Pick-a-Flick List for February
Hey guys!
The List we have all been waiting for. YOU CANT HANDLE THE TRUTH!!!
JK! Here is the list of all pick a flick submissions that were submitted in the month of February. If you submitted your February pick, your chances are higher than ever with only 287 submissions! I'll do a better job at reminding you guys, but the link is the same every month (you can find in the FAQ). You can find the link in this post.
We filtered out nothing this time except if a person submitted more than once, their latest submission was the one that was kept. We will verify their tier membership details after the pick instead of trying to filter out things before.
We will have a little LIVE later today with the drawing/popping ;)
If you need a reminder on the rules and how things work, you can get more info from the main post here.
PS - The members that were mistakenly left off last month, will have those previous submissions added in addition to their submission for this month.
Comments (129)
oscar-winning sorted by popularity ascending
Daniel Radcliffe Emma Watson Rupert Grant Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire Check Out this Movie about School of Magic Three task's From Hogwarts Be Saved
I'm pretty sure her and Carly have both already seen all the Harry Potters before the channel existed.
I look forward to this
The drawing is one post above if you didn't see it. Next one will be after April first.
I'm one who was not able to submit an entry and I'm okay with that 🙂 Much luck to those most tenacious of friends, who continue the sweet struggle ever diligently. Of all the souls we've encountered here... Theirs is the most... human! (Name the quote on that one 😊 too easy?)
Sounds really familiar but I can't place it. Is it K Pax? Or something like that?
Someone please upvote 2001 space odyssey and godzilla vs mothra.. I wanna see her recations to Mothra!!!
when is the list updated?
Love The Iron Claw choice
That may be my next pick once Sunshine is watched. 🥳
Is the drawing happening soon?
soon
I feel stupid asking this, but I have been getting conflicting info...is it correct for me to say that if my movie were ever to get picked, then I cannot everr be picked again in a later month??
And yes I read the rules link and have read it b4, just wanna clarify cuz someone else has now confused me on it...
I just want to tell the moderators I appreciate what amazing and PATIENT people they are. It has to be an exhausting job...🤣lol.
True. This Pick a Flick thing can't be that fun for them.
I don't see my name either and I only have one email with Patreon and submitted Excalibur (1981) (I think) But I definitely submitted for February and January. Edit: just to be clear I'm not mad or upset or anything ridiculous as that. Just clarifying that there seems to be a problem. I appreciate that there's a ton of BTS work that Cassie and her team does.
Not sure how I got missed. I entered the January poll and thought I had entered again right after the draw. At least someone else is going for the Blues Brothers. There are some great picks on here though .
That’s me! I see another person also submitted The Blues Brothers so there are 2 of us at least.
I'm not sure I see my submission here, unless I messed up the form somehow
did you do a new submission between feb 1st and feb 28th?
Be still MY heart!! Been wanting to see THUNDERHEART on a list so bad!! Such a great movie! 🍿
+1 for THUNDERHEART One of my favorite Val Kilmer movies
Ha! Someone picked a movie that I'm in (I didn't pick it). I'm surprised, it's a decent movie in my opinion but I don't think it's all that well known.
LOL, I was 6 then. Probably would not be appropriate for a 6 year old to be in that movie. I was in Real Steel, just background but at least I can say I was in a scene with Hugh Jackman.
I can't believe how forgotten of a movie Raising Arizona is. It's probably the funniest Nicolas Cage, John Goodman, and Holly Hunter movie ever. It's a Coen brothers movie too!
Sorry but how exactly do I vote? I’m struggling with the excel sheet bc on my phone
Search 'pick a flick' here for the link and submit there. It may be too late for this one, but not sure. People send in suggestions all month and she picks one randomly near the beginning of the month. So people submitted all February and the drawing is either tonight or tomorrow.
Bummer, mine's not on there. 😕 At least someone chose the same film I did, so fingers crossed for that one! 🤞
Hey Terdell! I see you submitted one for December and January, but it looks like you missed submitting for February. Make sure you submit one now for next month!
I love Pick-a-flick. Of all the entries on there, I have 50 chances of one of the films on my main list being picked. Some of those are duplicates, but so what? 50 out of 286 is great odds.
City slickers and Thelma and Louise good picks 👍
Below are 31 entries off the list that I would very much like to see a reaction. Thus, the odds of a movie being selected that I would very much like to see a reaction = 1 in 9. (Of course, there are additional entries that I would be fine with.) Actaylor84 – Children of Men (2006) Antonio G – Kingdom of Heaven 2005 ArsTropica – The Illusionist (2006) bgb1975 ( – A Perfect World (1993) Brian H – The Big Chill, 1983 CallMeWheels – Cold Mountain 2003 Chase – 25th Hour (2002) Clay F – Thelma & Louise (1991) Cole – People Like Us (2013) CT – American Beauty (1999) Daniel D – The English Patient (1996) Demuscat – Collateral 2004 Edmund D – That Thing You Do! (1996) Edmund D – That Thing You Do! (1996)) Francisc0 – The 13th Warrior 1999 Gabor A – Invictus (2009) Graeme – Tora! Tora! Tora! (1970) Gray – Cold Mountain (2003) Jacob K – Sleepers (1996) Jan B – The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2009 Jay – Road to Perdition (2002) Julia – Sleepers 1996 Rick – Rob Roy, 1995 Salim – Invictus, 2009 SeanATX – In the Name of the Father - 1993 Shreddy – Source Code (2011) Story A – August Rush (2007) Terry Y – The Whale (2022) Uncle P – The 13th Warrior (1999) Wolfie – Thunderheart 1992
There's 9 of those on my list, Clay, though I see quite a few good ones that just didn't make my list. Lots of good stuff being thrown in the kitty.
I don't understand why I'm not on here
David! You submitted one for January, on the 31st, but you didn't resubmit in February. Everyone has to resubmit each month (using the same link)! Sorry about that!
From a reply below- "some of the members who pay in full for the year were mistakenly left out last month!" - PIB Good to know the problem was found.
Fingers crossed for my pick, Temple Grandin.
Good one. One of my favorites.
Yeeha. There's two of mine on there. Then again, I got tailpiped last month so it's a fair shake. I can feel a win coming on! Speaking of being tailpiped, there are 3 Joe's on there but no FULL MONTY. I can only assume that Joe Cross topped himself.
I absolutely posted a Feb pick for "Kinky Boots" and did it after each reminder post, but name or movie pick not in the list.
I see the submission, but it was made on January 31st @ 2:35pm! I see the one for March though!
Wow!!! 3 of us picked Cider House Rules!!! Honestly, I don't know if Cassie will like it, but it's one of my favorites and is just so well done. I think as long as she understands what kind of movie it is before going in (IOW, doesn't think it's a RomCom like Officer and a Gentleman), she might like it.
If it wins, Art, we'll need to point that fact out in BLOCK CAPITALS!!!!
I see my movie but someone else had submitted it. Oh well. Are we suppose to pick just one or a few?
One pick per month, the deadline is the 31st, make sure you use the same email associated with your patreon account
Raising Arizona is a great one. I could suggest that, and its made by the Cohen brothers.
I still need to see that. Been on my list forever.
Dang. I thought I submitted a pick but it’s not on the list.
I did pick a movie but apparently it was not put on the list.
I finally made the list! Yay! Was feeling like I was standing out in the cold at Studio 54.
Just curious, Chris, since we seem to frequently have similar taste, what did you pick? I don't see Chris Thom on the list. Are you the "Chris" with nothing after it?
HI !!! Wow, you're beautiful.
Thanks
Hmm , the list says Horror of Dracula, yet I entered (and was confirmed) The Final Programme. I guess I’ll just have to enter it again for next 2 months and see what happens.
It shows that "The Final Programme" was your pick for January, you submitted "Horror of Dracula" on Feb 10th! Hope that clears it up!
Come on... Octopussy.
She and Carly already saw it…so it’s a wasted pick (like mine when I found out Cassie wanted to see Air)
This is quite the list of movies! I just skimmed through it quickly, but it’s a very diverse list, many of which I’ve never heard of…at least I don’t think I have. The PiB community is a very diverse and eclectic group. Very interesting. Thanks to you and your team for putting this together.
Clearly I'm not doing this right, since my pick isnt on the list.... I may need some assistance
Chris it looks like you last submitted in Dec and Jan, but not Feb! If you make your pick for this month, I can make sure it's there for the next draw!
🤞 RED ROCK WEST (1993), Nic Cage, Dennis Hopper, Lara Flynn Boyle
Terrific movie, and very underrated. Your post made me wonder whatever happened to John Dahl, and it seems he has spent the past two decades working almost entirely in TV. It's a shame, as his film work is solid-to-great.
Didn't see mine on there. A lot of great films though. I did see "I am Sam" on the list. Sgt. Lincoln Osiris will be none too pleased with that one.
You are on there! You're listed as "The S". In the future when you submit your pick, you can change your display name to whatever you want to be seen as!
The Equalizer 1, 2 and 3...Dungeons and Dragons, Conan the Barbarian, Xanadu, The Hitman's bodyguard 1 and 2, Monster Hunter, RED 1 and 2, Can't hardly wait, This is 40, This means war, Sorcerers apprentice, I am number 4, Warcraft, Now you see me 1 and 2, Dirty Grandpa, Men of Honor, The General's Daughter, Gods of Egypt, The 5th Wave, We are the millers, The last Witch Hunter, Limitless, Warm Bodies, The Mortal Insturments city of bone, Riddick movies, Barely Lethal, American Sniper, Killers, Brides maids, The Jackal, Vampire Academy, Loser, Ender's Game, Hot Tub Time Machine.
Can't Hardly Wait would be a fun one for Cassie and Carly if they haven't seen it yet. I think the first Equalizer is on the channel already. Warm Bodies they've seen already. Bridesmaids I'm thinking they've probably seen but that would be hilarious.
I'm excited. Even though I TOTALLY forgot what I submitted.
It's either Rob Roy or The Nice Guys, according to the list and your name here.
The no duplicates thing is clever because you could manipulate the odds if you teamed-up. Alas... no shenanigans for me... I mean you.
What "no duplicates thing" are you talking about?
My submission is not on the list and I definitely submitted. This display name, Gone with the Wind (1939).
Gone with the Wind is there. So you picked the same as that person. Your entry was therefore chosen from the two to be removed. It may have been more than two. 10 people could say GWTW but only 1 person will be chosen.
I see many movies I like. I see my entry. I also see Sicario (that patron needs submit a different movie). Looks like less than 290 submissions. Our odds are getting better the less that participate.
Strange, I found the movie I submitted, "The Nice Guys" on this month's list but not my display name. It appears to be a duplicate name on the list. Although I'm not 100% certain I remembered to submit a pick-a-flick entry this month, so I'm not sure if I made a mistake or if the list has the wrong name. If "The Nice Guys" wins the draw, I don't really care about my name being attached; I just want to see the reaction!
Shout out to OldAsDirt's very excellent movie choice. I mean, I really, really like it! 😂 Especially since it was the same as mine! (The excellent The Russians Are Coming The Russians Are Coming)
You and my nom de plume will be very happy if it wins - along with the other 5 who requested it on popcornrequests.com.
Thank you for the list and for the generosity.
Hmmmm...my entry for "Flash Gordon" (1980) isn't listed :(
When did you submit it?
Not seeing my Interstellar submission, could be because I forgot last month, or maybe it's been seen outside the channel. If so that's a bummer, love that film and would to see the reaction.
Interstellar is listed as "Unseen" at popcornrequests.com
Thx for sharing. I wasn't entirely sure my switch from GMail to Proton would go off without a hitch this month, but nice to see it did! And with someone else making the same pick, 1:143 is not too shabby. PS: also, nice to see so many underrated movies on the list I would gladly stand behind.
JPDotCom23 submitted Spotlight (2015), which is awesome but is listed as "Seen" at popcornrequests.com.
I think seen films, and other disqualifiers get removed AFTER this is published, as this is just to confirm received submissions.
Just seen the list , For the first time! That’s so cool and exciting! So many great choices! Can’t go wrong!!😊
These things help the work day go by faster lol Thank you Cassie!!🍿
Yay!! ☺️ good luck everyone!
I thought duplicate entries were removed to keep the odds the same for everyone.
"PS - The members that were mistakenly left off last month, will have those previous submissions added in addition to their submission for this month."
I didn't see my name. When I open the form Google is signed in to my other account and it's a real faff to change it. Surely you can just look us up on Patreon? Much simpler.
That shouldn't be a problem as the account you're signed in with isn't shared with the form recipient. I'm pretty sure I was signed in with a different email than I submitted
I object only to the abbreviation of my screen name from Mike LL to Mike L, which confuses me with Mike L(emon). The extra L is important, lol. I guess whoever does this likes to do less typing. 🤣
They did that to me too, Mike. "Clarence N" could be anybody!
It's a relief to see my choice is the best choice. No disrespect, guys and gals. It's just nice to know I know myself so well.
Now we need to know what's your choice
Didn't see mine. Must've used the wrong email?
Hmm you might have used the wrong one... I see your pick for March though!
Mike L has a 4 in 287 chance of getting a film he's chosen because someone else picked The Russians are Coming... Nice odds.
I did notice Mike L(emon) had extra chances this month. Good for him. But I hope I win. 😂
I have to say, I love the eclectic range of films on this list. It's such a refreshing counterpoint to the polls, which tend to default the recent and familiar. There are many films on this list that would never get near a poll victory, but which I'm very excited to see with Cassie.
Which ones are you thinking about for example?
Double entries: Bill M — The Searcher (1956), The Searchers Edmund D — That Thing You Do! (1996), That Thing You Do (1996) Henrick — The Hunt (2012), The Hunt (2012) Tech C — Shaolin (2011), Shaolin (2011) EDIT: PiB has explained some people were entered twice after last month so they may have just chosen the same movie again
I hope they stay because That Thing You Do and The Hunt are top tier for me too.
Some interesting variety of picks for sure. For the record, my screen name is not a first & last name. It's a reference to the twilight spaghetti western named KEOMA (1976). Keoma is rather infamous for the musical score and songs. It's a remarkable movie, elegiac, poetic, mournful, philosophical, beautiful ... BUT the music is divisive to say the least. Most people hate the music and complaints are in the 1st paragraph of most reviews. BUT I LOVE THE MUSIC. It took a while to grow on me, and I don't deny that it is too distracting for most people. The songs are folky, semi Leonard Cohen knock offs with a shrill female vocalist and a male singer who sounds like a conical growling Schwarzenegger. The lyrics describe explicitly what is happening & what characters are thinking, like a Greek chorus. I love it, but it can be hard to take.
Thank You… Thank You… Thank You 🙏
Didn’t see mine, but I requested Sleepers, so with that being on the new poll I’ll assume it’ll be watched sometime soon. Rooting for Eight Men Out with the baseball season coming up. Also, The Nice Guys, The Book of Eli, City Slickers, The Cider House Rules would all be good.
Did you submit on time and enter the email associated with your Patreon? That last one is a common reason for not appearing on the list. Don't worry, Sleepers is on the list so even if it doesn't win the ongoing poll you still have a chance to get your pick. :)
Didn't realize this was a thing so I submitted for March :)
One the great things about having a name that starts with A, I never ever have to scroll far to find my name in a list.
There are a ton of great films here. Congratulations everyone!
I hope Air wins…😀😂
In case this wins, here’s the trailer: https://youtu.be/Euy4Yu6B3nU?si=KT5v_8c0yxXwbWy9
Huh. I could have sworn I submitted one. I guess I didn't
The list is looking a little light with only 287 entries tbh
Someone requested Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along-Blog! I originally found it because my celebrity crush was Felicia Day, but Nathan Fillion and Neil Patrick Harris are great too.
Quite a few double posters in there: Tech C Steve Larry D John C John D John B Joe? Jim C/jimmyc JC/JC762 Jay Henrik Edmund D Clarence N Bill M 2-Can
Looks like there may be 2 different 2-Can's, and maybe there are two unique Tech C's that both like Shaolin (2011) :\
Many great choices!
Yes indeed. Some of my favourites on the list apart from my choice would be In the name of the father, children of men, kingdom of heaven, collateral, sleepers, dallas buyers club. Wouldn't mind American Beauty, Innserspace, English Patient.
I guess it will be considerably fewer than 287 entries going into the draw given the number of duplicate entries on the list? Not bad odds!
Come on 'Your Name'....also Cassie it's not studio ghibli
I don’t know who that other 2-Can is, but I like his taste in movies!
Good luck 2-Can, if not me, I hope it’s you!
Wow. Thanks Cassie, I can see mine straight away. Looking forward to the pick 🤞
Whoever that Dallin guy is picked a really good movie, just sayin 🤷🏻♂️
There is kothing to choose
Cassie picks it herself later today in a live show, this is just the list she'll draw from