💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
May 12, 2023

Am I releasing too many videos?

Once again, I am becoming a little frustrated with Youtube! While the subs go up, my views keep going down in comparison. The Starforged coverage totally struck out. Which is very odd, considering it was an often-requested game, and people also wanted more longer series coverage. I feel like I wasted a lot of time on the game.

Do you think releasing 3 videos a week is too much? Should I go down to 2 videos on the Dungeon Dive per week, or are you happy with 3? I'm wondering if I'm releasing more than people care to watch, and I'd rather not waste your time or mine! Not sure what's going on.

You all here are my main focus, so I will really value what you have to say in this poll!

Am I releasing too many videos?

Comments (47)

D
Darthus · May 14, 2023

Just to chime in, I mostly subbed to your channel to hear about more niche "dungeon delve/overland exploration" sandbox boardgames that don't get covered on other channels. I really enjoy your reviews, rundowns of top games in certain areas and the ocassional deep dive. I'm intriged by solo rpgs but don't really play them (and am usually more of a fantasy person), so I would have watched a "what is/what I like" about Ironsworn in general, but since I already know about Ironsworn, am not super into solo RPGs to begin with, and don't dig sci-fi as much, wasn't as into content on Ironsworn: Starforged, especially long form content. I think if you do long-form content, it's gotta be a deep dive on a thing that has proven interest and people are hungry for more of. Just my 2 cents! I also voted for you to do 2 vidoes, not because I want you to do less stuff, btu I don't want you to burn out and would prefer 2 videos on really badass topics diving deep than 3 higher level videos on maybe less interesting topics.

G
Geoff Bowers · May 14, 2023

Do as many videos as fits the general genre of the channel and can be produced at a high quality. I'll watch anything you put out there but would be happy to see 2 per week if it works better for your own planning. Focus on your niche and Patreon rather than riding the Youtube algorithm. BTW i don't always see new DD content on youtube; would be good if you announced all videos in multiple places (like here) so we have a better chance to see them rather than wading through the forest of youtube notifications.

G
Genghis Pawn · May 14, 2023

very late to this party: I'm not sick of you at 3 a week, but I won't be offended if you feel like it's better for you to step down to 2 a week. More broadly, I dunno what the "YouTube Experts" say, but I would imagine that rule #1 is (or ought to be) "know your audience" -- and when you get right down to it, you are aiming for a weird audience. The Starforged video might have been too late to catch the hype and get picked up by THE ALGORITHM, but I don't think you *want* to be making channels to catch whatever's the focus of hype right now, and I don't think you want to build an audience who expects that you will do so. To offer a rough analogy, you want to find a group of viewers whose viewing style allows for the equivalent of "slowquesting." THE ALGORITHM isn't really built to help you do that, but just remember: you made it to >10k subs without worrying about it much at all, and as frustrating as the last while has been as you try to do what "The experts" say and it doesn't work, you're fast approaching 20k subs anyway. I think the plan should be to try to convert more of those folks into Patrons.

D
Doug Cooley · May 13, 2023

I dearly love the channel and your approach in general, happy to be a patron.

D
Doug Cooley · May 13, 2023

I'm hoping to start doing some wargaming content (for noobs) in the near future, and while this is not a vocation for me and I have no concern if more than 5 people join the channel, I do plan to include fun extra content somewhere in the video to get people to keep watching and generate buzz.

D
Doug Cooley · May 13, 2023

II am equally guilty of that, when I did a deep dive of the wargame Panzer at area21.site (not sure if it's still functional) I had serious issues with the rules, and even had the designer scream at me. That was kinda the end of deep dives for me for a while. To be fair, the entire community had issues with the rules, and wargaming is a fanboy-heavy population.

D
Doug Cooley · May 13, 2023

I will give a little feedback on the Ironsworn videos. It is much harder for me to engage if I sense the creator isn't either, and your frustration with the mechanical complexity came through pretty clearly. While that's not a bad thing for a review or a one off, having it at the very beginning of a video or two makes it considerably less likely to continue watching that video.

D
Doug Cooley · May 13, 2023

I've been enjoying the Runebound series and am looking forward to the AH2e, which is my fave (everything but Miskatonic in my collection). I didn't even look at 3e.

J
Jeffrey Alan Ryker · May 13, 2023

I watch all of your videos, but Dungeon Dive is my primary gaming community and I just enjoy hearing you talk about things, so I don't know how representative I am of your general viewership. One thing that I hope for content like this is that it's evergreen. Ironsworn is not a fad game, so hopefully it gets you the views you feel you need to make the effort worthwhile, but it just does so in a slower manner. Maybe it'll even get you more views than average in the long run. I saw above you mention getting frustrated by the popularity of your kickstarter content, but (I'm sure I'm not telling anything) kickstarter views are almost disposable, only good for as long as there's a campaign running. I appreciate hearing from you about them, no doubt! But since it's not what you prefer to make, I hope you see eventually see the return on your deep dives.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 13, 2023

I will always do 1 or 2 deep dives a year. Going to finish up Runebound next month, and then later in the year Arkham Horror 2e.

T
Tim Burnett · May 13, 2023

I totally didn't notice the Starforged content! I've been busy living my life. I'll check it out when I get a chance. I voted for 2 vids because I have a hard time finding time to watch them all, but really the more that's out there, the better in the end when there is time.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 13, 2023

Sounds like most of you are into the three a week schedule, and that’s great because so am I! I just wanted to make sure I wasn’t wasting my time with you all thinking it was too much!

B
Ben Snook · May 13, 2023

3 videos a week is a luxury for me, but I became a patron on 1 a week, and would stay a patron on 2 a week. I find myself with less time for YouTube at the moment, and even with prioritising DD I don't always manage all 3, maybe 4 or 5 a fortnight. I haven't voted as I don't have a definite answer, but you could trial 2 a week for a few months and see what happens. As many have said, there is heaps of value in your channel as a repository, not just as live TV. Oh, and consider mentioning your Patreon at the end of your vids!! No one will hate you for it, it is so ubiquitous these days that it won't clang, and it might just net you some more followers 🤷‍♂️

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 13, 2023

I like doing 3 a week. :)

J
Jonathan Franklin · May 13, 2023

I know little about YT and statistics, but wonder if the issue is more about content and less about frequency of videos and more about the breadth of topics covered. I found DD a few years ago when the primary content was thematic/immersive board games. DD is almost more a lifestyle channel now, covering rpgs, solo rpgs, books, game books, board games, etc. I wonder if some of the audience is watching each video, but not as many are watching every video.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 13, 2023

My first video was for a game book, so that kind of coverage was always part of the package. It’s always been about thematic games set in fantastic worlds played on table tops. Now the table top just shares more space with RPGs, because that’s really where the good stuff is happening right now. But most of the coverage is still board and card games. Of the last 30 videos, 19 were for board and card games. All were for thematic games set in fantastic worlds played on a table top. :). But people aren’t even really watching the good board game stuff much, unless it’s a popular Kickstarter game. I get more views from doing dumb unboxing videos than I do the stuff I put a lot of time and effort into. That’s super frustrating! If I just wanted to chase numbers all I’d do are super low effort Kickstarter videos.

s
samurguybri · May 12, 2023

If doing three is a strain and non productive, slow down. As someone who already likes what you do, I love more content.i feel like you maintain quality well and do interesting videos.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

I like doing three. :)

C
ChargingBuck · May 12, 2023

I voted for 3 but I wouldn’t mind 2 and then something you are interested in but unsure of how it will do on YouTube as a Patreon video.

B
Brandon · May 12, 2023

Similar to many of the other people here, I enjoy the in-depth coverage you provide. As soon as you release a video I tend to watch it, but due to life happening I may not watch it all in one sitting. Have faith in your process, it’s worked to get you here.

C
Christopher Zirk · May 12, 2023

I watch this channel more than any other, but life is busy enough that I can only get to 2 a week. But you have built up such an extensive library that I like to pursue older videos of games I’m interested in - and may watch those instead of new ones. I’m often playing catch-up to get through them. I love the analysis you give to each topic.

D
Didier J · May 12, 2023

Hi Daniel, i subbed because i found for once someone who covers in depth reviews of my favorite type of games and i didn't find something equivalent among the French board games channels. As you were saying in a video about "Hexplore it" , that you surely recall, a game needs more than a superficial try in order to decide if it's good or not, and you were citing Tom Chick who had published an in depth review of this game on his blog , review that decided you to do a second try and test. So, at least for myself, i find your videos very interesting and useful and it helps a lot to make up my mind and avoid buying a game that doesn't correspond to what I'm looking for, or in a contrary, makes me discover new games i never thought I'd be interested in. But this is a completely and solely personal opinion. I'm not a good example, my RPG board game culture is very superficial and i can't speak for others but i also always enjoy watch a review about games i know well , just to have a different opinion or approach about it.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

Tom Chick is such a great voice in this hobby.

C
Christopher Bussmann · May 12, 2023

Most of your videos interest me and you should release as much content as your are comfortable creating. I do struggle to find enough time to watch/listen to them all but appreciate the deeper level of engagement you bring to your subject!

T
Tom Cohen · May 12, 2023

Daniel, the DD is my most-watched YT channel. I watch all your videos all the way through. I realize I may not be an outlier on this front within this Patreon community but perhaps in the DD YT at large. I think you put out among the best gaming YT content there is. So, my opinion here may not be all that valuable - other than for encouragement. I love 3 videos a week, but you need to do what's right for the channel and for you at the end of the day. I'll support you regardless.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

I like 3 a week as well! :)

J
John R · May 12, 2023

I watch all your stuff but have to say I prefer your intersectional coverage of board games vs RPGs. I could be in the minority and I know you’re fatigued by the crowd funding cycles and may be following the key word trends for “solo rpgs” but i get the most excitement out of your positive & negative impressions of cardboard 😇

J
John Berry · May 12, 2023

Not to be sycophantic but I’m happy to watch all of your videos all the way through and I comment / thumbs up every one. I think Starforged maybe was already well known to the community and has loads of videos already. Also I really associate the channel with Fantasy more than Sci -fi so I wonder if others do too?

P
Perplexing Ruins · May 12, 2023

I love your vids, and is probably my most watched channel, but there's been some slight personal YT fatigue happening. Limited amount of time as it is - perhaps 3 a week is taken for granted? I would be ok with two a week, knowing your time and effort could also be used enjoying your time playing, reading, etc. Also, I think you "bravely" tackle some less popular games (like the small card games) and perhaps those arent for everyone...As for the starforged, again, just time to sit and watch. You do GREAT work though, I encourage you to keep doing what you want

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

There is definitely some Youtube fatigue happening.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

The last couple of months I've been doing a lot of research about what's wrong with the channel, and the single thing that all of the "experts" say is to be consistent - stick to a schedule. And if the Dungeon Dive is anything, it's clockwork! But that doesn't seem to be fixing the issue.

A
Apollo Smith · May 12, 2023

Hi Daniel, I mainly like old school fantasy themed dungeon crawls with exceptions like dungeon degenerates that I learnt from you. I am watching your videos to discover/ watch you playing/ reviewing games that I may enjoy playing. If the game is not of my taste, most of the times I will not watch the video but most probably leave a like.

W
WillyBeans · May 12, 2023

I hate to have a negative spin, but I want to give my feedback in case it's helpful. Unless our stars align, I tend not to be interested in the same things you are making videos for at THE SAME TIME. This will often mean that I am greatful when I can hit your back catalogue for things I'm currently into. At that point I am so thrilled to have indepth coverage -- like League of Dungeoneers, Quest for the Lost Pixel, Brimstone, Sleeping Gods. These are all videos I watched to death months or even years after release. But if I've only vaguely heard of a new game, I likely will check out after 7 minutes with the attitude of 'seems neat, but not really what I'm looking for right now' This is a big part of why I'm a patron. I love what you do, I want you to keep doing it, but I know I won't be into a deep dive of a particular thing you are focusing on TODAY I'm reading this over and can't imagine this is remotely helpful. I hope at least it helps explain some of us 7-minuters

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

Thank you!

J
John Boatofcar Shawler · May 12, 2023

Starforged has been covered to death in the Youtube scene and at this point it’s kind of old news. I tune in mosty when you’re reviewing new games I’ve never heard of. As a fellow Youtuber (Amigos Retro Gaming) I can tell you that most people tune out of every video after 10 or so minutes. But it’s the longer videos that get you Patrons, so even though the stats don’t bear out making longer videos, it’s what your more active fans want. Plus, the 10 minute watch window might vary from one part of a video to the next.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

For me most people tune out after 4-7 minutes. I'd love to hit that 10 minute mark!

C
Carlos Erhart · May 12, 2023

I normally watch all of your videos but for some reason, I hadn't seen the last two pop up in my feed??? I did enjoy the first one but honestly wasn't expecting more on it after your earlier post about the challenges you were running into with it. I do really enjoy all of your content and look forward to it very much. I love seeing as much of it as possible...even if I am a bit late getting to view it sometimes.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

I'm hearing that a lot lately. People aren't being recommend my videos any longer. It's been going on since last October, and I'm not sure how to fix it. I put out new videos every Sunday, Wednesday and Friday.

S
Sean M · May 12, 2023

I appreciate your in-depth analysis and perspective on games, Daniel, and definitely want to see you stick with this format. YouTube is fickle though so I certainly sympathize with your frustrations.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

As long as you all are happy. :)

M
Michael S · May 12, 2023

I watch every video you put out and I don't think 3 per week is too much. If I had a complaint, it would be that your videos are sometimes too short. I get excited you've published a new video and then I'm sad when it's over in 10 or 15 minutes. I like your longer videos and the detail you go into but I'm probably a minority in the overall YouTube population in terms of attention span. I know next to nothing about the YouTube algorithm and how to increase viewership so I can't offer advice there. But I think you produce unique content that I always look forward to and I think you should keep doing what you're doing. And if you decide to change it up, I'll still watch every video.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

Thanks! Most of my videos are 20-30 minutes, but lately I've been trying out shorter videos to see if people watch more of them. One of the most important things about a video is how long people watch, and 98% of DD viewers check out after 4-7 minutes! Longer videos are actually EASIER to make, so I'm glad you like them! :)

O
Order of the Black Oath · May 12, 2023

I suspect that the Starforged video might have come a bit late, since the release hype is over and by now there are hundreds of videos about it. Also, I think that most of your fanbase is already super familiar with such a well known game and maybe didn't feel the need to watch it. I like the three weekly videos because it's a nice variety, but I couldn't even begin to guess what would work out best for you.

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

Could be! I like doing 3 a week, too! I just don't want to overstay my welcome. :) I'm beginning to wonder if people are growing tired of my shtick. :)

J
Joe Johnson · May 12, 2023

Weird, I loved this series. Three a week seems great to me. Maybe folks just prefer everything in one lump sum?

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

Not sure. Usually for a review of a popular/requested game, I'd have 1k views by now. The Starforged review has about 300, and part 2 totally sank. This whole past week has been trending downwards. Not sure what's going on!

T
The Dungeon Dive · May 12, 2023

You all here are my main focus, so I will really value what you have to say in this poll!