Is Subverse Adult Game of the Year for 2024?

I've been playing over the weekend. I tried it a little during early access, but waited for the 1.0 to really dive in. So far I've got similar impressions to what you're saying here. There's a lot that's good about it. Particular the story and characters. But the biggest disappointment is the implementation of the sex scenes. They just feel disconnected from the rest of the game. Even some of the recruitment scenes don't really fit their place in the story. Like the dialogue before Taron's scene is about eagerly rushing off together for a quickie. But then we're shown the Captain seemingly taking a nap while Taron sneaks up on him. I can't comment on the devotion quests, because I haven't unlocked any yet. I actually just learned that those exist from watching this video.