Next car giveaway, want your opinions.

I found a local dealer that actually has some reasonably priced cars.  Hard to do in this market.  I also found a student who is graduating this year, has a disabled father, is already working in an auto shop training to be a mechanic, and he is trying to save money to buy his own car.  👍🏻  Great candidate.  Several cars to pick from, but 3 of them are rebuilt titles, meaning they were in an accident and totaled by insurance, then repaired.  Here's those 3:
https://ridemaxautos.com/vdp/19745775/Used-2006-Toyota-Avalon-4dr-Sdn-XLS-Natl-for-sale-in-Rustburg-VA-24588
https://ridemaxautos.com/vdp/19746170/Used-2014-Kia-Forte-4dr-Sdn-Auto-LX-for-sale-in-Rustburg-VA-24588
https://ridemaxautos.com/vdp/19746233/Used-2012-Hyundai-Sonata-4dr-Sdn-24L-Auto-GLS-for-sale-in-Rustburg-VA-24588
All 3 very low miles, seem to be well repaired.  I would need to drive first, but assume I can't find any problems.  Or there's this one:
https://ridemaxautos.com/vdp/19863653/Used-2005-Toyota-Corolla-4dr-Sdn-LE-Auto-Natl-for-sale-in-Rustburg-VA-24588
This one is older, a bit more miles, but it's a toyota with a clean title.  I'm leaning toward this one, because I think it is more likely to be a dependable car for longer.  Of course it is also cheaper.  I will have to save longer to buy the other ones, but that's ok if it's the right call.  I thought you guys might like to be involved in the decision.  Thoughts?