💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
The Eye of the Beholder (1 of 6)
The Eye of the Beholder (2 of 6)
The Eye of the Beholder (3 of 6)
The Eye of the Beholder (4 of 6)
The Eye of the Beholder (5 of 6)
The Eye of the Beholder (6 of 6)
September 3, 2024

The Eye of the Beholder

Before I get into this brief topic, a quick update on the Ironsworn giveaway. Last week my wife was super busy, and then she went out of town for 4 days, so she hasn't had the chance to read the prompts yet. She will this week, and I'll announce the winner after that.

But now onto a topic on which I am sure everyone will agree with everyone and there won't be any arguing at all - art!

No one ever disagrees about art!

I've been working on putting together my Top 10 list of the games with the best art, and let me tell you....it's been an arduous task.  There are so many amazing artists out there, and so many games with so much great art! I look at my shelves and they're overflowing with great looking games.

And there are SO MANY styles. It's almost silly to compare The Gloom of Kilforth -

to Escape the Dark Castle-

 but I like the art in both of these games. Could there be a bigger difference in styles?

There is also the powerful draw of nostalgia. My love of nostalgia has been well documented on the Dungeon Dive, and one of the most powerful forces driving that nostalgia is the art. I am, of course, specifically thinking of artists like Gary Chalk, and other artists who worked on those earlier Games Workshop games. It's very hard to divorce my feelings on the art from my feelings of how the art makes me long for days when my life was simpler.

And then there are the very modern styles like the art found in the Arkham files games, which, IMO, constitutes one of the best libraries of art assets ever compiled. The draw here isn't nostalgia, it's more of a pure visceral reaction.

But still, there is that pesky thing called subjectivity. Is a top 10 games with the best art even a topic worthy of devoting time to? I mean, the art in a game feels like it's exponentially the single most subjective element of a game!

As much as I love the art in Dungeon Degenerates, there are people that absolutely hate it. And I get that opinion. This game provokes strong opinions at polar opposite ends of the spectrum. I think it's the best looking game ever made, and I know people who say it physically makes them sick. We're both being hyperbolic here, but still...it's the perfect example of what I'm talking about.

So I am curious. What do you all look for in a game when you say a game has "good art?" Are you looking for something bold and unique? Are you looking for something classical and iconic? Do you prefer bright colors or black & white? A sketchy or painterly style? Something a little sexy? Perhaps you prefer gruesome. Maybe you like sexy and gruesome combine, in which case there is Kingdom Death Monster!

I think for me, when I'm looking at a game's art, I want the art to help embolden the theme, setting, and overall vibe of the game, and that can be accomplished in a huge number of ways.

But I'm curious about what you all think. What are some of your favorites?

 

Comments (15)

J
Joe Fell · September 7, 2024

I don't think I really got into fantasy art in games until I saw Bill Willingham's art in D&D. That drew me in more as I loved his art style. But Larry Elmore is such a classic as well. I love comic books so if it's got comic art then I'm drawn in immediately. But I also love the art in games like Tanares Adventures and Chronicles of Drunagor. I remember when I started reading the Lone Wolf series as a teenager and loving the gritty pen and ink art in those books as well.

C
Crazy Volucris · September 6, 2024

wohoo, well that's a real topic😆 and i am very curious how you handle it... i guess it's nothing more personal than the "taste" of Art... and i recognizes that it's (for me) a very important... so it should underline the feel of the game and support it's "narrative" in the best way it could. And for me there is no preferred "Style/ Art" everything got it's place to shine.

J
John Boatofcar Shawler · September 3, 2024

I am one of those people where I won’t buy a game just because I like the art, but I definitely won’t buy a game because I hate the art. Dungeon Degenerates, Mork Borg, and some others just turn me off completely no matter how good those games may be!

T
The Dungeon Dive · September 5, 2024

The aesthetic appeal of something is super important.

S
Shieldice Studio · September 3, 2024

Such a fantastic topic, and an impossible task haha! The spectrum of styles is almost infinite, it seems, but my go to is anything that gives me a Sword & Sorcery or old-school fantasy vibe. I think nostalgia usually drives my tastes. If it reminds me of the pictures in a favourite childhood game-book, or the cover of a 90s PC game I was fond of, I'm in. Occasionally, however, that more modern, digital 'concept art' style seems to grab me too when used correctly. For example, I've got all of the Symbaroum books, but I've never properly played in that world. Also, an art style not usually to my taste, but used in a way that gives the game a unique personality (such as the Root board game and RPG), can also hook me. In other words... I have no idea 😂 If it feels right, it feels right. I'd say the only style I always avoid is straight up, unedited stock photography of knights or cyberpunk cosplay etc., some of which are awesome photographs, but it just doesn't get me in the correct headspace for play and immersion. I suppose, as a favourite style in general, I'd say anything in the realm, in between, or even remotely close to Michael Whelan and Bernie Wrightson. Those are two very big pairs of shoes to fill though! 😂 🎨

T
The Dungeon Dive · September 5, 2024

Hard to beat Whelan and Wrightson!

C
Christopher Zirk · September 3, 2024

There are fan made print & play games that I just can’t play because they typically have little to no art, and don’t draw me in. I need the art to establish a sense of place & atmosphere that I want to be in.

W
Wrycon · September 3, 2024

This question made me think of the game The Others: 7 Sins and Adrian Smith’s art - particularly the piece of the Hellraiser bondage deviants lounging in a room together. I don’t know much about the game - heard it was ok - but my desire to own it is very highly fueled by the art.

C
Craig Price · September 3, 2024

Shawn, I absolutely love Van Gogh! And that’s the beauty of art! It’s subjective. Remember, at the time everyone hated Van Gogh. He never sold a picture in his lifetime(Maybe one) but… Put it next to some of the other masterpieces of the day and it sticks out! It’s bold, it’s refreshing. Just like Degenerates is in a land very similar Dungeon Crawlers, Degenerates is the Van Gogh! I can’t wait for another game as bold and exciting and there nothing on the horizon that I know if that’s doing anything new. I hope I’m proved wrong😊

C
Craig Price · September 3, 2024

An impossible question but a really interesting one. There are so so many beautiful games, amazing artists, from amazing oil painted cards and boards beautifully, intricate works of art to simple pixel style games where a few well placed blocks can create as much character as the most complex fantasy art. So, I always look for originality. Since this is the dungeon dive I think by far my favourite looking game is Dungeon Degenerates.Thats not to say that Everdale or Wingspan aren’t beautiful, but exciting looking games for me are original, a touch weird maybe, somthing breaking the mold of its theme. I follow so many crawler games and artists and Noones doing anything exciting, nothing has captured me like Dungeon Degenerates did! I think that game should push all artists to try new things. It’s certainly inspired me to try new things.

T
The Dungeon Dive · September 3, 2024

I totally agree.

G
Genghis Pawn · September 3, 2024

Aw man, I'm supposed to be working :D I'm going to riff on some stuff and probably fail to answer the intended question (humanities degree FTW) and it will get long, so to avoid clogging the feed I am going to eventually post it all as a reply to this comment I'm writing here.

G
Genghis Pawn · September 3, 2024

1) It might be interesting to package a video as less a "top 10" of games with "the best" art and more a "10 examples of when art does something cool (for me)" or something like that. You could then explore "cool things" art can do in/with games (which is still subjective as all get-out) without feeling like they're competing. Thematizing different ways that art can interact with and "add value" to gameplay seems a worthy goal (and if the algorithm wants to see "Top 10" in the title, well, the first words out of your mouth in the video could be used to largely disown that). Put another way: what counts as good art in a game (for you) depends in part on how you're trying to play. 2) Thinking about how art impacts me when I play games, I am initially inclined to distinguish four broad cases, some of which may overlap. 2a) "I feel that the art is foundational for or constitutive of play." - These are mainly cases where you want to say "This game without this art would not be this game" or where the idea of a re-skinned second edition seems like sacrilege. I think I'm most likely to feel this way when the art is foundational for the world-building/lore and atmosphere of a game that is narrative-driven (such that I am playing as a character in that world) and the rules are built around that. Sleeping Gods might be an example, for me. Dungeon Degenerates seems like a candidate; DD without Sean's art would not be DD. - A different kind of case: I am fascinated by games (like Dark Venture and Civitas Nihilium) that are a unified design produced by one designer, so that whether I am reading the rules or manipulating the mechanisms or admiring the art, all of that can ve a form of "play" that engages with one designer's vision. These games need not be played that way, but some games afford it. (Tight-knit design teams might afford something similar, in addition to 1-person designers.) 2b) "I feel that the art enhances or complements play." Here again, games where the art supports worldbuilding/narrativity are central -- and FWIW, I would include solid flavor text as "Art" in this discussion, not just graphics/illustration. A re-skinned version of Arkham Horror with the color palette of Spacers would detract from the theme and damage the game, I think. But a new edition/printing of Arkham Horror could easily integrate new, thematically apt art and it might even be an improvement. The art enhances the game but the game could survive with different art. Many Gamebooks might fall in here, where illustrations are sparse or the prose is a little clunky. 2c) "The art is there, and I may enjoy it or may not, but I do not feel that it is truly integrated with play." This is the home of many a Dry Euro -- and even many a Charming Euro. These games might afford fun play that is more mechanical, but they likely afford less interesting narrative play. EDIT: This is also where I would put edge cases where I want to collect a game for its great art even if I never play it. 2d) "I am turned off by the art and/or feel that it contradicts or detracts from play." - Me personally, I am not terribly thrilled with cartoon animals and pass on a lot of games if they rely on that "palette" for their worldbuilding. That's wholly subjective, of course, I just feel that there is a bit of an overt attempt at mass-market appeal that seems out of place with many games and/or the way I would like to play them. This is a case where I rely on the art to anticipate play and I am steered away (perhaps wrongly). - But this can also go the other way, where I (try to) play a game and then wind up re-assessing the art. An relevant case here (I'll name names) is something like Dungeons of Draggmar. I actually like the art from that studio at first glance, but once I find that the game is a broken mess I am forced to re-assess that the quality of the art is essentially a misleading marketing ploy, and I wind up ret-conning my admiration and finding the whole thing distasteful.

O
Order of the Black Oath · September 3, 2024

That's such a difficult subject! For starters, I think I can appreciate good art, without having to be necessarily the style I enjoy (kind of how I can appreciate jazz as a musician but you'll not catch me listening to it dead). I personally dislike any cute and "fun" art, and even if a game has rules that I think I'll enjoy, I just can't bring myself to buy it if I don't like the art. Some art I'm more neutral about, and I can simply ignore. And other... well, let's just say that I have a lot of games I just buy cause I loved how it looked, like all the UVG stuff, haha.

G
Genghis Pawn · September 3, 2024

^The last point here is a valuable one, I think: someone might feel that a game's art is great and very collectible even if they barely engage with the game as a game (much like collecting v reading books are 2 different things, as you often note). One big question is whether that kind of game art appreciation is what you intend to cover in a vid.