Just a feeler because I'm thinking ahead a couple of chapters.
Normally my work is described as being very positive and upbeat with hope etc...
Sometime bad things happening is good for the overall story- but I worry about the tolerance of my readers as a whole for such things.
So curious how you view this?
Oh and Chapter 36 is almost done, but my brain when down a rabbit hole.
Comments (36)
Some of the best characters are forged by the messed up things that happen to them. Learning to deal with bad situations is something everyone has to deal with and would humanize the character.
Rather than make bad things happen to him personally as in family dying or what not. I would introduce him to his polar opposite someone who was similar to him but chose a path that lead his people to destruction. Maybe bc he was so focused on power that he sacrificed things he didn’t realize were so important before it was too late.
As long as you don't pull an M.H.Johnson on Silas, I'm fine lol
Man I love most of his books- what did he do to a character?
I’m okay for bad stuff for a while as long as it doesn’t turn Silas into an insufferable I’m so sad woe is me character *cough* hwfym *cough*
No mopey
I honestly feel like something bad has to happen to make the plot armor realistic and provide depth. Also, if no faction ever does something epic to piss him off for revenge, how does the universe/ system as a whole ever come to know not to mess with him and by proxy Earth. I, honestly, felt like the werewolves were going to do something to either decimate Earth, the safe zone, his friends/family or some combination of such, that it would force him to retaliate and grow/use new allies and powers while incident saving the world.
Bad things can add dimensionality, as can good things. The things to avoid, imo are: 1. When bad things Nerf the character. 2. Wallowing.
Yes, for the love of sweet baby Jesus, no wallowing.
I get the escapism of reading and generally like characters winning but I really wouldn’t mind some painful experiences to harden Silas. Was just thinking earlier that Silas has pretty much made friends with every alien he has interacted with except a few people. It’s impressive but it’s also a bit off a bit. There is something to be said about betrayal, a bit of suffering and pain. It adds a lot of character development and growth to a character.
Absolutely agree, It’s been a while since I’ve read a story where a well written new ‘friend’ turns out to be a a spy or betrayer.
My concern for the story is that between Galen, the current situation on the auction planet and the peak families/Hell system he's being painted into a corner in the short, medium and long term which would feel like serious use of plot armour to resolve in his favor and make for a worse story overall
Considering how many fights these people get in, it's extremely unlikely (borderline ridiculous to be honest) people close to him don't die. I'd axe his mother, sister and maybe someone else from his team to something that is Silas's fault. Have him get darker for awhile and relook at trusting people. I'm the opposite from some of the comments on here. I think 300 chapters with only happy endings makes for a dull story (I like your story and enjoy reading it!, lol, this is a common enough problem though).
It does feel like Silas could use some hardening/motivation. He thinks he knows how vulnerable and weak he is, but I don’t think he actually comprehends it.
It could also help these old world leaders to full understand how woefully unprepared they are for this new world. No daddy Silas around to keep things running smooth and play nice with them. They could use a dose of reality as well.
Where is the: "Kill Silas off, who needs an MC anyhow?" Option?
Hey slow down there grrm fan XD we dont want a goft ending here, that sucked lol
Of course I want to read about Silas winning but the multiverse world you have and are building is dangerous and high tier individuals can be very cruel. So, for me, it would be unrealistic to think that nothing bad, very very bad, and/or traumatic would not happen to Silas at some point. However, I would expect to see him “win” by overcoming and escaping, if necessary; and have some tremendous growth and progression come from it
Bad things happening isn't an issue for me. It's that he has zero agency and can be killed, tortured, and enslaved on a whim from any of these factions at any time. The system will stop enforcing its own rules, regularly takes things from Silas, and has flat out told him he is an expendable pet.
I read these books to escape to a different place. If I wanted to read about trama I would just have to look at my life. I enjoy books that have happy notes on them. I understand that some things have to happen. But isn’t losing your whole way of life traumatic enough. If this gets to depressing- then I find something else to cheer me up. Please don’t do the self loathing pity party.
No self-loathing pity party incoming. And I agree I read for escape too, but I do feel like there have to be hard things that happens to characters - it's really about how they deal with it to me. I am very mindful though that I'm not perfect so I listen to all your input.
As long as he wins
I mean not to provide a spoiler.... but that's a given. I'm not GRRM who killed the only good man in the entire series at the end of book 1.
Don't care just have the family be off limits to the bad thing.
Fair enough
Honestly there is no way that Silas would get through the entire integration and probationary period without some bad trauma, but I don’t want his trauma to be a whole major theme of the storyline. Jason’s traumas and his reflections on it almost take over that storyline at times, and I find myself telling him to man up and move on. I read for enjoyment and escapism. Adulting and its associated trauma’s we all deal with in a daily basis, so I really hate it when the MC goes on a multi chapter pity party. That said, the story goes where it goes. I just know that I will start whining if as soon as we get some semi-resolution to the love triangle we immediately jump into a long arc of woe is me
I can’t pick a voting option because none captures my view on this. I think the comments here about Jason in HWFWM captures my view well. Perfectly okay to have Silas suffer to grow as a person. Where I quit reading is when suffering and betrayal are the only plot drivers. I quit books and series when that happens. And I’m not super worried you’ll go down that path as an author based on what I’ve read so far. Just finished “Control” on audiobook and looking forward to “Invasion”. So appreciative of ethos story!
One of my favorite parts about another series of yours under the Burke name..Prism Academy .. It brought a ton to the story and made the MC stronger in the Long run. Bad things are part of life when your in war and he is most definitely in a war, even if a different kind.
I would rather read about progression through creatively solving problems versus progression through depression …so don’t dwell on it if you choose catastrophe as he doesn’t have time for an emotional self-discovery tour.
Yeah not meant to be emotional self-discovery- but more of a showing of mortality. I get the concern.
As long as we're not going into GRRM territory with the whole extended Ramsey/Theon storyline, I'm good.
ugh- never.
Very much depends on the bad thing and how it will influence his growth and the story. Like Randidly Ghosthound loses an arm at some point and suffers tremendously but it leads to growth and new powers, etc. Rand gets trapped in a box and relentlessly tortured but it opens some doors and drives his development (and trauma).. but the bad stuff didnt last more than a few chapters for each. If that makes sense and to give some examples.
I struggled with Randidly's arm more than Rand's box. Mostly because I feel like the system as laid out would not have any problem regrowing his arm. I have a touch of claustrophobia- so the box was pretty intense to me and the enemies were very evil. I however believe that chapter at Dumai Wells where he escapes is my favorite one in the series. Asha'man kill!
I chose the third option. My thought process was the torture that Jason in HWFWM went through. It’s something the left scars but he endured and it led to some incredible storylines. I also like the way that initial arc went. That being said I do love the overall levity of your stories.
Bad things happen no one wants them to it’s part of life. Make Silas more relatable by dealing him a heavy emotional blow or cause him some form of trauma but emphasize his recovery. The steps he takes and the challenges he faces trying to overcome them. ‘He Who Fights With Monsters’ I feel does a great job over the series of showing the development and struggle people go through when dealing with trauma. Personal opinion.
