Your chance to weigh in on an upcoming series
Opinions about setting for a new series I'm starting next year.
Apprentice book 1 is what I'm going to write after I finish Exploration (WttM 10)- despite the fact that it won't release till July. That's because of audio recording deadlines.
I haven't started putting words on the page yet for this series and am currently in the dreaming about it stage. I mean that seriously, in that I often dream about my series while I'm doing the prep work for them. This is especially true for new series.
One of those dreams caused this question.
Apprentice was originally conceived of as the main character trapped in a reverse time dilation bubble. (Why will be shown early in the story). When he is trapped the world uses magic heavily, etc...
When he comes out magic is much weaker, less common, and most of the magic is in the forms of artificers, alchemists, and some darker beings.
Originally, he was going to be discovered and awaken in a world with about 1600-1700's technology level but with a touch of magic. Ie... rifles that fire bullets with magical charges created by alchemists rather than gun powder. It would be a society with a dying aristrocracy and the rise of populace governments.
But one of the dreams had it set in a more modern world with more of an urban fantasy approach.
Either would be set on an alternate Earth, so there would be similularities but also differences to the real world and not just the existence of magic.
So which would you prefer and if you feel like saying why, please comment.
Comments (17)
I'm down for a good urban fantasy, although 1600s you could introduce a more fleshed out tech tree i feel... which techs lead to other techs etc. That could be fun... A man out of time who can influence the technological advancement of civilizations. I know ME touches on those themes but it would be nice to to put a Civ style tech tree front and center.
I’d definitely want the MC to be able to wield “old magic” too
That would definitely be the point that even just as a mage who was in the process of testing to become a full mage, he is incredibly more advanced than any mage in the "modern" world.
So, I'm stuck. Unless the setting is specially stated as modern urban, then in my head everything is the 1600-1700....ish. Now, that's not fair, but it has to do with the way I read. I get a movie going in my head then use the written word to move it forward, it means I may not read every word, but also means i can re- read books several times and it feels like the first. So, my suggestion is either start of the dark ages,allowing for the finding of artifacts from fall of Roman empire, or start somewhere during the cold war, lots of hidden government items and secrets to play with. I'll read it either way, as you really don't disappoint.
I’d be fine with either, but if you go 16-1700’s, you almost have to incorporate religion whereas you can skate by it from a modern standpoint
Honestly I loved reading Eric Flint’s 1632 series. I gave up after about the 5th book when he started letting others write in his world, but the concept of a person with knowledge and skills from the future, learning to function and thrive in the past is fun. Add some magic and it gets better!
I love the Returner's Defiance series by Bruce Sentar, especially how it started with the first couple of books. Would love to read more stories in a current setting.
I’ve read several of Bruce’s series- but not that one.
I can’t argue with writing from dreams, since I do the same thing myself, albeit a bit differently. However, I’ll be declining to vote. Since you said you wanted an honest opinion? I suggest you pick the urban fantasy, because the trope is already overdone in a more primitive setting. Honestly, I doubt I’ll be reading either way. My favorite series you have going right now is AB, despite it’s flaws. And yes, it’s surpassed WttM.
Thanks for your honest feedback. All my series are like my children, different, but I don't have favorites. That said, I wish that more of the audience had felt like you do about Apocalypse Breaker. We had high hopes for the concept.
It would also be very cool to see what the MC does with magic in a world that’s not technologically advanced to see if there’s a major difference in the things that they come up with
I’m gonna be honest 1600s and 1700s seems like a great setting but if you were to move it to more modern times like right around the industrial revolution would be amazing
There is currently a series fairly close to what you described as being somewhat industrial. That being said modern has been done alot, and if I had to choose between the two I'd choose the premodern one. Just before the fall of civilization would be fun too. Idk why im adding that.
I guess I don't know what that other series is. But I would add that, I don't think I'm re-inventing the wheel. What do you mean befreo the fall of civiization- like the fall of Rome or something along those lines?
You have Magic Eater, which has some components of lower technology levels, whereas WttM was more modern and urban, along with Apocalypse which definitely is more urban. Clearly the answer is Steampunk 🤪
I was just gonna say something similar to this but then saw you already had!
urban fantasy more overdone IMO. Would be interesting to see more pre founding of our country times
