Suggest a character! 28 (Extend)

For this artwork of May-looking-character-that's-definitely-not-from-Pokemon-due-to-copyright-reasons, the pose requires an item inserted "there". The Not-Pokeball would be the obvious choice. However, I figured it's not "elongated" enough to warrant an expression like that. But... I like the expression... So I tried making it a Potion instead.

But looking at it again, both items are good options to me. One looks big, while the other has a better view "there". I don't know which one to choose. So, I figured I'll let my Patreon subscribers choose instead!

Which one do you like more?