Best Girl Poll 2026
It's time for a fun poll. Nothing that's going to affect content development, but just something to see the fans' tastes of what we've done to date. Now that we have three games' worth of potential love interests under our belts, we figured it was time to see which girls are getting the most love.
While I don't want to affect the voting, I do figure that it'll be mostly a cat fight between Kallie and Carol. Mostly, I'm curious who else will get votes. I know there's at least one hardcore fan of Marisa out there and a few for Apollyon (Polly). When we did something similar for The Interim Domain, there weren't a lot of surprises there. Well, except for the lack of love for Kara or Natalie, but that can be explained away as both coming later in the game and having shorter storylines.
Thanks for your interest and patronage,
-Kinderfeld
Comments (46)
Anita.She just broke my heart
Selene and Polly were my favorites in Interim Domain! If I had to choose one... Maybe Selene, but mainly because her ending was my favorite. Polly is a very close second tho! Really wish both of them (and Mira as well) got more content in the game (not just lewd scenes, but scenes in general).
I love Laura. And Carol. They are so kind and caring. Kallie making a bogeyman out of her betrothed who mainly only wanted her to stay close, something most men would want from their woman, made me think that Laura would be the better match. Shelley and Eve are out because of too much casual intercourse in the past. No one there to treat a STD in the apocalypse.Btw., I started a new playthrough to give Kallie another chance and noticed that the start date (Wednesday, 10th of June) doesn't match. Friday is the 13th, which would put, the novel into year 2025, right?
Alice, Sydney, Hana N&T, Apollyon for sure TID
Naomi from N&T, Anita and Polly from TID and my personal favorite Eve, from Toxicity. She's a brilliant addition to the cast and adds that layer of support and competens that makes her feel unique. Doesn't hurt that her latest scenes are chef's kiss with the balance of budding love and tough exterior.
Soooo many to choose from: Sidney and Hana (N&T) Tina and Polly (TID) Kallie and Shelley (Tox)
Also, a huge shout-out to my "girls": Alice and Anya
This is goddamn impossible lol
Try being me, who finds something lovable in all of them.
Mira's my girl.
I really liked Sydney in N&T. And Anita in TID!
Sydney too! miss that redhead gotta replay N&T soon
Sydney N&T
Sydney from N&T. Redheads are a weakness. 🤣
That's just cruel to make us choose each character is so fucking lovely I just can't . But kallie is just too much of a sweetheart and carol too. And Mira grew on me over the time .
I'd say also robin and Polly from TID are amazing characters and Sydney from N&T and Shelley from toxicity are favourites too.
I vote for Mira, even if she is not the frontrunner. I played TID with great pleasure and from the beginning I had the hope of building a romantic relationship with Mira. And lo and behold: it turned out well! Of course, all the other ladies are always worth a love, especially Kallie at the moment, but Mira, that was something... 😊
Carol is my favorite but I have to add that Mira and Apollyon are top 3, due in part to their growth as first friends and then LIs. There is something truly special about timeless beings finding something special in one man across all the eons of their experience that makes their choices to choose and enjoy mortal existence with him something no mortal woman can compete with. If I went with top 7, I'd add Kallie, Selene, Sydney and Julie from N&T. Like M&M's - you can't have just one!!
Nonono, don't do this to me... Robin, Polly, Sydney, Hana, Eve, Selene... All of them!
Other - I am team Naomi.
Our favorite garage gal Eve
Selene
My vote is Sydney From Now & Then. I felt a good connection with her and my MC in the story and felt she was a good fit. She also had a leveled head during the course of the game and I was happy she became a mom. :) For The Interim Domain, I enjoy Mira, Anita, Marisa, Robin, Apolloyon, Selene and Natalie. It mostly how their stories are impact by the MC and thier bonds with the other women during course of the game. For Toxicity: Main girl Kallie who has won me over. I found it funny how I enjoy Kallie growth of a person as she is slowing learning to find love in a person with understanding that they are human. I'm start my IRL relationship about the same time frame when Kallie and My MC start theirs in the Game around (late 2024 through current.). It was a slow build up for the charaters learing about their problems but at the same time understanding that they are more than their past and they see the good in each other. I will have to say that Kallie has inspired me to be more of myself in my IRL Relationship by being more open and embarce each others flaws and working together. :) Thank you for making this Vote. I enjoy share my thoughts. :)
That's great to hear. I write about people with flaws or real issues as a way to process my own losses, but also as a way to show people that it's okay to be who you are and that you're not alone in the world. If you find someone willing to be there for you, that's a wonder to behold. I will also say that Kallie's growth arc is pretty great and she becomes the one to keep John in line in later chapters.
I voted for Carol, but that's only because Shelley wasn't there. She's my favorite girl in all your games (even though I love them all)
Huuuhhh tough! I have so many, but I'll mention some: N&T: Carol and Sidney TID: Robin and Polly TOX: Callie and Shelley
Tough choice but I'm loving Laura from TOX right now. There's just something very alluring about her.
And no, I don't mean "Dat ass" Well, yeah, but not just that 😊
Mira was a baddy no question about it
Robin from TID
Sydney, Shelley, Carol and Kallie.
This is cruel, forcing us to choose between those sweet girls. So cruel in fact that I’m going to throw a complete curveball and give alternative names from each game. Sydney from N&T Selene&Polly from TID Eve from Tox This doesn’t mean that the options in the poll are worse… just… hard to choose 😅
I can understadn your feeling aout Sydney. She is a Good girl. :)
Carol N&T - Polly ID - Kallie Toxicity
Marisa. "We just got time for us..." gutted me.
All of the goodbyes in TID are meant to be hard, but Marisa and Anita's are both particularly painful. Marisa in particular because she finally feels like she can have the life she wants with Michael.
I'm new, I did not even know y'all had more games. Can I get them here on patreon as well?
Yep, just put "Interim Domain" or "Now & Then" in the search bar and scroll down a bit to find the posts with the download links.
Tina and Anita!
Naomi
Damn this is hard.
So many good choices. So many good girls to love.
Shelley. Redhead, bubbly, a bit awkward and weird. nuff said
totally agree, I love Shelley
Eve from Toxicity
Laura for sure