The Shining | Full-Length Reaction
Comments (61)
King wrote Dolores Clayborne with Kathy Bates in mind after her performance in Misery. I think it’s the best movie adaptation out of all of his books.
This is the second time I’ve seen this movie since it came out. I was so angry at the way they changed the book that I never watched it again, but I was curious to watch it with you Frank. Stephen King didn’t care for this adaptation either. The only thing I can say is, I can praise it for it cinematography and the sets. The ending is so different than the ending in the book and that’s what made me absolutely insane.
I felt so disappointed when I heard how much better the book is
I am soooo excited for Doctor Sleep! I think it's the only time a movie made me need to read the book.
Back when the novel was a new bestseller, some friends and I climbed the creaky spiral staircase in an old lighthouse in SC and someone had painted “REDRUM” in the room at the top. We got the hell down those stairs. 😎
lmao smart😂
When I was a kid, the back seats in a car only had lap belts and it was optional to use them. It's amazing any of us survived!
oh wow
the instant replay of the bat swing hahahahahahahahaha
had to lol
Too real watching during the current huge snowstorm
for reallllll
I’ve tried to watch this movie so many times and I think I never made it past the staircase scene. So terrifying. They should’ve given Wendy a gun. Also I remember finding out Hallorann died here through twitter when Welcome to Derry was still coming out. Someone said “I can’t believe Dick Hallorann survived the cosmic entity of It and then died by a bum with an axe” and honestly yeah, my thoughts exactly. I thought he would be in more scenes at least but we spent more time with him coming to the hotel than trying to save Danny and Wendy. 😭 We could hope that in the It universe they wrote Hallorann survived like on the book instead of connecting the universe to this movie. Crossing my fingers that we might see him again.
That's what I'm saying, it was so underwhelming that that was how he died
Scatman Crothers, musician, 1955: https://youtu.be/SnRqD5-5G7A?si=RXCr41D1JTaXfZSz
The scariest moment in the book is when Halloran, in the process of rescuing Wendy and Danny, begins to consider killing them - It’s only for a moment, and his kindness defeats the impulse, but it’s a sign of the Overlook’s influence over people who “shine,” who sense its evil. The most moving moment in the book is Jack’s final words to his son before trying in earnest to kill him: “Run away, Danny, and remember how much I love you.” 😢 Book Jack is a good man struggling to overcome addiction and slowly influenced by the hotel. Movie Jack is Jack Nicholson playing crazy from the get-go.
I also remember the scene where Danny is calling to Dick in his head in the book. The movie depicts it without us really knowing what Dick is seeing/hearing (lying in the bed when his eyes get all wide and terrified). I really loved how the book depicted the immense power of Danny's "shine" in that moment. (I also liked the paintings on the walls in Dick's apartment). And you put it perfectly explaining how diff Jack is in the books.
Fun Fact: I smashed red VW Beetle that Halloran sees on his drive in the snow is Kubrick giving a middle finger to Stephen King, who was no happy about his lack of input into the film. King had Jack and the family driving to the Overlook in a red VW Beetle.
“Family annihilation” with or without suicide often happens when a man is facing financial ruin or some other public humiliation. Look at Alex Murdaugh.
That story is so horrific. So so horrific.
Franklin, Halloran does not die in the book.
True! Halloran confronts the hotel, is tempted by it, and finally drives away with Wendy and Dani.
There are deliberate mismatches between the hotel’s layout in some scenes versus others, to keep viewers off balance. For example, in the aerial shot, there’s no hedge maze. And tracking shots of the lobby show that the manager’s office has a hallway behind it - but during Jack’s job interview, there’s a window on the back wall.
Interesting.
Kubrick hints quite a bit here that Danny is sexually abused by his father. That’s original to the movie.
Examples?
King was not a fan of this film, because it really just uses the source material as a springboard for Kubrick’s own idea. Fans of the book will know that Jack’s character goes through a slow transformation from loving father and husband to possessed killer. And Dick Halloran doesn’t die, he rescues Wendy and Danny. This is a different story, and both are exceptional in their own way.
I would have loved to see that version
It's been a long time since I read the book, but isn't Tony a protector of Danny? His future self protecting him by using the shine from the future? I just Googled it to refresh my memory, and it seems to be accurate. Anyone? I know when I saw the film (before reading the book), I thought Danny was so creepy and possibly possessed. That misinterpretation on my part (and perhaps other viewers) does such a disservice to his character. I'm so glad I eventually read the book.
Yes, the book is King’s best horror novel imo. This is less a case of “the book is better than the movie” and more of “the movie and the book are two completely separate works of art.”
A brilliantly made movie. But Kubrick pushed Shelley Duvall into a mental breakdown from which she never fully recovered. The exhaustion and tears are real.
I didn't know this, and it pisses me off to learn it. 😒
Franklin, you should check out the documentary Room 237, which analyzes the symbolism and hidden messages in Kubrick's film. As someone who appreciates art and analysis, I think you'd like it. It's almost like a longer video essay. 🙂 it has its critics, though. I'm going to share two other video essays recommended on Reddit (haven't watched them).
Yes, it’s fascinating
I think one of, if not the main, drawbacks of this film is that while it takes its time to unfold, it doesn't do a good enough job of getting us into Jack's head space. The book is so in depth with that.
Yes, Frank, trombones in the opening music score. I played trombone and flute in grade school, Jr. and Sr. high school and college bands and for awhile in community bands. You finally do see a character's connection to his younger self in Welcome to Derry which showcased his "shining" abilities and backstory. I enjoyed the book much better than the movie. The book is to me is more tragedy than horror. The film I felt portrayed Jack, by Jack Nicholson, to be more about cabin fever and losing touch with reality, the theme of alcoholism is downplayed, as is Jack’s creative writing impotence, with the “all work and no play” reveal, suggested to me he was never seriously trying to write. Shelley Duvall as Wendy is a more victimized role in Kubrick’s film, but in the book she is a much more complex character. The one character in the film who is believable to me and seems trustworthy at all times is Dick Hallorann, played by Scatman Crothers. I believe him when he senses Danny has psychic powers. He alerts the forest rangers to serious trouble at the hotel. But I do not like how Kubrick handled Halloran in the film compared to the book. I also felt the movie discarded the emotion of the book’s ending, and I won't say more otherwise I'll ruin the book should anyone decide to read it. After reading the book first and then seeing the movie I understood King's disappointment and frustration in Kubrick's adaptation of his book. Still, I think Kubrick’s film remains thrilling as a stand alone film and can see how it is looked upon now as a classic. Kubrick is telling a story with ghosts and the ghosts may not be present in any sense at all except as visions experienced by Jack or Danny. You see madness and the energies it sets loose in The Overlook which is an isolated situation that definitely magnifies them. You end up asking yourself what is real and what isn't. Who is hallucinating, who isn't? There are believable events like Jack’s manuscript, Jack locked in the food storage room, Jack escaping, and the famous “Here’s Johnny!” as he hatchets his way through the door. But there is no way, within the film, to be sure with any confidence exactly what happens, or precisely how, or really why. If Jack’s body was not found, what happened to it? Was it never there? Was it absorbed into the past, and does that explain Jack’s presence in that final photograph of a group of hotel partygoers in 1921? The film definitely has a creepy score and some very memorable, chilling and haunting scenes.
The film is also a visual feast. I even appreciated the sound design on this watch -- I sometimes have to intently focus on sounds as I am so highly visual (in some media, though, it's done so well that I note it right away). For example, when Danny is riding his Big Wheel over carpet then hardwood/tile then carpet, etc., the sound was captivating to me. But oh the colors in this movie!!! Genuinely stunning.
I find this movie less scary than just deeply unsettling. God damn Jack Nicolson does unhinged well. And I feel so very proud of Wendy when she whacks him with the baseball bat!
It's interesting to compare actors in different time periods ... this was peak when released and still is super intense and effective ... but on another hand, it feels a bit campy. 🤷♀️
"Vibes are weird." is taking me out lmaoooo They truly truly are. Kubrick can make a drive through the mountains for a seasonal gig seem like a prelude to the apocalypse.
😂
Shelley Duvall is such a queen to me. If you ever have a chance to watch it in your own offline life, 3 Women is another great showcase for her talents. (And is just a great movie, period.)
To me, she will always be "Hello, I'm Shelley Duvall" from Faerie Tale Theatre. Such a warm presence in my childhood! I loved her quirkiness and whimsy.
The earliest car I remember as a child had no seat belts. None of the trucks had seat belts. I guess the first car we had with them was that station wagon. But we never used them. The biggest difference then to now is just the number of cars on the road. Most families had one vehicle. We had farm trucks but only one family car. That was the same for pretty much everyone. It wasn't nearly as dangerous for that reason. Don't get me wrong. Not saying it was a good idea, but there weren't anywhere near the number of accidents. Also, cars were made of metal and could take a hit. Now they are mostly plastic and your chances of being injured are much higher. I enjoy this movie much more now than when it came out. King is a favorite author and as with most of his more 'horror' themed works, the books are just so much better. Kubrick made some interesting choices. King, himself, was very disappointed with the film. It's been so long since I read the book, that I can just watch this as a movie now and enjoy it but it's not the masterpiece that King wrote. They mention that it's built on Indian burial grounds but that's not in the book at all and just led to more "juju' nonsense attributed to Native Americans. UGH I have to stop. My Dad never talked to my mom like that. But men in general were much less respectful to women. I remember when we'd be at the table and my dad would shake the ice in his empty glass of tea and my mom would pop up and pour him more tea. Not a word spoken. I also remember the first time I called my dad out on that at the dinner table as a teenager. Didn't go over well. Now as us girls got older he changed a lot. I think it became about being the kind of man he would want for his daughters. Just like at the beginning when they only show Wendy the kitchen and show him the maintenance. Woman's work vs Men's work. Oh, a lot of these old captions were added in many years late as captions became a thing. They were often taken directly from the scripts and wouldn't reflect any adlibs or director's changes. So yea, they kind of suck sometimes. That plunger is what you push to open a walk-in from the inside. If no one on the other side bolted the door shut. There are differing opinions on what filming this movie with this director did to Shelly Duvall. You can find information and form your own opinion. She for a fact did suffer from mental illness later in her life. Very sad story and she died poor and pretty much alone. I remember her most fondly from playing Olive Oyl opposite Robin Williams' Popeye. Your timing of watching this as I've had about 12" of snow fall here and the temp is currently 2degrees. Very ironic and has made me laugh several times. I will throw in that everyone who says you need to watch Dr Sleep is on point. It is also a far better adaptation of King's work.✌️💖
Oh reading your comments, made me recall an interview I read long ago. Shelly Duvall was asked how it was working with Kubrick and she ended up hating it, said it was unbearable. She commented on how he had the actors repeat some scenes over and over and over for no good reason. She would have to cry for hours and hours for a scene, stay in character far too long. Also how Jack had to stay angry and act crazy over and over. This went on 5 or 6 days a week with long hours, for months.
Another movie to add to your Stephen King universe list: Dolores Claiborne. Not supernatural but absolutely super, absolutely natural. Kathy Bates' best performance, imo.
YES!!!!!
I love the establishing shots of Danny on his bigwheel and him and his mom doing the maze with him. You just see that they did it so many times. While Jack was going mad at his typewriter, Danny learned the layout of the whole place. Boy can get around how he wants.
Also I think Danny outlasted Jack mainly because he knew the layout of the maze, but Jack was already flagging so hard probably because he’d wasted most of his energy hacking through doors (it’s a hotel, you can’t find the key?) and innocent bystanders with an ax, also having been brained with a bat and fallen down a bunch of stairs. He was not at peak when he decided to perform the rampage. Tbh if he’d waited just a few hours Mr Halloran would have been back on a flight to Miami and there would have been no escape vehicle.
“Familicide”. A teacher at my high school died this way at the hands of his father a year or two after I graduated. Tragic. I realized I haven’t watched this movie in so long I forgot a lot. Also this is the first watch where I realize Jack also has the shine, he’s just too unwell already to recognize where he ends and the visions begin
You gotta check out the sequel doctor sleep it's so good, and it Helps explain a lot
You MUST watch Doctor Sleep! It's the sequel to The Shining and it's directed by Mike Flanagan, so you know it it slaps😊
Please, please, please watch Doctor Sleep. It's a beautiful movie.🤗 And I would like you to react to the Shining Miniseries. It's not a visual masterpiece Like the Kubrick movie but I prefer this one because it gives much more dept to the characters and the original story. Please watch the miniseries and then Doctor Sleep. 👃👃👃
Oooh YES! I love this movie, it's yucky and gloomy outside and my ewok has been put to bed. This is one of the first King movies I remember being allowed to watch. I still go around doing the "REDRUM" finger wiggle - I can't help iI. The only thing I don't like is how Shelley Duvall (the actress that played Wendy) was treated. Kubrick is a perfectionist and made her do so many scenes over and over (the baseball bat scene she had to do 127 times). He isolated her and was mean. It's why her acting seems so real. Kubrick was brutal and she was really having stress, anxiety and almost complete mental breakdowns. She's said it was a valuable learning experience but as someone with chronic anxiety and C-PTSD, it's just upsetting. Also, this movie really shows how much Jack and his son, Ray, look alike. That man could not deny that boy if he wanted to.
FUCK HIM FOR THAT
yes! one common thing to note about interpreting whether or not it's really a "ghost story", is that whenever Jack is speaking to the hotel staff, he's looking directly at a mirror. very great filmmaking, although no doubt the behind-the-scenes stories are infamous.
ahhh i like this
Talk about the perfect movie to watch during a snowstorm! Everyone stay warm and stay safe this weekend. Rates of DV go up at times like this, check in with those who need it. I think part of what makes this movie so successful is how interesting the lead actors' faces are, it really adds to the scenes. Shelly Duvall is so unique and expressive and Jack Nicolson's face is so naturally villainous lmao
Have 9 inches of snow here so far and sleet soon to appear, UGH! Hope you are doing well. Agree about the faces!!
This movie is such a classic. Though I know Stephen King didn’t like this adaptation because he felt it differed from the book too much. Also the director was notoriously abusive toward the lead actress, which is why her emotional displays are so absolutely fried by the end. It’s real distress. For awhile after my son stopped letting me cut his hair, he looked just like Danny and it was soooo cute. Now it’s longer and he looks more like a surfer boy. He says he wants it to grow all the way to the floor, we’ll see if he tolerates the brushing that long 😅
I have no doubt Kubrick was capable of pushing Shelley Duvall too far, and stories of how grueling and combative the experience could be are widely corroborated, but Duvall herself refuted suggestions she was abused or isolated on set by Kubrick and said he was the reason she wouldn't have traded the experience for anything.It's one of those stories that took on a life of its own, in part because of how convincing her performance is! And of course in part because powerful men in Hollywood did that kind of thing all the time. https://www.forbes.com/sites/timlammers/2024/07/11/shelley-duvall-once-shot-down-shining-rumors-about-stanley-kubrick/ https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/news/shelley-duvall-career-the-shining-stanley-kubrick-b2578217.html
