💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
December 29, 2022

Do you enjoy when I cover a game multiple times in a detailed series?

I'm asking this on Youtube as well, but I wanted to hear the opinions here. The first video in a series will get good traction and engagement, and then more often than not the subsequent videos get fewer and fewer views, comments and less engagement. 

People say they want detailed coverage of a game, but the numbers say the opposite.

I'm at a loss of what to do with the channel, As the subscribers go up, the number of views stays about the same in terms of percentages, or has been dropping on a lot of stuff since October, with a few notable exceptions. Something definitely happened to the channel in October that I still can't figure out. 

Even following what people are looking for when they search for things on the Dungeon Dive hasn't yielded many positive results. Not sure what's going on with Youtube, but the channel seems to be stuck in some kind of engagement purgatory or something. 

I've been trying to fix it, but nothing I'm doing is working. 

I want to gauge what people here are looking for. 

If you don't like the detailed videos / series, what do you want to see?

Thanks for your input!

Comments (38)

C
Christopher Zirk · January 3, 2023

Just to clarify my Yes vote (in case it matters), I do enjoy multi-series when each video shows a new aspect. For example, the core set of a game in one video, expansions in the next, etc. This way I feel I'm learning something new in each video. I think the Dungeon Dive does a good job at this format. I find it less enjoyable to watch a multi-series if it's one long play though that's broken up into multiple parts. I also really like seeing in the videos the more subjective experiences the game provides - the feeling the player gets when playing the game. Again, the Dungeon Dive does a really good job at this. When I'm looking at a game, it's hard to know if the mechanics of the game will give me a great play experience. So I really look for the feelings & impressions that are shared in the video. I mention this because if this is an aspect that other viewers want as well, then perhaps an idea is to make sure each video in a multi-series includes these feelings & impressions. (I'm just throwing out ideas for your consideration, I'm not trying to critique in any way.) I also like seeing a game compared to other games that are similar so I can also get a sense of how a game might play. For example, when you did the Which Of These Four Small Box Games is Right For You, I found that very helpful for me to get a better sense of which game I might invest in. If viewers find like that aspect, then an idea would be to throw in a mini-comparison of similar games within the videos of the multi-series.

T
The Dungeon Dive · January 12, 2023

I really do need to make more comparison videos. People really like those, and it's relatively low stress content to create.

D
David Voss · December 31, 2022

I think Facebook and YouTube are run by the same people. For some reason Facebook continues to display posts from over a week ago instead of displaying new posts on the default feed. I absolutely hate that I have to change sort order to new posts every frickin’ time I view posts on a Facebook group page to make sure I see all new posts and not just the latest one. Every time. Why can’t it learn that I do that every time and give me what I want? I hate having someone else deciding what to show me when they get it wrong over and over and in the case of Facebook refuse to make it a setting that people have asked for for years.

D
David Voss · December 31, 2022

I’ve heard that likes and comments are important. Maybe see if there’s a way to encourage people to post comments (ask questions?) to see if that helps?

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 30, 2022

Thanks for all the insight, everyone! Really appreciate it. Gave me some good things to think about.

L
Louis Garwood · December 30, 2022

Hey Daniel, I do like the longer multi video deep dives, but for games I'm interested in. I've watched your dungeon degenerates ones a bunch, but I've only watched the first one of the Shadows of Brimstone series. So I can't say that it's necessarily the format that causes engagement/disengagement for me personally. In October you did your horror month. I'm just not into horror, so I disengaged during those videos unfortunately. Maybe that's the case with a bunch of dungeon divers? Anyway, I hope you figure it out and are satisfied with engagement. I just got my crowd sale copy of Quest for the Lost Pixel after watching your videos on it and the interview with Peter Jank, which I loved! Keep it up man, you'll figure it out!

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 30, 2022

Thanks! This is a common sentiment, and one that I find curious, and at odds with how I view things. I tend to watch videos on games I am NOT interested in, to see if I would be interested in them. It's how I discover a lot of the games I cover on the channel! Just recently I had zero interest in Oltree, but watched a few videos on it, and it ended up being a great game! I had zero interest in Mork Borg a couple of years ago, but watched some coverage on it, and now I love it! I guess I tend to make videos more for the seekers! :) Or I'll watch anything put out my Marco Omnigamer and Geek Gamers because I like what they have to say, even if I don't like the game they are covering. It helps me grow my own interests in the hobby so I can bring more interesting things to the channel. But I know there are different habits for different kinds of viewers! Trying to appeal to both is the challenge.

G
Genghis Pawn · December 29, 2022

I think the boardgames-related Youtube space and your usual style of coverage may lend themselves to weird consumption patterns for a long series. I'm probably an example of a weird consumer. If I hear about a new game someplace else I'll search on your channel to see if you have content on it. I'll definitely watch a Look At or Review video if you have one. From there, if you have a series of videos, I'll probably watch at the first video if I'm intrigued by the game. If I'm quite keen on the game then I may watch a multi-video series -- but I generally do that *only* if I'm quite keen on the game and want to learn more about it or sort of do a ride-along. Because I know that a ride-along through one of your series probably won't just be gameplay. (Some of your older series to feel that way). We're going to take detours into cinema and books and who knows what else. Which I quite like, but, if I see that you've got 7 videos on the game, the bar gets set higher for how keen I need to be to commit to the whole thing -- because for me, your content isn't "second screen" viewing. I either pay attention or I don't kid myself. (Though I do sometimes let them play in the background to add a view). That said, I don't understand how most folks engage with YouTube. I subscribe to your channel and a few others. Each day or so I'll log in and click on "Subscriptions" on the left to see what's new. I'll generally Like and watch them all eventually (with caveats above about series: I might wait until I'm keen). Whenever I watch I comment when I can to feed the algorithm, and occasionally I'll let the video play on the tab without actually watching it, just to add a view. I don't think this is how most subscribers do it. I've heard subscribers say "your video wasn't in my feed." F*** the feed -- I subscribed to avoid trawling through the Feed; I go to Subscriptions as my landing page.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

That's exactly how I use youtube as well, and I think you're right - that's not common.

J
Jonathan Franklin · December 29, 2022

Is it possible the board game space is saturated and the one-shot solo rpg play-throughs and reviews has more room for growth? I learned about Rangers of Midden Vale from geek gamers. I wonder if a series "RPGs for board gamers" could work. I was intrigued by Rangers because it has skill checks that lead to different story branches and is playable by a group with no GM as well as solo. If there are others in that genre, maybe bringing rpgs to boardgamers could work as a themed series.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

"RPGs for board gamers" - that's a great topic! Because that's basically what I do. But I could frame it more like this.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

It's crazy. The poll on Youtube with 249 votes shows 91% favor a long series. Is Youtube just not recommending follow up videos to people?

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

I think the key might be to release one episode a week of a long series, and each episode should have a drastically different title.

D
David Voss · December 29, 2022

Maybe people love the idea of a long series but what you’re seeing is the reality that people don’t have the time or really aren’t interested in it. I love the idea of going to the gym, losing weight, climbing a mountain but my fat ass is going to continue sitting on the couch watching YouTube videos or Netflix. People buy gym memberships cause they like the idea but don’t go. People buy tons of board games that they would love to play but don’t play them. There’s a lot of examples of people saying what they would like but doing the opposite.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

Yes - exactly. :)

D
David Voss · December 29, 2022

Just some unorganized random thoughts… Do you have a group of content creators in the same space that you discuss things like this with? What’s going on with YouTube, are they seeing the same thing, etc? YouTube has been weird in what it presents on my homepage. Some of these videos I have no idea where it’s pulled them from. Sometimes it’s pulling up videos that are many years old. I have to click on the subscription section to see channel content I’m subscribed to. Are you able to tell which videos brought in new subscribers? Were upticks specific to any crowdfunding campaigns like DUN? Runebound is a great nostalgia game for me that is unlikely going to be pulled off the shelf due to so many other games. I’m skeptical of a series on an old game like that, which is crazy expensive to buy expansions for (and a roll to move mechanic that people hate). Maybe people will watch the first because it’s a new video, nostalgia, etc but beyond that what would viewers get out of it that would be relevant to today? Does Deep Dive need to be a series? Would it do better if it wasn’t seen as a 1 of 6, 2 of 6, etc. Is there a psychological fatigue factor that deters people from committing to a series like that? Would shorter focused videos do better covering specific topics of a game? Spread them out so that you’re not turning off subscribers because you’re covering a title for 2 months that doesn’t appeal to them? What about just some 20-30 minute videos where you just ramble about solo rpg or dungeon crawler stuff without having to focus a lot of time on production and editing? Are people here for the deep dive series, solo rpg, dungeon crawler games, or just listening to you talk about games? Will people be too busy playing all of those piles of games they just bought from Barnes&Noble? 🤔😜

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

The number one search term by a huge margin is "Solo RPG" This term drove the most traffic to the channel. It just so happened to coincide with my shift towards that kind of game. Those two things combined led me to believe that the solo RPG content would do well, but it hasn't really done all that well in relation to how much that search term is used. It's really weird. My Youtube home page has also been totally bizarre the last few months. I get almost no board game / RPG stuff recommended any more, except for the super popular D&D stuff from people like GinnyD and Critical Role. Youtube seems to be further squashing the little guys in favor of the big guys.

J
Jonathan Franklin · December 29, 2022

I feel guilty for voting 'no', but wanted to explain it a few ways. 1. I like deeper dives that are not regurgitation of rules, but have attention span issues, especially when I don't already own the game being discussed. I often know if I am interested in the game after the first or second video. 2. Unlike some of the comments above, I am not sure if engagement in December is down or if it is dominated by year-end Top 10 lists. 3. I have seen a new acronym recently, USP (Unique Selling Proposition). If the deeper dives are not working to get the viewer # where you want them to be, is going deeper into niche topics worth your time? I am not sure. How about if you did more bite-sized ones that have specific topics in the video title, so if someone has a question about Runebound 2nd ed. combat resolution, they can find that video by title? I know this is antithetical to your style, but I wonder if there is a tension between your long-form journalism and the average YouTuber attention span. You are amazing at what you do and I adore it and support it, but if it is about making more $ per month, I'm not sure it is the right path. 5. Could you have a few series. Deep Dive, Solo RPG, and a more 'click-baity one'? Top 10 in under an hour, Top 10 boss battler, Top 10 solo dungeon, etc. I hope this can balance your interests and your desire to monetize the channel.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

Thanks for the thoughts! Appreciate it. Good stuff. I really want to stay away from the click-baity shit, but it's probably something I need to do if I want the channel to grow. I'm going to experiment with some stuff this year. Last year I started the bite-sized 5-minute reviews, thinking those would do well, but they didn't, and that short scripted content took exponentially more time and effort to create, so those definitely aren't worth it.

M
Mara · December 29, 2022

I think you have a unique format in making such detailed videos, and over the long run I think Youtube rewards channels that follow what their creators love to do (or at least, it rewards those kinds of creators more than some other platforms). If I may engage in a bit of speculation, the holidays, the new year, and the recent upheaval in the D&D 5e crowd has given the whole gaming community a sense of anticipation. We don't know what's coming yet, but there's a sense that something is about to change. In other words, I think longer videos are fine but perhaps people are looking for a new normal, in their gaming world in particular. Personally, I'm more interested in smaller games at the moment. It feels like there's tons of them, and I don't have the funds or the time to test them all out.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

There will definitely be a lot more coverage of smaller games. I was actually thinking of jumping on the One D&D bandwagon even though I have absolutely zero opinion on it. LOL. I was actually going to do like a 1 minute video where I basically state I have zero opinion, as a joke. But my channel isn't really a joke channel. :)

L
Liam · December 29, 2022

I love the series on games, but I think the problem with views would be that it would have to be games people loved - for example, I could see someone watching one episode on Talisman, but then deciding to find other content they might prefer, rather than watching 5 or 6 more videos. In terms of monetising, it might make sense to do just big games that you know have a huge following, and are still available as well?

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

My main problem is that I don't like most big games that have a big following that are still available. LOL! ;)

G
Gankatron · December 29, 2022

The TL;DR: conclusion to my monolith of text is probably, the extended content coverage may actually be of most interest to your current subscribers/patrons, so perhaps do them occasionally based upon preference polls, which may help to decrease attrition, while generating new viewers with the rest?

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

I prefer the deep coverage. That's what I'd like to do more of. I think I've come up with a few solutions here. 1) do one long epic video. I know those do very well on youtube. There are 8 hour reviews of Skyrim that have millions of vies. But that would of course mean fewer videos while the mega one is being made. 2) more time between episodes of a deep dive. Maybe one episode every month, or every 2 weeks.

J
John Berry · December 29, 2022

I voted no because if your engagement is dropping off on multiple part videos people have seen enough from the first vid. I think maybe one video on a subject and then re-visiting it a month later?

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

Yep - that's another possibility. One video a month or something for a series.

V
Viktor A. · December 29, 2022

I am tending to Yes, but I am missing the "it depends" option. I normally watch every video at least a few minutes, but then it depends if the game is for me. If it is a game that does not interest me much, then there is no need for more. If it is something interesting, over time I will watch all of them, but it simply takes time to go through my to-watch list. 15-20 minute videos I'll watch mostly in one go, but everything longer needs to be split over multiple days...

G
Gankatron · December 29, 2022

The answer for me is yes, I like the longer detailed videos, but you have to do what is best for you to keep making content. It isn't surprising that the shorter attention span videos bring in more hits. The longer ones are an extended niche commitment, and likely cater to current subscribers like a self-fulfilling prophesy of likes, that probably has a bigger effect on decreasing viewer attrition than attracting new people. Viewers like the quick synopsis Top 10 types of content, ones where they will get max exposure to guide their buying desires, whereas the extended series are the antithesis of that, only one game for a very long time. I also think that people may get turned off when they realize the amount of time they need to commit for the bottom line, of course missing out on much of the nuances of the experience. It is a reality you will have to balance. My father was an artist and had to make the decision to continue with the more creative side of his career or switch to the more profitable side of graphic design (i.e., advertising). My birth ensured the latter choice and he did well financially during those Mad Men days prior to computers. It was only after he retired was he able to go back to making art that satisfied his creative desires. Taking that route was probably the better option as being an artist living in a hovel with wife and child probably isn't as romantic of a reality as it sounds. You already have your time split between the DD and what I imagine will be a less viewed literary channel (no offence, I mean I watch it, but atm gaming is king), so something likely is going to have to give, unless you find yourself a sugarperson (sugarmomma still sounds better, but I choose not to assume). The reality is, most current subscribers/patrons will still remain if you focus primarily on less detailed multiple game content, so in a practical sense the decision may be obvious, even if it pains me to say so. Plus, you are asking this during an extended coverage of a heavily modified SoB campaign, While it is one of my favorite games and is how I first found out about the Dungeon Dive eventually leading me to become a patron, is as highly niche as you can get. Also, if you did an extended coverage of a game I didn't care for (UNO Legacy, for instance), I can't say I would necessarily watch it unless I felt there were some aspects of game design that would be worth the time commitment. Despite the impressive amount of creativity that goes into your SoB project and its coverage, most board gamers likely don't even know about SoB, or if they do, probably haven't played it, so the interest in a multiple part series of how to mod your SoB game is too niche/esoteric for them to commit the viewing time. Just to be clear, ...thank you, I love it. You have added a unique way to modify my SoB experience that I would not have otherwise. I have to admit, I also like Top 10 lists, so either way, I'll be sticking around.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

The truth is, I enjoy doing the detailed stuff more than anything else.

J
John R · December 29, 2022

For detailed vids, I think you'll always get some sort of drop off because people will watch the first vid to see if it's for them and then trail off on the rest of videos exponentially with only the die hard fans of these games watching the rest of the series. Personally, I'd prefer a huge 2-3 hour video of a detailed look, but understand if you want to keep it episodic as I may be in the minority on that one

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

I'm totally down with doing a single long video, and that is a possibility, for sure. It would of course mean fewer videos in a given period of time, but that's one of the solutions I'm thinking of.

B
Ben Snook · December 29, 2022

I tend to watch almost all of your 'single' videos, and tend not to watch all of your deep dives, because not all the games resonate with me and I don't have multiple hours available to do them justice. However, my most valued videos of yours are actually some of the deep dives. I appreciate this is a real paradox - such specialisation is by its very nature hit or miss in its appeal, which is quite the risk when the content is one's source of income.

T
The Dungeon Dive · December 29, 2022

Right? People say "We love the deep dives" or "We want series of playthroughs!" and then they don't watch them. LOL.

M
Michael S · December 29, 2022

It's not just your channel. Pretty much every channel I've watched that has a series on any topics has fewer and fewer views on the later videos. I think it's an attention span problem, which I'm sure the YouTube algorithms aren't helping. I definitely enjoy your detailed videos and I watch all the way to the end of the series.

A
Apollo Smith · December 29, 2022

I voted yes, but this goes mainly for games that are appealing to me. I really enjoy your whq series because it is my fav game. I haven't spent time to other series though, where the game did not match my taste that much.

C
Crazy Volucris · December 29, 2022

Yes detailed look at vids… that‘s what brought me to Shadows of Brimstone etc. I like the way you are handling games etc. and I heared this from other content creators… seems to be an issue… but than again this is what your channel makes it so special… maybe don’t overthink it and just do what you like and you will get the best result. That’s just my opinion 😌

M
ML Hanson · December 29, 2022

I think (at least for the last month or so) that the holidays may have caused a general dip in viewership with everyone being busy, etc. It’s probably at least part of the issue.