SBNTS Sequel Poll

Given how cass reacted to the shining, doctor sleep would be great follow up

10 Cloverfield Lame? Over numerous horror classics?Who is voting for this? 🤣

Doctor Sleep (theatrical cut) would be a perfect review!

Hopefully, she will react to the close 2nd 10 Cloverfield Lane

winner movie's are Weapons Troll Hunter Harry Potter and the goblet of fire chitty chitty bang bang ghost busters frozen empire Hulk 2003

I did see Weapons. Guessing that will be on the Nope! list if it's not there already. Although the ending is kinda funny for a few minutes.

Scream 2 is one of the ones I want Cassie to react to this October. Now just add in Train to Busan, Frailty, and Fallen.

Olympic style voting would be awesome (ie doing a 2nd poll with the top 3 voted choices only )with this many choices, albeit the process would take longer.

Less than 1% difference between Scream 2 and 10 Cloverfield Lane.

Scream 2 won? You gotta be *expletive* me...

teenage mutant ninja turles out of the shadows Amazing movie

Yes! Scream 2 won the poll. :) :) Definitely the best of the crop of movies offered.

Oooff Picking cloverfield as the winner. Before alien, 28 weeks or scream 2. Tragic. For her and for the yt views. We need vetting on these polls. I want answers dammit.

I hope she watches Doctor Sleep, this spooky season, even though its currently in 3rd place. I think her love of Ewan McGregor will make it a little less scary for her.

I think GoT is making Cassie a little bloodthirsty. She may just watch all the Scream movies now, lol.

Sweet, Scream 2 actually won. It got pretty close there for a while, and I'm so used to movies I vote for losing! I must confess, I really didn't think Cassie would be willing to watch another Scream movie. That's why I voted for it over Split, which is my pick-a-flick vote. I really think Cassie will grow to love these characters, and the who's-the-killer aspect of this franchise if she sticks with it. 🙏🏻 P.s. I hope Cassie rewatches the first movie beforehand, or at least a recap. It's been a couple of years since she reacted to the first one after all!

where conjuring

I would have been happy with Scream 2, Halloween 2 or Cloverfield. But Scream got my vote, glad it won :)

Having seen Weapons recently, and it's one of the best movies this year, for me. Wondering if we can get it on a poll this October?

Come on people, get Doctor Sleep up over 500 at least…The Shining was one of Cassie’s best reactions ever

She liked Cloverfield (2008). Seemed to be one of her favs last October. She absolutely hated Scream (1996) when she reacted to that in 2023. She was not a fan of Blade last October. Glad that Blade 2 is a distant 4th.

Heads up, fellow reactor Jen Murray will endure "Evil Dead" (1981) this week...keep her in your prayers.😆

4,060 votes! That's about a grand more than normal, ain't it?

I will be the first to say that this isn’t my genre, but I definitely overlooked the popularity of 10 Cloverfield Lane. I’m sure there a lot of non horror genre fans voting on the poll, so I’m not surprised that Scream 2 is winning based on familiarity, but I wouldn’t have thought the same would go for 10 Cloverfield Lane. I actually thought Split would be compete for the top spot based on comments through the years.

Because of certain ongoing discussions here I want to quote the Patreon rules from the FAQ post: “It’s okay to have different opinions on movies/shows, and you’re free to debate/argue/discuss your points ALL DAY LONG, but there’s no harassing or name-calling other patrons. This obviously doesn’t include friendly banter”. I have been through this comments section multiple times and have seen nothing that violates this rule in even the broadest interpretation. No one enjoys hearing that other people dislike a movie they like, but at the same time no one enjoys hearing that people like a movie they dislike. Can I suggest that if someone’s opinion on a film, for or against, really bothers you that much, maybe just don’t read their posts? Because that person has a right, as expressed in the rules, to give their opinion, and give it multiple times if they so wish. Hopefully we can move on from this as the rule is rather definitive. (somehow I doubt it though)

Oh cmon its gotta be scream2

I hope she reacts to the Top 2 or Top 3, but not Top 4 or more. This is a sequels poll -- we need originals.

I worked on DR Sleep. I was the Assistant Colorist in post.

Had to be Dr Sleep for me, one of those unexpected classics. Dare I say, like Aliens better than the original.

Would love it if she reacted to the top 3 or 4. Probably not going to happen though. Cuz then we'd get doctor sleep and blade 2. Kinda sincerely feel bad for all the ppl vehemently opposed to a scream 2 reaction. Even though I voted for it.

Unsurprisingly it looks like Scream going to win, but personally I’d be very happy if Cassie reacted to the top 4 if it finishes with Cloverfield, Doc Sleep & Blade all being there.

Hmm.....don't really have any feelings about this poll. Vote for sale! Any takers?

Why can't I see Bjorn's response on my post below? There's a "Load replies" button, but when I click it, nothing happens. I think I've seen others complain about this.

Mods. Go take a look at the very first post on this thread. This guy has already been warned about his avatars (there’s one on the Update post that’s since been removed - the one where Gray responds “lol I guess the mods are asleep”) We warned this guy but he has once again put up a vulgar avatar. No messing around required anymore. Just ban his dumb ass.

It may not win but I love the fact that Doctor Sleep is on the radar. I know when you eventually watch it there will be plenty of objectionable stuff that hurts the heart to see. And it aims to and successfully captures the creep of The Shining at times. But there’s also some greatly loveable stuff that goes on that anyone can appreciate. I have many favorites depending on my mood, but The Shining has to be No. 1 for me and I really appreciate this sequel and its homage to the original film.

I don't know why this movie popped into my head, but has anybody else seen Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter? I feel like that could be a good not too scary movie for Cassie, lol

Unrelated but I don't care RIP Charlie Kirk

I’m a lifelong, die-hard ANOES series fan, but it disappoints me that ANOES 2 is NOT in last place. Easily worst movie on the list. But I’m down for whatever. 👍

These are all far too scary for me.

Please watch “What We Do In The Shadows” (2014) for October. It’s the perfect for you and Carly for Halloween.

Richard mentioned three legendary horror filmmakers in a post below. I believe Cassie should offer up polls of their work for inclusion in her Halloween reactions. John Carpenter Cassie’s already seen several of his best films (Halloween, The Thing, Christine, Starman and Big Trouble in Little China). But she still hasn’t seen several of his horror films, those being: The Fog (1980) Prince of Darkness (1987) They Live (1988) In the Mouth of Madness (1994) Vampires (1998) George A. Romero Cassie hasn’t seen a single film of Romero’s, which borders on criminal. Must see films include: Night of the Living Dead (1968) The Crazies (1973) Martin (1977) Dawn of the Dead (1978) Creepshow (1982) Day of the Dead (1985) David Cronenberg It’s my understanding that we’re finally gonna get Cronenberg’s masterpiece, The Fly. But other great Halloween fare directed by Cronenberg includes: Shivers (1975) Rabid (1977) The Brood (1979) Scanners (1980) Videodrome (1982) I’m aware that several of the movies on the above lists are really not horror, but Cassie’s certainly picked plenty of scary-adjacent film in the past and several of the listed films would have zero chance of getting a reaction otherwise.

Wow, these comments. It's like people aren't allowed to vote for what they want to see.

okay but hear me out. Weapons. its as funny as it is spooky. kind of.

Any Tremors sequel is a yes all day long.

Wow, a film written and produced as a standalone is in 2nd place in a Sequels Poll … smgh

Surprised not to see Just Plain Bob here. I figured he’d have a lot to say about this poll.

If you want to stop Scream 2, then vote 10 Cloverfield Lane that has the best (really only) chance to beat Scream 2. A few hours ago, 10 Cloverfield Lane had closed the gap to a mere 4 votes with Scream 2. Now I check, and Scream 2 has surged. I was hoping 10 Cloverfield Lane would win. Both get reasonable reviews. IMDb 7.2, Metacritic 76, RT 91%, RT Audience 79% - 10 Cloverfield Lane (2016) IMDb 6.3, Metacritic 62, RT 83%, RT Audience 58% - Scream 2 (1997) The best chance to affect the outcome (1st place) of the poll is to vote 10 Cloverfield Lane or Scream 2.

I voted for Scream 2. Not only is it a great franchise overall (though some parts are better than others), but also your reaction to the first one was one of my favorite reactions of yours ever. Having said that... since you reacted to The Haunting of Hill House last year, will you continue with the Mike Flanigan shows? The Haunting of Bly Manor would be up next. Probably the least popular one out of the bunch, but still good and worth watching. Just don't expect it to be anything like Hill House and you won't be disappointed.

🤣🤣🤣up your butt , vote or die followed by an I'm sorry 🤣🤣🤣 literally LOL

So, I don’t have alot riding in these October polls, as I’m not really a horror fan. I suppose out of these movies I prefer the Blade and Underworld movies. However, I shall not vote for them out of the principle they are not horror movies. I should imagine having them on a horror poll must be a little frustration for true horror Fans.

Surely Psycho 2 should be on the list. It's pretty decent

There are two Ghost Story movies, from 1981 and 2017. The first had a fantastic cast and a couple of creepy scenes but it was panned by most critics. The second was awesome, nothing too scary but funny and sad at the same time…..

I voted for Doctor Sleep since weirdly it would be kind of a horror break-through for Cassie, if that makes sense, lol. It's losing, so no worries.

Scream 2? Lol. Tremors 2 or blade 2, heck alien 3 is more fun to watch then any scream movies

Dang, thought doctor sleep would hold in to 1st or 2nd place

Poltergeist 2 is a good movie. Scary but not to scary. Perfect fit. Many of the same cast are in the sequel except the oldest daughter. She was murdered after the first movie came out.

I am a bit disappointed but not shocked at all that Tremors 2 is so low in the score. Not quite as good as the first, but still a good watch I think. Oh well. Also, for your own sake please don't bother watching Alien 3 it's infamous among fans for being nowhere near as good as the first 2.

I'm curious what Richard thinks about Scream 2, from the dozen or so comments I'm unclear whether he's a fan...?

I feel like Scream 2 will win based on sheer general popularity - but Blade 2 is a masterpiece. That's not hyperbole - Guillermo del Toro directed it - and he later went on to win Best Director and Best Picture for The Shape of Water.

Wasn't Mrs. PiB scared silly by the first Halloween? I did not expect to see that franchise here again. I went for the sequels to Blade, Scream and Nightmare on Elm Street.

I like Blade 2 *shrug* ... maybe the next poll will be more my thing

Ah. Since Split's not going to win, might as well throw a vote for Doctor Sleep to stop Scream from winning. 😀

I thoroughly disapprove of all this nastiness

Someone should let Cassie know Doctor Sleep was made from the same guy who did The Haunting of Hill House. So even if this doesn't win, it might be something she'd want to consider watching Spooky season or non-Spooky season, given how much she enjoyed that show.

If you watch Alien 3 make sure its the assembly cut. The theatrical version is absolutely awful. 10 Cloverfield Lane may not be a sequel but it is set in the same world. As is Cloverfield Paradox. Blade 2 is great, i think its the best of the 3. Split is amazing James McAvoy is superb.

10 Cloverfield Lane is NOT a sequel. In fact, Cinebinge reacted to it thinking the same and I think it spoiled George's reaction to the film because he kept trying to associate the previous film to it. Rather than enjoy what the movie was.

Split is excellent! And 10 Cloverfield Lane would be my second pick, and then Dr. Sleep.

I voted Nightmare on Elm Street 2 as, at that time, it was genuinely subversive to take a successful franchise with a male audience and make it gay

Blade 2 is an all timer.

Disappointing to see Split on the list. It's a fine movie, but it's much better to go into it not knowing it's a sequel. I guess that ship has sailed though.

Forget the poll, Cass. Just watch Halloween 2 just for me please. kthanksboo!

I'm a tender soul so I have very little skin in this game. I have a sneaking affection for Halloween 2, though. Jamie Lee returns and it's a pretty suspenseful stalker movie. I'm personally looking forward to Cassie watching some lighter fare, and let's face it....there are few things lighter than a Fly.

if doctor sleep wins, i think maybe we should give a heads up for that one scene?

This poll is too close for comfort. 😳

I wish I could vote for all of these haha

Hello Cassie / & Carly: I’m many ways karate kid is a famous Halloween iconic American moment (from 1984☀️: Would you put The Karate Kid” on your Halloween 🎃 poll list?? 🙋🏻‍♂️

10 Cloverfield Lane has closed the gap to a mere 6 votes with Scream 2.

I dint care for 90% on this list. But its hard to please me so im used to it scream is pure shite and i would never watch them. I can tell theyre bas just from half a trailer Alien 3 is interesting as its the best on here... Even in its theatrical release. But i dont care too much for that one... The movie onky becomes good in the Directors Cut. The exact opposite of the first Alien movie that becomes a bad movie in the Directors Cut. Too much is shown, and the effects are just not there yet. Hate when the xenomorphs walks down corridors like a bloke... Get on all four mate.... 😎

Damn is Poltergeist 2 that bad lol? 2% damn haha, so me and a couple other people, Poltergeist 3 was objectively bad, no doubt , but 2, I guess it's just me. Because that preacher guy was the boogie man for so many 80s kids, and Will Sampson as the shaman was a badass, although they literally lifted his lines practically straight from the Carlos Castañeda books about a (fictional?) Yaqui Mexican shaman, since Cassie probably won't ever watch it I'll just say one of my favorite dialogues but just the Will Sampson parts, Craig T Nelson also has lines but he's drunk and needs to hear this: "You feel like a leaf at the mercy of the wind don't you? Since the day you were born someone has been doing something to you, and they've been doing something against your will, but now you feel like a leaf in the wind,.... No matter how much you like to feel sorry for yourself, you have to change that, I'm a warrior, a warrior would rather be defeated and die than act against his nature, that is a path you have chosen to take, whether you know it or not, YOU should assume full responsibility... Responsibility for everything, EVERYTHING in your world." I love that, you can't of course, but you do the best you can.

So first of all - I definitely do not consider Alien 3 to be a horror movie! And if the time came to react to this film, which version are we talking about - the theatrical version or the director's cut? Because in this case, these are two completely different movies!

10 Cloverfield Lane currently 2nd place losing by only 16 votes to Scream 2. **Scream 2 - 387 **10 Cloverfield Lane - 371 4 days remaining in the poll. Maybe Scream 2 will lose steam. The current bottom 5: 8. Underworld 2 - 180 9. Alien3 - 156 10. Tremors 2 - 155 11. Nightmare on Elm Street 2 - 99 (next to last) 12. Poltergeist 2 - 76 (last place)

Once again we can count on the worst movie leading the poll - yes, Scream 2 is easily the worst movie in this poll. And that’s saying a lot considering how bad some of the other films are.

Nice to see my streak of picking losers shows no sign of stopping! 🤪

I'd like to see Cassie react to Paranormal Activity (ONLY the first one).

So, since Freddy and Michael Myers are getting low votes, next year would be Hellraiser and Friday the 13th franchises. Hellraiser would have such sights to show you, cassie!!!

The directors cut of Doctor Sleep is a woefully underrated film. Great casting, and an adherence to both the novel and the Kubrick version of The Shining. Highly recommend.

Scream 2 is the perfect October movie IMO. Part of that is probably my age range and the nostalgia, but it's also chronically on cable this time of year, and the seasonal associations just....are. Almost as much as the original Halloween, in my book. Actually surprised you've gone all these years without seeing it. It's lived on cable, HBO, streaming, and other movie channels for a while now. Hope you can enjoy it for what it is, if it wins. Think of these movies as a thrill ride/roller coaster and almost like a self-defense cosplay exercise. Go through the motions of the film, and maybe be that much more prepared for whatever comes in life. But it's all make believe. No need to take it too seriously if you don't want to.

Fortunately, looks like Blade 2 doesn't stand a chance at a distant 4th. The first Blade is so monotonous. She didn't like the first Blade.

Doctor Sleep is, full disclosure, kind of scary and horrifying, but it is SO one of the best sequels of any genre ever. I voted for several, but I don't mind if this wins but I just have to say it's pushing your boundaries some Cass, but the story, performances etc. really great. 10 Cloverfield Lane, ALSO, so good, so unique too, I personally think anyway. I'm a big horror fan in general so I can probably wax poetic about all these choices really, so I'm good no matter what wins, I'm just happy it wasn't a hundred degrees in Socal today, it's getting to World Series weather and the cool mornings and evenings of autumn that are my favorite time of the year 🎃 👻 😁

SPLIT = Must see performance!!!

I voted only these two: 10 CLOVEFIELD LANE and 28 WEEKS LATER. Happy that 10 Cloverfield currently a strong 2nd. Split and Doctor Sleep are my next top choices but couldn't bring myself to vote for them. 1st Scream destroyed her. I am ambivalent. I recognize that the 1st Scream may be revolutionary for the genre, e.g., with the satire (which she couldn't appreciate b/c the movie too real to her). I have only watched the first Scream once, and that was with her reaction. I have never watched a Scream sequel and don't intend to. I read that Scream 2 apparently makes fun of how bad sequels are. Glad that Halloween 2, Nightmare on Elm Street 2, Alien 3, Tremors 2, Poltergeist 2, and especially Underworld 2 are not performing the greatest in the poll. Remember THE SEQUELS RULE = "All sequels with rare exception are bad."

Cassie if you watch Alien 3 watch the assembly cut. But be aware Alien 3 the theatrical cut sucks. The third film was done by David Fincher who got screwed by fox studios interference as a first time director. It’s inferior to the first two but the assembly cut would be an acceptable film by itself. But the alien series has found glory again with the newest film. ALIEN ROMULUS! It takes place between the first two. But watch Prometheus and Alien Covenant before Romulus.

nightmare on elm street and halloween r classics

I honestly don't care about any of these, but I imagine "Doctor Sleep" will make Cassie squirm the most, given it will make her have to revisit "The Shining" (I'm guessing it's still the scariest movie she's ever seen, and, given her unwillingness to watch titles like "The Exorcist" or "Hereditary," she apparently doesn't want to challenge that status it holds). 😏

Only one I see on this list that is worth watching is Doctor Sleep. Cas would love that since she loved The Shinning. I will strongly recommend, The Exorcism of Emily Rose. It is based on the true story of Anneliese Michel,

Really pulling for Doctor Sleep but it looks out of reach. Not too scary I guess, but a fine sequel. I will say though, if Rebecca Ferguson ever came up behind me and said "Well hi there!" I would...need to change an article of generally non-visible clothing. In the bathroom. After I got done shaking.

Critters, The people under the stairs are ridiculous enough to be considered scary but not too scary. Plus nobody reacts to them. Flowers in the attic would be a good reaction. Split or Blade 2 would be my choices from that list. Why no Saw 2?😅

A Nightmare on Elm Street was the horror franchise of my childhood. From age 7-12 Freddy haunted my nightmares. I do feel plenty of nostalgia for the rest of the series but don't think the sequels are really worth your time. Not when so few horror movies get watched every year. Besides the first the 3rd one is pretty good and I think the best one is the final movie "Wes Craven's New Nightmare". But again there are better horror films to watch. You've met Freddy- a slasher icon. I think thats enough.

Most of these are pretty bad. Scream 2 is all right. Halloween 2 is ok but is a true slasher flick unlike the first one.

“Vote or die!” Looks like GoT is having a major impact on you, Cassie. 😂

Any of these would be fine EXCEPT for Alien 3. What a tremendous let down that movie was after one of the best sequels ever made set the bar for horror/action sequels. I’m not familiar with Doctor Sleep at all, so won’t be sad if that doesn’t make the cut.

Cloverfield Lane? Really ppl, really lol? Smh. The Scream franchise is awful too wtf. Yall have no taste lol.

Do you like scary movies? I mean there's one obvious winner and if it doesn't win, I'll Scream! 😂

While not the scariest, Split is the superior film be far!!

I'm not much for scary movies, but Split was really cool.

top 12 winner movie from popcorn in bed

Evil Dead 2 could have made the list. I don't think she has seen the original, but it can be skipped as the 2nd is really a remake rather than a sequel. The humor blunts a lot of the intense parts, so I'm confident Cassie could handle it at this point.

10 cloverfield lane is not scary

Dr, Sleep? why would you want to watch a sequel to a movie you fear. The Shining?

I just hate having to leave this community. I like it here so much. But I guess that time of the year is coming around again. And I'll just say so long until November. Have fun!

There are a lot of good choices on here that make this tough. But I ultimately lean towards Scream 2

The original from 1951.

Would prefer "The Day The Earth Stood Still" from 1951.

Going with Doctor Sleep since I've been needing a bigger reason to finally see it for a few years now, and I need a good new Ewan movie in my life.

Personally hoping for halloween 2 (Underappreciated sequel imo). Blade 2 would also be cool, though I remember the first not really being your vibe, cassie. 2 is more action-y though, and blade is just a smidge more tender a character this time around lol

I actually think Doctor Sleep will be a little cathartic for Cassie. She built up such a natural defence in her mind after watching the shining that doctor sleep was instantly dismissed. The shining was just a supernatural slasher. It was Kubrick's "atmosphere" that kept building and building that made it unbearable for Cassie. Full metal jacket is just a Vietnam war story. Again it was Kubrick's "atmosphere" that turned it into what it was. Doctor Sleep is definitely not a Kubrick production. It's still got some tough scenes to get through but there's a lot more respite too.

Really should skip Nightmare on Elm Street 2 and go straight to part 3.

Ultramarines: A Warhammer 40K Movie -- If you can think around the primitive CGI visuals, there's plenty of action, plus the Black Legion and the Chaos Demon that takes over Captain Severus (the late Terence Stamp) are some scary dudes. And John Hurt from the first Alien film voices the Imperial Fists Chaplain Karnak.

Split!! Come on....Doctor Sleep.!!! Lets go.... 10 Cloverfield lane.???? Over those other ones...

I dont know why but the Scream franchise never did it for me…i love horror movies and seen many many of them but i never got into Scream

I have little to no interest in any of these films. I'll probably use October the way I usually do: catch up on my backlog of reactions while ignoring most of the "Spooktober" fare. But you guys knock yourselves out! 👻

There’s an unwritten rule that any sequel that just has the original film’s title followed by a number is a bad sequel. This poll does a lot to prove that rule, with the possible exception of Blade 2.

Blade 2 was better than the original

10 Cloverfield Lane will be tremendous better, it's very unique and I know you won't be bored. But great poll though 👌

NONE OF THE ABOVE! I recommend "Trick 'R Treat" (2007). It's inarguably the BEST Halloween-themed movie EVER! The only reason it's not at the top of every scary movie fan's favourites list is that it tragically didn't get a theatrical release for dumb reasons that had nothing to do with the movie's quality. The film festival early screenings were universally positive, it received critical praise, and its beloved by genre fans. I finally saw it in August 2009 at the After Dark film festival in Toronto, and it was amazing! It's never going to win a Scary movie poll because it's not mainstream enough. I haven't even been able to get it on the poll for the past 2-3 years, so it's not gonna happen. PLEASE Cassie, just watch it! You recently picked "KPop Demon Hunters" as a surprise pick, so please pick "Trick 'R Treat" as a surprise Halloween season pick. "Trick "R Treat" is the perfect Halloween-themed movie, and it's scary-but-not-too-scary. It features Anna Paquin (Rogue from the X-Men films) and Brian Cox (Stryker from X-Men 2, and more notably, "Succession"). Carly would probably also enjoy it.

Come and see, horror war movie

Train to Busan: One of the best zombie films ever. Great performances (you will probably cry). Fallen: Denzel Washington. Nuff said. Frailty: Directed by Bill Paxton. Starring Bill Paxton (probably his best role) and Matthew McConaughey.

DOG SOLDIERS (2002) starring Kevin McKidd & filmed in Luxembourg. The best werewolf/lycan movie. The setting takes place in SCOTLAND. Can we make a reaction to it? 🐺 🎖️ Its my bday on OCT 28. Cheers 🍻

Doctor Sleep. I like it more than The Shining Despite Scream 2 acting like it’s in on the money-grab sequel cliche, it’s still a money-grab sequel. Voted for Split and 10 Cloverfield Lane also

Underworld 2 even has some romance. Cassie would love that

Cassie, you are really asking for it with some of these movies. Don't blame us if you get scared. Glad to see you getting ready for all the fun this season.

Has anyone else seen The Conjuring: Last Rites yet? Better than the Devil Made Me Do It, but not as good as the first two. Imo

I'm glad Cloverfield Lane is doing relatively well. I don't like the other Cloverfields, but Lane is awesome and I hope more people check it out

I'm still not resting until you see the 2003 remake of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Cassie. It's a rare horror movie in which the remake is better than the original.

Make sure you watch the special/extended version of Aliens 3 if you decie to watch it. It makes the film 100 percent better.

Thank God Underworld 2 isn't winning. Voted for Scream 2, Halloween 2, Alien 3, Doctor Sleep and Blade 2. Guess if I could've chosen 2 more it would be 28 weeks later and Split. Scream 2 is the one I'm rooting for mainly. Her reaction to Scream in 2023 (and The Thing of course) was the best part of Halloween PIB reactions that year. Very happy she's reacting to The Fly 1986 this year.

Alien³ - please watch the workprint, known on digital services as the Special Edition. Similarly, watch the Director's Cut of Doctor Sleep -- but be warned, I don't think it belongs on this poll as it will probably be quite frightening for you.

Cassie, you must react to The Monster Squad!! Such a fun not so scary 80's classic!

Gotta be 'Split' Absolutely fantastic

Scream 2 sucks. Dr Sleep or 28 Weeks

Booo lol, scream ain’t close to scary and slashers are like bottom shelf horror 😂. To each their own though.

Scream 2, really? Cassie loved the first one so much.🙄

Oh, come on, it's gotta be Split! We can't even say why but you know why (and how does she know it's a 'sequel'?). And it is by FAR the best movie on that list...

Tremors 2, scars mixed with laughs, the very definition of scary, but not toooooo scary!

Yes.... Go Dr Sleep, one of my favorite sequels.

It has...BEGUN.

Please put the Conjuring up for vote!

Not sure why 10 Cloverfield Lane is on this list. It is not a direct sequel to Cloverfield, nor is it set in the same universe. The film was initially developed as a separate script called The Cellar before being acquired by Paramount and Bad Robot, who decided to turn it into a Cloverfield movie strictly for marketing purposes.

Personally I thought Dr Sleep was poor felt like a parody at times. Not too many great films on this list. 10 cloverfield lane maybe

Scream 2, great. Doctor Sleep Director's Cut, amazing.

Tremors 2! Dr sleep sucks

"...Sequel Poll!" Sequels? Sequels?!?!?! I said it somewhere else and I'll say it again here, somebody at PIB *needs* to DM Richard and have him make multiple polls for October. Please.

NO on Doctor Sleep. Just NO, please! Haunted Honeymoon with Gene Wilder please!!!!!! :)

Dr Sleep....Cassie needs to go back to the Overlook hotel. Hehehe

Oh boy, please not alien 3. It's so awful. I'd swap with monster squad!

Saw 2 should have been on here. Its one of those rare ones where the sequel was better than the original.

I see Highlander 2 (1991) is not one of the choices; Good decision there, Cassie!... Although maybe one day we could have a Worst Sequels Ever poll; Jaws: The Revenge (1987), Batman and Robin (1997), Neverending Story 3 (1995) or Superman IV (1987). I personally think any one of those abysmal movies would make a great Cassie reaction!

Cassie, Halloween 2 is great, so i hope u will watch that and Monster Squad, The Craft, Doctor Sleep, I Know What You did Last Summer, and Silver Bullet. I love the Vote or Die .lol.

I can’t believe I didn’t vote for SPLIT given it’s my pick-a-flick vote each month But the chance for Cassie to watch SCREAM 2 is an opportunity I don’t think will come up again any time soon. It’s now or never I fear.

Voted for bunch, but if she somehow see Alien 3, she will hate the opening of it. (I think she might not) Like I did the first time I saw it… I would rather have her watch Predator 2.

Halloween 2 is as good or even exceeds Halloween 1. Give it some love.

There's some actual good ones on here: 28 Weeks Later and Doctor Sleep are both fantastic...but 10 Cloverfield Land is one my all-time favorites. Going with that.

Alien 3 just needs to be erased from history all together.

I voted for "Scream 2"

There's a lot of good choices here 👌

I'd suggest Extra Ordinary (2019), an Irish spooky rom-com horror comedy that sadly isn't all that well known. It's a great little movie, though -- take what you'd expect from an American horror comedy, run it through a quaint cozy Irish filter, and there you go. While I suspect that lesser known movies don't get the clicks, Cassie would definitely enjoy it!

You have to watch the classic, Gremlins!

Recommendation The Conjuring insidious When A Stranger Calls With Carly The Monster Squad Silver Bullet The Craft

Please let SCREAM 2 win! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 I have no doubt these characters will grow on Cassie if she just keeps watching.

My votes are for Nightmare 2, Alien 3, Tremors 2, Underworld 2, and Blade 2! I can agree with everyone that Nightmare 2 is the weakest link in the franchise, but what makes it worth watching is of course Robert Englund's performance as Freddy, he steals the show in every scene he's in, and not to mention I somewhat recently met its leading actress lol! Alien 3 is also the weakest link in the franchise also for many reasons, but it equally has many moments that makes it entertaining and has its scary moments and I still enjoy watching it for that reason! Tremors 2 is a worthy sequel and is just as fun as the first one, but definitely not better than the first! Underworld 2 is a fun and action packed sequel that dives deeper into the world of Vampires and Werewolves and of course the ever so beautiful Kate Beckinsale is awesome as ever! And finally Blade 2 is just as good as the first one but a little darker and slightly more violent, also one of its main actors I've also met recently lol! Good picks Cassie, can't wait to see which ones win! I'm still hoping for Van Helsing this Halloween season! Love and support 🥰😇🙏🤗✌️🌹

I voted for Dr. Sleep and Split. Because the Shining is one of the only 80s horrors I've ever seen that I thought was anything other than cheesy crap. And Split has James McAvoy who, as far as I'm concerned, can do no wrong yet.

Reccomendations: The Omen (1976) Carrie (1976) Vertigo (195?) The Dead Zone (1983) The Andromeda Strain (1971) The Omega Man (197?) Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978) The Thing (1951)

doctor sleep!

Doctor Sleep is hands down the best movie out of all of these

The Innocents from the early 60s had some scary moments when I was 10-11. Based on Turn of the Screw.

And if Scream 2 ends up winning, I hope you also watch I Know What You Did Last Summer and The Blair Witch Project. Then you'll be able to watch Scary Movie and understand all the references, as it parodies those movies along with others.

Split was great, any movie my parents go out of their way to tell me they enjoyed must be incredible XD

Bride of Frankenstein (1935) a sequel that is better than the original and it's Not Too Scary! Hey, I'm serious, guys!

Not trying to be a killjoy or spoiler spoilsport or tattletale but one of the movies listed here would probably not be eligible for the PiB Pick-a-Flick under one of the listed content restrictions. But I know some people wouldn't think it disqualified .... I guess I'll just have i leave it there. One person's "Do not pick a movie featuring ______" is another person's "No spoilers!" Or "It's not that bad". I'll just vote for different candidates.

I'd put Halloween (2018) and Halloween Kills on there. That storyline makes way more sense than Halloween 2-the Curse of Michael Myers or the H20 storyline. As good as H20 is the plot of Halloween '18 and Halloween Kills makes more sense

Lady In White should be given a look. Halloween mystery-fantasy

Doctor Sleep is an incredible film! It’s directed by Mike Flanagan who did Haunting of Hill House which you ended up loving. If it wins, I’ll also recommend watching the directors cut, it adds some great character moments.

Voted for scream 2, alien 3, doctor sleep and tremors 2. Scream 2 is just lots of fun. Alien 3 is a movie i enjoy more now then when I was a kid. Its the 1st movie from David Fincher who made zodiac, the game, girl with dragon tattoo and though he basically disowns it now you can see lots of his potential already. Doctor Sleep i think is an excellent sequel that I thought would be impossible to nail as a massive fan of The Shining. Made by Mike Flanagan who did haunting of hill house. I think it will a fun full circle from early in your channel for you to reenter the Shining world. Also very meta for spoiler reasons. And as for Tremors 2, its just a blast of a sequel that keeps the comedy and fun and was a gigantic vhs/hbo staple that played a ton in the 90s and since Carly liked the first is also an October movie she can join for

As you watched Blade last year, I really think you should watch Blade 2 this year as imo it’s better that the first movie. Because I’d be shocked if Scream doesn’t win as it’s just a very popular franchise. I like them but I think they are a bit overrated tbh.

I'm guessing you mean Halloween II 1981 as different timelines could count as the next chapter to the 1978 original

I don’t know any of these. How to vote? 🥴 I wish Train to Busan was a contender.

One more suggestion: Psycho 2! It's actually way better than it has any right to be!

The Scream sequels get progressively worse. Hopefully with Stu coming back for number 7 it'll get redemption but I'm not holding my breath.

Tremors 2. That’s it. Boom. 💥 Anyone feel those Aftershocks. ;-)

Forgive my French, but how in the holy hell did DOCTOR SLEEP make this list? It's a fantastic film, but as both a) a sequel to THE SHINING (a film that horrified her to the degree that shots from it in other movies like TWISTER and READY PLAYER ONE have given her PTSD) and b) a movie that has one particularly nasty scene that is almost certainly going to actually traumatize her (and that is not hyperbole as it actually traumatized me, a fairly desensitized moviegoer) that I think actually violates one of her non-negotiable rules, I can't imagine how it got past her team of vetters. Nevertheless, as a big fan both of the movie and of its director Mike Flanagan (the man responsible for THE HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSE and MIDNIGHT MASS), I am voting for it... along with SCREAM 2, the criminally underrated ALIEN 3 (with the hope that it will be the longer assembly cut that she views), BLADE 2 and finally SPLIT (for the reason that everybody who has seen the movie will know). This is sure to be an entertaining October.

Split is a horror? NO Also thanks for ruining the joke

Dr sleep is also good

If Doctor Sleep does end up winning, please make sure to watch the director’s cut🙏🏻 it’s a superior version, which ties things together in a better way than the theatrical.

Good thing Cassie was kidding because I won’t be voting in this poll. I’ve never watched any (not a single one) of the originals so have no idea on the sequels.

Blade 2 or Underworld 2!!!!

Need to see “Unbreakable” before we watch “Split”

Cassie you're gonna have trouble with Doctor Sleep, girl. It's awesome for the die hard Stephen King fans but be careful sweetie. ☺️🤘

The Elm Street sequels are pretty hit or miss. 2 is a big miss despite its more recent cult following.

Blade 2, Halloween 2, Scream 2, Nightmare on Elm Street 2 & 28 Weeks Later. It's totally worth it 👌.

Um...none of these, if you're looking for 'not too scary'. Try "Murder By Death"

Hard to choose there's to many good options if Alien 3 (1992) wins i hope Cassie reacts to the Assembly Cut and not travesty that is the theatrical cut 🤞

Fingers crossed for 10 Cloverfield Lane and Split for John Goodman and James McAvoys performances alone!

Rumors of sequels after Cameron's "Aliens" have been exaggerated. 😎

Halloween 2 from 1981 is a great continuation of the first film.

It’s gotta be Scream 2! One Scream movie a year feels like a good rhythm

Also we better get The Fly day one of October 😂 been dodging it for years now

Scream 2. It is a legitimately great sequel

Between Scream 2 and Split for me . Split should be watches regardless of season