POLL | What should we watch next? IT: Welcome to Derry OR Heated Rivalry???

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE watch heated rivalry my life will literally be COMPLETE IM BEGGING

Watch Severance and my life is YOURs!

Miles + Heated Rivalry please and thank you

NOOO DONT LET THE YAOI WIN PLEASE WATCH WELCOME TO DERRY

heated rivalry w/ jay would be so funny

please do heated rivalry with the perfect person bachelor crew, i think it’d be the best combo

It seems like heated rivalry is going to win but I definitely recommend watching both it movies if you end up watching the series

eric x alan watching heated rivalry would literally heal me I think lmfao

Whatever happens please watch welcome to derry eventually. i need an excuse to watch it again

Okay Heated Rivalry is clearly winning the poll, but please please watch welcome to derry afterwards!

If you watch HR I'll cry

heated rivalryyyyy are you kiddinggg, it’s not even a debate fr

hr pls we need a break from the horrors imo

It Welcome to Derry pleaseeee I begggg

Heated Rivalry and then Welcome to Derry immediately after

HR is an evergreen. IT right after Stranger things will hit way better.

please be derryyy

welcome to derry, please give us canadians something during this trying time

hr is so peak

both...both is good

PLEASE heated rivalry

Plsss is there an option to do both 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

I literally have purposely held off on welcome to derry for you

WELCOME TO DERRY COME ON IT IS HUGE FOR PMI

heated rivalry will be so peak

heated rivalry please and thank you

I vote for a Heated Rivalry solo commentary!

Heated Rivalry winning is absolutely criminal

Watch not eventually

IT, simply because its probably the better version of what Stranger Things could've been

You got to watch Heated Rivalry with either Alan or Derek for the horniness factor!

Absolutely adore Heated Rivalry, and it's genuinely such a technically good show, but so is Welcome to Derry, so really either one is incredible.

Gosh I know Heated Rivalry is so trendy rn but I think It Welcome to Derry was so good. I think it captured what was good about the early seasons of Stranger Things and obviously seeing Bill Skarsgard as Pennywise is a straight up delight.

NO IM SORRY LOVE THE GAYS BUT YALL NEED TO WATCH WELCOME TO DERRY NOOOOOOO

is there an option for both 😁

I would love a solo commentary for Heated Rivalry like the ones from Bridgerton 🫶

Omg this is so hard!! IT Welcome to Derry is no doubt my favorite of the two shows, but I do feel that your reaction to Heated Rivalry will be so much more fun personally. Either way, I’ll be happy 🫶😊

I kinda expected more from It: Welcome to Derry tbh. The first few episodes almost lost me with the imo over-the-top/CGI horror-scenes, BUT Chris Chalk gives one of the years best performances in this & it at least gets better at the end.

I really enjoyed Welcome to Derry. A commentary for that would be very fun

also eric i know you dont take requests but you should check out the show silo with rebecca ferguson. it’s a fun concept, i enjoyed it quite a bit actually

Welcome to Derry was boring and terrible, Heated Rivalry was the best show I’ve seen all year. But sometimes terrible shows make for good commentaries so either way it’ll be a good time

HEATED RIVALRY I need Eric to go with us to the cottage

would absolutely love an excuse to rewatch Heated Rivalry another time (not that I needed an excuse for all the other times I've already rewatched it). I think honestly Derick or Alan would be great to watch this one with!!!

Welcome to Derry would be a very fun watch

derry!!

looks like heated rivalry is gonna win. Would love to see reactions to some of the stuff in welcome to derry but may have to wait a bit longer for whenever it gets done

IT Derry is so shit Heated Rivalry is gonna get you way more gassed !!!

All you guys suckkkkkkk. I want a Welcome To Derry commentary like Yesterday lmao

both pleaseeeee

wtf is heated rivalry.. why is this even an option… over derry that was literally just trending

Heated Rivalry is a MUST #GoTigers #GoMetros #GoRaiders

I was holding off on Welcome to Derry in case y'all did tracks for it, so I'm manifesting...

If theres a world where both get watched, that world!

oooo this is tough bc i was specifically waiting on watching welcome to derry in case u released tracks for it, but i also loved watching heated rivalry and think ur commentary would be sm fun

No fair this is a tough pick!!! I hope you get around to both no matter what!

i’ve literally been praying for HR to be mentioned

Watch both!!!

what if PMI did......b o t h ?

Welcome to Derry PLEASE (still wouldn't be disappointed by Heated Rivalry tho)

NEED heated rivalry with Deric

ive never needed a commentary track more than heated rivalry

Welcome to derry PLS it’s so good

I need heated rivalry tracks so bad y'all don't even understand

Will be happy for either honestly

you should also just watch both heheh

heated rivalry with derrick!!!

heated rivalry pleeease the first thing I did when i finished was check for your commentary 😭🙏 i needed you to witness the tiger moments

Pls watch Welcome to derry it’s such a great show at least watch it later 😭🙏

HEATED RIVALRY 🙏🙏🙏🙏

Heated rivalry will unironically rewire your brain. I’m dead serious

I see heated rivalry is winning and it’s only six episodes I hope you can watch both or pls watch WTD after🙏🫡

HEATES RIVALRYYYYT

heated rivalry will have you kicking your feet. you can do welcome to derry whenever but heated rivalry is the moment

oh no the vote is so close i guess we have to do boooooth! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Welcome to derry is maybe my favorite series of the year

WHY NOT BOTH PLEASE GODDDD

Welcome to derry pls 🙌

welcome to derry 🙏🙏🙏

Welcome to derry is the show of the year !

I know people are saying Miles for heated rivalry but I think Derick would also be fantastic

Heated Rivalry would be something different than what you have done so far and it is so much more than a gay hockey show. But I hope you can do both at some point. But if it’s between the two I pick Heated Rivalry

welcome to derry, you guys would have A LOT of fun with it!!

Please welcome to derry, I’m so conflicted on the show even though I had so much fun! Would be so hyped to see/hear you watch it

Pls welcome to derry 😭🙏

pmi heated rivalry is verbatim what my mom asked for this christmas PLEASEEE

Never heard of heated rivalry and bill skarsgard is goated in WTD

This is so tough because I would prefer Heated Rivalry but Derry feels more your speed. At least I’ll finish Derry if it wins the poll lmao. I dropped it after an episode and a half.

I think you’d have fun with Heated Rivalry BUT I think Welcome to Derry is way more your speed and you’d enjoy it much more—also happy new year, Eric!

guys please welcome to derry😭 genuinely a 10/10 show with no bad episodes. gonna be such a fucking upgrade from the last season of stranger things

Knowing your audience we all know what most people are voting for lol

what the heck is Heated Rivalry and how is it winning against 2025's best show: Welcome to Derry?

fuck it, make it a pmi first and commentate both at the same

Such a hard choice cause I know Eric will love welcome to Derry but I also love gay shit 😩

Welcome to Derry is such a good show!

which ever miles will do with you

Welcome to Derry for sure >>>

i need this motivation for watching welcome to derry

Eric WHY would you make us pick between two amazing options

I need welcome to Derry so badly

I need to see Eric’s reaction to Heated Rivarly. He’s gonna be tickled pink

need heated rivalry with miles or no deal

I cannot express how tickled I would be to see a PMI track to heated rivalry, Eric please dear god do heated rivalry

The reactions and annoying kid jokes would make Welcome to Derry an unforgettable set of tracks

both!!!!! BUT i would rather rewatch heated rivalry than welcome to derry soooo

heated rivalry i am genuinely begging yall

I hope welcome to derry wins

Definitely Heated Rivalryyy ITS SO GOOD !!!!!

Welcome to Derry truly is something that is so damn fun to watch. I was SAT every Sunday night

both! but if i’d have to pick one, heated rivalry 100%. best show ever you guys will love it

Would you redo the tracks for the IT movies with whoever you're going to do the show tracks with?