since it could be destroyed despite its own instinct of preservation. I love that you bring up the loss of Helen throughout your reactions. A lot of the discourse around Carol’s character dismisses the grief, anger and confusion that would come with her situation. It’s honestly a shame and a disservice to her character to just brush it off. If she hadn’t lost Helen, things could have been SO different
Exactly. prevents their own free will. Maybe Carol's immunity also makes them feel inferior, and they're hiding that Helen is very important. Her absence rather. Maybe for some viewers don't consider it because it's just out of sight, out of mind. Which is crazy to me
Your discussion at the beginning is one of the many many reasons this show is genius because it brings up SO many intersectional issues. As an indigenous person, I wouldn’t say Carol exhibits any outright racist ideals. I’d definitely say it’s more implicit bias. I feel like a lot of viewers immediately take the conversation in episode two and the fact that she wouldn’t even have to consider the eradication of racism (seemingly) or war (as we know it today). Which then leads to a question I’m not even sure how to approach in a short-winded way: is it worth sacrificing what makes us human to end conflict? I, myself, see the events in episode 2, and am like: I don’t really care if these people are surrounded with “family”, it’s still not that person anymore. *That should freak you out, people!!!* I think it was genius to cast a lead who is a white woman who had a generally insufferable and pessimistic outlook on life and humanity in general pre-takeover. She’s combatting losing the one person she loved, who she took for granted, and being completely isolated in the most obsolete human experience. Plus even though the hive are not individually the people they once were, she has to rely on them to survive in some ways. Like you said, it’s the shit you love to react to and I always love your commentary, but especially with shows like this. If you don’t already, I feel like you would love Crazy Stupid Podcast on YouTube, two creators I think of when I think of your commentary. They did episode-by-episode commentaries digging into a lot of the topics which arise in the show.
100%. And I definitely saw a lot more of the implicit bias in this episode, with how she reacted to all the non-English speakers' occupations, as well as her conversation with the Spanish dude over the phone. That's a question that also lowkey plagued my mind. What would we sacrifice to end conflict? And is it even fair for that decision to be put on us (The ones suffering under that conflict) I love love love Crazy Stupid podcast, It makes me so happy every time I see their channel growing In popularity
