This makes me so mad.
Comments (14)
I took the stuff out and bagged it. In doing so I noticed that the box is actually slightly bigger than my Roll Player big box that holds the base game and both expansions. Aka hundreds of cards, a giant bag of dice, player mats, etc.
The only thing worse than that is this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZerJuQPFdgs utterly barbaric. I have spare chipboard I could use to make my own little folding inserts and divvy up box space for multiple games, but I have yet to find a way of re-branding the outsides of boxes that's not awful looking.
Was looking forward to this game, but sold it off shortly after receiving it. Shelf space is an absolute premium on our tiny house, so there was just no way.
I actually put this aside after receiving it because I was annoyed at the fact that this tiny game will take up half a shelf as well as the giant format, frustrating (to me anyway) instructions. I’ll come back to it after the dungeon dive video hopefully showing off a little gameplay. I am glad to see in the comments that the box size and insert are likely due to a lack of experience and not the designers thinking their game is so amazing it should take up four times the space necessary. Should have been in an Iron Helm sized box. I’ll have to find an alternative which is too bad because the art is great.
My enthusiasm for the game has dropped about 80%.
As a general rule: me too. There are a couple of caveats in this case, though. This was a first time designer who I recall had to change their box size to fit a stretch goal insert, which ended up being bigger than they expected. The intent was to allow for sleeved cards and expansions to fit, but I got the impression that the designer was a bit surprised at how large it was all going to be. There might have been some limitations regarding the publisher's available box sizes too. The funniest part is the rulebook, which is the same width and length as the box. It's just enormous, and the way it is laid out suggests it wasn't orignially intended to be that large but got expanded so it didn't slide around in the box. I'd chalk this situation down to inexperience and trying to coordinate the sizes of different components.
SO MUCH empty space in the rule book. This really is a complete disaster of a production.
People making elaborate card games need to start paying attention to companies like (for example) Greater Than Games. Their recent definitive edition of Sentinels of the Multiverse felt economical and luxurious at the same time. 100% pulp.
weird
While I actually appreciate extra space in a box that is planning expansions, and dislike an absolutely tight box designed for non-sleeved cards, it seems in this case virtually every step was inefficiently designed. I'll assume the poor foreplaning was due to inexperience. Cautionary tales do have value.
If you think that’s bad, I once paid $60 for the Pearlbrooke expansion to Everdell at retail, and got a box with an empty form for several minis that came with the KS, a few bits (mostly little plastic pearls), and less than 50 cards. I won’t buy anything from them ever again, the expansion should have been $25 and in a considerably smaller box. I considered this outright fraud, to be honest. Great game, clueless or greedy publisher. I think it’s almost always better to get a third party storage solution, and if you have a 3d printer, even better (or use one at your local library).
My understanding is that the insert was designed by an engineer as a side project, and then subsequently had to be modified during production due to manufacturing restrictions. I guess that as a consequence the insert, box size, etc most likely represents inexperience followed by a series of compromises with the manufacturer to get things done.
Wow.
TBH the layout of the insert doesn't even make much sense as far as storage- unless expansions are planned.
