The First Ultimate Showdown of Overland Adventure Games - Talisman 2nd Edition
Time to judge Talisman 2nd Edition! Please assign a value of 1-5 for the following:
1. How close does it get to being effortless fun? Ease of entry – how easy is the game to learn, set up, play. Etc. (5 being totally effortless fun)
2. How well does it play solo? (5 being made for, or best played solo)
3. The visual vibe – look, feel, quality of art, etc. (5 being you'd frame art from the game to display)
4. The variety – does the game have enough encounters and stuff to do and see? (you can include expansions) (5 being it feels like anything can happen)
5. How adventurous is it? (5 being you feel totally engrossed in the world and and were able to create or experience a great narrative)
Comments (11)
4,3,5,4,3
1.3 2.3 3.5 4.5 5.5
I've only played the 4th edition: 1. 3 (simple to learn and play, but the decks are ridiculous to shuffle with expansions added in) 2. - (haven't played solo, but I'd imagine a 3) 3. 4 (beautiful art) 4. 5 (is there a game with more adventure/encounter cards?) 5. 4 (my partner and I play this for NYE, so many happy memories)
1.4 2.2 3.5 4.4 5.4 This was THE game that started me into this world back in the 80s in the UK. Maybe not the best game mechanically these days but I think will always have a unique place for me nostalgically as my ultimate game.
Same for me, my friend.
This game is greater than the sum of its' parts
Agree.
1. 5 2. 2 3. 5 Gary Chalk *chef's kiss* 4. 4 5. 3
1. 5 2. 1 3. 2 (I own 4th edition, which I rate 5) 4. 4 (with multiple expansions) 5. 2 All my ratings are based on 4E as that's what I own. For what it was back in the 90s when I first played, it was a wonderful game. Not so much for me now. Ultimately, it feels like a series of random events without narrative. Which is a shame because visually the newer edition looks great and on the surface would be an ideal solo game. Maybe I ought to give it another try...
That's perfectly fine. Not a ton of differences between the editions. Mainly art.
1. 5 2. 2 3. 5 4. 4 4. 3
