💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
October 12, 2023

How often do you comment on videos on YouTube?

The reason I'm asking is I'm thinking of changing the focus of the channel. I'm thinking about disabling comments on Youtube altogether. I'm just really tired of the negative comments I have to delete, of random viewers asking me questions I answer IN THE VIDEO, and of random viewers making demands as if I owe them something.

To replace that, I'm thinking of opening up a Patreon-only Discord server for people to use for discussion. This would be a perk open to all levels. Historically I haven't been a fan of Discord, but this seems to be something that people like.

Is this something anyone here would be interested in? 

Do you enjoy the YouTube comments?

Please let me know your feelings on this.

Thank you!

Comments (53)

L
Loren Jubilee · November 14, 2023

I don't ever interact on youtube. I find it a toxic environment.

T
The Dungeon Dive · November 22, 2023

Same! :)

G
G · October 22, 2023

Late to the party here, but I never bother making YouTube comments. I sometimes read the top few, because often enough, someone will leave a follow up point that is worth being aware of, but that's super hit or miss. I was actually just hoping there'd be a Dungeon Dive Discord set up. I don't and won't use FB, and I already use Discord for a variety of communities already.

J
James · October 16, 2023

I will occasionally leave youtube comments because I thought it showed the algorithm engagement. I don't think youtube is any good for discussion, but I do like seeing creators in niche hobbies of mine getting more exposure. I don't know if disabling the comments is a good idea or not, they might just be an unfortunate reality of the platform. I'm also of the opinion there are too many varied community platforms and it dilutes interactions in already small niche communities. I won't use facebook and other people don't want discord and that guy over there only uses mastodon instead of twitter. Seems tough to actually grow a community off-site. Ultimately, I'm supportive of whatever you decide. I understand how huge of a workload this sort of thing is and it's not generally rewarding enough to deal with obnoxious or hyper negative strangers.

J
Jeffrey Alan Ryker · October 15, 2023

I never comment on your videos since I can communicate here or in the FB group. I don't like the way discord organizes communication. I like facebook groups, the way posts organizes discussion. So I don't think I'd join a discord server. I'm sure others would. If you try transferring communication to the fb group, you could put a call to action at the end of each video reminding people, with a prompt to the discussion you'd like to start. I wonder who that might attract to join the group who otherwise wouldn't know about it.

B
Bearkrow · October 14, 2023

I don’t currently use discord but another YouTube channel I support uses it to communicate with their patrons and so I’ve been considering starting to use it myself. I do appreciate your channel Daniel and would like to be able to talk about games you feature. For example, I just purchased Tin Helm thanks to your videos. I never realized “solo gaming” was a thing before I found your channel. So in short, thank you 🙏 I always thought it was just a me thing.

B
Ben Snook · October 14, 2023

Would you be willing to post the most recent video here Daniel, for us? I saw the first few minutes, got so excited you read my comment I had to run to show my wife, then never saw the rest. I for one would find it really interesting to hear your reflections on the data...

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 15, 2023

It's posted! :)

T
Tom Cohen · October 13, 2023

I would join the Discord Daniel! I occasionally comment to help your channel out, but almost never read other people's comments.

C
Chad Spandet · October 13, 2023

I rarely comment but I do typically read through them if I'm particularly interested in the topic of the video to see the reaction. That being said, I understand the mental toll that spam and negativity must have being a creator. I have never really posted anything myself to FB, Discord, YouTube, etc. for that very reason. My advice would be to do what you think is best for your own wellbeing and balance that with how far you want to grow your channel and build "community". I think there are certainly trade-offs on that spectrum. Thanks for doing what you do! I will still be watching regardless of your path.

L
Louis Garwood · October 13, 2023

I hardly ever use YouTube comments. I read them occasionally, but almost never comment. I would join a DD discord though!

T
Toriko · October 13, 2023

Great suggestion by Aistis to keep the comments pending until they are reviewed. It seems risky to switch off comments, in terms of the long-term development of the channel. New viewers might want to casually participate in the 'community' at first, without having to switch to a different site altogether. Denying them the opportunity might turn a lot of potential members away. It creates a barrier and may obstruct the flow of the channel's lifeblood. Just some thoughts. I wouldn't like to deal with Internet toxicity either.

A
Aistis · October 13, 2023

I'm not a commenter, and I don't use Discord. I'm probably wrong to think this way, but Discord is a kind of segregation. I know a few creators who interact only through there and ignore Kickstarter or BGG comments. It's their preference, of course. Regarding the comments, you ignore them and block the malicious ones. It's as simple as that because you owe nothing to such commenters. I read the Youtube comments, though. To see what others think and sometimes to find some hilarious troll. I understand it's annoying, but you shouldn't be afraid - if you aren't, somebody will put them in their place. When I see that commenting is disallowed, it feels forced and creates an illusion of moderation. Your decision won't stop me from watching your videos. :) Edit: I know Rahdo keeps the comments pending until he confirms them. He said that this solved his problem of having negative comments.

L
Lee L Crowley · October 13, 2023

I have never used Discord - but if there was a private channel for this group that would be good (and I would sign up). If that means turning off you tube comments no problem - I don’t tend to interact that way anyway.

B
Ben Snook · October 13, 2023

I comment as often as I feel I have something useful to contribute, but I "consume" the comments on truely all of your videos. There are usually really useful nuggets to find in there. I also naïvely enjoyed the lack of negativity - I realise now that that was due to a lot of mod work on your part, so thank you. I would miss the YouTube comments, but would totally back your decision to remove them and I don't think it would affect my decision to be a patron or not. Re. Discord, I personally don't understand the appeal at all, finding it borderline unusable (we run RPGs on it, and half of us hate it). But I recognise that it has an enormous userbase, and would do my best to contribute to a healthy scene (there's always the FB group for when I don't want an unparseable anonymous stream of consciousness 😉)

B
Ben Snook · October 13, 2023

I hope that you starting this thread and the most recent video on 5 Things seemingly disappearing isn't due to some nasty troll bullshit...?

J
Jon Goodwin · October 13, 2023

I don’t comment much on YouTube - largely because I tend to watch videos on my TV. I think Discord would be cool. Now that Discord Forums exist, things can be kept organized by topic like a traditional forum. Running chat can be filled with stuff like ‘What kind of brew is everybody enjoying tonight’ 🍻

J
JC · October 13, 2023

Screw the haters. Like why would someone negatively comment on a dungeon crawl channel?? Who are these people?? Jeez I swear. Boggles my mind. I thought I usually remember people being pretty positive. Honestly one reason I love The Dungeon Dive-fantasy gaming curated by a guy who has a calming informative demeanor.

C
Christopher Bussmann · October 13, 2023

I try very hard not to read comments. I find them addictive and have to catch myself to keep from responding to trolls. Trolls are for fighting in miniature skirmish games, not for YouTube! I kinda wish comment sections didn’t exist, period. All that hot air contributes very little to a community, imo. I try to support you by Likes, subscribing, and this Patreon. I even bought a Shirt! Do you have a Discord?

G
Greg · October 13, 2023

Very rarely. I don’t read comments for the same reason you’re considering not allowing them.

F
Falen · October 13, 2023

I’m not on Facebook but am on discord so I would value a discord channel. I do like YouTube comments and have commented before. I think YouTube comments are a good way to increase engagement and ultimately increase views. I’ve noticed other YouTube influencers do things that you might be able to do (that are still within your sphere of integrity (something I admire about you)). Specifically I’m thinking of Paul Grogan at Gaming Rules! I think he also maintains integrity but does some things that positively reinforce engagement, Patreon subs, and views. One thing you could do is solicit, among your Patreon folks, some lieutenants to help mod for you. That could help you focus on the good stuff.

C
Christopher Zirk · October 12, 2023

I occasionally comment. But I always read the thread discussions of those that left comments.

P
Paul Summerhayes · October 12, 2023

I sometimes comment on your videos. I don't want to watch a video on one platform and comment on another. I am old and I will forget what I want to say 🤪

C
Carlos Erhart · October 12, 2023

I get why you get frustrated. Negative and dumb stuff sucks. I personally don't mind discord at all but I also like being able to leave comments ors read comments. Being able to see the video and then follow or contribute to a related discussion there on the same page is nice. That being said, the most important thing is for you to find ways that work for you and that can keep things fun and minimize stress as much as possible.

J
Jon R. Meyers · October 12, 2023

I think discord would be a good idea and agree with ignoring youtube comments. There's probably some sort of mainstream metric involved with more comments, visibility, and overall views, and this could just be me but if you ever read mass comment threads anywhere online, they're almost all full of useless small talk unless we're talking about itch, drivethru rpg, and BGG.

S
Sean Inglis · October 12, 2023

Abandon things that suck your energy and enthusiasm

O
OddCore · October 12, 2023

I'd be more active on discord as I almost never comment on YouTube, though I don't play solo board games really so the only content I am interested in is the solo rpgs so I might not be the main target audience!

D
Doug Cooley · October 12, 2023

I empathize heartily. If I had a channel I was populating regularly, I’d be smashing comments left and right and would probably make the same choice you are considering. I just stopped using BGG when I can after they took down a post they told me was a blatant trolling attempt (it wasn’t, it was just possible to misread the title as trolling if you chose to). Before that, I would post information in a thread and then get yelled at by people unhappy with two words (or whatever) that were included, or tell me I’m an idiot, or really any non reason at all. Just tired of it. I’ve moved almost exclusively to Discord groups at this point, where people tend to be nicer to each other. I am not nearly as enamored of very busy channels (Foster the Meeple comes to mind, it’s great stuff, just a firehose), but the more focused stuff tend to be perfect. I do occasionally comment, but not often. I’d be happy commenting here if that’s where it ended up. People have just become far too determined to carve out their own intellectual space with their preferences catered to at all times. If they want to push that on me, then they should make their own channel and do the work. Sorry, this is a touchy subject with me over the past five years. The Pandemic only accelerated it dramatically.

D
David C Autin · October 12, 2023

i've never felt a sense of community from any youtube channel**, so i really only ever comment on videos to support the channel. **the dungeon dive facebook group is awesome. it and other gaming groups are literally the only reason i'm on any form of social media.

T
Toriko · October 12, 2023

I only comment on here and BGG. I like to read the comments under your videos, though, as they seem quite friendly. I've never logged in to watch Youtube videos (no subs or likes) or used Facebook, and I don't understand the interface on Discord.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

Maybe a solution is to have a Discord, but then only moderate the YT comments for spam. That could be doable, I think.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

I wish Patreon offered a forum as a perk.

S
Scott J Poole · October 12, 2023

I believe it's important to abide with the negative and to exalt the positive. Having multiple forums for expression helps strengthen & grow the community. Discord is great, and I'm active in a few game/publisher specific servers. Some benefits of YouTube commentary; direct reference (you see something, you say something), and time-stamping. While some YT comments can be mean or frivolous, they can also be some of the most hilarious or insightful. I haven't had one belly-laugh from a Discord post. I have had many LOLs from YouTube comments. I wouldn't close that door yet, and certainly not before you've fully established other options. I think that would harm, more than help, your efforts.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

If I was seeing some benefits in views from the community engagement, I'd be more apt to put up with moderating the comments. However, the algorithm seems to really, really hate the channel (views continuing to go down, while subs go up, which is a really bad sign), so I'm not sure if the comments are really doing anything.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

The algorithm already really, really dislikes the channel (views continuing to go down as subs go up, which is a really bad sign for a channel), so I'm not sure if community engagement is really doing much.

D
David C Autin · October 12, 2023

it would not surprise me in the slightest if google's algorithm favored channels that allow ads over those that don't. in terms of popularity and content quality, there's no reason your views should be decreasing.

K
K Ryz · October 12, 2023

Your channel. Your health, good sir. Fully support you axing the comments section.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

Can't ignore them because they need to be moderated for spam. That's the main issue with not paying attention to them and keeping them enabled.

A
Apollo Smith · October 12, 2023

I rarely comment on youtube videos especially in a negative way. Usually I express my opinion with a like or dislike. I am in favour of the discord server!

S
Shieldice Studio · October 12, 2023

I only ever comment on channels I like to support. I think you should ultimately do what's best for you, especially if you're having a negative experience! The great videos are what we all come back for! 😃 I would happily join the Discord (although I'm still getting to grips with it myself 😂)

G
Geoff Bowers · October 12, 2023

Discord isn't great for conversations that are not real time. So for us outside of the principal timezone its just a disjointed mess. Better to have a decent forum solution instead. I do read the comments on YouTube, and contribute sometimes if i think i have something of value to say... or other times if i just want to help bump the algorithm. Got to have comments on for engagement, which means visibility juice on Youtube. It's a shame Patreon has such lousy community tools. I try and participate on FB but DD is the only reason i'm on FB so its not a part of my daily routine. I'd say.. pick a source of truth.. focus all your engagement there.. distribute your content far and wide, and keep directing people back to the source.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

The algorithm already really, really dislikes the channel (views continuing to go down as subs go up, which is a really bad sign for a channel), so I'm not sure if community engagement is really doing much.

J
Joe Johnson · October 12, 2023

I don't normally comment very often on YouTube. I do make an exception for your videos, because you're responsive to them. But I definitely feel you as far as disabling them goes. I say, pull trigger. A discord sounds great. It'd be a nice companion piece to the Facebook group.

s
samurguybri · October 12, 2023

I like YouTube comments to hear from other folks who appreciate the channel. I almost always learn about new games, books or music from them. I’m not a fan of Discord. It just feels like some long, rambling conversation that I don’t know how to jump into. i like a forum based approach, as it focuses the conversation. All that being said, comments can become an evil for you and I don’t want you to spend a ton of time on shitty interactions with knuckleheads. That can drain you and make you feel like humans suck. I like what you do and this does not have to be some sort of customer service model. Do what you need to do to keep doing what you do!! Your thing is great.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

I'm definitely not a huge fan of Discord either.

S
Seth Peterson · October 12, 2023

I think you’ll need to learn to ignore comments long term. It’s part of being a creator no matter the medium. I know some creators don’t even bother to read them anymore.

B
Blue Botic · October 12, 2023

Wow, I didn't realize you were getting so many negative comments. I'm sorry that you have to deal with that. Disabling comments wouldn't affect my impression of your channel at all. I'd still watch regularly. I do comment from time to time, but usually just to fist bump. I never really have anything substantive or interesting to say. I've never used discord and probably wouldn't show up there, but will definitely watch your channel with or without comments. Out of curiosity, is it a LOT of bad comments? Like dozens? or just 3 or 4 off putting comments per video? Is it possible to just ignore them? I know that some popular content makers leave comments enabled, but don't participate at all in them. That's a low/no effort option too.

J
Jason Secondi · October 12, 2023

I’m not sure if it’s a sign of age or what, but I always watch and “like” your videos on YouTube, ignore the comments section there and participate in discussions on the fb group which I find much more wholesome and welcoming. I’d worry that a discord group would water down discussions on fb.. but there’s probably a younger crowd that thinks Facebook is for us gen x folk; and would like having the Discord group. I find Discord to be a confusing mess of stream-of-consciousness vomited thoughts that is hard to follow or participate in. Now get off my lawn!

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

The FB group is great!

P
P0rthos · October 12, 2023

Discord! Discord! Discord!

K
Kody Christoffer · October 12, 2023

Personally, I find the Youtube comment section (in general, not specifically your channel) to be some of the most toxic content on the internet. I fully support content creators disabling Youtube comments. I have no idea how that would impact the channel over all (thinking here of the "almighty algorithm"), but I VERY rarely find anything of value in there. Plus I usually watch Youtube on my TV so comments are not usually seen for me.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 12, 2023

That's how I normally watch YouTube as well, and it's so much better without ever seeing the comments.

J
Jason Williams · October 12, 2023

Fair warning, I am become an old man yelling at clouds, but I don't participate on social media, and I don't comment on youtube videos. I do use discord.