It's time for NATMARES!!👻🕸️🕷️
Oh boy...it's that time of year again.
I'm scared for this pick 😅
Comments (103)
The Prophecy [1995] it is too obsecure to win a poll probably but has an all star cast for its time and is christopher walkin at his best.
Oh I agree. It's one of my favorites. and when Viggo Mortensen show up... So good.
Its rly cool you might do Saw! There are so many but the first is classic. If you end up watching multiple I’d recommend just watching the first 3 because they have their own contained story because of the director change I believe. Also the newest one Saw X is my favorite and takes place between 1 and 2 I think. Great movies :D
I voted for "It Follows" but the scary movie I highly recommend for Natmare season is "Trick 'R Treat" (2007). It's the best Halloween-themed movie EVER! It doesn't get the recognition it deserves because it didn't get a theatrical release at the time, but it's developed a cult following over the years. It's been a staple in my Halloween movie marathons since 2010 and it would be amazing if Natalie reacted to Trick 'R Treat! 🎃🎃🎃
Where's 28 days later? Not exactly scary but a great zombie movie
She had planned to watch it some months ago and it even won a poll but it's impossible to watch anywhere so it was put on hold until availability becomes better :)
Saw is a safe pick. :) Obviously NOT a "good" movie but it's fairly tame. No idea on Talk to Me, so that has my curiosity as well.
Highly recommend talk to me, I was skeptical going into it but it really is outstanding
No one will save you and Talk to me are genuinely fantastic, highly recommend even if they dont win this vote, they are really great movies, well done and terrifying in the best ways
I don't know why Talk to Me isn't higher on the list. Objectively one of the most inventive horror movies of the last two decades. Even if it doesn't place, you should still check it out. It was made by YouTubers! Here's their channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz_cDc_2arKIb6SlJoqFT0w
Pumpkinhead (1988)
Need Ready or Not added to the polls!
Somehow It Follows is overrated and underrated at the same time. Either way I still love it.
horror is my least favorite genre even though Halloween is my favorite holiday but It Follows was a VERY good movie. Definitely worth a watch. The original Saw is a good watch to understand where it all started and stuff if you like Saw but overall It Follows is a much better movie.
O how can I forget return of the living dead.
We definitely need a 80’s horror poll. Some suggestions Evil dead 2, the blob, an American werewolf in Paris, the shining, the fly, near dark.
Besides the gore she will love the twists of saw.
shhhhh
OHHH YES SAW is winning.. Nat will love this! ;)
Whelp, looks like saw is gonna make for a fun reaction, here's hoping she can stomach it 😂
do an actual scary movie like insidious
The original 2008 swedish version of "Let the right one in." is a fun and scary time!
I really hope we get some sweet horror-comedies for Natmare 2024, like Braindead/Dead Alive, What We Do In The Shadows or Return of the Living Dead.
Oh man What We Do In The Shadows would be great this year.
Havent seen It Follows heard its really good, would love for that one to win! I'm sure weve all seen SAW
Haven’t you Saw fans seen that movie enough? Lol. Lots of good to great ‘current’ horror films on this list that need some love.
I've only seen them maybe twice. And maybe 5 years ago. We are allowed to love classic horror films. There are other films I'd love to add to the list but between these options, Saw wins.
A Quiet Place: Day One was such an incredible film and I haven't seen many people react to it yet. It's definitely my favorite of the three. My main gripe with it though is that they cut a scene that I feel like adds a lot more depth to the story. Talk to me is also one of the best films of last year! That would have been my second choice. I love the Saw franchise but most reacters have done them at some point.
How is 'Talk to me' losing. That is disappointing. Such a good horror movie.
Right?! I’m pretty well over the Saw craze (for years now)
four words: David Fincher's Panic Room
Saw is definitely the right choice but all are good options - So excited for Natmares <3
nah saw stinks its played out.
Happy Wednesday Nat. If you read the films polled in order, you're asking us to give you our opinion on a horror double bill 🤣 Anyway, I'm going to go with A Quiet Place this time. Such a beautiful movie. Have a great day Nat 💛
I don't have a problem with any of these really but there's a thriller/horror/comedy from earlier this year called "Abigail" which was really good. It was made by Radio Silence who also made the latest two in the "Scream" franchise and also "Ready or Not", which would be another solid pick.
I am alone in thinking the Saw franchise is overrated
the franchise (sequels) yes... but the original is great and worth a watch.
Halloween 2018
Horror Comedy or campy: The Frighteners Teeth (2007) They Live What We Do in the Shadows
Bro how about writing your suggestions in ONE message instead of 20...
The Witch (2015)
The Strangers (2008)
Shadow of the Vampire (2000)
Rec (2007)
Ready or Not (2019)
Re-animator (1985)
The Mist (2007)
The Howling (1981
Fright Night (1985)
Frailty (2002)
The Fly (1986)
Drag Me to Hell
The Descent (2005)
Dead Alive / Braindead (1992)
Candyman (1992)
Audition/Odishun (1999)
American Werewolf in London
28 Days Later
Some good horror picks would be late night with the devil, thanksgiving, and the girl with all the gifts. Id prefer executive decisions instead of polls like you did with longlegs. Smaller, less known/financially successful movies dont stand a chance in polls and they are Some of the best movies
It Follows gets my actual vote. But since it's getting so little love, I gotta pipe up for NOWSY. Try to go in blind for a fun revelation 20-30 mins in.
Saws alright. Not at all scary though
I would love to see the fear street trilogy this Natmare season. It’s spooky, fun, and the plot is very well crafted.
Was a toss between Talk to Me and Saw tbh - but the first Saw is iconic and actually relatively tame, compared to the gratuitous gore of the sequels. Early James Wan and Leigh Whannell, Definitely a fun watch x
Oh 1 more suggestion I’m surprised nobody mentioned blade . I think it fits as a natmare it’s a action horror
How is Talk To Me not winning?
Because it's a lot less known than some of the other options
Saw is overhyped and by now, pointless to see
Without a doubt
Steven kings 1408 is extremely underrated to me and would make a great reaction video .
It-SAW bout time. Then you have to watch Saw 2 - 5, in order to get to the best one, Saw 6. Then there are 3 more movies... then Saw X.
Loki season 2 before Deadpool and Wolverine I beg u 😭 it aired during spooky season last year so its perfect timing!!
It Follows is the best movie in this poll.
I hope late night with the devil makes thr polls this year!
I really hope Saw doesn't win, but seems like it will 🫤
I know. Such a boring, had-its-moment pick
Talk To Me is an incredible horror movie made by fellow youtubers! I am so glad I decided to go see it in theaters last year
No One Will Save You is good enough not worry about the polls. I’d recommend Mandy for cosmic horror, The Frighteners for comedy horror, Green Room for horror thriller, and Humanist Vampire Seeking Consenting Suicidal Person for supernatural romance.
Smile is a great one! I recommend!
Another great Natmare pick would be 1980's "Altered States" screenplay by Paddy Chayefsky. Natile, it is unlike anything you've seen before.
But, Nat, Marvel Jesus' digital release is now official on Oct 1st LOL! Would it be possible to move the front runner SAW for the following week?!
Cuckoo would be a good one to watch!
If there is another poll, Insidious is a great pick.
Talk to Me was one of my favorite movies of last year. Even if it doesn’t “win,” you should watch just for a date night with the spouse :)
The first Saw is a classic but im happy to watch any on this poll
Saw is a modern classic. You gotta watch the first two.
Had to go with Talk to Me. Great movie! I can't recommend it enough. That and I'm completely over the Saw movies. But, I get it!
The only people not over the Saw films are the people that ONLY watch the Saw films. Talk to Me or No One Will Save You are much more interesting picks
It sucks It Follows hasn't won any polls the last few years. Nat you should just make the executive decision to watch it anyway!
This is how I feel about The Godfather and Scarface lol this is one of the few reaction channels that hasn't reacted to those yet, oh well maybe one day🤷♂️😂
I am also really hoping we will do a series this time. There are so many good limited series with just one season, that is perfect for Natmare season! 😁
Saw will walk it so don't really need to vote tbh it's not scary so you're be fine nat grossed out yes but fine
No One Will Save You is probably the freshest concept on this list.
Really cool movie. Very creepy and unique. Would make for a great reaction. Too obscure to ever win a poll tho tbh.
Hm. I haven't seen Talk to Me or No One Will Save You. They didn't look good to me. So I can't say for those. I voted for Saw, but I really didn't like these choices. But that's my opinion! I want to see what everyone else says. Yay spooky season!
I was 12 when I first saw "SAW" no spoilers I'll just say I didn't want to go to sleep that night 😂 shit messed me up lol
Hi Nat, looking forward to this year's Natmare season, come on patreon let's pick some scary films for Nat to watch.
Indeed! Last year, Nat got off light!
It's the most wonderful time of the year! 🎵 With Nat screaming in terror 🎵 And everyone telling you to tremble in fear!🎵 It's the most wonderful time of the year! 🎵
You want a good horror movie watch Mandy. But y'all not ready for real art.
Soooooooooo overated. One of the simplest plots I’ve ever seen.
Talk to Me is SUCH an underrated gem! but i’d be excited for any of these to win
Saw really fucked me up when I watched when it first came out
All fine choices although Saw isn’t my cup of tea. Talk to Me and It Follows are especially chilling