Thoughts on AI Art - an outline / thoughts for a video
Hey all! I think it's time for me to make a video addressing the use of AI art in games. I've seen enough questions / comments about it in previous videos, and I want to make sure my thoughts are known before I inadvertently praise something that I had no idea was made using AI things. It's bound to happen, and it might have already happened.
I think my take is nuanced, and it might rub some people the wrong way simply because I am not 100% against the use of AI in the creative process, however I am 100% FOR artists and creators getting paid and thriving with their craft.
With that said, I wanted to run my outline by all of you, because I value your input.
This is not for grammar / writing review - this is simply an outline I might use to discuss the topic.
********
Thoughts on AI art
I know it’s not actually “Artificial Intelligence.” But I will use this phrase throughout.
Addressing this topic because I see more and more questions / comments about “is that AI? Did this use AI?” and so on.
I don’t have the time, nor frankly the desire, to research every game I cover to make sure that no AI at all was used at all in writing / art. I barely have enough time to do what I’m doing now, and adding that kind of researching task on top of that is not something I am interested in doing.
And to what extent do I look?
Photoshop – other manipulating software that uses AI? Spell checkers? Grammer checkers? Grammerly? Suggested sentences from clippy? How far do I go in the research process – it would add hours to the pre-production of every video, and would require honest access to every creator, and that's something I cannot rely on.
I will also not be participating in the AI witch hunts. I’ve already seen this on toxic facebook groups – an artist is accused of using AI and then they have to defend themselves by showing their sketch books and WIPs – without any proof at all.
A lot of modern digital art looks AI because the AI process is using those as part of its thing.
It also just so happens to happen to minority creators more for some reason…I have a feeling that the ETHICS IN GAMES JOURNALISM people are using this tactic as another way to attack women and POC in the industry (both times I saw it happen were in connection with the new D&D books, and the anti-AI crowd was also complaining about the art being "woke" ).
Policing the use of AI is not the role nor the point of the Dungeon Dive, and I know for a fact that at some point I will inadvertently cover and maybe even love something that used AI in the creative process.
That is absolutely something that is going to happen.
Not because I want to, but because the technology will improve so much that it will become impossible to tell unless the creator specifically states it.
I will not deny myself a useful tool just because it used AI in the creation process.
Mythos tool as an example.
AI as a tool for the disabled – losing your ability to illustrate doesn’t destroy your desire to create.
If I lost my ability to use my hands to create music, I would not lose my desire to, and I would definitely seek out alternative ways to create audio art.
My favorite board game artist of all time lost his ability to illustrate because of a medical condition. He started dabbling in generative art to help satisfy his desire to create visual things.
Art assets are very expensive – the single most expensive part of game design from what I’ve been told by designers. Can cost many hundreds of dollars per unique image.
What is an indie designer who can’t afford art supposed to do? What about someone just making a little project to put out there?
Artists getting paid before designers because they get paid up front. I know of a couple of indie projects where the artists got paid and the designer did not – Designer actually lost money once the product went to market.
I’d prefer it if all parties associated with the development of a project get paid! I want the things I enjoy to be financially successful so that more things that I enjoy are created.
Using art asset packages – the same art gets used for multiple games (League of Dungeoneers and 4AD)
Using art by dead people – the same art gets used for multiple games (Mork Born things)
If AI is used, be honest about it – be clear about it – don’t hide it
Plunderphonics – uncleared samples in music. Generative music software employed by artists like Brian Eno. Collage art. There are legit forms of art that use derivative means to create.
THIS is super important:
Ultimately - I want all creators to be honest and clear about how / what was used if any AI was used so that the customers can make their decisions.
I wish there was a way to list the things used in the generative process – a clear list of samples and influences. What work by what artists were used? What prompts were used? Could create a reference document using meta data.
I will always prefer and praise human created things – it’s so stupid that I even have to say that! however, I know there will come a time when I praise something and it ends up being AI assisted. That is going to happen. It might have already happened.
I am, however, not going to say things like AI art is soulless, because people said the exact same thing about synth based music and electronic music, and we all know that’s total BS. Human’s have made incredibly moving music using electronic things and samples, just like there will probably be human’s who make moving things with assistance from AI.
It can be a tool to be used like any kind of technology.
But there needs to be a system in place to control it – artists should have a say in their art being used to train machines / AI.
Regulation is important.
I want people to get fairly compensated for their work – in all industries. And I vote and take actions to make sure that happens. I support unions, union workers, and want not a living wage for all, but a thriving wage. And these are not “leftist” ideas. These are humanist ideas – these are the ideas that make countries and industries and, most importantly, PEOPLE thrive.
I want artists to thrive.
AI art as stolen / IP theft
I am a HUGE proponent of paying for the things we like. I still buy albums (digitally). I buy 90% of my TT games (some games sent to me to cover). I buy ALL of my video games and movies. I spend 30+ hours a week covering games that I like, and a lot of them are from small designers, and I don’t charge them for it – never will. I never take financial compensation for my coverage.
I used to pirate stuff in my 20s and 30s. But I don’t any more, and I don’t like that I did. It’s easy to make excuses – I couldn’t afford it, pirating was easier, corporations suck etc., but the fact of the matter is I deprived an artist of their fair compensation for something I enjoyed.
Financially supporting the art we love and the artists who make it is crucial – it tells the creators and the producers what we want, and that we are willing to pay for it. I say all this to encourage you to do the same, and to point out one glaring hypocrisy I’ve seen from some of the Anti AI people I am acquainted with – I know for a fact that at lest some of them have no issues at all pirating movies, music, books, and videos games, all while preaching about how unethical and terrible AI generated art is.
To me, that’s a little weird.
Comments (20)
great article. 👍🏻
I make art from my books by paying for photographs and using Photoshop filters and actions that I also pay for. So some kind of AI is used in those actions. Just as I buy audio FX that alter the samples I buy, record or perform.
Thanks for mentioning that women and BIPOC artists have been targeted.
AI art looks completely irrelevant to me. I'm not talking about the money/job destuction aspect. I just find AI art definitely uninspiring and NOT fascinating. It's mostly generic page-filler I'd rather do without. Nonetheless, I acknowledge this is but the final, decisive step towards generic blandness. For decades, we've been able to immediately spot and appreciate the work of a number of artists. In the last 10 years or so... not as much!
A product with AI art is better than no product at all. But any project is always best served by human involvement. Appropriate attribution is important -- that is, a declaration that AI was used. But this line will start to blur as many digital-artists use AI and AI adjacent tooling even without knowing. Many heated debates in this area stem from an incomplete understanding of how AI-generated images are created. For example, in AI-generated art, attribution to specific human artists is not technically possible because AI doesn’t directly copy individual works -- it learns from patterns across vast datasets. As a result, direct compensation becomes challenging. AI raises all kinds of ethical conundrums in many fields of human endeavour -- not just the art community. I wrote an approachable and neutral article on how AI-generated art works for any that might be interested: https://www.fullasagoog.com/t/do-ais-dream-of-artistic-masterpieces/44
Thanks for that article!
Argh.. wish this post was on dungeondive.quest - hard to have a conversation here.
Thought about it, wanted this more for feedback rather than discussion.
We have been suffering of the narrowing of the horizon of human cultural creativity for decades now, and AI art is the next inevitable step on that road (and possibly the most significant). We humans draw from what we see in the collective cultural consciousness, and then because our analyses are individual and flawed, we inject novelty back into that collective consciousness. In this way, our creative output is both derivative and innovative, and it is an ecosystem of sorts. Market based economies by their very nature financially reward art with the broadest appeal. The consequence of this is that truly novel, subversive, or avant garde creative output generally sees a smaller exposure than mass art. The market is why we get Marvel sequels, and this has a similar narrowing effect on the breadth of inspiration that creative people are exposed to. Mark Fisher talks about this in Capitalist Realism (based on Frederic Jameson's concepts). The inevitable fact is that AI art will be cheaper than creatives, and will shrink the available job pool for those people. It will also not ever create anything novel, because it can't suffer from the same inconsistencies/traumas/inspirations/etc that humans do. It means that the general creative media that our culture is exposed to will be increasingly derivative, and it will be generally moving in a more homogenous and stale direction. This is bad for the development of new creative people, because they will have a vastly larger quantity of worse art to be influenced by. The thing the AI discourse generally misses online is that this is not a solvable problem through "ethical" consumption of non-AI art. It's coming and there is nothing that is going to stop it, so what we have to do as creative people is think about how we are going to subvert this new market movement. It doesn't matter how mad people are at WoTC over AI art, WoTC will do it, and their products will sell until they quit resonating with the culture. This seems similar to me as the rise of photoshop as a painting medium. The upside is that the barrier to entry for aspiring artists is dramatically lowered. The time, materials cost, etc are all far lower for digital painting. The downside is that sometimes it's the physical inconveniences and permanence of mistakes that actually bring the "soul" to art. I already think most digital art is inferior to physical media, and AI will continue that trend toward increasing blandness in my opinion. There will always be people that buck the trends or are truly innovative with their art, and AI won't stop that. I think the main concern I have will be if I'm able to find it when I have to sift through endless seas of blandness to find it. I suspect that the complete removal of the bar to entry for creating art is not necesarily a good thing.
The bloat of crap this is being created and that will be created is a very real issue - I should also mention that. Thank you.
If you all would like a brilliant example of the plunderphonics genre of experimental music, I highly recommend I Can Fly, by People Like Us. https://peoplelikeus-vickibennett.bandcamp.com/album/i-can-fly
Thanks for posting this! You lay out some great points, perspectives and considerations. I really appreciate that. Your calling for transparency is significant. Just like in other consumables, consumers should know whats involved, and yet it is usually very difficult to know. Like much other tech, it will get abused and be exploitative. I think more open calls for embracing individual art and expression would be wonderful to see! I think much population feels compelled to make a certain style, which often gets lumped into a certain digital/AI style or aesthetic. Cheers
Do you think transparency is the best possible outcome we can hope for at this point?
Definitely with you on that overall. I will definitely continue to use Nathan Park and Jes Cole in my games to create the art. We have an established process and more or less fixed prices. However, searching for new artists is a real pain! Until you find someone that you like, that is affordable and matches you in general just takes a lot of tries and time and money. So I totally get it to resort to AI tools - they are just quicker, easier and you mostly get what you asked for. Yes, I would love if the tools would spit out sonething like "used the following art in creazing this piece" or some other way of knowing. But most likely this will never happen, and as much as people say this is outright theft, this is from a law perspective much more nuanced and not as easy - otherwise this legal issue would already be finished and clear... I personally live to use it as a creative process. Let it generate things for me, just to see what is possible. And then I can decide the direction I really want from an artist. Some people get already destroyed for using AI tools for prototypes. Sorry, but would it be better to simply copy an image from google? To simply use a known artist picture? Totally fine in my eyes whatever you do - that is a PROTOTYPE and in the end, it will get replaced with real art. If the projects get funded in some way. What I really don't like are these witch hunts. All is bad, people are evil for using it. This is not how the world works, there is a lot more grey areas - like you mentioned, with Sean or people that really cannot afford it but still want a nice looking free game. Why not!?! Earning money with though is a bit of a stretch and I understand that. At least until the lawyers are finished and the first precedence cases are done. Then we will know for one or the other way, if it is at least legally ok. Even if still not morally. But even that sometimes is a grey area in my view - you can also get a cheaper artist from low cost countries or fiverr or similar - who might simply copy a style that you like. How is that different than AI art? Some say it is different, some say it is not. But as soon as there is an AI that can really simply draw better than humans because it learned by LOOKING at art (and there WILL be something like that coming) - where is the difference to a human doing the same and learning to draw? I know it is not yet, but it will come to that level.
I think it's a perfect tool for prototyping, and I should mentioned that.
on the topic of: "AI art as stolen / IP theft" a while back the OpenAI chief technical officer was interviewed and asked point blank if she knew where they got their data. her response was that they use licensed data (okay, fine) and "publicly available data" (oof). so basically, they use whatever is on the internet, whether it's facebook photos or youtube videos or whatever. in other words, she tacitly admitted that they are stealing creators' data without permission. not something you want to hear from a CTO. (and what made it worse is her facial expressions gave away the game -- she knows what they are doing is unethical, if not illegal.) as someone who works in software and who also has a lot of friends in creative arts fields, this topic hits very close to home. i think like you, Daniel, and many other DD folks, my take is nuanced, but at the end of the day i want creators to maintain ownership of their creations. i definitely appreciate how impressive AI is as a creation-assistance tool, and i love that it helps people create new art... but the way data is being harvested currently is so wildly unethical, it almost feels like digital manifest destiny. anyway. all your topics / points sound great to me, and your concerns are valid imo. looking forward to the video for sure. thanks for taking the time to address the topic!
Was trying to formulate a reply and this hit on most of what I had in mind. We've already failed to do much to regulate the use of "publicly available data" and have been bopping along without compensating those of us (i.e., all of us) who have contributed in some way to everything that makes use of it. It all comes into clearer focus when an artist who was intentionally working to create XYZ has it ripped off, but that just puts them in a place of honor aboard the leaky boat. Hard to say much more without falling into "leftist slogans" that... seem apt.
This gets philosophically complicated for games like Story of Many that used world and story generation tools to generate quests. Do they owe Matt Finch writing credit and payment for his contributions? I think not. Sci-fi and fantasy are particularly trope-y. Tropes are story building blocks. They are susceptible to AI because of their very nature. Digital art has tropes/styles/effects as well. There's a set of digital effects adopted by WotC artists, -something like concept art that's become almost a brand. But I've seen a lot of board games pick-up that set of effects as well. I wouldn't be surprised if WotC fed the whole catalogue to an AI, and fired all but a couple staff artists to remix tropes with AI and Procreate/Photoshop. I'm not saying I have answers, I just think it's far too nuanced of a topic to take a dogmatic stance.
That's exactly why I can't take the 100% against stance.
Absolutely fantastic post, David. I agree wholeheartedly.
