💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
October 25, 2025

True Detective! Should I watch season 2 or skip it?

Initially, my intention was solely to watch season 1. However, my love for Jody Foster and Mahershala Ali compelled me to explore seasons 3 and 4. I’ve come across numerous rational arguments both in favor and against season 2, so I’ll leave the decision to you all. Sound fair?

Comments (21)

C
Catherine Thurmond · October 28, 2025

I've only watched season 1 and 4 so I don't know.

H
Hunter Cox · October 26, 2025

Actually, wouldn’t mind you watching S4 just to see your reaction between that and the first.

H
Hunter Cox · October 26, 2025

Skip 2 and 4. Watch 3.

L
Lara Bryant · October 26, 2025

Whatever you do don’t skip 3. Best television acting I’ve ever seen by Mahershala Ali

S
Shane · October 25, 2025

I actually quite like season 2, but I understood why people didn't.

D
Devon Michelle · October 25, 2025

Watch season 4!!!! It’s so good!

O
OffBy50 · October 25, 2025

I'd say watch it if only for the fact that I wouldn't mind revisiting it to see if/how it holds up! I only watched it the one time when it came out and while it is a step down for sure, I remember it still being better than a lot of shows around that time. I still recall all the major plot beats and characters so it stuck with me in some sense!

K
KimM · October 25, 2025

I vote to skip Season 2. I didn't even finish it despite liking actor Colin Farrell...he was fantastic in the film "The Penguin". I enjoy Ali and Foster as well and vote to watch seasons 3 and 4.

i
iris · October 25, 2025

I havent watched it so I’d say either option works for me as long as you eventually get to season 4 🤞🏻. much love

C
Chris · October 25, 2025

2 had a lot of potential, but it was rushed and very impacted by a writer’s strike. Sad waste of a bonkers Collin Farrell. I’m maybe the only person on the planet whose favorite season is 4.

i
iris · October 25, 2025

No way, I love season 4 so much too!!

C
Cristabel · October 25, 2025

I vote skip. I can’t really even remember it it was just so grim and heavy and forgettable except for that grim heavy vibe. I loved S4 and S3 is also good.

J
Jen Bee · October 25, 2025

SKIIIIPPP 😝 Okay, so I usually try not to weigh in like this to avoid potential bias tainting, BUT since we’re being asked lol 🤷🏻‍♀️…So anyways, consider the following VIBE SPOILERS FOR S2-4. NO PLOT SPOILERS, BUT JUST MY OPINIONS OF WORTH. DO NOT READ IF YOU DON’T LIKE TO HEAR OPINIONS BEFORE WATCHING . . . . . . . For me, s2 way misses the mark and I couldn’t watch it. But s3 got me back in that s1 vibe again and I really liked it. Imo, though, it’s not as good as s1, but that’s okay because it still really delivers, especially as Frank said getting to watch Mahershala Ali, his performance is superb (duh lol). But the whole cast is really good, and I especially really enjoyed the dynamic between Ali and his partner Stephen Dorff. Now, s4. I was SO HYPED for s4. First of all, Jodie Foster?? COME ON. As the kiddos say, I am sat 😂 And two, I am automatically so on board for anything in an icy cold setting. And then of course, coming from s3, I assumed we were good to go. Now, idk. Maybe my expectations were too high. But honestly? I was SO let down by the first episode, I just didn’t bother continuing. For me, it was the lack of artistic craftsmanship that I’d come to expect from the show. Instead, it had that very artificial and pedestrian feeling coupled with weird pacing thats such a hallmark of too much of contemporary film making (and I’m very turned off from). Either give me immersive realism or creative artistry, and either way, definitely take the time to let moments breathe and make sure what is shown is meaningfully giving us a connection to characters. Too much contemporary films and shows don’t seem to know how to do that, and instead feel flat but with bells and whistles, like a gassed up soap opera that’s just checking boxes. Don’t get me wrong, there are exceptions to the norm still out there being made, thank goodness lol. But for me, s4 wasn’t starting out as one of them. Maybe I’ll try again to watch the whole series when Frank does and end up changing my mind, who knows lol! Love to hear anyone’s thoughts on that and what your experience with s4 was (plot spoiler free, of course).

m
melskmelsk · October 25, 2025

I'd to a large extent forgotten about True Detective when I watched S4 (for Jodie Foster and the setting like you) and I think coming into it without the expectation that it have a "True Detective" feel helped a lot. Without going into any detail, the subject matter explored in S4 was very up my alley so I found it easy to immerse into. I loved it. I'm curious to revisit it with Frank fresh off S1 and 3 and see if it holds up for me.

J
Jenny Jackson · October 25, 2025

Season 2 has a mesmerizing opening credits that's worth checking out but that's about it 😂

K
Kim D · October 25, 2025

I only ever watched season 3 cos I love Mahershala too. I'll watch anything he's in. I love Colin Farrell too though so I might check it out at some stage. Basically, I can't really give an opinion on season 2! 😃

F
FrankFreezy · October 25, 2025

fair

N
Nick Cangemi · October 25, 2025

Only season 1 is worth watching. Go back to Succession!

F
FrankFreezy · October 25, 2025

what?

A
AngryGreen · October 25, 2025

There are 2 of each option!

F
FrankFreezy · October 25, 2025

What do you mean?