💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
October 21, 2022

Do you like the Friday Podcast / Hobbycast episodes - Future of the Channel

Hi all! So these Friday Podcast / Hobbycast episodes take a ton of time and effort, more so than any of the other content on the channel. I spend a lot of time researching, editing and writing to do them.

They almost always severely underperform. From a creator's standpoint, they are not worth the time and effort.

Do you enjoy them and want them to continue?

Do you mainly watch them on Youtube?

I like doing episodes on topics outside of the realms of TT games, but when I do these episodes get far fewer vies, and when people do watch it's only for like 1 or 2 minutes, and it's killing my retention numbers on Youtube.

My channel totally tanked in October! Views for almost all of the horror-related stuff were way down, and the amount of time people spent watching the videos completely tanked. I've had people tell me that they haven't received a single recommendation for the channel this whole month, when usually they do. So not sure what's going on.

I'm really struggling with how to shape the channel to keep myself engaged and viewers happy. I need to have an outlet for my other related hobbies, so I'm thinking of starting a second channel devoted to books / movies. Mutiple-topic channels always do worse on Youtube than single-topic focused channels.

Any thoughts on that?

Comments (19)

R
Richard Lance · October 23, 2022

I listen and watch stuff that I connect with which is boardgames for me. So I’m always watching and listening to gaming content. Saying that there has been times I’ve dipped into other non content that you’ve made Daniel. Just depends if it peaks my interest.

C
Christopher Zirk · October 22, 2022

I like the Hobbycast, but it doesn’t show up in my feed as much, so I tend to miss them. Whether you keep them on the main channel or move them to a new one, my response to hearing you say that they take a lot of time is to suggest a monthly or quarterly release schedule. That way you have time for research, etc.

J
Joe Johnson · October 22, 2022

I think one thing that might be hurting you is a lack of consistency across the Hobbycast. Most podcasts I listen to have a set format they follow, even if the topics go wildly off the beaten path. There are established segments that ground everything together. Even if the conversation goes in a direction you don't find interesting, you know it will veer back into the familiar elements you enjoy. The Hobbycast is just kind of whatever you feel like talking about that week. If someone finds it interesting, they will click. If it doesn't strike their fancy, there isn't much else meat on the bone to get them in the door. I'm sure your episodes on Asian cinema and horror novels are thoughtful, passionate, and well made. But, I don't know. That's not really why I came to the channel, you know? (Though paradoxically I loved when you talked about 80s anime and introduced me to Crusher Joe) Am I saying stop doing non-board game episodes? Heck no! Especially not if you're passionate about them. But maybe some recurring features across each episode will keep folks coming back. I'm certain you can cobble some together. "Recently announced Kickstarters that caught my eye." "Games on my table." "Single mechanics I wish more games would use." "New releases in board games." "Some awesome thing I discovered on Itch.io." etc.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 23, 2022

"The Hobbycast is just kind of whatever you feel like talking about that week. If someone finds it interesting, they will click. If it doesn't strike their fancy, there isn't much else meat on the bone to get them in the door. " Right. That was the whole point of it - to give me an outlet for the dozen or so other hobbies I spend time on. One thing I don't like is single-focused hobbies. I'm all about constantly connecting the dots between all of my hobbies. Finding the connections between Asian cinema, David Lynch, and RPGs - and there always is one that I talk about! It's really impossible for me to view one hobby in a vacuum, you know? That has always been the focus of the channel. One of my first big reviews for Dungeon Degenerates didn't even really talk about the game at all! LOL. But it's not working, that much is true. So a change will be coming. :)

C
Clint Trice · October 21, 2022

I listen to most of your YouTube videos multiple times. I prefer podcast format to video.

P
Perplexing Ruins · October 21, 2022

I dont tend to listen to podcasts, prefer visual...though could be interested in listening/watching less structured content, like informal musings, chats, etc, where you are not required to use so much time? would be quite interested in hearing more comparison over time stuff etc

T
Toriko · October 21, 2022

I voted "no" partly because I don't listen to podcasts. They aren't for me. Sorry! If I'm going to listen to something, it's music. I'm only saying this to point out: not everyone who watches videos listens to podcasts. It sounds wise to create a second channel. Hope you get everything back on track before too long.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 21, 2022

No need to be sorry! :)

J
Jonathan Franklin · October 21, 2022

I think you should follow your bliss - I voted No because I think by asking the question, you don't want to continue, but don't want to alienate your audience. If they are time consuming, not getting eyeballs, and you are trying to make a go of the channel as an economic success, do what is proven to get you the revenue you need without sacrificing your values.

M
Michael Lee · October 21, 2022

Connect to the board games. So if a board game fits a genre or franchise, explore it in-depth. This ties everything back to games.

G
Genghis Pawn · October 21, 2022

I'm voting "No, don't do them" even though I like them (and mainly watch them on YouTube) because I think you've already got the viewership/retention data you need -- i.e., the votes that count. You're reporting to us that they're not working, unfortunately, and so it's time to adapt. ("Something-something definition of insanity something-something"). I can't speak for everyone here, but I've pledged the funds I can for now to try to help buoy you through this "taking the channel full-time" period. The whole point is to help cushion trials/errors/choicepoints like this one as you negotiate what you can do that (a) you enjoy doing, (b) many others enjoy watching, and (c) attracts additional revenue/support. It sounds like the current level of effort and revenue is not sustainable -- so the path forward cannot be to keep the current number of Patrons happy by maintaining the way things are right now. If we all voted for you to keep them and you did so, it'd be a tyranny of the minority steering you in the wrong direction. The only feedback I feel like I can offer is just to pull the issues apart as you think through how to tackle them. The viewership on the Hobbycast is one issue, and it's not specific to October; whatever happened in October is another issue, and it sounds like it's not specific to the hobbycast. And having a multi-focussed channel presents difficulties, but if *all* your hobbycast videos feel like they're not worth the effort, then making a new channel and putting in all that same effort "over there" wouldn't really solve the problem. I don't think. I'm not a creator and I'm not you, so I can only riff here. You might try switching to a monthly schedule for hobbycasts and see how that feels/plays -- maybe you're just doing them too often and getting burned out. Or you could play with format: maybe mix hobbycast-style themes with interviews or roundtables so that they're less of a monologue, and see how that feels/plays -- maybe they'll get a better reception. I'm not saying that splitting the content across channels isn't still the way to go -- I know you've thought about that for a while -- but it sounds like there are more challenges surrounding the hobbycast than just where they live. Keep experimenting if there's something there you don't want to abandon, or just take a break if you need to.

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 21, 2022

"I'm voting "No, don't do them" even though I like them (and mainly watch them on YouTube) because I think you've already got the viewership/retention data you need -- i.e., the votes that count. You're reporting to us that they're not working, unfortunately, and so it's time to adapt. ("Something-something definition of insanity something-something"). I'm pretty much in agreement here, at least right now.

D
Duderino · October 21, 2022

Personally, I usually listen to the hobbycast podcast episodes on Saturdays. Saturdays are pretty mellow at work, so that's why I listen that day. Also, I mostly stream the hobby cast episodes on Spotify since there usually isn't video. I don't pay for a YouTube subscription, so I can't listen while my phone is in my pocket when streaming the episodes on YouTube. I enjoy most of them, but there are a few I haven't listened to because the topic didn't interest me to be completely honest.

W
WarWizard · October 21, 2022

Daniel, I think most creators find that to satisfy the Algorithm you need to fit well into the taxonomy and it def does not understand adjacencies like Fantasy/Horror or even Horror/SciFi much less Detective/Weird Western, etc... Your fantasy/dungeon content (and all your content) is fantastic, but it simply can't fit it into the right content bucket, hence the drop in promotion (because it has to match the Advertiser's profile that is sold based on that taxonomy). That means you are correct in thinking about having content-specific channels. So if you want to get specific genres of content out there, happy to share what I know, just DM me...

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 21, 2022

Agree - I think multiple channels will be the way to go.

J
John Berry · October 21, 2022

I’ve been consuming them, mostly off line but sometimes on YT. I would not like to see your main channel suffer so if it were up to me I would do them on a separate channel and let it grow organically

T
Tom Cohen · October 21, 2022

Daniel I really enjoy them, but I understand ur challenges with the YouTube algo etc. FWIW, your content is always a must watch / listen for me wherever I can find it - so I would definitely watch them if you were to start a second channel - if you are to continue them.

J
Jakob Zgela · October 21, 2022

Whatever you decide is great but I really enjoy the book, movie, and video game conversations that connect to the board game content

T
The Dungeon Dive · October 21, 2022

Jakob - on the main TT channel, there would definitely still be videos about games that also feature books because that's something that is SUPER important to me. Combined topic videos are still a must have for the Dungeon Dive.