Struggling with Ironsworn: Starforged
I know this is a well-loved system for solo role-playing, and I also recognize that it is a very well made thing. I think the game does a great job of easing players into the mechanisms, and provides a very solid foundation to create worlds and scenes.
I am struggling with it though. Far too often, while playing, I find that the system pulls me out of the game. This is mainly because there are too many moves. For those unfamiliar, a move is basically an action you can take as a player that has both narrative and mechanical things associated with it; a move is a container containing a variety of things associated with a specific action, task, or thing to do. There are dozens upon dozens of different moves spread across categories focused on the character / fiction such as combat, exploration, and adventure, as well as categories focused on the player / meta such as session, and progress.
Every time I make a choice to do something in the game, I find myself looking over the list of moves to see if I am triggering a move or not. It's OK not to trigger a move, because not everything you do in the game is a move, just like you don't need to roll dice to do everything in another RPG. However, if you are supposed to trigger a move and you don't, or you trigger the wrong move and and pay the wrong consequence for that, you could seriously disrupt the momentum of the game and session.
I prefer how this system was implemented and used in the Mork Borg solo system Solitary Defilement. That is entirely inspired by Ironsworn, but the number of moves has been vastly shrunk down to only a small handful. Almost everything is done with a single move, a general adventuring move. As an example, you can do whatever you want to in combat with a general adventuring move, where as Ironsworn: Starforged has something like 6 specific combat moves that all accomplish different things.
In giving me an excess of choice, the system kind of paralyzes me at the table. And that's a frustration, especially considering how much fun I had working in my session zero as I was setting up my world and character. What I would love to see a stripped down version of this made specifically for Science Fiction, perhaps for Death in Space, similar to how Solitary Defilement was made specifically for dark fantasy and Mork Borg.
Comments (19)
I may give Starforged a look, although I certainly need no more games. I just got into Call of Cthulhu 7th in the last few weeks, running a small game with friends as we drive down to Ashland, OR (I'm in PDX). There is a solo "dungeon" generator for the system, have you looked at it at all? If you are interested, shoot me a message and I'll hook you up with a legit PDF of the Keeper's Handbook if you don't have one (bought a local hardcopy after getting PDF on DTRPG, and they include PDFs through Brick & Mortar if you buy at your LFNGS. I really like a combination of meatspace and digital when I GM.
Example: Fight moves would include charges, dodges, strikes, parry, that sort of thing. Recovery would include Catch Your Breath, recover, bandage, that sort of thing. As an engineer, I know that breaking down a system into managable parts is the key to understanding that system, it's the only way I ever learned Advanced Squad Leader.
If the moves were organized along the lines of what they generally did, it would help a lot. Then you could see the broad stroke and dig down from there. An extra layer of organization, but one that would be very useful.
I agree.
Mechanically Ironsworn is a masterpiece — but you have to click with the narrative model of play it espouses or you’ll just be fighting the system every move.
It’s a very well made thing. No doubt.
And related but old school iron sworn — https://youtube.com/@MeMyselfandDieRPG
I know people loves his stuff, I personally find it a little too performative for my tastes. He’s very good though!
It’s a mental shift that can be hard to get into.. I found the following very helpful to grok how it all flows together. Bad Spot — a great starforged series https://youtube.com/@thebadspot
Yeah. For me it’s just not worth the mental shift. I totally get it though. I’m, once again, in the vast minority in my opinion on it. :)
Sorry to hear it -- any chance you want to be the guy who makes the stripped-down version? I don't really know enough about the system to know how difficult it would be. From the looks of the 2nd image in this 3rd party guide sheet, there are 11 types of Moves? Any way to collapse the sub-types into just those 11? https://wiki.roll20.net/Ironsworn-starforged
The stripped down version is basically Solitary Defilement.
I agree with this 100%, especially making a stripped down version for Death in Space!
100 percent this. I’ve always had this issue with Powered by the Apocalypse games, but here it just seems exponentially worse because of the sheer number of moves. It’s just like playing a board game where every turn you need to reference yet another rule in the manual. It feels less like a grand adventure and more like I’m annotating references in a research paper.
Seems like a totally valid criticism. I'm sure some people love this; I can't think of anything worse 😅
I had the same problem with Ironsworn, and even though I own Starfoged, I just have no desire to play it. I recognize it's a great system but it just doesn't work for me. Not only it's too abstract and based on PbtA (a system I really dislike for soloing), it removes the kind of book keeping I really enjoy soloing. Moves overall just don't cut it for me as a solo player, I never know which one to use, as opposed to skills, which are always clear cut. And that's without mentioning the combat, which is so abstract and one of the things I love from RPGs in general. So yeah, I see it's carefully crafted and well thought out, but it's just not for me.
It's a weird thing. It's super abstract in some areas, and yet also offers up too much in other areas. Combat is a really good example of this strange duality.
I’m having the same issue with Ironsworn. I have it along with Delve and I’ve yet to get into it. I’m prone to overthinking and this system pushes that into overdrive. I think simpler is better for me. My next experiment is to try to use solitary defilement with forbidden lands. I think that’ll work well.
SD and FL should be a perfect combo! I'm with you. I have IS and Delve as well, and I was going to check those out, but I have a feeling I'm going to end up selling both. Actually, those would probably make for a good giveaway here....
