UNCENSORED ACCESS: A Few Good Men
Comments (14)
Kendrick is David from The Lost Boys. ❤️🔥
It’s a military trial, everyone in that courtroom is military, except maybe the family of the accused. So all the jury is military.
Exceptional military movie and YOU DIDN'T CRY! 😄👍
Ashleigh, you missed the point of the medical cross-examination. There was no poison. He had a medical condition that caused his death under the stress of the code red.
Trust me, you don't want to be on jury duty. I did it. It sucked. LOL I LOVE this movie! So good!!!! And so many big names! Tom Cruise, Demi Moore, Jack Nicholson, Kevin Bacon, Kiefer Sutherland, Kevin Pollak, Cuba Gooding Jr and Noah Wyle (he just won an Emmy for the show The Pitt!) Like others have said, the rag wasn't poisoned. I felt so bad for Dawson and Downey. It sucks that they still got BCD, but yeah, they should've said no. Although they still would've been punished for saying no and Santiago probably still would've died from the code red. A no-win situation.
Also, that dialogue between Tom Cruise and Jack Nicholson still gives me the chills! "You can't handle the truth!"
this is a court martial different then a normal trial and the usmc is a department of the navy and unit corp god country is not a official thing and only really seen in the marines
The Code Red was an illegal order and, per Military Code, they should have refused the order. That is why they were found guilty of conduct unbecoming. It is sad because they were trained to take orders and that is what they were punished for doing.
Big brain Ashleigh is back baby! Once again Covid is no match for the power of silly! Because you love court room dramas, I'd like to request a rewatch of 12 Angry Men...the Henry Fonda 1957 version is so much better than the one you have on your channel. Henry is Jane's papa. Other films I'd love for you to react to are: 1. Inherit The Wind - Spencer Tracy, Fredric March and Gene Kelly. 2. The Verdict - Paul Newman. 3. Rainmaker - Matt Damon 4. Anatomy of a Murder - James Stewart. 5. Witness for the Prosecution. 6. Absence of Malice - Paul Newman and Sally Field. 7. Judgement at Nuremberg - Spencer Tracy, Burt Lancaster and so many other terrific actors.
Honestly, I also think it's been so long since the previous 12 Angry Men that it will be like watching a new movie anyway.
The rag was not poisoned. While poison might have caused the lactic acidosis, it was shown that Santiago likely had a heart condition (explaining his fatigue, shortness of breath, etc during physical activity) which also explains the acidosis. The doctor insisted that it HAD to be poison because he would be in significant trouble if he missed the serious heart condition in Santiago’s fitness reports. It’s not that he lied, per se, but that he covered his own butt and insisted that there couldn’t POSSIBLY have been another explanation, even though Caffey had just demonstrated one.
To add to this, it's potentially two-fold. I think it's very likely that the doctor probably considered Santiago's complaints to be pretty standard for Marines who were simply struggling to get in shape, and didn't realize they were a sign of a serious heart issue until after Santiago was dead. My interpretation would be that he did the autopsy, realized his mistake, but put "cause of death undetermined" to cover his own ass, and then went and talked to Jessup, who threatened him (the 3am and 5am thing that Jo is talking about). Saying it was some sort of poison rather than a heart condition covers both Jessup and the doctor, by making it into a homicide and explaining away the cause of the acidosis. I don't know what professional repercussions there would be at minimum if the doctor had simply missed that Santiago had a condition until it was too late, but I'm sure Jessup could've promised the doctor that he would make sure his testimony would put the doctor in the worst possible position if he didn't back up Jessup's story.
Santiago choked to death on his own blood. This movie was written by Aaron Sorkin (first as a Broadway play, then adapted to film) - all of that *spectacular* dialog and character stuff you loved is mostly to his credit. The American President is ALSO written by Aaron Sorkin, and you should absolutely watch it for Presidents Day and/or Valentine's Day (it's about the president and also it's about a romance)
So, the question absolutely makes sense & we don’t get a definitive answer, but it’s strongly implied that the rag was not poisoned & the doctor lied because Santiago had a medical condition the doctor didn’t pick up on. Santiago should’ve been transferred simply for his health, and the fact that he wasn’t would have been a huge red flag on the doctor. It also means no one involved in the order expected Santiago to die, which is also the doctor’s fault.
