💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
January 12, 2023

Can I ethically cover games made by Zak Smith?

Zak Smith has created some of the most interesting RPG supplements ever created. His work is bold, gorgeous, beautiful, dark, haunting, subversive and creative, not to mention very useful. However, by all accounts he's a POS (although I don't think any charges have ever been formally made against him). I purchased his books many years ago, long before any of the accusations against him were publicly made. I purchased them in good faith thinking he was just a weird dude making cool stuff.

I've avoided covering any of his stuff because I don't want to open that can of worms on the channel.

The question here is: Can I ethically cover games made by Zak Smith? 

I'm checking the temperature here because I really don't know. I've always been one to separate the art from the artist in the things I personally enjoy (I still like Rosemary's Baby and Chinatown, for example), but I also have a history of celebrating more progressive ideas (like representation in games) on my videos.

I'm leaning towards never covering his material on the channel, but I wanted to get some other opinions.

Thank you

Comments (39)

E
Ed Hoskell · March 12, 2023

It's not censorship to make content decisions about your own (private as in non-governmental) media platform. Include, exclude, ban, promote whoever and whatever you please for any or no reason. My vote is don't bother with this one.

J
Jeffrey Alan Ryker · January 15, 2023

Whether you're worried about the ethics or David's pragmatic consideration, another thing to weigh against those concerns is how many other things of equal worth can you cover if you don't cover this. Coverage of this material will bump coverage of something else. You have limited time. There is so much going on in this space right now, that if I had any concerns, I would really think about what isn't getting covered this year that would if I weren't to cover this. That might make the decision easier.

D
David Voss · January 13, 2023

Regardless if it’s ethical or not, would it be worth it to you to lose any % of subscribers/views over? Not saying that you should always avoid controversy, just make sure it’s worth it. The Internet is fickle and unpredictable.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 13, 2023

Yep!

S
Sean Inglis · January 13, 2023

Can I ethically support the Dungeon Dive? I mean, sure, no guilt has been established, but I can probably find an accusation or two if I look hard enough. That should do it, yeah?

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 13, 2023

I know I've been accused of being a woke, leftist, socialist, communist, soy-boy for admiring diversity in games.

S
Seth Peterson · January 12, 2023

I knew nothing of this person until this post. I read everything i could find, and it seems like there is nothing of substance. He has won multiple defamation lawsuits already. Note, winning defamation is not exoneration of her claims, but those have never been anything past social media posts. You will inevitably have to address the elephant in the room if you speak to his allegations at all. Personally, I can separate the Art from the Artist, but I know many cannot.

G
Gankatron · January 12, 2023

Upon scanning your comment, I misread it to say, "You will inevitably have to address the elephant in the room if you speak to his alligators". I thought' "That is a creative aphorism, I wonder what it means?" I am sure there is some clever way to make that appropriate for an internet argument. :)

T
Tom Cohen · January 12, 2023

My initial reaction is that I don't have the time or inclination these days to watch, hear or read praise for a POS or their art. There is too much other fascinating and incredible stuff created by exceptional people out there to spend time on. That being said, if there was a way to describe what makes Vornheim the best city generator out there without mentioning or giving credit to the POS who wrote it - all in an effort to plant the seeds for others to build a replacement for it - now that might interest me. That might be hypocritical of me to propose, but imo whatever can be done to help our hobby move on from these people (and there have been a bunch of abusers/predators in our hobby exposed in recent years) and their legacies & products by replacing them with better alternatives - all the better. Is it too cliche to say "now get off my lawn?" :-)

N
Neil young · January 12, 2023

Ultimately he has never been prosecuted for any crime and I’m very very anti censorship. However no one has to cover anything that they are conflicted about. He has an odd lifestyle another comparison is Ezra miller who seems to ride the storm while others are crucified for similar behaviour. Stay away from divisive people as there is never a good outcome

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

Thanks for the great conversation, everyone! I think I might ask for some recommendations for some alternatives to his specific titles in other posts here. And if I make videos on those alternatives, I will not mention the other things by name, or invoke the name of the author. As I expected, it's just to omuch drama and heartache, and I don't want to offend victims of any kind of abuse.

s
samurguybri · January 12, 2023

How about doing a Patreon only video, if you really want to explore it? I've heard great things about Blue Medusa and Vornheim and would love to get your take on them, but don't want any $ to go his way. I don't know if you've checked out Michael Raston's Infinigrad stuff? He's made some great generators for his gritty and strange setting of Infinigrad, The settingis really like a kind of pure fantasy Shadowrun game in a magically infinite city. The game play is job and neighborhood based and he's created some marvelous tables and one of the best adventures evar: Pollute the Elfen Memory Water. It is a creepy and gross take on Elves and a Job that's location based. https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/256196/Pollute-the-Elfen-Memory-Water 10 foot pole Bryce really digs it. Here's his geneator stuff on DriveThru: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/365147/Infinigrad-The-Weird-City-Toolkit?src=also_purchased

J
Jonathan Stutzman · January 12, 2023

Not worth covering impo. Huge triggers for lots of different folks around that guy for legitimate and varied reasons. There is an abundance of great creative material to be covered, lots of which is more interesting then what he created and free of unnecessary drama which he brought to the hobby. I witnessed a lot of what went down and it was such a bummer. He was blatently abusive to people and apparently his partner who I absolutely believe.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

What about a video showcasing alternatives for people? I would have to find those alternatives (open to suggestions), and in some instances that's nearly impossible. For instance, there isn't a city generator on the market better than Vornheim. Vornheim is, however, OOP and super expensive. So an alternative would be HIGHLY valuable for 2 reasons. 1) something not made by ZS, and 2) something available and affordable.

M
Mara · January 12, 2023

In these sorts of cases, if there isn't anything out there, I just make my own! Of course, I agree that Vornheim is hard to top. Anytime I sit and try to make a city map, it's the first resource that pops into my mind. Really just the map creation technique though. I also would try to make it more sci-fi friendly, and I don't know if that would turn out well. But yeah, Vornheim and Maze of the Blue Medusa were major works in the OSR library that have influenced so many people since. Maze of the Blue Medusa because of the way it's laid out, more than the content, which is mostly Patrick Stuart's doing, I believe. I'm not sure.

M
Mara · January 12, 2023

Man, ok. I guess I didn't do enough research, or maybe this all came out after I had done the research I did at the time. But I was not part of any of these communities and didn't know Zak S. had this pattern of behavior. So I am also reconsidering my stance on the matter. Here's the reddit thread. It is quite the rabbit hole. https://www.reddit.com/r/osr/comments/apcutf/all_those_lies_told_about_zak_sabbath_zak_smith/

G
Gankatron · January 12, 2023

This thread has fostered some frank and non-confrontational conversation, which is a good thing.

G
Genghis Pawn · January 12, 2023

Could you do it ethically: I think you could, but a key component would be to clarify the purpose of the review. If you think he is morally reprehensible and should not get anyone's money (*I am assuming this is true throughout this comment), then the purpose of an ethical review cannot be to suggest to anyone that his work is worthy of purchase. As Christopher Bussman put it : "there is so much other great stuff to cover, why shine a light on this particular creator?" -- the only potentially acceptable answer would be "because there's these 1 or 2 things that this creator did that are truly unique and interesting, and I want players and creators to be keep hold of those babies while we hurl out the bathwater at as high a velocity as possible." The sole ethically justifiable purpose of the review would be to "lift" something useful out of the muck and, essentially, take it from him, throwing the rest away. If there are no such unique components of his work, then I don't think it could be done ethically. Could you do it without controversy and pissing people off? No, obviously the comments here reinforce that already. I take that to be a wholly distinct question, ultimately far less important than the ethical question, but I admit that in practical terms it is probably the more impactful question. While I think you could do a review that was ethically neutral and not blameworthy, I don't think there's any moral imperative to cover his work. And so I think it's fair for the practical consideration to take precedence in any case.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

"Could you do it without controversy and pissing people off? No, obviously the comments here reinforce that already. I take that to be a wholly distinct question, ultimately far less important than the ethical question, but I admit that in practical terms it is probably the more impactful question. " Agree.

J
Joseph Cannon · January 12, 2023

I've voted yes because you asked us to go one way or the other and I think it is a tricky question. I went this way because I personally don't see that covering this material (assuming that in itself the material doesn't promote unethical things) endorses the creator's lifestyle or ethics. If I felt that the material was worthy of coverage then I'd probably want to do so, but would want to make it clear that I wasn't endorsing the creator in their personal / public life. That said, you have worked hard to create a wonderful channel and if you think it might damage your standing in the community then it's perfectly sensible to give it a pass - as others have said, there's no shortage of games to cover.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

"That said, you have worked hard to create a wonderful channel and if you think it might damage your standing in the community then it's perfectly sensible to give it a pass - as others have said, there's no shortage of games to cover." Yes- this is super important.

C
Christopher Bussmann · January 12, 2023

Personally, I feel like there is so much other great stuff out there to cover, why shine a light on this particular creator?

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

I mostly agree. However, a couple of his books are, simply, the most valuable resources for what they offer. It really sucks. For example, Vornheim is the single best city generator I've ever seen. But it's just not worth the controversy to cover.

M
Michael Lee · January 12, 2023

The number of responses says it all; covering Zak S. is asking for controversy. You'll have people quit the channel, and "out" you as a Zak S. supporter. A very, very small minority, but enough to tarnish your online image. This sucks because I agree with, the guy has created some great art. The testimony against him, charged or otherwise, is pretty damning. And his continual non-repentance is obnoxious. He literally said that he wants to create more, but we (the internet) won't let him. As if it's everyone else's fault. Contrast this with Lois CK who apologized, owned it, and added it to his standup routine. Will he ever achieve the same level of fame? Maybe not, but he's allowed to be a comedian again because he's trying to be better.

O
Order of the Black Oath · January 12, 2023

Totally agreed.

C
ChargingBuck · January 12, 2023

I feel like if you are hesitant to show any relation between your channel that you have built from the ground up and some POS that could turn any viewers away from your channel, I think it would be in the best interest to focus on the millions of other awesome things out in the community. If you wanted to cover it in some capacity, you could always put that sort of stuff in your Patreon so you could put your thoughts out there but keep it separate from your channel and then get a feel for how things are received before doing anything on your channel to the public.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

"I feel like if you are hesitant to show any relation between your channel that you have built from the ground up and some POS that could turn any viewers away from your channel, I think it would be in the best interest to focus on the millions of other awesome things out in the community." This is how I am leaning as well.

M
Mara · January 12, 2023

I also have a lot of his games. I actually went and read everything I could about what happened, though it was a lot harder for me to find her side of the story, since it mostly happened on Facebook, in bits and pieces. Needless to say, it's complicated. Very briefly, there was a very open lifestyle in this household and Zak's wife at least tolerated it for many years. At some point, she had enough and left. While it often takes a while to recognize abuse, I don't know how fair it is to place all the blame on Zak. It was a weird way to live by my standards, but she did consent to that at the time, and she was an adult. The complicating factor is her history of mental illness, which is really hard to judge from a distance. I am one of the last people in the world who will forgive an abuser, but it's hard to say he was actually the monster he's been made out to be. That said, I've really gotten reamed online when I've tried to say something in his defense before, so apologies if this starts a bunch of drama.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

This is a totally valid opinion on the matter at hand.

M
Michael S · January 12, 2023

I voted no. I personally can separate art from the artist and believe in innocent until proven guilty, but I probably would never support the person by buying their product. I'd pirate it without qualms (although that's a whole other ethical issue, I suppose). However, given the current average IQ of the internet, if it was my channel, I'd pass. Unless you want to hire a moderator. BTW, I have no idea who this person is or what they are accused of.

G
Gankatron · January 12, 2023

I tend to have strong opinions that at least I think are well thought out, but I don't think there is a straight answer here, as for everyone who would be judging you in doing so will have their own opinions, not surprisingly polarized. Perhaps, the more pertinent question is, "Is it worth it for your channel to cover controversial topics?" Past the fact these are allegations (something which the whole Depp-Heard experience reverse sensitized the world to), assuming he is a sexual abuser, is there a way to cover his material with a sufficient disclaimer to distance yourself from criticism? Probably not, at least for some of your viewers. I own Woody Allen's, Roman Polanski's, and other questionable figures works because they have intrinsic value as art. I have a Deadman's Hand tattooed on my ribcage, which while more a personal statement regarding the capricious nature of life, also gives a nod to Motorhead's Ace of Spades, with Lemmy being an unapologetic collector of Nazi memorabilia. The classic question of should the scientific community use data obtained from forced human experimentation that extended to torture, is one that I am prone to say yes to, assuming the experimental conditions yielded scientifically valid data. Being an ethical-based vegetarian and atheist, I am confronted with that issue regarding non-human animals, and while I would like to see the cessation of harmful animal research, I wouldn't try to ban usage of previously obtained data. Still where these issues become difficult for me regarding artistic works is where I feel my support of their creative works will support them financially, I think you can be guaranteed there will not be a unified answer when this issue is put out to the tooth and nail of the internet. I don't financially support Papa John's, Domino's, or Goya due to my political views, but generally I don't say that in public because who needs the conflict? This will likely be a conflict generating subject, so is it worth it for you? For what it is worth, I am not going to vote because I don't want to sway you in one direction or another, but I would watch the video as there will be information there I can learn from, but I doubt I would buy his works unless I knew he wasn't going to be compensated for it. Of course I will feel badly if the allegations turn out to be false, but unless one's name is Amber, I believe it takes a certain amount of fortitude for an abuse victim to come forward, so I tend to believe it until proven otherwise. Inquisitorial systems aren't fair, but sometimes it seems the prudent option. I hope this helps provide a clear course forward! ;)

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

Perhaps, the more pertinent question is, "Is it worth it for your channel to cover controversial topics?" That's an important part of me leaning no as well.

O
Order of the Black Oath · January 12, 2023

I don't think an individual like him needs more publicity. I say no.

R
Ryan Kleeberger · January 12, 2023

Oh wow i wish there was a 3rd option: I'm torn! The discussion behind consuming art, etc., created by dubious or corrupt individuals is so, so difficult and complicated. I'd love for you to create a video on this very subject to expose and clarify your own thinking on this subject generally and then with respect to Z. Smith particularly. Maybe you will come to a more robust conclusion if you elaborate your own position!

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

Making an opinion piece on the subject could be an interesting take, but it could also end up being a have my cake and eat it too, scenario.

C
Christina Hatziemmanuel · January 12, 2023

I believe in separating the art from the artist, however I voted no as I think it might look bad for you to cover his stuff. He does also seem like a POS and, unlike Lovecraft is alive and well. I personally take less issue with people who've passed and can no longer benefit from media coverage.

O
Order of the Black Oath · January 12, 2023

Covering his stuff will most definitely put this channel in the black list for lots of people.

M
Mathew · January 12, 2023

I think courts should determine if someone is guilty and what you're doing by asking us is a good thing. I believe enjoying art despite the artist is also important. Lovecraft's work has touched so many things and it would be a pity to lose it all because of his personal behavior. I know it's always more complex than that, but that's my two cents anyways.

O
Order of the Black Oath · January 12, 2023

One could say Lovecraft was a product of his time. You can't say the same for Zak Smith. There's no defending the guy.