💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 5, 2022

What are some of your least favorite things about dungeon crawl / adventure board games?

What are some of your least favorite things about dungeon crawl / adventure board games?

I'm curious what ya'll have to say. For this week's podcast.

Comments (17)

R
Raygun1966 · September 7, 2022

Having to search for loose charts takes me out of the game. I'm glad to see that most games now have booklets of some kind. I also dislike power creeping where characters and players are no longer challenged or apprehensive about jumping into a fray without consequences.

S
Seth Peterson · September 6, 2022

Walls of text. I like story, but I don't like my boardgame to have a novel attached to it. Arkham LCG i think hits the sweet spot for narrative.

T
The Dungeon Dive · September 6, 2022

Thanks everyone! Going to recording early tomorrow morning, and I’ll mention some of these.

R
Richard Lance · September 5, 2022

Some of my least favourite things are……..Searching a rule book for a specific rule. Which is why I like Fantasy Flight rule books. Set up time can be a pain, but it’s part and parcel for the games I like best, so I accept it. Last one on the list. Give me standees every time. Trying to find the right mini out of a big KS batch can be a pain. Plus the amount of space they take up now.

T
Toriko · September 5, 2022

Minis and campaigns. I understand the appeal, but I would have a load more DCs if it weren't for these two things.

T
Tom Cohen · September 5, 2022

I have a few least favorite things, 1. Assembling/painting minis, e.g. I have a ton of SoB minis to assemble, and NOT looking forward to putting those together at all - but am SO looking fwd to playing the game. lol. See #4 below. 2. Unnecessarily complicated/overwrought and unintuitive/disconnected comabt mechanisms. E.g. I know it's 90%+ of the game, but the Gloomhaven card play really annoys me in SO many ways. I find that puzzle gets 100% in the way of the fun for me. Plus, that no sharing gold rule - that also makes me angry. LOL. I know it can be house-ruled, but that is so antithetical to fun. 3. I have been let down by a lot of the promises of these games. What I am looking for is an adventure/dungeon crawler game that offers open-world adventuring with lots of smaller missions - without a scripted / on-rails narrative - that all fit into a larger broad/overarching story framework that each mission works towards telling/revealing in small bites. I know this leans way more RPG than board game. I think it would be more like what the SoB Hexcrawl sounds like it may offer? Or maybe the upcoming Dungeoneers with a larger interesting story framework that links all of the individual missions together in cool and interesting ways. It probably exists, but it has proven elusive to me up to this point. Also, see #4 below. 4. KS bloat - I don't want 4 Gloomhaven-sized boxes of content filled with plastic. Standees work great imo. Grrr. Get off my lawn. :-) lmao!

G
Genghis Pawn · September 5, 2022

Made a post and somehow it's gone now. Trying again. Re: Adventure games: There's often a mis-match between "gameplay coherence" and "narrative coherence." The progression of the game through phases/rounds up to the endgame often doesn't track with the progression of the narrative. A game might have a deck of questy/task/event cards and you spend ~5 rounds collecting them and resolving none, then the game sort of explodes into completing tasks for ~5 rounds, and then its over. And the quests/tasks/events might only rarely fit together neatly into an over-arching narrative (even if a creative storyteller might often be able to patch them together). The result is that a game might look epic and lavish, and might occasionally offer a grand adventure, but may not often feel that way in the playing of it. I think you've referred to it in terms of "seeding" the game. There don't seem to be a lot of games that successfully strike a balance between hyper-scripted campaigns (with perhaps more limited variation between playthroughs) and totally unstructured sandboxes.

J
John Yuh · September 5, 2022

My favorite dungeon crawlers are dungeon universalis and warhammer quest. Both requires a lot of time to play and set up. There is some unsolvable tension: shorter game do not provide a good feeling of exploration and epic adventures, while longer or more complex game are harder to put on the table. RPGs solved this by letting one person do 90% of the up front work, the game master. But I dont play RPGs, I dont really like playing a role and its too much discussion.

l
lew · September 5, 2022

Not enough interesting events and choices that don`t rely on combat to resolve. I love rolling lots of dice, so I rarely feel interested if that`s missing as feel dice add some drama. I do like it if the game allows you to mitigate those dice results. Poorly written rules and scenario books with pages of errata. Not enough proof reading, and playtesting with people new to the game who don`t already know all the rules off by heart.

B
Blue Botic · September 5, 2022

My least favorite thing about dungeon crawl adventure games is lack of actual adventure/exploration mechanics along with too much combat, too much grind. Also, complexity and bloat with little substantive gain. I often ask myself what I could rip out of a game without truly affecting it, or even enhancing it. I’d rather have 3 dials I can turn, each with a big results, than 20 dials with little impact. Games are getting bigger and bigger, but not better and better, in general. The grail for me is small, tight, thematic, immersive, and truly adventurous.

T
Turhan · September 5, 2022

Seconding this - I'd like a lot more non-combat confrontations in dungeon crawls as well.

A
Andi Lennon · September 5, 2022

The things I like are mostly focussed around a sense of setting. Something that enables the players to feel a genuine sense of exploration and discovery. When the aesthetics and lore work together with the mechanics to offer that rarest of beasts - true escapism. This is a kind of elusive and ephemeral quality that is difficult to pin down but I know it when I've encountered it. Anything that avoids the common tropes of vanilla high fantasy has a head start in this regard. What I don't like -aside from elements that others have mentioned (like bloat, component creep, fiddliness and set-up time) - is that very few DC/Adventure type games feel tactically or strategically rich enough. For me, min-maxing a characters attributes and abilities just doesn't cut it, especially if after all that work, the actual turn sequence essentially devolves into 'I move up to the monster and hit it'. I want difficult decisions and to feel like my choices matter.

S
Seung-Hyun Yoo · September 5, 2022

DCs have tendency of having messier rule books. Not sure why they are so badly written.

D
Dan Brazier · September 5, 2022

Fiddliness! Too many tokens and modifiers to track; that I'll no doubt forget. Looking at you Sword & Sorcery..

B
Brian Knouse · September 5, 2022

Crazy setup time and tear down time. Sometime half the battle is me mentally being in the mood to setup a huge game. Often times I setup a game that takes awhile and then I am not in the mood to play it.

J
James · September 5, 2022

I have a dedicated game table so I can set up games the day or week prior and then leave them set up as long as I want. I honestly don't think I would enjoy this hobby if I had to set up and tear down every time I wanted to play one of these huge games. I don't know how people that play on the kitchen or dining table manage, some of these games are just ridiculous in size.

T
Turhan · September 5, 2022

Two things; Rules and expansions bloat. A lot of rules get way too big for their own good, especially as more supplements and rules get released. Shadows of Brimstone seems fun but it is a monstrous undertaking to get a campaign in imo, even more than Gloomhaven. Second is that I'd like to see dungeon dives take more risks in mechanics. A lot of systems almost don't feel different enough to me and can seem a bit generic with just a different facing. I think it'd be cool to see more outside of the box mechanics.