💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
July 5, 2022

When the "better" game isn't the one I want to play

This is for an upcoming episode of the Hobbycast.

When the "better" games isn't the one I want to play

On my Ten Things I Love About Stars of Akarios video, a viewer asked me which game I would rather play - Stars of Akarios, or Deep Space D6 with the Long Way Home expansion. While these two games are polar opposites in terms of production, they do scratch similar space-opera itches; they are similar thematically. 

Personally, I would rather play Deep Space D6 because it simply fits into my life better these days.

Another viewer followed up with the following three questions:
Which of those 2 games is: 

- better designed?  

- more robust/diverse? 

- provides a greater feeling of a space combat and exploration?

The answer to those questions is probably Stars of Akarios. It is probably the better made game of the two, and yet it is not the one I want to play.

There are other games like this as well. Mage Knight is a "better" designed game than Runebound 2e; Gloomhaven is a "better" design game than Talisman. However, I'd much rather play Runebound and Talisman!

I know the term "better" is totally loaded and subjective. There are certain things many modern gamers look for in their games, things that make those games "better," and I totally recognize those things. I'm pretty sure I would argue that Gloomhaven is objectively a better designed game than Talisman. But the fact is, I just don't want to play it.

What are some "worse" games you'd rather play than some "better" ones?


Comments (16)

G
Genghis Pawn · July 7, 2022

I'll rant on this a bit. Preface: Daniel, you seem to be focused on cases where you "would rather play" a game that is (you say) objectively less-well designed, but is -- if I'm hearing you correctly -- easier to set up, or more bite-sized and coherent with your schedule/mood, or something along those lines. Generally: you would often rather play something a bit "lighter," is the vibe I'm getting. I don't think this basic issue is unique to boardgames. I'll offer an analogy below to a case I read about. One of my aims here is to suggest that it can go the other way, too: folks might also prefer to play games that are "heavier," even if they think they are *less* well-designed. It's not always that folks forgo good design for "lighter" games. A bunch of psychologists have studied how people (and by people, they largely mean batches of ~15-30 undergraduate students at private Universities in the US) think through graphics and diagrams, and they've come up with a bunch of prescriptions for how to design "better" graphics. But if you think about it, their prescriptions tell you how to design graphics for an audience of folks who have very little relevant, expert knowledge *IF* your goal is to have the audience extract information as rapidly as possible. That's what they objectively measure to determine what kinds of graphics are better: how well undergrads can extract information from the graphic. So their prescriptions are, largely, to keep things simple and clean, add legends and explanations, really highlight the "key info" and omit any "superfluous info", etc, But if you look at how successful graphics are made by experts for experts, they're often messy and difficult, can require lots of background knowledge to interpret, can take time to read, often contain lots of info (because you don't know in advance what your audience will think is key info and what they will think is superfluous), etc. It's not that the prescribed/simpler graphics aren't truly "better-designed" **as evaluated by a specific measure**, it's that the measure may not be the relevant one for you to choose if you're thinking about which graphic you prefer to make or to examine. Because maybe your audience isn't undergraduates; so maybe the relevant measure isn't "how easy is it to read this?" Analogously, it might make sense to suggest that "better-designed" games are (in part) better because they are easier to learn for a new player; maybe they are more modular designs, with clear delineations between rules/systems; maybe they are easier to remember and get back into the core of a turn-structure, etc. -- and maybe all that can indeed be measured objectively. Suppose it can. Still, if you're not a new player, if you're looking for a game that was made "by experts for experts," maybe that's all pretty boring, honestly. Maybe you want something messy and difficult sometimes that isn't so easy to pick up. More generally: I don't think the right contrast here is between the Objective and the Subjective. If you prefer to play shorter games, that doesn't mean you have to give up the objective side of things. Your preference is subjective, but the average length of a game can be objectively measured. A short game can be called "objectively better-designed" IF we assume that the design was intended to hit a specific sweet-spot for length-of-game, because the length of the game can be objectively measured. Now, why would you *want* to design for short length, and why would someone *prefer* a game like that? because of a preference. Any time anybody says a game is "objectively better designed" all they mean is "there is an objective measure I can use to determine that game X's design fits a specific design goal/preference better than game Y." Objective-talk is just being used sometimes as a way of hiding Subjective-talk. (Which is part of what can make the "FrOm a LoGicAl PoInT oF ViEw...." and "I'm JuST beEinG ObJecTivE" brand of gamer commentary so irritating.) To try to offer a bridge beteen my analogy and boardgames, think about something like Race for the Galaxy. There's a lot of iconography there that's a burden for new players to learn, but "expert" players can jump right in. Lehman has talked about this a bit -- though he thinks what's cognitively difficult here isn't entirely the iconograpy: https://youtu.be/JcyyeAww2wc?t=2084 Another example: see this Podcast about the component-minimal design of Radlands and how much thought went into its footprint on the table, starting at 50:46 https://nerdlikeaboss.com/077-the-design-of-radlands-with-daniel-piechnick/ someone might have a preference for small footprint games like this, or someone might prefer sprawling across whole tabletops. The preference is subjective, but we can measure the amount of space objectively.

G
Genghis Pawn · July 8, 2022

...aaaand yeah, that probably ended up too long. Sorry to clog the feed, will scale it back in the future ;)

R
Ryan J McLaren · July 6, 2022

The big equalizer for me tends to be rough edges—a highly desirable trait! Given two games on equal footing in terms of complexity/time/footprint, I'm almost always prone to favour the oddball because they are more likely to surprise or at least present moments (good or bad) at the table. I'll suffer inferior mechanisms if they foster better narratives.

T
The Dungeon Dive · July 6, 2022

Yes! Same here.

R
Richard Lance · July 5, 2022

Better doesn’t always mean fun. Lots of my games are not shining examples of game design. They have randomness, events which can’t be mitigated and dice. But if they are dripping with theme and are good fun….we’ll that’s just fine by me. I do tend to like the sprawling Dungeon crawl or adventure game. That sense of being part of a big epic adventure.

J
Jakob Zgela · July 5, 2022

So much goes into our taste and preference. With board and video games, music, art, books, food, you name it. History, prior exposure, previous engagement, sentiment, theme, mood, time of year, etc. love the question and discussion.

M
Michael Lee · July 5, 2022

Trying to define "best" game is like trying to define a "dungeon crawler." At first it seems easy, but what makes it a dungeon crawler? Before long you need to make almost arbitrary limitations, or you end-up with a LOT of games fitting the criteria.

T
The Dungeon Dive · July 5, 2022

Right. That's definitely part of the topic.

M
Michael Lee · July 5, 2022

There are apps to help you pick the "best" movie for you, right now. Sometimes it's Rambo, other times it's Deer Hunter. Both about returning Viet Nam vets, and VERY different movies. Maybe we need the same for board games. This probably already exists...

B
Brian Knouse · July 5, 2022

I always come down to, is the game fun for me. I will take fun gameplay over better production values any day! The game may be quirky or have some things I don't like but you can usually house rule any game and just have a blast with it. Some of those rougher games are my favorite games!

V
Viktor A. · July 5, 2022

To answer your question: I experienced this with my son and Mice & Mystics. I so wanted to play it with him, but he did not like it at all. A few weeks later, CoraQuest came in, and he wanted to play the hell out of it. Both games are similar in the general concepts, and I would say that M&M is definitely the better designed game - yet children love the easiness and artwork of CoraQuest. And yes, my son also loves Talisman, so far his favorite game - and he wants to create a Talisman clone himself "playing today in the real world". Let's see if he really works on it, probably in summer break... ;)

T
The Dungeon Dive · July 5, 2022

Perfect example!

D
Doug Cooley · July 5, 2022

The “better” game is the one you want to play. We forget how subjective art is, and gaming is a space that is largely art, including the actual playing bit. Like performing a Beethoven sonata, the pianist’s own experiences and preferences combine with the composer’s. It may be a lesser “regarded” sonata by those who want to be the keepers of truth, but it’s really time-based sound created from incomplete static information and only is “better” in the sense that someone studied musicology and wanted to look like it was worth the time and effort to get the degree by claiming one has a “superior” use of quartal harmony or some such. Games are no different. We play them like we play composed music, starting with a static foundation and then dancing above it. We should dance like no one is watching.

T
The Dungeon Dive · July 5, 2022

While I agree sometimes, objectively Talisman is a worst designed game than Mage Knight. Roll and move, 90% luck, player elimination, etc....these are all things that have been designed out of games, and rightfully so.

V
Viktor A. · July 5, 2022

I think the main difference for most of these games is, that they are kind of easier for the mind to play. After a long day working, it might be easier to just roll a die and do what you are told in Talisman than playing a puzzling game of Gloomhaven. Still, all of these games have their right to exist, and it is totally fine if people like one or the other - or even both!

G
Gankatron · July 5, 2022

It really depends upon my focus and energy level, both of which are interrelated. For instance, while I will purchase an interesting looking FPS earlier in the day, by the time evening rolls around and I have the time to play, I will more likely go to a familiar turn-based game that requires less energy output on my part. That being said, making time to play board games is more difficult for me than just sitting down and clicking on something in my Steam library, so I actually am far more likely to build a social event around a more involved/"better" board game in a genre.