Any questions on League of Dungeoneers?
Anyone have any questions on LoD they'd like me to address when I record my review?
Comments (19)
Hi Daniel, I am interested in the topic of permanent/semi permanent maluses a hero can acquire (-X to a stat, injuries, etc.). What does LOD do in that regards? Can it easily make a character unplayable? How easy is it to recover? Thank you.
Hi- first time posting on patreon! I am interested in reboxing and storage of the game. Also, how does it play on a smaller table space? Is there some choice in how you can arrange the tiles to make it fit on a smaller table? Can you remove previous tiles and keep track of the previous dungeon tiles on graph paper sort of like advanced heroquest if you need to? How easy is it to play solo and your potential solutions with playing with fewer than 4 characters??? Also, I am really interested in how it plays as a sort of 1 shot random dungeon crawl experience versus a campaign which is not something I have time for. For me, I am looking to play random generated dungeon adventures and like the idea of the same character having future adventures and growing etc, but through further randomly generated adventures and dungeon crawls rather than scripted campaign. Thanks for all you do and have a great day!
Thanks, Michael. I'm pretty sure all of these were topics already on my mind! So we're on the same page. :) You'll be happy to note that this isn't a big narrative campaign game! At most the campaigns are ~6 quests, and there are many dozens of standalone quests. It's more about keeping your characters alive and having random quests.
I'm interested to hear more about the variety and immersion of the quests and campaigns that come with the game, and how they stand up against other modern dungeon crawlers
That will be interesting comparing with DC. I’m also all in on that from original campaign and the new updated content but… I struggle with the abstract nature of the combat - I.e. combat in a room bears no relevance to the positioning in the room and there is no ‘real’ ranged combat from either heroes or monsters. Be great to get your thoughts on that as I really want to get into it but need someone to ‘sell’ me on that bit I feel.
Hi Daniel - a list of suggestions in case any make sense to cover (and apologies to others as some have already been suggested). I’m an all in backer on this and very much looking forward to your views. *How does it compare to WHQ95 and DUN? (Those seem the most mentioned comparisons) *Whats the balance like for solo play or less than 4 player characters? *Accessibility of the rule book? *Options for one hit adventures? *Any immediate house rule ideas jump out? *Overall longevity? *What is neoprene map for? Can you use as a base surface / table cover to put room tiles on? *Does it all pack back into the box OK? *How engaging is the storyline? *Any obvious ideas for a further expansion jump out? I.e. theme or components? *Does this make you think you might get rid of any other games as this fills the gap? Best wishes, Lee
a big caparison video between this, DUN and Dungeon Crusade will be hitting in March!
I'm fond of comparative analysis. How does it differ from other big boxes, etc. EDIT: I see you plan to cover this. Excellent!
This got a little meandering, sorry: Much as I love The Dungeon Dive, I myself don't actually play many dungeon crawlers. From this perspective (as someone relatively on the outside of that genre) it can sometimes be tough to work out what makes 1 game in the genre more appealing than another. I doubt it would be fair to ask "What does LoD do that no other dungeon crawler does?" or "Is this game worth it for players who aren't bringing a bunch of nostalgia to the table?" or anything quite so pointed... but something like this kind of gets at some questions that float around my head sometimes. Thinking about the unboxing video, I think I can already guess what some of your take-aways about LoD will be for folks who love/collect dungeon crawlers, and I can also guess at some take-aways for folks who want to loot the components for their own (solo) ttrpgs. What would you want someone to take away if this was the very first video of yours they watched, and the very first review they saw of a dungeon crawler?
"What does LoD do that no other dungeon crawler does?" - this is actually a good question, because the answer is that it gets the closest to replacing the game that everyone says they want - WHQ'95.
I would be very interested in hearing your thoughts comparing this to other games of the genre and even games like D100 and RPG dungeon adventures.
I have a big comparison video in the works comparing 12 points between LoD, Dungeon Crusade, and Dungeon Universalis.
I'd love to hear your thoughts when comparing LoD with Shadows of Brimstone, since it's my all time favorite dungeon crawler. I'm excited to get my copy of LoD!
I was very interested in your observation about reversing your boardgaming journey towards more effortless games, and this is an issue for me - I'm all in and won't regret it a moment but keen to learn more about how much maintenance and management is required to play solo, and whether you think 2 players would make a big difference.
good topic!
I’d like to hear a bit about the dungeon event table; is it something that can be expanded on and does it integrate well into the dungeon dives. My favorite part of whq & sob are the event cards! Skill tests, lore, and the emergent storytelling they bring are critical for me to break up the combat. Also my interest is really piqued by the “hexcrawl” stuff that’s baked into the whole system. I’ve always meant to bring that into SoB but I’m crap with diy content.
Yes. The events are somewhat limited right now, but there is an expansion coming that adds to this!
I had trouble figuring out duration of effects. EG. Spells
I'd like to know how easy you think it would be to incorporate any of the WHQ 95 adventure and roleplaying game content. Or just any of the WHQ 95 stuff in general. I'm halfway through making my PnP version but not sure if it's worth it to complete it if LoD will be a suitable replacement.
