Should I continue with the Arkham Horror Retrospective series?
I need brutal honesty.
Even though I tempered my expectations, the reception to the first episode of the Arkham Horror Retrospective has left me totally deflated. I put so much work into this thing, and it's in the top 5 lowest performing videos of the last few years.
For context, at the low end of the spectrum, my poorly performing videos are usually at about 1.9k views by now. This episode is at 1.1k views, and I put exponentially more time and effort into it. I even re-did everything except the interview twice because I wasn't happy with the results the first time! Probably sunk like 40 hours into this thing already.
I am a firm believer in quitting early and quitting often if things aren't working out.
I don't want to devote a year of my life to something that people aren't interested in.
So, should I continue with the series? It really is all up to you guys! I value what you have to say, and want to provide things you're interested in.
I'll be bummed if people don't want to watch it because it's something I've wanted to do since the beginning of the channel, but I'd rather know now than continue with a project that holds little interest for people.
Thank you!
Comments (86)
Thanks for all of your amazing comments! I really do appreciate it.
I'm late to weigh in, but for what it is worth: I have never had interest in the Cthulu-verse, nor in Arkham horror the game in any iteration. (I prefer my fantasy in a medieval setting). Yet I watched the entire first video and was fascinated. The interview was great, and the retrospective on the fiction was fascinating. Great work. In retrospect, I think you might have done better splitting it up. People might have been put off by the length. Total length is seen in the thumbnail, and this first installment was a whopping 2:20. I'd bet that some people assumed the creator interview itself was that long. I'd have cut it in half. PS: the content was so good it made me, for the first time ever, contemplate getting one of the Arkham Horror games!
Hey Daniel. This may not be helpful but I kind of watch your channel because I think you’re a very personable and genuine person. Keep to the content of doing videos that YOU enjoy doing if that is at all financially viable. I may not be into Arkham horror now but I might be down the track. I’ve watched your videos that are 2 years old that I find particular interest only now. Your channel become the one I search for specific games before I search wider! Piece and love 🤜🤛
Thank you!
Hi, Daniel! In my opinion, the content is tops and maybe the views slowdown it's related with the summer season, people going in holidays, etc. At my workplace, we slow down our publications in social media and everywhere else because of that. Also, we hold the new big content for premiere it on September when most of the audience go back to their daily routines. I think that content that you already posted would end getting views on the long run. As an opinion, maybe breaking the super edit down in smaller episodes would work better maybe? You already have the chapters on the first video (intro+interview then books+first edition). I hope that some of this feedback helps you and cheer up!
Thanks, David. Appreciate it.
I’m gonna check it out later on and get back to ya. I’m not as into the Lovecraft stuff as the Fantasy. (esp Dark Fantasy)
I haven’t watched it yet because I’ve been in production with a few commercials right now, but looking forward to it hopefully tomorrow! I’ll be sure and spread the word to some of my friends I know would be interested as well. I definitely appreciate the hard work and dedication you put into your content!
Hope your productions go well!
I'm sorry to hear that the video didn't perform well Daniel. I can tell you that I personally really enjoyed the episode. Your interview with Richard Launius was excellent and the book recommendations and mythos history were really cool. I grabbed a couple of the books from your list today. Another factor to consider is that yesterday was a hell of news cycle. It's possible that also affected things.
Haha. Yeah. News cycles have been insane lately. Maybe I need to start a politics channel? Yuk!;)
On the main, I frequent Youtube for board game news and reviews, lofi beats and some long format interviews... and yet i'm inundated with caitlin clark basketball videos and women doing yoga poses. YouTube is a fickle cesspit of clickbait doom scrolling and digital pervulsions. While as a niche content provider you have to use the platform for distribution, I'd recommend looking to alternative revenue streams. Forget the view counts and focus on the subscriber numbers and patreon conversions. Strongly suggest you restore a higher patreon tier that offers nothing more than an opportunity for those of us with disposable incomes to support your pursuit of the content you want to create rather than content you feel coerced to create. The Dungeon Dive is **excellent** and very much appreciated!
Specifically on the arkham series.. might have been better to isolate the interview and bill it as just a general game designer interview, listing all the games Richard has been involved in. Concatenating the Arkham 1E review and mythos overview muddies the water, and reduces your potential audience. Better for this to be its own video that refers people to the interview.. maybe even quotes from the interview. I suspect getting access to and interviewing dungeon-plunging game designers is a part of your unique talent stack. You should draw upon those powers more often!
I will rarely watch a video upon initial release. My life is busy, and I will definitely watch when i have time. Arkham horror is a game I’ve always wanted, so a deep dive is amazing. I joined your patreon because of your shadows of brimstone deep dive. Keep up the great work!
I think maybe such a lengthy deep dive on AH is a bit too niche? It's a reasonably popular game and setting, but while I had some passing interest I don't have enough of a connection with it to sit down and listen for 2 hours. I can only speak for myself, though, and I admire your passion for stuff like this!
Could be! Thanks. :)
I'm very much just a sample size of 1, but I've been looking forward to this series since you started talking about it. I haven't got around to watching it because it's quite a long one and I actually want to make the time to give it my full attention, whereas with a lot of your other videos it's something I put on in the background while I work or play video games. Also, while I don't personally fit that description, I think a lot of people prefer to watch videos about games they either play or are interested in buying/playing, so it's possible there's a lot of people who will be less interested in AH 1e due to it's age than in 2e and 3e?
Maybe because it's summer time? As for me, I've played Arkham Horror LCG and liked it very much, but I don't think I'd watch a video on any Arkham game now... but keep up the great work! I watched and LOVED a *TON* of videos you made so far, and will continue to do so!
I filter in an out randomly, rarely watching a video as soon as it's posted. Sometimes I'm distracted by another hobby and not even watching tabletop videos for a couple months. Having said that, I'm pretty "Cthulu'ed Out" at this point. As a whole. It's just not what I'm into theme wise so I'm a lot less likely to watch.
I totally get that. A theme that you're not interested in is just something that happens.
Dude I think you need to do these videos for you first, and the rest of us second. You said this is something you've wanted to do since you started the channel and I think that's your answer right there. I don't remember how I found your channel, but when you started with, "I hope you are doing well, and if not, I hope you are soon" that's when I hit the "subscribe" button. And I'm glad I did, because you've helped me discover some games I wouldn't have known about, and subsequently enjoy playing very much. Keep up the great work.
I hope you stick with it, at least for one or two more. Maybe rather than tackling them in order hit one of the more accessible games next. Eldritch was a gateway for a lot of people, and Elder Sign seems to be getting talked about a lot lately (don’t know why) in all the solo game groups I’m in
Continue? Absolutely. I could tell you put a lot of time and effort into this first episode. It was such good quality, that if felt like I was looking into a museum's archival footage. The deep dive into Arkham Horror fits the identity of the Dungeon Dive, and its absence will diminish the channel. Arkham Horror is such a seminal work, that it deserves a close examination to put it into context of the age it was created, and its continuing influence now. I understand that you need to monetize the art that you make. But like all fine arts, not everyone recognizes the value of supporting museums. If you don't create this content, then no one will. I predict someday there will be a Boardgame Hall of Fame and your content will be in it. I know that's highly idealistic, but that's how I feel about this series. On a more practical level, you can control how much time/effort you put into the subsequent episodes. I'm just brainstorming ideas here so throw them out if you need: For each of the A.H. 2e expansions you can put in less time if that helps to recoup your time to give to other projects. Viewers seem to like the episodes where you compare/contrast similar games side-by-side. So that technique could be used for the A.H. 2e expansions if that helps to save time making the content while still representing all game material in videos. Also, a side-by-side of A.H 1e, 2e, 3e & E.H. core sets may appeal to viewers. I'm guessing that the content of the older games (A.H. 1e & 2e) may get fewer views and newer content (E.H. & A.H 3e) may get more views. If that's true, then the side-by-side comparisons with both old and new games may bring in the views you need. Finally, recall that the Runebound 2e series was a slow start. But just checking now it looks like the 1st episode has accumulated 9.2 K views (which seems excellent to me) and the subsequent episodes have about 2.2 K views. So I think the A.H. series will build over time, but with even bigger numbers than Runebound because E.H. and A.H. 3e are still in the current Zeitgeist of games. Ultimately, do what you love, do what you have a passion for. I see your passion in the A.H. 1st episode, and so it would be a shame to cut that series short.
Thanks! The time / effort will be much less for the subsequent videos, for sure. I
I haven’t watched it as yet. Only because to get the game it would cost me a lot and take a while to track down. If I watch I know it will give me cravings for the game. So why do that to myself. Stupid I know Daniel, but that’s the honest reason for me buddy.
Not stupid at all! :) I totally get it.
I think the best would be to separate these into smaller videos. That way you can directly see, what really is "tanking" (though I think none of your videos are tanking, they just need some time to get up to speed). Especially long videos need time to watch them. Can you see if people skip specific parts or chapters? That might also be valuable information...
I would love to see more of it. Really enjoyed the first part of the first episode. Still missing an hour or so. I need a few days to get the time to get through a long video like this. But looking forward to see the last part. I just started my own Arkham Horror journey recently. Never played those games before, so I was very excited about the series. I will watch it all.
Oh nice! What are you starting with?
I really like this video and I hope you will continue with that series. And I know how frustrating it can be when you put your heart and soul in those videos and they perform not that well😢 I already watched it twice maybe I missed something😁
Haha! Right on, Chris. It was really nice to talk with you yesterday!
Hi Daniel. I loved the full video and the format. The RL interview was great, like all of your interviews are. I thought it was great to have the RL interview, followed by the mythos literary background and then the First Edition overview. I may be an outlier, but I love your long-form videos. I know what you mean about the popularity of long YT vids. My older son has a YT channel and he does 1 hr+ playthrough videos of classic and modded Pokemon video games. He also edits videos for other content creators who do similar 1 - 2 hour playthrough formats. Those channels routinely get 100's of thousands of views per video - sometimes when the creator just does 1 video every couple of months. There is a very specific market for those types of playthrough videos that reliably get huge view numbers. However, I will say that the other videos (shorter overview ones that my son has created) do NOT get the views - even though they are like 10 - 15 minutes long. At first, I thought that was counter-intuitive - but I think there is just a certain segment of video gamers who want to watch long-form playthrough videos. The short-format overview / strategy vids are just not of interest to them. I love ALL of your content, as you know. However, there is probably a significant segment of your audience who are looking for the 15 - 30 minute 'overview / review' content on the unique / niche games that you highlight so well and so often. Those of us who love your deep dive series too may just make up a smaller segment. There likely is also a political event impact over the last couple of weeks, too. The view numbers are probably not due to a single thing. However, I would love to see you continue the AH deep dive. I dug my 2nd edition stuff out in preparation. I got it years ago when my oldest (the YT kid above) was like 6 yrs old - in preparation to play when he was older - when getting expansions before they went out of print was more of a thing. He's now 22 - LOL. Time to finally play it with him. Your series has got me fired up to finally get it to the table with him. As always, thank you for all your hard work and long hours putting together content that you and we love.
Yeah, I LOVE long form videos. Most of my Youtube watching is videos over an hour. I always see them do so well, so it's pretty frustrating when I try and they bomb! LOL.
I don’t always have time to watch content as it is published but will catch up on this
I'm going to break out the review portion of the video and post it as a bonus video on Friday. Some people might accuse me of double dipping, but I think some people will appreciate that.
Double-dipping? If a vocal minority criticizes you for that - no offense, but F them. They can go make their own content. lool. Breaking out the review section for those who have the most interest in that part of the video is a favor for them. Just my opinion.
I think people are being scared off by the length of the video. I believe they would respond better to shorter cuts which makes the content a little easier to digest. I did enjoy the content, but it is a lot different than anything else you have on your channel. Maybe the audience wasn't ready for such a big change and they would enjoy it more if it was cut into smaller videos.
From all of my research, longer videos actually do better! I've seen 8+ hour video game reviews with millions of hits, and my shorter videos don't do as well. I do think that it was a poorly conceived video, and I definitely botched that. Unfortunately. We'll see if I can right the ship! I think these games are a lot more important than most board games, because of how intertwined they are with the fiction that inspired them, and the fiction they're now inspiring. They exist in a space that deserves more than just a standard "This game is good!" review. You know? But I obviously misjudged the general audience's patience for such an endeavor. Personally, this video is something I've always wanted to watch, but no one has ever made it, so it was up to me! BUT, I need to constantly remind myself that most people aren't me. :)
As someone who has never played any of the games I was very entertained and super impressed with the work you did. I am pumped to see more! I was expecting something more like your Shadows of Brimstone series when you announced this and the scope of this series clearly eclipses that series by a lot! I hope this first video gets a long tail in viewership because it absolutely deserves it. That all said, I can see having the interview as a longer section in first video in the series being a harder sell to the casual viewer of your channel, as interview videos are (by number) less common for you. Best of luck!
I’m two thirds through the video and would like the series to continue but YouTubes algorithm isn’t made for extended segments. It wants short, endorphin hitting things that force the viewer to binge watch like addiction. Not ideal. The interview was amazing though, loved it
See, everything I've read says just the opposite! Long form videos are really popular right now. I constantly see 8+ hour long videos with hundreds of thousands or millions of views - it keeps people on Youtube for them to serve up ads! I think, honestly, this was just a poorly made video for the channel. A wrong way to kick off the series.
I was lucky enough to have enough free time to sit down and watch the whole video yesterday, but that doesn't always happen. Typically, I'd need to watch it over a few days if it was that long. I think it's one of the best videos you've ever done (Bravo!) and I'm very excited to watch the rest of them. I totally understand that you can't spend a ton of time with little to no payoff, but selfishly, I really hope that you do continue these!
As long as you guys want it to continue, it will, because I really want to do it!
I wouldn't worry about the lack of views so far too much. It just came out a couple days ago, and it's a long video. That's not a criticism, I just haven't watched it yet cause I simply haven't had the time.
I have not watched it yet, but intend to.
Absolutely loved the video! I haven’t played Arkham Horror but still loved the deep dive into its history. Only you can answer if you want to keep making em. But I’ll keep watching em. :) I assume one challenge is that it’s an “old” game by today’s standards therefore people aren’t looking for videos for it. The next challenge was that it was pretty unclear what the subject or goal of the video was when I clicked on it. It was really three videos in one. So I wonder if they would’ve performed any better if they were broken into three videos with clearer names about what the subject of the video was. It seems YouTube viewers need to know the one clear singular goal of the video before the click on it.
I want to keep making them, but only if ya'll are interested. :) It was just a poorly conceived video. I thought people would be interested in the Where the Madness Began title. I know I'd click on anything with Arkham Horror + Where the Madness Began, because I'm interested in the subject. But I think I'm an outlier when it comes to what I watch, and I need to remember that! :)
I loved the video. All three segments. The interview was pure gold. A few thoughts: - I watched the video about 5 hours after you posted it, and you were already mentioning in the comments about the how the video was tanking. Lots of people are out and about doing lots of things on their Sunday. I was saddened to see you in a negative headspace about views only 5 hours after posting. - I watched in chunks over several hours, and out of order--first the interview, then the game review, then the mythos source material. I have no idea how YT processes my non-linear, segmented engagement. I will likely watch the mythos reading section again to write down book recommendations. And I'll likely stream the interview several more times over the next few months in the background as a I work on creative projects. This is how content consumption works for many folks nowadays, so who knows how YT is packaging those metrics for you... - Many content creators these days are trying to figure out how to fit the ideas they want to share into the YT passion shredder.
I’m absolutely in for a full watch of the series but I’ve been traveling so haven’t had a chance to dive in. Please continue! It absolutely is at the top of my list of things to catch up on YouTube wise.
Hi Daniel! I saw this as an email and read the poll question and your comment and felt bad that I had not even seen it pop up in my feed yet. I had a few thoughts to share because I totally feel your frustration dumping a lot of time into something that doesn't get the expected response. Here's a number of factors that may bear on the situation for the moment: -July is prime summer vacation time, and it's the third week of the month now, so maybe timing is a factor, people just may be out doing other things while the weather is nice. -Length may be a factor; you might consider keeping this one up as the "full-length" version then relaunching a "multi-part miniseries" version, which may help because it could cater to those with less time to watch a single video which is going to be probably the majority. -Timing, part 2- if it were me I'd release Arkham Horror stuff more around Halloween than mid-summer. Id predict a bigger majority of people aren't into spooky RPGs year round but might dip into it around October. -Personal taste: While a lot of fantasy and dungeon fans love AH, not all do, and I have a ton of fantasy and dungeon and RPG stuff but never got into AH much. Loved Betrayal at House on the Hill but didn't make the leap to AH from there. -All that said, I'm going to watch the video and maybe it will change my mind! I did just recently buy the solo Cthulhu RPG book that came out recently, but haven't cracked the plastic on it yet. I got it to see how the solo rules worked. -Keep rocking it! Like you said AH is a landmark IP and since Lovecraft is public domain it probably will be for a long time. If it were me I'd maybe shift topics for a while and then periodically put out more of the AH series to build anticipation and offset the low views on this one with fresh dungeon content to appeal to your biggest core audience. This one may be a "snowball" type video that gains momentum more slowly. -Keep rockin it! Your work is solid and your content is always quality.
Thanks! The episodes aren't going to be back-to-back. Probably 2 a month. The timing was probably terrible, but also, I vowed never again to do spooky games in October. I did that once, and the channel completely tanked for the entire month! LOL! It was totally wild.
I voted no only because this particular topic isn't something I'm super passionate about but at the same time I believe in working on things that you care about. If it makes you happy and you can ignore the metrics then you do you!
Thank you! :)
I think you’re competing with the YouTube algorithm elevating Biden dropping out of the race. I wouldn’t read into it at this stage and give the video a week to make its way into folks’ feeds
Haha! Yes. And last Sunday it was Trump getting shot. LOL! I can't wait for politics to be boring again. :)
I think long-form interviews, especially with “obscure” people (he’s a legend, but only to such a narrow sliver of us!) are a tough sell on YouTube. Like folks tune in to hear your voice and see your interactions and thoughts on the game, but it’s 1:30 into the video before we see the game. Don’t get me wrong, I ate it up. I love the deep dive into the background creators and source material; but if you need to chase the views a bit and give the masses their bread and circuses by keeping the games front & center and intersperse the background stuff in between in small doses, then I’m still there watching, happy that these masterpieces are getting their due. What I’m trying to say is I’m a supporter even if you have to work with the algorithm to keep views up!
TBH I skipped this video in my Subscriptions feed. It's too long. It looks like it should be 3 videos: interview, Mythos primer, AH1e review. And even if it was 3 videos, I already know about the Mythos; and I rarely watch interviews because they're too slow-paced (even at double speed). What I'm interested in is: What is the Dungeon Dive's review of AH1e and is it worth my time, effort, and money to look into buying that game? I've got 80 other videos to watch. I need quality product reviews from a critic whose opinion I trust.
Yeah - it was probably a failure of presentation. I constantly watch videos that are 8+ hours long, but I need to realize that others don't. :) Luckily there are chapters so you can skip right to the AH1e review. :)
I loved it! Listening through a second time currently!
When I search for Shadows of Brimstone in YouTube, your playlist is the 3rd to appear. That's how I imagine it will be with Arkham Horror. :)
I love in-depth, long form content and you are exeptionally good at that. Personally I have no issue in simply watching the video in pieces or dedicating the time. However, if you need or want higher initial metrics I would suggest releasing smaller videos as chapters of an episodes. Regardless of numbers—arbitrary, as they are—I think you are doing the correct thing by engaging with your community. I say keep up the incredible work you do, and I really do appreciate the blood, sweat and tears put in.
The only thing I really care about is what ya'll have to say. :)
My girlfriend and I are huge Mythos / Arkham fans and yesterday we agreed to watch this in place of one of our movie nights! I'm not saying you should base your choice on this fact, but my suggestion would be to give it some time to see how it fares, before making a decision. It's a longer video which is harder to slot into ones day. Personally, I am super interested and willing to watch it all!
Great! Thank you.
I'm surprised I'm in the minority with a NO answer. I don't think you should continue anything you aren't 100% passionate about. There is opportunity cost where you could work on something else. In fact, I'd say in the future you should do 2-minute promos for a series to test the waters and see how well they will do.
I'm personally 100% into it, but I just want to make sure you all are. Because of the overall bad performance, I didn't want to devote a ton of time and effort into something my patrons don't wan't to watch. Personally, I've never been MORE into something I've done on the channel! And I think that's why I am so deflated with the overall reception right now.
Daniel, this one is for the history books. Arkham Horror is one of the most important games of all time and your videos will be watched for years and years in the future. Yes it will be worth it! You're the best person for the job, you're the one that this game deserves. I loved the interview!
First month on Patreon purely to support the endeavor! Well, not just for the series. Been a fan for a while but I believe this kind of immense creative work deserves something special. I’d love to see what you have to say about the game moving forward ❤️ it’s incredible quality of effort so far. You rock! Keep doing what you’re passionate about.
Appreciate it! I'm betting the 2nd episode does better.
I don't think "First 24h viewership" or "viewer retention through the last minute of the video" are the right metrics by which to judge this video/series. It's going to be a slow accumulation, and will hopefully stand out to the folks who find it as "different" and attract them to the channel/patreon. For all the same reasons, the algorithm may not know what to do with it, but I think it's too early to judge that. The bottom line is that this is what you want to do with the channel. I would much rather see you do that then turn the channel into something else.
And this is exactly why I asked here. :)
Is there a way you can continue the series without it requiring a heavy time commitment?
Of for sure! I'm almost positive that the rest of the series will be more normal in length, and in time commitment. The rest of the series really is just about the games, with brief discussion on the stories that inspired them. I think this first episode just wasn't a very good episode to start with. I probably should have done things differently.
You all really are what matters, so I value all of the opinions being shared here.
I liked it and learned a lot. Selfishly I answered yes … that you should continue. 2h+ for this video mais require ppl to plan when the watch it. How would it feel to give it a bit more time before deciding on the future of the series? If you decide to move on to something else, well …. I am sure it will be super too.
I enjoyed the episode and hope you continue. It was a long one but I had a lazy Sunday to watch it all. If future episodes are of similar length I will likely need a few days but I will watch them! :)
Future episodes definitely won't be as long. :) I think the longest of the future episodes will be around 1 hour. Most will probably closer to the more typical 30-45 minutes
I think long form videos take more time for people to watch them, I always wish I could see who has hit “save for later”. These are awesome videos for the history of games and you should keep doing them!
I will watch it soon and would watch any future videos on the subject. But...if you're looking at the numbers and you don't think the general YouTube board gamer public is going to watch then maybe it's not worth it? As you pointed out, judging by past performances on other videos, the Arkham retrospect may not turn out to be a popular video series. I think you would know better than anyone at this point. It's too bad that it has to come down to numbers but I understand why.
I don't care too much about low numbers if the DD Patrons want to watch it. :) You guys are what matters.
I, for one am really looking forward to this series, unfortunately with work, I haven't been able to watch it yet, but I will be watching it (and any others) for sure.
I haven’t watched the first video yet, but do plan to. I’ve been interested in this game for a long time but haven’t looked into it closely. So I’m excited to hear your take on it
I watched the whole thing yesterday. Thought it was great! I hope you continue with the series. I imagine some people see the running time and get scared off.
Fwiw—I’m looking forward to watching it, but saving it for a full sit through later this week. I bought the original chaosium edition when I was 13 back in the early 80s.
I just signed up for your Patreon due my interest in the series so I certainly hope you continue!
The Patrons are definitely what matters, so thank you!
