So I'm just discovering that a lot of people don't really mess with the romance genre. Why is that? I don't really have any stake in the game I'm just curious!
Comments (111)
Romance, like horror, action or other Uber-specific genres, can have extremely predictable story arcs which makes them not very fun to watch for cinephiles. There are exceptions of course, like Eternal Sunshine or Call Me By Your Name (would love your reaction to this btw!) that step outside the genre and the happily-ever-after expectations, so I’d argue that romance - blended - with something else is usually worth a watch…just like Everything Everywhere is an action movie blended with family drama/philosophy :)
I like them. There is some good in most genres. Excellence even. If you’re taking recs, I would say this little movie called Once.
Personally I think there's a lot of overly soppy, unrealistic, fairytale romances that just play into stereotypes and can seem sexist. But when they're done well, I love them. As others have mentioned, the Before Trilogy are masterful. Can't recommend them enough. And Carol is incredibly beautiful. Would love to see your reaction to it too. Especially as it's perfect for the holiday season
This got me thinking again about romance movies and a movie version of "Phantom of the Opera"- 2004 came to mind. Frank I don't know if you have ever watched musicals. This tale is a romance, but a very dark and complex story with mystery, obsession and tragedy about a disfigured musical genius who haunts the Paris Opera House and falls in love with a young soprano. This movie version stars Gerard Butler, Emmy Rossum, Patrick Wilson, Miranda Richardson and Minnie Driver. I've seen the live Broadway production several times and it always gave me shivers, thrills and tears....this movie version did the same. You may want to consider viewing on your leisure or as a reactor.
I really like them
also highly recommend phantom thread
please please PLEASE watch the before trilogy. it’s not that i dislike romance movies. i just like them to be annoyingly philosophical and pretentious and dialogue heavy
Amen. They are so naturalistic and realistic though. Great characters talking about everything and anything and creating a true bond. They're beautiful ❤️
No clue ! i LOVE them ! would love to see more reacting to Romantic drama's
I don’t know I’m a bit of a romantic so I love them but I like the romantic dramas more than the romantic comedies. But they both have a time and place. I just love movies in general, horror, drama, romance, action, animated, I just love a good movie, regardless of the genre.
Romance is just boring to me.
People: What about the Before Sunrise, Before Sunset movies??? I can't recall the order. I also LOVE the movie "Once"
You got the order right! And it's why I insist on Rye Lane. It's a modern, Black, Before Sunrise! Let's do ittttt!!
For me it’s that usually i think the woman settle for the lead man in romantic movies I always felt like they deserved better
I agree that misogyny can prevail in most romance movies. I'm a very curious person and so I will give a movie a chance simply to see if it has any entertainment value for me....BUT when I begin to watch any that end up over the top regarding misogyny, I simply do not continue to watch. There are some really asinine films out there that should just be burned regarding the treatment of women. I also do not don't cast a vote with my money towards any director's or writer's newer film released to view, that I know has disappointed me in the past when it comes to their treatment of women. . As others here have mentioned, I really enjoy a good love story that has a secondary subplot or brings in other areas of interest...such as Titanic, The Notebook, City of Angels, An Officer and a Gentleman, Legends of the Fall, The Thomas Crown Affair, American Gigolo, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button as well as films already mentioned in the comments. I also love a good rom-com as well and there were many mentioned here by others worth a watch. Some people may not consider the movie Groundhog Day a rom-com, but I do and it's hilarious and a "what if?" movie. I also enjoyed The Proposal, Bull Durham, Notting HIll, As Good As It Gets, Four Weddings and a Funeral, Roxanne and 50 First Dates. Countless other rom-coms I've seen, too many to mention. I've never viewed romantic movies or rom-com movies as real life, although aspects of some can be relatable. Perhaps at my age, having seen a ton of films allows me to not take things as personally as I once did when I was young. But I will still fight against misogyny with my retirement dollars and calling out discrimination, sexual harassment, violence against women, and objectification.
Romance, like horror and comedy, is really hard to do well. It's also more subjective than action/adventure or drama. An explosion is exciting, a death is sad...but is a man surprising a woman with thousands of flowers romantic? Or creepy? Most romances land on the "creepy" side for me. But not all of them!!
I am very very picky when it comes to romance movies. Half the time the situations just seem like hell on earth and the chemistry between the actors just isn’t there to make it believable to me
Because I'm healed and now it all looks like love bombing 🤣🤣
It's interesting, reading the comments, I think people put expectations on romcoms that they don't put on other genres... Of course they're unrealistic, they're movies! And I question why we let misogyny pass more easily when it's drama (where women are too often just plot devices for a male protagonist to get sad over) or action movies (where they're oftenprizes to be won at the end), and we sort of accept that it's just the way those genres often are. Or expectations of realism that we don't put on other genres either, like superheros or fantasy. Or even drama, there's a lot of wildly unrealistic dramas around. Like, in Lord of the Rings, there's only one line in the entire trilogy where a woman talks to another female character! (and it's a kid). Don't want to go into spoilers in case you haven't seen it. Beauty standards happen in fantasy, drama and action as well, where you'll never see a fat woman unless it's a tragedy about how her fatness impacts her life. My dad, being a doctor, is constantly remarking on how most people in dramas or action movies would be dead or permanently injured for life within 5 minutes of the plot, but nobody refuses to see action movies because the explosions would never go like that in real life! I don't know. I think people want romcoms to be real life and on message in a way they don't demand from other genres.
Talk your shit Lola🔥🔥🔥 100% facts
I tend to prefer slow burn romance, so usually ones that happen in TV shows or books, not films, which are a bit too abrupt. However, sometimes I can get in the mood for them, and I'll binge a few romance films, like Bound, Before Sunrise, Signature Move, Anything's Possible, Bridesmaids, Crush, the Shape of Water, or Saving Face.
As many pointed out, a lot of it is rooted in misogyny. Romcom/romance movies are really the only genre that focus on women, so they've been painted with a broad brush as trivial or dumb. And people love to write off the entire genre due to bad ones they've seen, but there are problematic and bad movies in EVERY genre. There are also great romance/romcom films. I do understand some people don't enjoy stories focused on romantic relationships though, which is valid, I just feel like the hate for the rom genres is oversized when compared to others. As for great romcoms, When Harry Met Sally is one of my all-time favorite movies. I also love While You Were Sleeping and The Wedding Singer. Bridesmaids is also a favorite film of mine, but I wouldn't label it a romcom. I suppose many do because it's a comedy that features a predominantly female cast and has some very minor romance elements to it, but I'd say it's more of a comedy-drama (it has some great emotional depth to it, and I find the protagonist's struggles relatable on many levels).
I totally agree with this
Romance films tend to not be particularly romantic tbh.. imo romantic plotlines work best when they’re not the main focus of the story Romcoms can be fun though
When done right, ‘romance’ films can be completely character driven. Writers have to create suspense in fairly low stakes situations - so the good ones spend time investing you in the characters and creating satisfying, complex arcs for their growth. That usually involves a level of immersion in the character’s social life and gives way more room for supporting characters to shine. It also makes the writer lean heavily on dialogue and subtext. Call Me By Your Name has no villains, no shoot outs, but it puts so much emphasis on subtext that you get this intense teenager urge to replay conversations with your crush over and over again searching for hidden meanings. Theres something achingly familiar in some of those stories that I don’t really feel with other types of media very often.
That being said, misogyny can really spoil the genre from the creators commodifying ‘Rom com’ to the audience’s constant devaluing of ‘chick flick’ content even if it is sophisticated and creative. I’d just suggest choosing content carefully :)
Can we recommend 'Love Actually' or 'Last Christmas' during the month of December. We're not huge fans of the genre, but these 2 we watch religiously every year ..... both will make you laugh and cry equally but leave you feeling uplifted, and with a spring in your step.
I also like The Family Stone
Oh the other hand, if you decided to watch The Way We Were (Barbra Streisand + Robert Redford) in honor of Redford’s phenomenal career and recent death, I would be all-in and I would begin crying during the opening credits. Cheesy splendor.
Some great comments and insight. I don't care for the typical romcom, but there are some great films out there with beautiful portrayals of connection, love, and storytelling. I would love to see you react to these: 1) The Before Sunrise trilogy Before Sunrise is my favourite romance film of all time. Each film released about 9-10 years apart. I think that last film would hit differently now at my age. I haven't seen Before Midnight since it came out in 2013. 2) Lost in Translation This is such a beautiful classic. The soundtrack, cinematography, the subtle acting that says everything while sometimes speaking very little. 3) Ghost Okay, but this is truly a classic. Patrick Swayze, Demi Moore, and Whoopi Goldberg. I'm a sucker for love, and this movie makes me laugh out loud and bawl my face off, no matter how many times I've seen it.
Another vote for Ghost here too ...... superb film
I love them! Call me by your name is top tier cinema. BUT I do not like crying and a lot of these are just mostly ugly crying for me. Gotta be in the mood
It’s my fav genre when it’s done properly but it’s extremely difficult to get right so you’ll only find a GOOD romance once every couple of years. Call me by your Name (my fav movie of all time) gets it right. So does Heartstopper s1-s2. Bridgerton s1-s2 and Bridgerton spin-off Queen Charlotte get it right. And, although it’s a very dark road, imo IWTV gets it right.
It’s because romance is geared towards women and our society is misogynistic.
real
I think people treat them like representatives of real life instead of what they are....fantasy and mild social commentary. For example, when you watch a fantasy or action generally there is a certain level of suspension of disbelief that romance movies just don't always receive. Personally...I love them but the quality has been low for the last decade or so ... 90s and early 00s were the peak.
That's a good point about the suspension of Disbelief
I hope we can all agree that a romantic film and a “romance” film (genre) are not the same thing. There are some glorious movies with a love story at the center, but they are as different from genre romance as a literary novel is from a bodice-ripper. Example (with the caveat that we now know Woody Allen is a predator and an asshole) : his movie “Annie Hall” with Diane Keaton is romantic and a comedy, but I wouldn’t lump it together with romcoms.
Good distinction to make for sure
There are so many movies with a romantic love at the heart of a great story: Out of Africa, for example. But genre romance movies don’t interest me much because they are so often predictable. IMO, when you’ve been in love as an adult, and you’ve experienced the pain, the reality checks, and the difficult work of keeping love alive, the fairytale love stories lack the depth of the real thing. Love is hard. Romance is just the fun part before the work begins.
Sorry for another comment but I'm realizing I also don't like them because as a woman I'm supposed to like them? And they often don't even seem very positive in the message toward women!
This: “chick flicks” talk down to women.
A combination of misogyny influencing both the disinterest in male audiences who don't want to be associated with socially-deemed "feminine" feelings, stories or emotions and the often watering down of complex dynamics or complex women to create a specific heteronormative narrative leading to women, the target audience, feeling exhausted, unrepresented, reduced, or bored with it all. That said, I'm a sucker for romance and easily manipulated by cheesy romantic archetypes in film and will cry at anything even if it's pretty unrepresentative and flattening of my own queer womanhood (and there are complex and dynamic stories that don't represent me in any way shape or form - not an important factor unless we're discussing bigoted exclusion or misrepresentation!) A good story is a good story. How we feel about stories is cultural and sociopolitical.
bars
I agree with much of what I see in these comments as to why people dislike romantic comedies - which is what most people think of in terms of "romance" film genre. There are some good classics, but rom-coms really did become an oversaturated genre of formulaic, stereotype-affirming "fairy tales" marketed to women. The thumbnail you picked is interesting because it's actually full of films focusing on romantic relationships that are not rom-coms. I adore Before Sunrise 🌅
Wait!! Hold the phone everybody... Frank has not seen Bridesmaids!!!??? 😮 We must rectify this grave travesty of fate!!!
Oh yea, I'd be down for that. That shit was hilarious lol
For me its simply boring or it fills me with sickening envy. I'm painfully single so watching people fall in love is just annoying lmaooo but exceptions to the rule are things like "Nosferatu" or "Interview with the Vampire" or k dramas like "When Life Gives You Tangerines". I need there to be stakes.. life/death etc. Real existential issues that are intertwined with the love story...Hell, I would consider the slow burn romance in Godzilla Minus One to be one of my favorite love stories along with Sinners... as you can see I literally just listed all horror films minus the k drama lol... I also just cant relate to many romantic characters because they behave in ways that I never would so its a hard watch...
felt
Romance and Rom-Coms are chock full of red flags and unrealistic expectations that women are basically conditioned "this is what your life should look like otherwise your relationship is trash". Most of it is extremely toxic and, especially women, will have unrealistic expectations on how the relationship should look. I'd much prefer shows like Vikings, Fallout, or Alien: Earth and movies like The Long Walk, Sucker Punch, The Help, etc. I watch a lot of True Crime and listen to court cases to pass time at work. My boyfriend's answer: Because women grow up and realize that stuff isn't real and an actual relationship is work, compromise, and you don't need grand gestures to prove you love someone. It just creates a society of disappointed women.
Love both of your responses
I don’t mind a love story if it’s like a secondary subplot to something else and done well (tons of caveats on that) but I’ve never been entertained by romance as a main plot. I’m pretty sure it’s been said, considering all the comments this post has already gotten in like 45 minutes(!) but most romcoms and romantic dramas are riddled with misogyny and unrealistic expectations that I can’t see as escapism for myself. I can see a bit of lust as escapism but if the story is about love, it's most likely going to come off as boring and formulaic to me.
totally Feel you on that
Can I just add that I hate the RomComs that feature a beautiful woman but the leading man is yuck? I swear it makes me seethe...it feels like an insidious form of misogyny. 😂
...or a male writer's fantasy lol
I find it quite ironic, spending days reading fanfiction and romantic stories, that I can't really connect with most romance "classics"? I haven't been growing up with those films, and watching these as a grownup - it's clear that most of these 80s-2000s romcoms present some highkey misogynistic and quite toxic ideas These films usually just push heteronormativity and stereotypes. I think romance works best when it's not just "kithing for the sake of kithing", but when it grows naturally within the plot. "The good place" mastered that for me, really 🤭 and most of the queer stories from recent years 🤭
This is true. And yes, not growing up with it can play a big factor in how much of it you can take
I mean they can be pretty lame, I don't think it's necessarily a no-no but the quality varies wildly. Romantic comedies can be very premium though.
I feel you, but so can every genre.
Also don't get me wrong I LOVE romance just I like when it's a little spice in there lmao (no wonder iwtv is my favorite )
preach
I love the romance genre! I think it’s just easy for people to crap on it. I mean they called them “chick flicks” for years as if being geared towards women is less than. I think people also don’t like to give them a chance
Very valid
The ones I grew up on - from the 90s and 2000s - were rampant with terrible messaging. As an example, She’s All That implies that if you change everything about your physical appearance, you can get the hot jock guy. There’s also way too many films to count where a guy doesn’t take No for an answer, pursues the girl relentlessly, and ends up getting with her, implying that if you keep hounding her and pushing her boundaries, she’ll eventually give in More often than not I just don’t relate to this genre because the women in it often excuse behavior and actions I wouldn’t. And the men writing these women are often clueless as to what constitutes as romance to real women, while rewarding mediocre men with women that would honestly be better off without them. All the women have done by the end of a lot of these movie is learn to lower their standards. Though, sometimes women write bad romance movies too (Trainwreck with Amy Schumer comes to mind, her character needed therapy, not a relationship) Also, not all, but a lot of these movies are formulaic and boring, to me anyway But I know a lot of people like formulaic, it’s comforting, hence the popularity of Hallmark Channel movies I’m not anti romance genre, and there are definitely some gems that Ive revisited over the years. Good romance movies with competent characters do exist Overall, however, Its just not a genre I get excited by I think I prefer to read my romance more than watch it. Maybe because there’s a cerebral aspect present that’s often missing from the movies. And books are often written with more depth and complexities, both the men and the women characters Ready for y’all to fight with me lol, I know my opinion won’t be popular 🤺💁♀️
nahh all your points are very valid
Since we're talking about it, Frank, you've probably seen bridesmaids, no?
I don't think I have
I like romance in films/TV if it's actually written well. I grew up watching and loving romcoms but looking back now, so much of it has just aged like milk 😬 Some notable exceptions would be The Holiday, The Last Holiday, Big Fat Greek Wedding, and While You Were Sleeping... Though I think the pattern for these examples is that the romance is only an element of the plot 🤷🏼
aged like fucking milk😂 I feel that. So many problematic things
personally i just don’t like it when the main focus of a story is romance, since i was a kid it always felt boring to me. it’s still the same now, with rare exceptions like queer movies (carol, imagine me & you, for example). a friend actually recommended "the proposal" to me a long time ago and it wasn't that bad, so that’s an exception too. i think i just don’t really connect with heteronormative romance, which is mostly what you get from hollywood movies
Very valid
Because women like it. On another channel I subscribed to, the two male hosts have by now watched about 20 romcoms... Still, *every single time* they watch one, they make very sure to remark in the intro that of course they've never watched it before because "romcoms are not my thing, you know" or "I saw the poster and thought it was gonna be stupid" or "my girlfriend went to watch it, but I didn't" or even, straight up "when this was in theaters, I rejected all chick flicks on principle". It becomes irritating. They just have to remind everyone every time that they're only watching a romcom for the channel, that they never would otherwise. Like it would make people question their masculinity or something.
Fucking wild isn't it. It suck so much how ingrained that casual massage in it is. It's almost like they know they're gonna be flamed by the men in their comments, so they have to leave that warning beforehand
I find most romance films to be simplistic and unoriginal. I mainly like classic love stories based on books, like P&P. I'm also a person that is drawn to the dark in art -- books, poems, tv/film, songs, etc. When I was young, I was a hopeless romantic. Life sure smacked that out of me. ❤️🩹
Yeah that's me too... love the Jane Austens, Brontes, etc. It's not that I hate romance, it's more the formula for a lot of romcoms is super predictable so it feels like watching the same movie over and over. Plus, if im 100% honest, I cannot stand romcoms where the woman is beautiful and the guy is yuck...they infuriate me! 😂 I'm always thinking "how dare you market this to women!" It feels like an insidious, sneaky form of sexism! 😅
I don't mind it. I think however too, for me personally, it isnt not romance like shows like interview with the vampire or things like that, I do get tired of Romance kinda the same with horror, I never was into the paranormal movies or things like that
gotcha
I've never liked romantic movies much but I frickin' love it in RPG's. Just has a whole other feeling for me to the point where an RPG feels like it lacks something if it doesn't have romance at this point.
Totally get that
Heteronormativity. Amatonormativity.
I fucking love Carol though lol there are exceptions
It's your audience. Other channels do well with romance. That's why I always think reactors should just watch movies THEY like or are curious about. Then you will build your natural audience and find people that like those things too. If you build your audience on what you think or see as being popular your just building the same audience your competitors have. It's the same people and unfortunately that leaves a not out groups out. It's the same for black cinema as well. There is an audience for it but if you don't watch the movies and give that audience time to find you you won't build it up. Your white, male dominated audience will never ask for these movies because they haven't seen them themselves. Everyone does the same movies and same shows. It's boring when there are so many other kinds of movies, like romance, suspense, drama, and black cinema. I'm a subscriber to several channels but I only pay for 2 patreons and they are the ones who are willing to watch just about any movie. It's nice to get an alert and see a movie they no one else has reacted to yet.
You're making A LOT of very wrong assumptions about me and this channel in this comment that I don't even have the time to debunk
For me personally, I watched it a lot before because I never felt romantic love and I wanted to understand what it was. And a lot of movies and tv show made me idealize the idea of romantic love. I still haven't fall in love but I'm in peace with it now.
i feel you
I know some people who just think it’s dumb or predictable but I think it depends on the person
i see
Im a woman scorned right now. No romance for me until the feeling passes
DITTO
Its SUPER toxic. A lot of troupe that use to be considered romantic are pretty terrible now.
No shocker there. I love me some good romance or romcoms though. 🥰
I’m not totally out, by any means, but I’m always wary—I had an ex who was deep in the genre, and I genuinely think it warped her perception of what love is supposed to look like. To both of our detriments. To be sure, far from everything in the genre is apt to do that… but a decent bit of it…?
Honestly, I think a lot of it is either misogyny or internalized misogyny. It's popular to dunk on things that women love. That being said, it doesn't help that a lot of romcoms weren't well written and oversaturated the market pre-MCU
That's understandable
I get it, I do. However, im just a jump scare, gasping, plot twist, gut wrenching loss, apocalyptic girl at heart. I need something more devastating. It's me, not the rom-coms. 😅
This!
I'm one of them. When do I watch one I usually enjoy it, but I don't go out of my way to watch them as I'd much rather dedicate the minute amount of time I do watch movies or TV to be a genre I really enjoy like horror, Sci-fi or similar. 🤷♀️ Now I have Patreon I spend even _less_ time watching new TV/movies 😂
I hear you. Sometimes it's just about taste and preferences in Genre
Can’t speak for anyone else because I LOVE romance! But if I were to hazard a guess I’d say it might be harder for some people to get involved in the worlds of romance stories because the stakes are generally much lower? But some of my absolute favorite movies and shows of all times are heavily romance.
Word
Couldn’t be me! Love romance/rom-coms. I see Call Me By Your Name up there. If you’ve never seen it, god would I love to see you react to it.
I'd also love a Call Me By Your Name reaction
With some exceptions, generally the cheesiness? With that said, Bridesmaids is one of my favorite movies. Not sure that's technically 'romance' tho...
I feel you. We could all use some of the cheesiness. We live in a dark world
It really depend on your audience. If you have cultivated a very analytical fandom, they might not feel inclined toward romance as it is usually seen as just " fun" . Could also just be misogyny but I'll be charitable
I hear you. My audience loves romance. Romance movies are usually high on the voting polls But yes misogyny, you for sure. Don't be so charitable next time😊. They don't offer the world the same courtesy
I know some people consider them 'chick flicks', so it's at least partly misogyny. I personally can't stand war or mob flicks/shows.
I love a good romance or rom-com. Can't have everything I watch be some heavy stuff.
Real talk
Im not one of those people hahaha! I loooove the romance
🔥
