Help me pick the last NATMARE movie!

I'm new here. Just sharing my appreciation for Natmares season. The fact that she does this while not being a horror fan is a really cool. Knowing that, it's fair to assume that she won't appreciate or enjoy most if any of the really intense scary gory horror films. So I'm happy Ready or Not won the poll. I think she'll have a better time with that over terrifier. Being new here I dont know if Nat has watched these or not, but I think they are good with just enough horror for someone like Nat.... Babadook (2014) I See You (2019) The Ritual (2017)

Yeah Natalie I just don't see you enjoying Terrifer. Its mediocre film making/ editing with over the top gore. Theres nothing of note thats good about it other than the practical effects and the performance of the clown. If you want something gory and gross then sure but the other two options are way more interesting

Ok one more comment, this time about the winner. I'm very happy Ready or Not won out in the end. Enough has been said about Terrifier, so I won't touch on that. I remember when "Blade 2" came out it was friggin huge, at least among the kids my age. And then Blade Trinity uh, existed. I'm confident the Scream franchise will continue to be worked through. So as for Ready or Not. It's a wonderful movie, I've seen three or four times. The atmosphere, the lead actress, the supporting cast, the premise, the location. It all blends together great. I have no doubt you'll love it. If you like the movie, a similar kind of experience would be "The Hunt" from 2020. I won't spoil it, but it's good fun with another great lead. Samara Weaving is wonderful. She was great in both "The Babysitter" movies. (From 2017 and 2020) Lastly, a movie called "Mayhem" which is about an office going nutzo. But it's also a comedy horror. All the movies I've suggested are very funny. Mayhem and The Hunt are definitely "anytime" movies. The Babysitter movies are a bit more standard horror themed, but also don't have to be locked to Halloween since they're basically comedy movies that spoof horror.

Can’t wait for AoT to be on a pole one day!

I thought Scream 2 won a previous poll?

yeah… i don’t think you’ll be able to even sit thru terrifier so it’s prob good it’s last rn

non of these are scary what a waste of a season. No insidious type movies or anything

I still maintain you have to watch Student Bodies, the original Scary Movie. I'll sit down now 🤣🤣🤣

Dang! I'm scared to look in the comments for the last poll now! 😂 Since I've been skipping the natmare movies (cause I can't do horror) I'll just let everyone else fight it out for this one :P

So as crazy as it sounds, I think it would probably be best to start with Terrifier 2. There's nothing really from the first one that you NEED to know for the second. While Terrifier 2 does have some extreme scenes, there's also a lot of humor, and an astonishingly likable protagonist, which the first movie lacks. Then you could either continue on to the third movie, or backtrack and catch up on the first. From a fan of the franchise, the "appeal" of Art the clown is in his next level physical acting. Since he doesn't talk, he has to communicate with his face and body. Even though he's horrible, he has a TON of charisma, and is always fun to watch. You always want to see what he'll do next, even when you know it will be horrible. I don't want to spoil any more than I already have, but, I worry if you start with the first one, you won't want to continue with the franchise, which would be a shame because Terrifier 2 does so many cool things. I would say though, to prepare. If you need to bring in a friend to watch it with you, I don't think anyone would complain. But, I guess we have a year to figure that all out right?

At least we know that Natalie reads our comments. And now that Blade is out, this poll is more representative and Terrifier is in last place, where it belongs. (I actually like the Terrifier franchise but it's not a movie Natalie will enjoy.) It's just a shame that Trick 'r Treat (2007) didn't at least make it on a Natmare poll. Natalie and most of her Patreon members don't know what they're missing by not watching Trick 'r Treat. It's been a staple of my Halloween movie marathons for 15 years! 🎃🎃🎃

See where some healthy debate gets you? 😅 I appreciate it x Terrifier still sucks tho, it’s barely a movie. More torture-porn than Saw ever was, and I just don’t see Art’s appeal tbh. I understand why it’s got such a big following tho.. kinda

Aw blades so fun tho, hopefully yo u have fun with whatever wins

Nat, I am confident when I say this: you can not handle terrifier. I think it would be the first movie you back out of and I don’t think you’d find it an enjoyable experience.

Eh, Blade is horror-esque, wouldn't have minded. But Ready or Not is fun too. 😊 I don't understand the love for Terrifier. I love horror, but that "movie" is just bad on almost every level. You want gore? Watch Braindead / Dead Alive.

My goodness! Such strong feelings over Blade and/or scary movies! Thank you Natalie, for doing what you can to make your viewers happy! I'm sure everyone appreciates it.

Ooooi dont think you would like The Terrifier lol. Ready or Not or Scream 2 would definitely be more enjoyable for ya lol.

NO!

Where the Steven king movies? Any of them are better than this list. 1408 is very underrated.( cujo, pet sematary ,Christine, misery…) oh well maybe next year.

Well you got off really easy this natmare season with no actually scary movies being done. Annoying that fast and furious took up so many spots and we get less horror this October.

My vote is not Terrifier, this is pure gore-genre horror and that is so not the vibe.

Let’s go Terrifier lol

Interesting that everyone is voting for Ready or not, I thought it was a pretty bad movie when I saw it. It is a strange list IMO, where is The Shinning? Where is Barbarian or some of the other classic horror films? Maybe Nat already saw them? Who knows

Do yourself a favor and do not watch Terrifier .

Idk why people are upset. I was gonna suggest she could react to the top 2 on the poll since it's the last week and there should be an open slot if she just does one fast and the furious movie again next week

I mean I’m still gonna vote for Terrifier just because I think the YT edit would be hilarious… and short lol

Was wondering why I had a second email about a poll lol. Also are planning on playing any more horror games? You should check out Silent Hill 2 Remake. Or save it for next year if you don’t plan on anymore the rest of the month.

Blade

Still can’t believe Terrifier is on this poll. That movie is out of Natalie’s league. Worse than Human Centipede, by a long shot.

You gotta do the whole scream franchise at some point ;-)

One day Trick 'r Treat will be on the polls. One day...

Really hoped that Scream 2 would win but i guess that is never happening. Would love it if you watch whole Scream franchise, scream franchise has 6 films currently and 7th is on the way.

So much anger over Blade not being a "true" horror movie, only to then turn around and pick Ready or Not, which is a Dark Comedy action horror 🤣.

I’m sure she will add Blade again to another poll after Natmare season .

Well now I'm upset you dropped Blade /s

Nat, that's just positive reinforcement for bad behavior.

That one definitely got heated lol. Now I feel bad

Please for the love of god dont watch Terrifier, its just a gorefest 😅 not really scary plus you probably will have to censor the entire screen for most of the reaction

OH GOD NO

The only time I've ever backed the leading pick and you reset it lmao 🤣 too funny 🤣

I don't mind that Ready or Not is winning...but the Scream series...so fun...

Take 2. Scream 2 ha ha Nat you da best 😊

I can't blame you for putting Blade on the original list, but it would be nice to see the community pick more movies and shows that you're going to enjoy or be interested in. They always provide better reactions than stuff that you're not going to care about.

ready or not, please is the best

Ready or Not… here we come.

Scream 2 definitely because we watched the 1st ! We gotta watch the second one together

We could always do Blade after Natmare Season. But I'm stoked for you to check out Scream 2 or Ready or Not. If I'm not mistaken, the directors behind Ready or Not started carrying on the Scream franchise. Also some more ideas for future Natmares: You're Next VVITCH Trick 'r Treat (2007) Last Night in Soho

What about Talk to Me?

Fair enough