MUSICAL MARCH - 1960's
some hate this ideas but most seemed to be excited - Let's watch some musicals on the channel!
Plus - after Kpop Demon Hunters, I'm craving some more bangers.
Multiple choice and these are from the 1960's so vote for all your favorites!!
FRANCHISE FRIDAYS:
So I literally JUST finished filming MiB4 and while it was my least favorite of them all, I didn't think it was awful or anything. Just no one can replicate the connection the Will Smith and TLJ had when it came to their witty lines, imo.
What's some franchises you're hoping to see on the poll? Don't worry - I'll also include a director option and an actor/actress option. I know some want me to get to the marvel shows but I'd really appreciate keeping TV shows for Wednesday uploads.
Comments (142)
you'll love A Chorus Line. singjng, dancing, songs about discovery about sex, body image etc.
When are you going to react to wicked and wicked for good
1776 is especially of the moment (It's from the 70s though, so not applicable here, just putting its name in the hat). It's a Tony-award winning musical about the founding fathers that deserves way more attention than it gets. Maybe it could be a good watch for 4th of July or next President's day.
It's not letting me vote, but if I could I would vote for West Side Story
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum should definitely be on any list of great, 1960s musicals. It's an excellent adaptation of the stage show, with Zero Mostel reprising his Tony-winning role.
Sweet Charity. Worth it for the Bob Fosse direction, and Shirley MacLaine is always amazing.
Ashleigh should do Yellow Submarine "augmented"
Sooo.. Musical Mondays? So many great suggestions!!
I just remembered another Musical, Repo! The Genetic Opera, has a familiar face from Buffy return.
I voted for Yellow Submarine but would it not be the best thing EVER to have Ashleigh reacting to Dr. Horrible´s Sing-Along Blog?!?!?!?
I've mentioned the Twilight Zone many times because the writing is so excellent. And it reflects so much about the human condition and is very relevant more than 60 years later. Another advantage is that 155 of the 156 episodes are 30 minutes long... which means with the commercial breaks you're looking at 22-23 minutes a pop. Ashleigh cold to stack 4-5 binge watching episodes in each post.
Oliver, Peter Pan, and the Music Man are good Musicals... My Fair Lady has a great cast, but has like two good songs. GI Blues, Yellow Submarine, and Blue Hawaii aren't musicals, they're Singer Films (as in, they're excuses to create a film to make musicians/singers stars to sing their own songs... this isn't Mama Mia where the songs are all ABBA songs being performed by actors playing roles and the songs help drive the plot, these are films built to let the singer/group sing their songs while making lose stories to fill in space between the songs... essentially the Monkees TV Series only with more runtime so they can do more songs) Hello Dolly! and Funny Girl are just Streisand doing a Broadway version of a Singer Film. Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is a Disney Movie, not a Musical... it is like Mary Poppins or Bednobs & Broomsticks... it has musical numbers in it, but it really just Disney liked songs in his films to help move the story along (A Beach Movie, also from Disney, put a huge lampshade on this with "Can't Stop Singing") The only real Musicals on this are : My Fair Lady Oliver Peter Pan The Music Man West Side Story Those five are the only ones that should have votes... and My Fair Lady and West Side Story are modernizations of older stories with songs added in: Pygmalion and Romeo & Juliet respectively... This leaves, Oliver, Peter Pan, and The Music Man... I voted for those three, because they are the three that should be getting votes. Everything else is just polluting the list.
There are a lot of things you've said here that aren't facts, just opinions stated as if they were facts, so while I disagree with you on a lot of this, I'm not going to argue opinions. However, you're factually wrong about Chitty Chitty Bang Bang being a Disney film. It was from Warfield Studios and released by United Artists. Oh - and your definition of musical is absolutely bizarre. Mary Poppins isn't a musical? What planet do you live on? "Disney liked songs in his films" 1) yeah that's why Disney Studios wrote and produced so many MUSICALS, and 2) Disney also released a bunch of movies without songs in them, so that whole argument is moot.
I didn't know there were so many fans for Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. I generally don't think of that as a movie musical. My Fair Lady and Music Man are horrible stories with great music. In both of them, the movie doesn't realize that the male lead is the villain. (At least in Music Man there's a vague redemption arc. But instead of him solving the problems he created, they're just hand-waved away through unexplained magic.) I still voted for them, because the music is iconic enough, and it's interesting to see Ashleigh watch "classic" movies she doesn't connect with.
You're missing so much when looking at these stories through the lens of 21st century realities. George Bernard Shaws 1912 play, "Pygmalion" is the basis for My Fair Lady. 1912 that's the year the Titanic hit the iceberg. That great playwright was 9 years old when Abraham Lincoln was shot, so his reality was extremely different when compared to ours. And the interpersonal dynamic between men and women were far different when the Music Man was released in 1962, or My Fair Lady on Christmas 1964. And the Music Man depicts traditional Americana at the start of the 20th century. It's not just the creatives who are different, the audience attending these movies were very different, their truths were very different, their experiences were very different. Musical from the 30s, 40s, and 50s also reflect their times.
Rock Of Ages would've fit this list
Do you mean the 60s musical poll?
Music Man is my #1 but won’t be mad if My Fair Lady or West Side Story (the original) wins, those are 3 of my all-time favorites!!
Well, I voted for My Fair Lady and Music Man, although I must admit I do have soft spot for the Matthew Broderick remake. Franchises: I want Bond back so we can finish watching Ashliegh collect future ex-husbands. Mission Impossible would be a fun new franchise. Night at the Museum or Shanghai Knights/Noon would be fun little franchises to round out some corners. More Hitchcock, more Thin Man, the Road pictures with Bing Crosby and Bob Hope
Meridith Wilson the man who wrote the music and lyrics for The Music Man, also did so for Unsinkable Molly Brown. Debbie was born for that part. The only other person who could have played it was Gwen Verden...a better dancer, but as good a singer...but with the same powerful personality.
Fun fact regarding the Music Man. After they started shooting, Shirley Jones told the producers that she is pregnant. Week after week and month after month they continued to let out her dress, in order to hide the bulge. During one scene Shirley is in an embrace with Robert Preston. And the baby kicks. He exclaimed what was that?! Many years later that baby now all grown up visits Robert. He sticks out his hand to introduce himself and Robert with a little smirk says, "We've already met."
Which film will win? West Side Story or My Fair Lady. West is more dance centric, with plenty of great songs from extremely talented Sondheim and Bernstein. My Fair Lady is filled with great dresses Ashleigh would love along with great songs and interesting character development. Both are terrific. Both, Ashleigh will enjoy a lot. Still surprised Chitty has almost 30 more votes compared to the Music Man... which is another heads and shoulder excellent musical. I like Funny Girl because of Barbra Streisand, but in regard to the excellence of movie musicals there are only three A+ films on this particular poll, and that's My Fair Lady, West Side Story, and the Music Man. I am excited to read what other musicals Ashleigh will list for her 1930s, 1940s, 1950s, and 1970s polls...
Lately, if two films are really close in voting then Ashleigh watches both of them. Which is great because Ashleigh then gets variety!
Oklahoma was 1955...Ashleigh would love the Academy nominated performance of Debbie Reynolds in 1964's Unsinkable Molley Brown. We all know Ashleigh is a burst of energy and so is that Debbie Reynolds' character.
Oklahoma! and Cinderella 1965, The King and I, by Rodgers and Hamerstein are great musicals!
Another good one not on the list: How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying (1967)
Robert Morse was the star on Broadway in 1961 and you're correct recreated that role in 1967...He also played Bert Cooper in Mad Men...doing so when he was in his late 70s and early 80s. He too had a long life, living to 90.
What about Moulin Rouge? There's just so many bangers in it and the movie is just fantastic. Edit: Nevermind didn't read the 1960s part🤣
Think she would enjoy it
Audrey Hepburn is good in My Fair Lady but her casting has some controversy. Julie Andrews portrayed the role on Broadway but they did not cast her in the film because they wanted a more well known actress. Julie Andrews starred in Mary Poppins instead and ended up winning the Oscar that year beating out Audrey Hepburn who was also nominated for My Fair Lady.
And they had Marni Nixon sing the songs for Audrey Hepburn to lipsync.
I wonder what will happen over the next 36 hours??? Will The Music Man get more votes compared to Chitty Chitty Bang Bang and win the coveted third place???
Suits and Mad Men would be two interesting choices for Wednesday. And if Mad Men wins a future poll, I hope Ashleigh watches How to Succeed in Business without really trying...before she would start the Mad Men adventure. The very talented Robert Morse is in both. In the 1967 movie he's in his 30s and in the 21st Century TV series Mad Men he's in his late 70s and early 80s.
These are all the kind of non-emotional musicals I hated growing up till I finally saw a few with dramatic storytelling and emotion and fell in love with them. I'd want you to watch Les Misérables from 2012 if I could see any musical reaction, but Hello Dolly's okay since it was in WALL-E. I really haven't enjoyed how TV shows have taken over the Wednesday slot every week. I miss 3 movies per week on YouTube.
I really love some of these choices. Not only did I get to see some of these in the theater when they premiered but we owned several full albums. Yellow Submarine was the first song I learned to sing when I was a kid. I still know most of the words to most of the songs in Oliver. And it looks like West Side story is in the lead. And I'm totally here for it. Prefer this version. Can we have dance movies as a category someday? Gene Kelly will probably need his own category. In the meantime... Yay! Fun!
Gene Kelly and Fred Astaire should both have their own category...Asheliegh could compare Fred and Gene dancing with Vera Ellen and Rita Hayworth. Though classic 30s Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers are great. And nobody was a better female tap dancer than Elenore Powell.
South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut is a wonderful musical.
YES!
I also like Doris Day & Judy Garland musicals : Calamity Jane (stars Doris Day & Howard Keel) Meet Me In St. Louis (Judy Garland classic) Seven Brides for Seven Brothers Stars Howard Keel & Jane Powell, funny singing & dancing
Also; Harvey Girls, Gay Purr-ee, Ziegfeld Girl, Easter Parade, A Star is Born, My Dream is Yours, Romance on the High Seas, and On Moonlight Bay
You should try futuristic, horror musical "Repo! the Genetic Opera" its wild and stars GILES (Anthony Stewart Head) as a singing serial killer, Alexa Vega (from SpyKids) and Paris Hilton?? It's pretty divisive, one of those you either love it wholeheartedly or think it's the stupidest shit ever lol
For that matter, Dr. Horrible's Sing-a-long Blog is also a musical...
The Music Man is SUCH a good movie. And you Philistines want Chitty Chitty Bang Bang? She already hated Bedknobs and Broomsticks. When will you learn? Your taste sucks.
Hey dude, why so hostile. Yes, Music Man is better than Chitty, but Chitty is not the same as Bedknobs. Other than the Music Man what is your favorite musical? Telling someone their taste sucks is extremely arrogant. Every era is different. There are plenty of great musicals in the 30s, 40s, and 50s.
Only two surprises are that the Music Man is so far behind and so few voted for Funny Girl. And from the Music man, little lisping red head grew up to direct Apollo 13, Beautiful Mind, Cinderella Man, Far and Away and so many other great films.
Trivia question: What is the one thing West Side Story, My Fair Lady, and the King and I have in common? Answer: M.N.
No one cares
I haven't been a Patreon for very long, has Ashleigh ever had a tie vote in one of her polls? My Fair Lady and West Side Story are back and forth, neck and neck...who's going to win over the next two days. Ashleigh, in case you don't know show Natile Wood is, she's the little girl from Miracle on 34th street, all grown up.
There have been several neck and neck polls that Ashleigh, just recently within the past year, has chosen to watch both because they were so close!
how about Sara Connor chronicles
I would love for you to finish the Muppets franchise by watching the two more recent movies!
For Franchises: Pink Panther with Peter Sellers, The rest of the different Batman movies (I believe there are four left), Nutty Professor franchise including the Jerry Lewis original, The Love Bug franchise, Anaconda franchise, I Know What You Did Last Summer franchise, and Continuing the Conjuring Universe (including Annabelle and other related individual films).
Oh yes! The Love Bug! I think Ashleigh would get a kick out of those!
Oliver was the first VHS tape my family ever owned. Haven't watched it in decades, can only remember bits and pieces, but it holds a special place in my heart
I was super traumatized by Oliver as a kid. (We also had the Rats of NIMH and The Dark Crystal, just in case my brother or I tried to think for a minute or two that good things happened to good people...)
Yeee!! So excited to see some of my favorites are up there in votes! I know this is going to date me, but I saw Chitty Chitty Bang Bang as a kid and I didn't stop singing the songs for at least a week!! You liked Breakfast at Tiffany's so I'm pretty sure you'll love My Fair Lady. As far as franchises goes.. what if you finished a couple? So Jurassic World: Dominion and Jurassic World: Rebirth, then US Marshalls (sequel to The Fugitive) and Jewel of the Nile (sequel to Romancing the Stone) ? It would give a little variety AND completion! :) :) And if you did an actor franchise, you could do Keanu Reeves with: Devil's Advocate, The Replacements, Constantine and The Lake House. OR.. if you wanted to do a whole month of animated movies (and you haven't seen them yet) you could do the Toy Story movies. :) Or OR... you could do The Da Vinci Code movies, but there's only 3 so you'd have to plan something for the last Friday. BUT, I'm pretty sure you'd love those.
Ohh.. just had a thought.. you could do the Catherine O'Hara tribute and then The Da Vinci Code movies. That'd work!
There is a musical movie that is also a true story called La Bamba which I wish you would watch. I would also like you to watch Once Upon a Time for Wednesday TV series
Yesssss.. LOVE La Bamba!! I think she'd REALLY like OUAT!
Wednesday TV options...1960s Twilight Zone, Once Upon a Time...love to watch Ashleigh's reaction to Rumpelstiltskin...and the interesting rewriting of various good and evil characters. And the quirking innovative sci-fi "Farscape"
Fun fact regarding Chitty Chitty Bang Bang...Dick Van Dyke was in fact six months older than Lionel Jeffries...the actor who played the grandpa to Van Dyke's kids. At 43 Dick wasn't so young performing many athletic routines.
can you believe he just turned 100? crazy!
Funny Girl is classic Streisand. The Music Man is a classic as is My Fair Lady.
There's an MiB4?
Yes, it’s not that great but there is a cartoon that is oodles better.
While reacting to What's Up Doc... Ashleigh asked if Barbra was a singer who became an actress, or an actress who likes to sing... She was always a singer first...that is her great superpower...she sold a couple of albums before her film debut of Funny Girl in 1968.
Damn Yankees! and/or Li'l Abner but they're 1958/1959 respectively.
Damn Yankees is certainly a film Ashleigh would enjoy.
Of course, with Fred Astaire it's not just about his greatness, it's about the many talented ladies dancing with him...each with their unique dancing talents and personalities...from Ginger Rogers to Vera Ellen, and Rita Hayworth, and Elenore Powell. From the 30s, 40s, 50s...and someone mentioned the 1968 Finian's Rainbow...Fred last movie, for a 69-year-old he was amazing...though that film was far from his best. Fred continued to dance on TV specials even at 70ish.
My favorite Rita Hayworth moment is still 'Put the Blame on Mame.' I know, it's one musical number in a film noir. But still. Pretty sure the character of Jessica Rabbit was based on that performance.
You would LOVE Victor/Victoria with Julie Andrews. But, that’s from 1982, so not old enough for this poll. 🤣
I have been hoping to see that as a choice in an upcoming list. I love that movie so much. It is so damn funny. So many great moments and performances. All the actors were top notch and knocked it out of the park.
My theater kid heart is so happy seeing this poll. Hope other years get a chance on another poll sometime to. Love ‘em all: Hello Dolly, Sound of Music, My Fair Lady, Oklahoma, Music Man, South Pacific, Brigadoon, Fiddler in the Roof, Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, Annie Get Your Gun, Gypsy, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, Jesus Christ Superstar, Westside Story, Hair, Hairspray (‘88 with Ricki Lake and Divine), Grease, Cats (stage version, not newer one) Phantom of the Opera, Evita, Les Miserable, Newsies, Chicago, Rent, Burlesque ….
Yessss... That is an excellent list. And please don't forget 'Chorus Line'
If West Side Story wins...Please go for the original 1961. And thank you for including so many good choices. I hope at some future point we also get to pick from a Rogers and Hammerstein poll...so many great musicals: Oklahoma, South Pacific, King and I, Carousel...You've already enjoyed the Sound of Music...which was created by that genius team. You've enjoyed Gene Kelly in Singing in the Rain, how about another Gene Kelly film..."An American in Paris" set to great George and Ira Gershwin music. And of course the wonderfully talented Fred Astaire in so many movies from the 30s, 40s, 50s...He's ageless, born in 1899, he was performing great routines when he was 13 years older than Gene Kelly.
Ashleigh said that all of these are from the 1960s so we are definitely voting on the original. Absolutely would love An American in Paris & Carousel on a later poll.
For future Musicals, you might also like: Hairspray (2007), Enchanted (2007), Chicago (2002), Fiddler on the Roof (1971), Moulin Rouge (2001), Oklahoma (1955)
Yeah but the music is near constant and all written and performed by the same guy so I stand by it!
You need a month of Jim Carrey to get you caught up. Ace Ventura, Dumb and Dumber, Liar Liar, and Truman Show should get you all set.
The only musical I ever liked isn’t on the list. Into The Woods , but the stage version with Bernadette Peters. So I’ll sell my vote to the highest bidder, bid opens at $500
This is a poll for musicals from the 1960s - no amount of money would put Into the Woods on this poll.
West side for life, but only because bye bye birdie isn’t on the list….
Franchise-wise, I have no hot takes, just hoping to see Bond again (mainly for closure), and hoping that Director/Actor will win some polls. Mission: Impossible could be fun (would fit perfectly into two months), but maybe finish Bond first.
BOND!!
I would choose A Hard Day's Night or Help instead of Yellow Submarine. Just watched A Hard Day's Night again and it was hilarious.
If West Side Story wins, please do the original 1961 version.
The poll is for movie musicals *from the 1960s*. That's the only West Side Story under consideration.
So little love for Chitty Chitty Bang Bang?? 🥺 I realize it gave some of us nightmares but the SONGS!!!
Yes...the child catcher is nightmare fuel but Dick VanDyke is AMAZING as always! Truly scrumptious you could say!
Mary Martin Peter Pan?
Funny Girl should be voted higher as it's Barbra's Oscar, and we know how Ashleigh feels about her.
I just met a girl named Mariaaaa…
I know it's from the 70's but you gotta react to Jesus Christ Superstar.
Peter Pan and Westside Story (if they make the cut) have to be the right versions… Peter Pan with Mary Martin as Peter, and the ‘61 version of Westside Story. Soooo many good musicals that could be on in this list. Can’t wait.
Ashleigh has the Mary Martin version in one of the "Musicals: Live!" collections I sent her s few years ago.
HEY! NOT SURE WHY FOLKS ARE HAVING TROUBLE READING - THIS IS A POLL FOR MUSICALS FROM THE 1960s! MUSICALS THAT ARE NOT FROM THE 1960s ARE NOT INCLUDED ON THIS POLL!
Not taking any chances
West Side Story (1960s please - no Spielberg remake)
This is a poll for musicals from the 1960s. It does not include the Spielberg remake.
If you're going to do Yellow Submarine, do the other Beatles movies...and please do Across the Universe!
OMG OMG OMG.. Well..I LOVE That You are doing this FINALLY.. But LMAO You are gonna have to do this again .. Grease, South Pacific, Oklahoma , Finian's Rainbow
Grease is from 1978, South Pacific is from 1958, Oklahoma is from 1955 -- out of your four suggestions, only Finian's Rainbow would have been appropriate for this poll.
In 1976,a non musical porn version of “My Fair Lady” called “The Opening of Misty Beethoven” opened. There was,eventually,a porn musical version released in the early 2000’s.
Love a a good musical. You've already reacted to my favourite Little Shop of Horrors. For Franchise I have a few that spring to mind: Rush Hour Planet of the Apes. Old or modern NOT the Tim Burton one Insidious Paranormal Activity The first Mad Max movies Test
For the first time ever, I voted for SEVEN! SO MANY GREAT CHOICES!!!
But...Se7en wasn't a musical, I'm confused.... ;)
For Franchise Fridays - I vote to continue the Christopher Guest movies so you will be sure to watch Waiting for Guffman.
i swear i have been waiting for West Side Story to be on a poll for YEARS & it's in the lead right now! i haven't been this excited since Sound Of Music & Adventures In Babysitting were done in the same month. I'm not religious but please for all that is holy give me this one thing 🙏🏻
Not a musical, but I think you would really enjoy The 10th Kingdom miniseries
My Fair Lady Hands down BUT those of you not voting for Oliver clearly have not watched it. She must watch both, period!
I agree, she should watch both! But...my weird partnership with "My Fair Lady" is "The Music Man", because the character building on the central characters are, for me, so enriching. And .... Robert Preston ........!
Yellow Submarine is one of my favorites. We watched it every year when I was a child. And, I got it on physical media every time it came out on a new format as an adult.
I have a special affection for this one: our dad was from Spain. He was so old fashioned we teased him by saying he was born before 1491. He had a sense of humor and agreed. But! When he first heard the Beatles on Ed Sullivan, he was entranced and predicted they would be the icons they did become (he had a similar reaction to "Scarborough Fair" with Simon and Garfunkel). When "Yellow Submarine" came to theaters, in 1968, he took me to see it, and we enjoyed it together (there was a short before the movie started. It was about surfing, and for years I remembered it was being a legit part of the movie). Later, he braved Manhattan, taking me on the subway from Brooklyn to see "Beatlemania" on the Broadway stage.
The Bourne series, or Mission: Impossible would be my suggestions for future franchises
So many great ones! For the '70s musicals, l vote Pete's Dragon (1977), all the way! I love it SO much!!!! It was one of the movies you unboxed yesterday! Thank you for having such great content and making me laugh all the time! You're the best! Love ya, girl!
I forgot to add The Great Race during the livestream
YES! "The Great Race"! Curtis and Lemmon together again, joined by the unbeatable Natalie Wood!
I just realized that I thought Chitty Chitty Bang Bang and Bedknobs and Broomsticks were the same movie. I was very confused why it was back on the list!
OMG don't say that to Ashleigh - she'll *never* watch Chitty Chitty Bang Bang if she thinks it's like Bedknobs and Broomsticks! 🤣
Oh my gosh, such great movies! I had to choose four: Yellow Submarine (my all time favorite animated movie), West Side Story, and of course the two Elvis movies. I mean, c'mon. Lol.
Also, if you're interested in going The Beatles movie route, I definitely suggest their other films A Hard Days Night, Help! and (if you're feeling REALLY brave) Magical Mystery Tour.
Still no Cannibal! The Musical 😥
I'll add it to the next one
thank you for this idea :P and I hope we work our way to Mamma Mia one day :D
more musical polls to come!
On the franchise side, the Kingsmen movies would be fun
Love this idea! Just hope the copyright overlords don’t give you too much of a hassle. We know music can be tough on the youtubes.
send prayers lololol
I never know how to talk about this one anymore since the title is literally a slur...forgive me....I do think Ashleigh would really like the Bette Middler version of Gypsy. She'd DIE during Gotta Get a Gimmick
if there is a 70's poll please put Harold and Maude on it (and yes I consider that film to be a musical)
That's not a musical - that's a movie that has music in it.
Guys, hate to be a downer, but we should save “Chitty Chitty Bang Bang” for when Dick Van Dyke passes some day.
I dunno. At this rate he'll outlive all of us.
Oh boy - Music Man and Chitty Chitty Bang Bang have my votes - especially CCBB for Dick Van Dyke's 100th year on this planet!
Oh god. Even though I voted for it I hope Chitty doesn’t win. Ashleigh would hate that one 😂
Wow, literally none of the musicals I would have recommended for you are on this list. I would point you at Rent, Little Shop of Horrors, Chicago - three classics which you're likely to love.
Did you not read the name of this poll -- musicals from the 1960s 😂
To bad Basic Instinct isn't a musical. I don't dabble in musicals too often but My Fair Lady is really good.
Ashleigh! So many bangers! Wish you could watch them all!
Me too!
also MiB 2 is uploading currently! Will share soon!
Fast and Furious?
