The First Ultimate Showdown of Overland Adventure Games
2023 will see a lot of coverage of overland adventure style games.
Games where the focus is moving a hero or party of heroes across a fantastic land, having quests, random encounters, with combat, loot, and some kind of character progression. These games have a particular kind of map that is often bigger than one location, but not necessarily an entire planet. They usually have a more epic feel in how they approach adventure. I have somewhat arbitrarily picked which games to focus on for this first entry. There are others that I love that aren’t featured here, and those will be featured in other such videos in the future!
The Five Categories of interest will be (voted on by the Dungeon Dive, and Dungeon Dive patreons, with commentary by the Dungeon Dive):
1. How close does it get to being effortless fun? Ease of entry – how easy is the game to learn, set up, play. Etc. (5 being totally effortless fun)
2. How well does it play solo? (5 being made for, or best played solo)
3. The visual vibe – look, feel, quality of art, etc. (5 being you'd frame art from the game to display)
4. The variety – does the game have enough encounters and stuff to do and see? (you can include expansions) (5 being it feels like anything can happen)
5. How adventurous is it? (5 being you feel totally engrossed in the world and and were able to create or experience a great narrative)
These five categories will each be assigned 1-5 points, and at the end of the comparison we will see how the games stack up. This does of course remove one of the most important categories, and that is personal choice, so I might have to weigh in after the totals to give an alternative conclusion.
In this group, the following games will be looked at:
Hexplore It - Valley of the Dead King
Talisman 2nd Edition
Runebound 2nd Edition
Pauper’s Ladder
Dungeon Degenerates: Hand of Doom
The first game to vote on is (voting for each game will be open for one week):
Hexplore It - Valley of the Dead King
Please assign 1-5 points for each of the following categories:
1. How close does it get to being effortless fun? Ease of entry – how easy is the game to learn, set up, play. Etc. (5 being totally effortless fun)
2. How well does it play solo? (5 being made for, or best played solo)
3. The visual vibe – look, feel, quality of art, etc. (5 being you'd frame art from the game to display)
4. The variety – does the game have enough encounters and stuff to do and see? (you can include expansions) (5 being it feels like anything can happen)
5. How adventurous is it? (5 being you feel totally engrossed in the world and and were able to create or experience a great narrative)
Comments (15)
I tend to look at my favourite board games with rose tinted glasses so my marks will reflect that. :) 1. 3 (first volume wasn't so bad compared to latter ones' expanded ruleset) 2. 5 (even though I actually prefer to run 2 characters) 3. 4 (love the art, lots of uniqueness) 4. 5 (granted, you need the expansion and a couple of card decks) 5. 5 (quests and encounters make sure that each play is different)
Oh yeah! I think we all do. :)
I actually started with Sands of Shurax (SoS) and decided the system while rich in choices left me unable to relate to the characters/races and holy moly it was complicated. While not having played this version, here is my best guess at numbers: 1. 2 2. 5 3. 3 4. 3 5. 3 Overall Notes: In SoS I loved the art, the exploration, and the different cities with their lore - just to name a few of the features I really liked. It was certainly not effortless and I felt like I was just trying to survive the first several turns, then I coasted along until mid game.
I would try one of the first two. They’re so much better.
This was supposed to be fun guys and gals. Lol. Don’t think too much about it. Just enjoy the fun! Vote even if you’ve only seen the box! There was no thought at all about the five games chosen or the 20 not chosen.
Why not showcase the latest HEXplore IT rather than the first?
As was stated, more games will be featured in future entries in the series! 5 at a time. We’ve got so many great games to look at throughout all of 2023!
I’ve not played any but the last two in the list, but I’m excited to see what goes on. So i’ll save voting for later. I’m more curious about learning them than having them in a showdown. A ‘compare and contrast’ is more what I like. I really enjoyed your Tunnel of Doom walking video and that’s what I would love to have the games reflect in some way. Finding special spots, dealing with terrain challenges and marveling over views and fantasy strangeness. I try to emulate this in my TTRPG sessions, but it’s tough. Breath of the Wild gives me a partial feeling of this. I wish the special spots were even more varied and able to be interacted with. Like you,I spent a lot of lovely time playing solo imaginary games in my yard and in the field next door. I was also in Scouts and did a ton of backpacking and my family went camping, so Ihave many impressions of wilderness travel and feeling free in nature. Of the board games I have a few give that give me a strong sense of place and discovery: 1. Dungeon Degenerates. A very weird world that feels like you can interact with in numerous ways and they effect what you do. You’ll be covering g this. 2. The sense of wondering what’s going to happen in Star Wars:Outer Rim. I mean the game is too damn long and you don’t interact with the planets too directly. That being said, They each have themes around the activities that you can do there and the folks you can meet. You can even have encounters just out in space, I like that. Tokaido, while not the best, finely tuned game, feels so immersive to me. We pop on some old school Japanese folk music, look at some of the ukiyo prints of the pilgrimage and nerd out on food. It the game I play where some people ignore winning conditions to try to have baths with monkeys! Great sense of place and interacting with the places, even though you’re just collecting points. Far Away is also amazing with how interlinked the animals are to the environment and to each other. The AI requires some interaction and interpretation but that is a really fun part of the game.
This is just for fun, in jest. A way to involve the community. Nothing "official" or "binding" in any way, shape or form. This will just give some good things to talk about when I make the video! This will just like the other showdown videos I've done, where I talk about each game, and rank them according to certain things so people can pick the one that is right for them. I mean it's called The First Ultimate Showdown...that right there shows it's in jest. LOL! There will be multiple ultimate showdowns. :)
2023 is going to be amazing!
1. 3 (smooth once you get the hang of the rules, conditions/keywords should be easier to reference) 2. 4 (controlling two characters involves a lot of scribbling/erasing, controlling one limits your options because most aren't designed to play alone) 3. 4 (second edition + the new encounter pack with artwork) 4. 5 (with the big expansion) 5. 5 (feel like I could do anything)
Really looking forward to this. I've watched videos on all these games and they all interest me, but haven't played any of them. I'm trying not to spend as much on games this year but I will be closely following along to see if any of them pique my interest enough to break my resolution. 😂
This is a super cool idea, but I personally have played none of these games. I could vote based on what I would guess/think, but I don't feel confident about that. So here's hoping the rest of the Patrons are a bit more savvy than me. If not -- if there doesn't turn out to be enough votes/discussion here in our Patreon nook to properly implement this interesting idea -- then I for one would vote for you to open it up to a broader group (like the facebook group that I know nothing about), rather than kneecapping it.
Yeah - I'll have to monitor the votes. Maybe I'll do a week here, then a week at the FB group.
1. 2 2. 5 3. 3 4. 4 5. 4
