July 28, 2017

Why Does Creepypasta Suck

New video! I thought it would be at least another day of editing but i pulled an all-nighter instead, whoops. Now that's what I call /r/nosleep!

Why Does Creepypasta Suck (YouTube)

Comments (8)

K
Kevin William Walker · June 29, 2026

So, I wonder where a bunch of these creepy pasta-esque non-jokes in internet comedy feature in all this - particularly from creators I otherwise like, _e.g.,_ 'The Dirt Man', 'I've been here the whole time' on DropOut, the ending of every second Brian David Gilbert video... I'll maybe give _Too Many Cooks_ and all the stuff with Kenneth in 30Rock a pass just bc I was young enough to really love those, but you get my point?

K
Kevin William Walker · June 29, 2026

I mean, _Mr Meaty_ was a real tv show.

G
Greg McDaniel · July 30, 2017

I always thought "Jeff the Killer" was the most unbelievable of the popular Creepypastas. "Woooo, he cut off his eyelids so that he never sleeps, and is always out to get you!" Do you know what happens when you cut off your eyelids? Your eyes dry out and you go blind. Terrifying. Maybe he kills people with his white cane? Or sets his seeing eye dog on them?

D
Dundough Breadbox · July 29, 2017

Many levels of like

P
PogieJoe · July 28, 2017

When will get the Creepypasta about the Lost Episode of Jenny Nicholson in which a parallel universe Evil Jenny is secretly tapping at the window in the background the entire time?

J
Jenny Nicholson · July 28, 2017

Oh I just opened the window and she climbed in but I cut it, I thought it was boring

J
Jason Wynn · July 28, 2017

handle woman lol

B
Blue Corn · July 28, 2017

Your commitment to your craft is imposing.