What's the best version?

Is with guitar separate keyboards?

Default

Beta version tends to bring down the bpm for nothing when splitting track vocals & backvocals - Also no access to downpitch anymore on this version. For advance mostly for signers you want to be able to directly chop the vocals and back vocals on you system. Then extract your version. No one wants only an empty track without back vocals. You also can't export the tracks independently at ounce on separate tracks. It seems the beta version was mostly for quality maybe and adding a better mix... I'm really wondering what it brings. insted why don't you just integrate the new features to upgrade what you already have mastered ?

With guitar

please dont remove any of it. Honestly its my fav program

is it possible to add a L-R slider for each track? so that i could send synths to one side (left) and all others to the other side (right)

Hey, the Beta is showing the wrong key pretty much always, just letting you know 🤠🤏

i went to that link when i try uploading my file it take me back to login no matter how many times i login

Why is it that I paid, and I am still being told to become a patron?

Hey, love the app .. it's great. I joined Patreon so that I could split more music, but it's not obvious where to go to get back to that from here. Please make it more obvious for dummies like me.

ο σαρωτής μου ζητάει κωδικό

ο σαρωτής μου ζητάει κωδικό

Bonjour Melnik, Malgré mon abonnement, j'ai toujours le message "Trop de demandes depuis votre adresse IP. Veuillez réessayer plus tard...." je ne sais plus comment faire, aidez moi svp, merci, bien cordialement

Melnik, please help. My app has stopped working. Voice Remover just goes round in circles

How to remove payment card without add a new card?

Olá boa tarde gstaria de participar dessa experiência de produzir músicas

NÃO CONSIGO ENTRAR E USAR O QUE DEVO FAZER ?

Привет, я подписался, но не могу им воспользоваться. Say anything... Shift + Return to add new line

I have a year paying $1 a month and now I can’t use it, yet I’m still paying $1/month. Will I continue to get access?

abune oldum islemir

I subscribed and it doesn't work

GH

I think that the standard version works beautifully for what I need - But, unless there is a significant infrastructure reason to remove a version that some people are using, I would encourage you to leave the options open for folks having good results from the alternate versions.

Estoy suscrito desde hace un año, pero no puedo ingresar como suscriptor, solo a la version gratis y necesito usar , ayuda por favor

salutare sunt membru abonat si tot restricti am nu pot crea negativ

HI THERE! I AM A MEMBER. CAN YOUEXPLAIN ME AS MAKE TO CONTINUE USING THE VOCAL REMOVER WITHOUT THE RESTRICTIONS

Whatever version you stick with, please make it so it includes Key and BPM info! None of the versions/formats I tried included that.

https://patreon.com/vocalremover?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=creatorshare_fan&utm_content=join_link

Feedback: current release version works well with power metal, reasonably well with melodeath, but I tried it with a neoclassical anime theme song and it sounded like shit. Original song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6OTGA43-_7I

Check your email confirmation and use that link. It is is exclusively for member patrons, and it works.

OLA JA FIZ O PAGAMENTO E NAO CONSIGO ENTRAR

I just purchased it but it is still locked to me

ainda não conseguir está bloqueado para mim

acabei de adquirir ainda não tive acesso

Pague el mes anterior y funcionaba hoy me vuelven a descontar automaticamente pero ahora ya no funciona

Acabei de comprar novamente a assinatura e fala que estou tentando repetidas vezes no mesmo IP dizendo para ser Patreon. So que ja sou

cada mes me cobran y no puedo trabajar con el separador de voz..... como puedo cancelar mi suscripcion ? quiero cancelar porque cada mes me cobran y no funciona esto

PAGUEI EBNAO TO CONSEGUINDO ACESSAR

Pagué y no puedo trabajar con el separador de audio

HI

pues me pasa lo mismo pague 6e y no me deja separar ,esto es una estafa?

Hi! I tried to use vocal remover today, but unfortunately, it said I used 8 hours today. Can you give me an offer unlimited for using Vocal Remover?

Já paguei, não liberou, vou cancelar e pedir reembolso

Curious to know if eventually there will be aversion that splits vocal harmony lines.

I paid as well and it still says too many from the IP address 🙃

same problem for me, pay every month and keeps giving me the IP Adress issue

I paid as well and it still says too many from the IP address 🙃

Hi its making me pay several times after I have just cleared all my browsing history and now I cannot use the service this is poor !!!!!

Hello , i already paid to be a patron , still says too many IP address

Hello! Have there been any changes to this link as well? https://vocalremover.org/pt/splitter-ai

Hello

UTUI

the vocal remover no longer seems to work

Amazing app, thank you for enabling me to create great music from my old recordings

Дякую!

Man f*cking awesome app, thanks!

Como resolver?

Assinei para mais acesso ao vocalremover.org/pt e não melhorou em nada.

I paid and still want the fee. Please unblock or refund your money,

Hola, dejé pagado el mes y me vuelve a salir el mensaje de "demasiadas peticiones de una IP y hágase patreon etc." ¿que problema puede haber?, un saludo

please cancel my membership: kamilfornalczyk2015@gmail.com

hola

nancy , creo que en tu banco lo puedes hacer, buscar donde estan tus descuentos automaticos y borrar este

necesito darme de baja

👍

Hello

como se entra me acabo de suscribir

Hi Melnik Dmitry, when I split a vocal and music, so is there any way to modify the vocal on my way? I really need to do that.

I just paid and cannot use it, why? How do I log in? I paid for a month!

Дмитрий, добрый день. Я стал частью сообщества креатора Melnik Dmitry! Я не знаю почему у меня не получается отделять слова от музыки... вернее слова отделены, но музыка очень расплывчатая и невнятная. Скажи пожалуйста, в чем проблема?

me neither

i help me

I signed up and paid $1, but I still can't use it

The Guitar Version works much better for me! Thank you!!

i usually use it the splitter to mix house and techno and the IA has some difficulties with separating the melody from the claps and cymbals, but generally Defaut work better but as carlos says it is very dependant of the instruments used in the song

Im finding for poor sound surrounding with echo using cam im able to remove it.

I use all of them. They all have different behaviors and offer different results depending on the track. If one could switch easily between them and choose the best result on each instrument, could be useful, nevertheless I notice slight tone and time variations. Sometimes results for drums is better on Default, sometimes on Guitar. Some instrumental results are better with Beta. The more stable choice is still Default.. I try all of them, honestly.

Hi, I dontated but still cannot use the IA. Edited: Just found the patron link, thanks!

eu estou pagando porque que não esta loberando

ACABEI DE PAGAR E NAO TA LIBERANDO MEU ACESSO

SOU UM PATRON E ESTÁ SENDO NEGADO MEU ACESSO A LIMPAR NOVOS ARQUIVOS. TENHO QUE DOAR MAIS?

как блин в этот сайт войти невозможно!!!

hello everyone

For everyone saying they are getting an error message "too many requests from IP address"...you have to use the link provided in the welcome email. Friendly piece of advice for "Melnik Dmitry", you might want to be a little more interactive with the people who are paying for your service, it's just basic professionalism.

I just joined as a patron but i still get this . "Too many requests from your IP address. Please try again later or become a patron" What am I doing wrong ?

no puedo separar tracks y pague la membresía, esto es una estafa. presentare una queja por robo a este usuario de Patreon

I paid but cannit get access

Also subscribed and am still getting the "too many requests from my IP address" error... sad

same here, just subscribed but cant use the features.

don't work , i'm suscribe

Could you please find a solution , I've already paid for the subscription

Its not working

it doesnt work for me even when i paid bruh

Assinei para virar patron mas continuo recebendo esta mensagem: Demasiados pedidos de seu endereço IP. Por favor, tente novamente mais tarde ou torne-se um patron. O que devo fazer?

Thank you for your beautiful project. It's changed so much and made many things possible.

Hi I joined patron but still get this sign 'Too many requests from your IP address. Please try again later or become a patron'

The server is down and I can't use vocal remover

Does he respond at all I need help with something

Hi everyone, I'm new to this patreon group. I'm a saxophonist and I need a instrumental track to perform at my live shows. I need help to remove the alto saxophone from this track at this link. Can someone please help me? https://youtu.be/rxuCrz9dW4M?si=5wb_BdupcoNYdZQG

Your version is beginning to fall behind others. It struggled with whistles, horn instruments, some lead guitar and other noises. Are you still working on this? If it's AI have you made any steps towards machine learning?

Hi the patreon payment this month was credited to Patreon Ireland Limited. Is that correct? Thanks

Thank you for creating this tool! From what I've seen, a lot of new people seem to come by basically everyday and there are no new posts since the beggining of 2023, I think I speak for all of us when I say, pls come back!!!

Hi...I am new to the group. I just wanted thankyou for the vocal remover. It has opened up my creativity so much. Now I can go back to earlier projects I had and retool them with updated sets. Thanks !!!

Are you still doing any development on this? We haven't heard anything for quite a while. Just wondering if there's any chance we'll ever get a batch converter. It doesn't need to be for hundreds of files at a time, but maybe 10-20 at a time would be really helpful.

Hi Melnik, Im a patreon and finding it a very useful tool. Is there any possibility of splitting what ends up in the music file more discreetly into guitar / piano etc? Mostly I use the isolated bass tracks with only drum and vocal in order to learn the bass parts of songs Im covering. Adding back the music track makes the bass a bit obscured but just one of the "music" instruments would be good

6

Agree, it you could make one for background vocals (backing track) that would be awesome

Un error desconocido a ocurrido. No se pudo ejecutar 'decodeAudioData' en 'BaseAudioContext': no ​​se pueden decodificar datos de audio------ esto me figura cada vez que quiero procesar un audio .. me podrian ayudar?

Can you make one that seperates backround vocals?

Can you please add mp4

Hey melnik! Love you website, have been using it regularly for over a year. Can you please send me an email at djkarmanj@gmail.com? I have a business proposition for you.

I tried first 2 versions on synthwave to remove the horrible drums they add to the songs. The problems i hear is a volume drop on the drum beats. The "Default" leaks some snare The "Beta" is better in snare removal but slightly leaks the drums...maybe 1-5% Here's the song to try: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ci0Kgdpgsw Nevertheless great results

I think it is really dependant on the song. I think default probably sounds better overall but also the 5 split definately has it's uses if quality is not your main concern. Yes the bass sounds better 4 ways but having that guitar seperated out of the music section rlly helps with hearing non-traditional sounds within the music? (i don't know the technical terms i apologise (Though this probably makes more sense for electronic music rather than more acoustic sounds)

Thanks... love 😍😍

I was wondering. Film is usually shot using multiple recording systems you got a music track, effects track and dialogue track basically but if you got a movie shot on VHS where naturally effects and dialogue are recorded on one track, how would you rate the current version of separating the two? Also, I’m currently trying to separate dialogue and sound from this https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13230716/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0_tt_7_nm_1_q_the%2520unknown%2520crea

I've been scammed

HI! Will you develop an acapella splitter? I mean, an algorithm that can split different voices of an acapella ensemble or a choir?

The splitter never works, always error 404. At night doesn't work?

COMO MANTENER EL CORO, Y LOS INSTRUMENTOS SOLAMENTE??

OTRA BAJADA MAS, PLEACE...

MAS, PORFAVOR

SI DONO MAS DINERO ME PERMITIRIAN OTRA BAJADA POR FAVOR

Eu sou patrão

I like With guitar.

The guitar seperator is really useful to remove guitar from my backing tracks so I can play them myself and being able to seperate them to get a listen to them isolated.

I Need to become patron

I'm trying to remove the vocals from a specific song I want to use as the song I walk down the aisle to for my upcoming wedding. It seems like no matter what I try I can't get the vocals to completely delete. I just want the instrumental but I can still hear vocal choppiness in the background. What do I do?

Please add a music visualization

Пока еще не пробовал.

Mel! I've been enjoying your service a great deal. That's why I paid more than $5 per month. If usage increases, we will compensate you accordingly. THANKS! Gary

I like with guitar...because I pull my guitar tracks in and out of my songs often to tweak them or replace them completely.

It's unreasonable to work for $5 a month. I thought $5 was just to maintain the website. In 1 month I lost $5 for the next month and I did not receive any notification ​

Hi Melnik, where is the 5 stem splitter with guitar version? I have been using your Default-4 Stem Splitter and it works okay but always be better if you can do it. Please confirm if you still have the Guitar 5 stem splitter version so I can try it. It's not in the link that you provided above. Thanks...

everytime I tried second time it said I asked too many, I have donated monthly

currently not working mate. could you have a look please?

فعلا مزيل صوت رائع ودقيق وخيارات كثيره شكرا كانت تجربه رائعه لي

Man your vocal remover is awesome. Happy to use it thanks G

Uma coisa de gça e vc cobrando, vou denuncia e pedir estoo do meu credito;

Som horrivel, parece som de robô, não gostei.

Just signed up to ne patron as I use accapella ripper regularly still saying to meant attempts today my g love what u got going on

Hello. Is it possible to separate parts in classical music with your app ?

This Is My Best App But Yet I Only Get Limited Service 1 Accapella A Day I Love This App So Much Yet It Make Me Sad

Hi, I am a patreon, but I want to remove the guitar, how do i do that please.

I already paid 5$ for using your app. Please enable me to use your app.

i need the music and sound effects 100 percent removed and keep the vocals

I became a patron and its saying that I need to become a patron

en lo particular prefiero mas la version con guitarra, ya que la pista de drums esta mas limpia, tiene mejor calidad de sonido. como recomendacion sugeriria aumentar la calidad del algoritmo para el bajo, ya que los demas creo que estan bien. thnks :)

I'm paying and using the correct url, but the Splitter AI page does not allow me to upload files, all the other ones do. I'm interested in using the Splitter function primarily. Thanks

If you are noot paying! You wil noot get ze vocal remoofes!

awesome software hopefully you can keep on developing it

The same thing happens to me, I already paid and I can't use it

Too many requests from your IP address. Please try again later

Unrelated to what you posted but I just wanted to thank you so much for your website. honestly elevated the way I approach music and produce it right now Thank you very much!!

Украина

Украина

Eu sou patrono quero retirar a voz e não consigo !

Eu sou patro

Honestly, I like both default and with guitar 'cause that way I can get splits with great quality (I did tried the beta but it wasn't as good). But I've been having a better experience with the one with guitar so far. I get better split tracks with that one for most songs I tried.

I've tried them all for one and the same song. When I use the music stem from the default it looks like the same as the beta version except when I use the music stem from the guitar (the five stems). That looks and sound differend. But it's good to make a combination of...

hi

been encountering this message "Too many requests from your IP address. Please try again later" Remove vocals from a song

Nevermind, was only able to split 1 file, please help fix

Encountered it in google chrome, when I used edge it worked fine

and btw guys - it's not that hard to notice that you need to have "?pateron" variable in URL in order to use the patreon version...

Having a guitar as an option is much better it helps me to separate exactly what I need! Also, would be possible to add .ogg file output support, please?

The beta excels comparitively to the default when seperating chorus/opera flavored music from normal voice lines, such as the scene with the evolutionary from guardins of the galaxy, which i needed to seperate for an edit

Twice signed up as Patron, Bank account shows withdraw $5.00 and still give me notice of too many download ?????

tbm estou com o mesmo problema

Twice signed up as Patron, Bank account shows withdraw $5.00 and still give me notice of too many download ?????

oh, it's back! Hooray!

the link shows a 404 error page, please fix.

Same here

Melnick, please provide a good link by today or I will cancel my membership. Thank you.

Same

Same.

the patreon member link is not working. I cannot access. Help!!

https://vocalremover.org/ aca es la app

Hi, Melnik one question, i m using this to dub... make voice over in other languages on original films. do you have any feature in mind to split the male-female or different vocals in different tracks?

Hey I became a patron and still cant do any songs??

hi friend, i can't able to download the splitted songs! it shows something like api8 webaddres page with empty! please fix that. sometimes server error 404 occurs during uploading files.

chat

Dmitry i wrote in caht

Awwsome

hola

when I try to download vocal it showing this - https://api8.vocalremover.org/split/listen/vocal/75696287/fa85bd it is so bad I can't able to download it and its happening again and again

Привет я заплатил подписку но у меня до сих пор не подключены дополнительные функции сервиса

Guitarrra é removida juntamente com pianos.

plz do it with arabix songs not very good with that

ola

Kak atstanavit zaplatu Ka dengi nesnial bolse

Можно узнать у вас? С чем связан мой глюк на сайте..? У меня идет бесконечно долгая загрузка трека. Перезагружаю страницу и по новой! И только лишь с 15 - 20 го раза удается просчитать партии и все разделить.

I keep getting “Network error occured, check your internet connection.” errors. I mainly use the “with guitar” mode and stick to files around 30mb. I’m also on mobile data, which could contribute to the issue.

is there a way to separate the Lead Guitar and the Rhythm Guitar?

He has a version for patrons

I pay every month, but still saying "to many use on this IP" Only use one time in a week !

When new update for Vocal Remover and Isolation?

Hey, will it be possible to add an algorithm responsible for reverb removal in the future? I'm sure it would be very useful...

Are you going to add more instruments it can separate like Keys or Synths?

@Chatiphat Phanrudee "the chorus"... you mean the BACKING vocals...!?!

I want the singer's voice and the chorus to be separated.

Eu sou patrao

Hi Melnik, I tried your guitar isolater on "what they do" by the roots, which has some beautiful work by Chalmers Alford. But it seemed to be struggling on some of the chords. It puts part of it in the music section and part of it in the guitar section. I'm thinking it might need more training on clean guitar chords. Amazing work though and I thoroughly enjoy using this program, its produced some of the cleanest separated tracks ever. Thank you!

Beta version sounds much better, but still can't isolate all the bass (yes, I understand that it's not a bass technically, but...)

I used this Ai to remove vocals and when I downloaded the music tracks, they sounded like they had a warble to them. They weren't clear like the original track was. any way to correct this? It sounded like an old tape that was worn.

The Beta version gives me much better final results a lot of situations. Try it with Boney M. - Oceans of Fantasy ;) and compare to the Default one. Thight, more dynamic, and the musical instruments are "stay" in the mix much more. Versus the Default version where they are struggles a lot more or just simply vanished. I just love it. Please keep the Beta too.

Would you be able to add an option to download all the separate tracks automatically already putting them inside a folder?

Conseguiria adicionar uma opção de baixar todas as faixas separadas automaticamente já colocando elas dentro de uma pasta?

Melnik Dmitry Very nice work my friend. Thank you!!!

Es genial ! Muchas gracias por tu trabajo

I became a patron, but still cannot use the app

I'm sure it depends heavily on the source, but the differences were very minimal. I downloaded all 13 tracks into my DAW, setup a separate bus for each- Default, Beta, With Guitar. Then, I muted all tracks except the matching tracks from each bus. Finally, I used mute buttons to A-B each result. Here are my notes: Song: You'll Never Leave Harlan Alive - Brad Paisley Vocals: The Beta resulted in cleaner vocals for me at least. There was no discernable difference between Beta and With Guitar Bass: I heard very slightly less phasing distortion on both Beta and With Guitar Drums: Beta was much cleaner than Default. With Guitar had slightly less ambience than Beta, but Beta sounded overall better to my ears. The kick especially sounded more rounded to me. Music: I heard almost no difference between Default and Beta or With Guitar when combining both Music and Guitar. Thoughts: The only really strange thing I noticed is a wood block that ended up in the Music track for all 3 algorithms. However, With Guitar did seem to grab at least part of the initial transient, which hurt the drum stem overall, but had very little impact on the quality of the Music track. Overall, I had better results with Beta, but I really like the option to have a separate guitar stem. Thanks for all the great work!

Default is the best by far. The other two versions (Beta and Guitar) mistake too much of the vocals for music.

Is there any way to boost naturally Bass to EDM tracks?

for vocals specifically i noticed that Beta would produce a nicer-sounding vocal file but would also contain more artifacts from something like the drum track. the default is amazing because it removed all artifacts from vocal track but the sound quality is not as good

Não consegui separa som de guitarra/violão. Não encontrei link com essa trilha.

ok

dengan perkusi juga kalau bisa

hello

hello how to separate several voices

The tool is really superb! I would suggest keeping both default and guitar splitters since sometimes bass and guitar results are mixed up with not the best clear results on bass. So I would suggest getting your bass drums and vocals audio from default and only your guitar from guitar splitter.

It's an excellent tool. With Guitar add sound is till better

my answer: IT DEPENDS. sometimes with electronic music that don't have any guitar might confuse the ai and split stems in the wring section. so the best option when it will release is that we could chose the differents stems we wanna the AI to split before prosessing. eventually, if there is more instruments that can be isolated the option to chose how many and wich stems would be the best of all world ... Also The BETA put the bassline of one song to the music channel and then switched while the Default had it corect. note: the baseline is the same trought all the song and it's the same 3 notes

Idea: Add "backing/hidden vocals" remover/extractor

same here whats up with that?.

Too many requests from your IP address. Please try again later or become a patron

Me two i paid for the membership but it says

I have been using this to split out different tracks for some of my live band recordings. It works really well with drums, bass and vocals. Don't quite get total split between guitar and keyboards, but it works well enough for me

I paid for the membership but still I can't use it

Hi Mr Dmitry

Personally I like your guitar stem. I think you should go in the stem separation as you do it very well and being patron of your site is very affordable as well. If you are gifted in music don't waste it, Take advantage of your knowledge of music to create stems ( especially that those are the most modern standards of making instrumentals).

Predefinito, complimenti per il lavoro svolto!

With guitar 5 stems splitter

I LOVE DEFAULT, ITS THE BEST!!!

I like the possibility of adjusting the guita

Default works just fine. But the 'with guitar' is no good. When I go to that I choose a file, it loads pretty fast, then says "audio processing" then moves to "loading" that goes too 100% and then nothing. The tab crashes or it sends me back a few screens and back to default. I got one song to work finally and it was really good. But one; one single song out of 300+ It's a waste of time and a disappointment.

I like all of these. Thank you very much!!

Those are all good. All depends on how the song was mixed. I normally try them all first. I need something that can isolate saxophone. Great job... so far so good. Thankyou for your service.

Para la música y la voz lo mejor es la Beta, para el bajo lo mejor es Predeterminado, Batería es lo mismo en las dos. El problema de la versión con guitarra es que se come algunas notas y cambia el sonido de la canción

default is the best for me!

default is best for me, with guitar eliminates a lot of music

This has been amazing for me and the creativity. Keep it going!! 👌🏻🎶😜

For me hast default the best result. Guitar Version has artifacts.

by with guitar will more reduce- so gitar is important -but quality of another is not the same as by default

All are great depending on the quality of the track you're working with.

hi default is the best version , my name guy harris senior for 30 years

Default & Beta are best. Whenever you use "with guitar" it removes any type of piano. I've done multiple tracks and it's done that multiple times. I think its best to stay with Default & Beta, if you had to do one, beta.

They all good although I would say for some type of voice isolation Beta worked for me as the best. Specifically speaking in audio where I wanted to isolate voice from orchestra and left with only strings, cello, bass cello etc. sound.

I tried Journey's Don't Stop Believing and the guitar one seemed like it couldn't tell the difference between the piano and guitar. It seemed to remove all of the piano in the first section of the song for the most part. Both the default and beta are solid choices!

I really only remove vocals, so the splitter isn't really for me. I only tried one song, and it seemed like the Beta voice channel was slightly cleaner.

I Cannot access at the programm. The app tell me “donate”

I only really need to remove the vocal so for myself all three work but do feel the guitar stem needs a little more refinement as it seems to lose some of the other sounds within music and bass but keep up the good work

cannot access program what to do

For my purposes, I just need vocals removed and a clean instrumental, and I found the default to be a slightly cleaner sounding version. Both still sound phenomenal compared to every other site on the internet doing this, so keep up the good work!

I made the same song in all three options: the new one with guitar I notice that it's good that the guitar is in separate parts, but the bass disappears, it's not in the bass channel or in other instruments. In the beta or in default it does not do that, the bass is still there. If all the channels are combined in the vein or default version, the song remains the same as the original, however, in the "with guitar" version, some instruments are lost

A Plus with guitar....! Great work you are doing, keep it up.

i tested the beta & the guitar option with manchester orchestra’s angel of death. the beta option has less spots where each stem leaks into one another, however the guitar option seems to do a better job with the drums. given that the guitar option adds an extra isolated stem, i think it is better overall.

I think the guitar options is very important and its a small step for a huge success, but it still needs a lot of improvement, because the algorithm doesn't fully understand that it shouldn't make full parts of the songs disappear. It needs to be fixed.

I think default and the one with guitar are very useful

With guitar it's the best option ever, congratulations to your work man

I tried all Versions with Gary Moore's All your love with focus on Bass and found with Guitar is the best

good one

I tried with an acoustic ensemble: with the beta version the double-bass & brushes-snare are better

I think the guitar is a step in the right direction, at least for separating a lot of general pop/rock, its when you get the more adventurously recorded material that things get interesting, espcially with ambient pieces.

Yesterday I isolated the solo in/all over 'I Heard Her Call My Name'; leaning very much towards the guitar option because of this. But they're all amazing. Keep them all?

Thx! Spasibo!

a batch feature would be life changing

i prefer the beta version! Much more stable when compared to guitar version! yes guitar version having some issues but i beleive that this beta version will comeup with massive new ideas and stable.

with the few songs i tried it on, the beta variant seemed to yeld the best quality, however the guitar version is more useful because it further splits the track. if anything, i would suggest leaving as is, with emphasis on improving the guitar version

Default...I would've voted With Guitar if it wasn't for the fact that certain instruments disappear (mainly, piano).

The guitar splitter having some problems… usually some of the music parts disappeared without a clue. I think you need to keep all of the versions, and keep working on the guitar, until it’ll be fixed. So: don’t remove anything yet. It’s not the right time.

Greetings ~ ~ I have tried (various music) from several artists and styles (from the 1920s to the present) . . . ~ from simple to completed musical layers (and) found that - the version with the guitar - is more outstanding in terms of separation and is headed in the right direction. ~ however, to be transparent, it (also) depends on the source, as some of the layers are not separated. ~ this could be because of the recording. ~ as I am assuming that the tracks are more separated or combined and depending on how the original/studio separates it, which WILL determine the outcome of the track. ~ so the results WILL VARY! ~ I (also) have used it to separate BGM from Anime and using the vocal/SFX parts individually to add them to my collection of SFX and Music is very helpful! ~ I realize that these things take time to - "train" - so it is worth it to see this program's Ai learn as it goes along and see what (actually) changes with each iteration - "watching Ai history in the making" - is just mindblowing. ~ I am looking forward to seeing more - tweaks - done to this Ai and seeing how it progresses . . . ~ THANK YOU! for a VERY USEFUL TOOL!

Thanks to the release of the Guitar version, I was able to complete a complex remix and send it off to a label :) Appreciate ya boss, it's a really useful tool!

The plus guitar one is fun, but I too have noticed it almost completely remove the piano in some tracks eg Shut Up by Madness. The default is the most solidly reliable one, when it comes to doing what it's supposed to.

I'd love one where you could change keys after the song has finished removing vocals

The guitar version is my favorite but, based on what others have posted here, I wouldn't remove the other versions since they seem to offer better results depending on source material and what the user is focusing on isolating.

Sorta related question, but does the splitter have the ability to remove applause from a live track?

I mean, as long you keeps both, cuz actually the one with the guitar works really bad for bass lines

I have noticed that when I use the guitar splitter option some of the other tracks disappear. The piano part on the beginning of Toto's"Hold the Line" and Clapton's "pretending" vanished. The simple vocal remover option is the best.

I think the guitar version, which is great, is taking away votes from beta, which I use all the time

All my tests for the guitar splitter, give a nice guitar track but very little to nothing on the music track. No piano or any of the other instruments. However with the normal and beta splitter these instruments come out great.

With guitar is super cool, but there was a section where the keys were completely removed, as George mentioned. I am not sure where it went

I've been trying to isolate an electric guitar from a rock cover. The track was phased flipped to help isolate the lead guitar. I put it through all three versions and the Guitar Splitter was better able to isolate the guitar from the drum's symbols, but the Beta track overall sounded better over Default. I think with time and tuning the Guitar split can be better.

I tested the guitar splitter with a tune called "Rhythm of Your Life" by the Rippingtons and it omitted the piano part all together. So, my guess is that it may be a little buggy. But maybe you can get it to split the piano part to another separate stem? I'm waiting for a serarate stem for the sax. There are a few tunes I would like to remove the sax lead.

Each has different qualities. I really like with guitar. Keep them all. Thanks so much for sharing.

I'd very much like to be able to separate out sound effects from film and television as well. They often end up on the same track as vocals.

please dont get rid of the guitar stem feature <3, my guitarist friends and I will cry.